Re: Fascinated by the engineering
TomD
"I don' t in any way mean the following to be a criticism, as in the context of unfavorable opinion. I find your engineering interesting to study. It seems over engineered by western get-a-serviceable-product-out-the-door standards of western Period Furniture. Are you replicating oriental engineering as in making a reproduction or applying oriental engineering to an inspired work. (I am not smitten by oriental design so I never studied the engineering. Is 2 or 3 layers of engineering redundancy usually built into oriental furniture?)"
This is a typical metric as though early furniture didn't ever get covered entirely in gold leaf or intricate carving, there has always been a range of available complexity and cost, though arguably less in the colonies. The flip side is the beefy and over joineried style for the cheap seats, literally and figuratively. Large over-joined pieces are often practical where it reduces the reduction required to make a pieces. An example being Windsor chairs which are both overbuilt, and multi-joined.
"I don't understand the need for dovetailing the battens to the top. Is this feature a design element? It does expose the batten ends at the table edge for better or worse."
I can also be pocketed so that it is not seen from the edges. I don't like cutting away parts of the table top myself, but it may well be a good method.
"The top already has what is the equivalent of a bread board end that would aid in keeping a top flat, if needed(I might add, more handsome than the typical bread board which I am not a fan of). That said, I never saw the need for bread boarding to keep a top flat. We don't do it to benches, so why tables?"
Well tables are much wider. But the idea that it isn't needed, or can even end up causing trouble seems right in this day and age. Whether it was true prior to air conditioned homes, in many regions year round air or humidity conditioned, and modern glues, I don't know.
One possible reason is that there is a prejudice against end grain being visible in woodwork, so to make a table where the lord and master is at the end, and rubbing his elbow on end grain, might not be acceptable. Pure speculation.
Another reason is that if the top is thin relative to loads, like, who knows, sword fighting, the BB may support against splits, pine that is less than one inch, could blow if someone just sat against a corner. We tend to regard BBs as a mater of keeping things flat, but there may be other structural reasons.