New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Cabinet Build - Complete

Posts

Cabinet Build - Complete

#1

Cabinet Build - Complete

Brian Holcombe

All set, delivery to my parents house was uneventful. Finish is varnish, my father and I did the varnishing at their house.




My mom will take some nice photos of it soon.

Re: Cabinet Build - Complete

#2

Re: Cabinet Build - Complete

Hank Knight

Brian, that is very elegant. Nice work.

Re: Cabinet Build - Complete

#3

Re: Cabinet Build - Complete

AZ in Colorado Springs

Very nice cabinet.

I have a question. Why did you orient the tails vertically? Seems to me that I have seen them more often oriented horizontally.

Structurally, it seems to me they could go either way. Is it simply a matter of personal taste?

Re: Cabinet Build - Complete

#4

Re: Cabinet Build - Complete

Brian Holcombe

Thank you both!

AZ, I like the tails up for aesthetic reasons primarily.

Dovetails work mechanically on one panel and with a glue hold on the other and since the side panels were reinforced by many sliding dovetails I decided that the top panel would gain the most support by having the mechanical support of the tails to keep it from coming out of flat.

The top panel is further supported by one heavy dovetailed batten which is hidden beneath an interior panel.

Re: Cabinet Build - Complete

#5

Re: Cabinet Build - Complete

AZ in Colorado Springs

Thanks, Brian. That is perfectly clear.

Re: Cabinet Build - Complete

#6

agree

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"I like the tails up for aesthetic reasons primarily. " agree

This build is over engineered. Not a problem except in the time it takes to build which you may want to shorten for future projects. Compare a Krenov case of similar size. While I am not smitten by the philosophical discussions between the covers, the Krenov books reveal some clever engineering that can lead to light airy builds.

Years ago we would have a full time furniture builder/restorer give programs at our club. He advocated looking at antiques that survived for guidance on how to build new stiff. I have learned a lot from this approach and never pass an opportunity to poke into antique furniture to see how it was put together, what failed and what survived.

English drawers have been particularly inspiring. Compared to what one often finds in modern (and old) US furniture the English drawer will have substantially thinner sides and bottoms and more dainty dovetails. Yet they survive apparently as well as the more robust US approach.

Re: Cabinet Build - Complete

#7

Re: agree

Brian Holcombe

There are a few things I would definitely change to how I built the structure to simplify the case, while maintaining my design.

I started with limitations on material, and worked around that. So there are some things I would change about the case sides, namely starting from either full width material or thicker material allow me the room to rabbet the outside edges (to make 5/8"~) and leave the center portion heavier to allow me to build through and through tapered sliding dovetails into the design, which I would then finish in the same manner of installing moldings.

That would knock the built time down considerably and still retain the integrity that I designed into the case, but it would have consumed more of the more expensive materials.

Re: Cabinet Build - Complete

#8

Re: agree

TomD

""I like the tails up for aesthetic reasons primarily. " agree"

Structure and aesthetics are related particularly in design styles that reveal structure. Form follows function. Of course in this case we have a substantial rationale as to why form followed function. I have built cases with exposed dovetails with the tails on top, and at a height where they were not very apparent. Somewhat disappointing I have to say.

"This build is over engineered. Not a problem except in the time it takes to build which you may want to shorten for future projects. Compare a Krenov case of similar size. While I am not smitten by the philosophical discussions between the covers, the Krenov books reveal some clever engineering that can lead to light airy builds."

Of course in virtually all his builds the case size is minuscule, and any loading pretty much non-existent. The engineering solutions may be different at a different scale and use.

"Years ago we would have a full time furniture builder/restorer give programs at our club. He advocated looking at antiques that survived for guidance on how to build new stiff. I have learned a lot from this approach and never pass an opportunity to poke into antique furniture to see how it was put together, what failed and what survived.

English drawers have been particularly inspiring. Compared to what one often finds in modern (and old) US furniture the English drawer will have substantially thinner sides and bottoms and more dainty dovetails. Yet they survive apparently as well as the more robust US approach."

A worthy approach, however:

1) Everything has survived at some point or another, while stuff was not made in similar quantities.

2) The lighter and more refined the better families it was probably designed for, and the better care and condition it was probably maintained under. There are old gold encrusted cabinets at Buck. Palace, and they have lasted well, but it doesn't prove gold leaf is the ultimate structural approach.

Of course dovetail-wise the oldsters often used horizontal tails, and covered the pins with molding. A win win for molding planes.