New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

General International Brand

Posts

General International Brand

#1

General International Brand

Clementine

I'm confused. I have a General table saw and it is wonderful. I was shopping for a miter saw, which General doesn't make. But on some websites like Home Depot, I see General International miter saws and they are red, not green like General tools, and inexpensive. Any idea on who makes these red General tools?

Re: General International Brand

#2

Re: General International Brand

John in NM

They are all Taiwanese or Chinese made now. General ceased Canadian production around 2012 as I recall. Even the green ones are made by the same contract factories as make Powermatic and Jet stuff these days.

Its too bad, but that is the way markets go.

Re: General International Brand

#3

Re: General International Brand

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Lucky you; the General machines made in Canada are sturdy, quality machines.

This being the hand tool side, you're likely to get just limited info here; a post over on the main board will capture more power-tool users. Although there are few hand tool only folks here (most of us being hybrid tool folks, using machines or hand tools as we deem best for the project at hand), a lot of us have a smaller array of power tools than you'll find among the community on the main board.

Re: General International Brand

#4

Re: General International Brand

TomD

I still have a general jointer, and a GI planer. The latter is pretty good, and was made when they were still making stuff in Canada, and didn't want to sully their name. As good as a lot of stuff from Asia is, you can't tell from one day to the next what the quality is going to be, so personal recommendations are pointless. Where factory a product is made can be equally misleading if quality control is a product of company reps.

Re: General International Brand

#5

Ellis Walentine

General International *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

Click the link below to learn more about the GI brand.

Full disclosure: General International is a longstanding major sponsor of WoodCentral.

I have visited the factories in Taiwan (not the ones in mainland China) and have seen firsthand how most of the consumer woodworking machinery imported to this continent is manufactured and assembled. I firmly believe that you can get anything you want in China, from the best quality to the worst, from the most advanced to the least. If you want rock-solid, world-class machinery, it's yours for a price. It's also possible to get inexpensive machines there, and there's a great deal of competition among the US and Canadian companies for shares of this larger consumer market. What distinguishes one company's machines from the rest is dependent on a lot of factors, not least of which are design, industrial engineering, quality control and ground-level oversight of the manufacturing processes and supply chains.

Design is all about knowing what your customer wants and/or needs, and defining the best compromises between features, functions and cost. Some lesser-known brands take the path of least resistance and simply buy the lowest price goods, whether or not they are made with adequate, properly fitting or long-lasting components. Others bring their own innovations to the manufacturers and contract to have the machines built to spec at the best prices possible without compromising the design standards. Industrial engineering takes into account existing cost-saving materials and processes while specifying certain requirements and features that may exceed or replace the standard manufacturing practices of the subcontracting factories, features that are often exclusive or defining of the brand. Quality control has to do with actual technicians monitoring the output from all the vendors that supply parts for the machines. Effective oversight has to do with having "boots on the ground" --engineers, even executives -- where the machines are made, to insist on a level of overall quality that befits their brand.

All other things being equal, there is likely to be a solid correlation between brand reputation, cost and quality. Just because a North American brand has moved its production offshore doesn't mean that it can't or doesn't exert a great deal of control over the finished product. It's fair enough to see what other woodworkers think of their purchases and make your buying decisions accordingly.

Ellis Walentine, Host


General International

Re: General International Brand

#6

Re: General International

Clementine

Ellis,

I realize I posted this on the Hand Tools side, and that's my bad.

I try to read every response you make to the messages posted here, even the ones that are not within my particular area of interest. I know we will get reasoned and informed information from you. I fully agree with what you stated here. I don't have a problem with where a tool is made for the reasons you state. One gets what he pays for, so I think I should look into a purchase as much as possible and then make my decision on the basis of what I see. Thanks for your response.

However - I have General's website in my Favorites. I followed the link you have. They are the same link. I entered a search for "miter" and for "miter saw," but I did not see any returns for a miter saw of any size or color, including the ones advertised by Home Depot and numerous other websites. I just simply want to know if the General International that I know and the company where I have made purchases is the same company that makes these red miter saws at the moderate cost advertised. If it is, how can I make an informed decision when I can't find more information on them?

Re: General International Brand

#7

Ellis Walentine

I'll have to get back to you on this...


Re: General International Brand

#8

Re: General International Brand

TomD

I am not sure if I was clear that the GI planer I have is one made in Taiwan. Actually all the heavy industrial planers I have bought were taiwanese, going back over 30 years, and they were all great.

Re: General International Brand

#9

Ellis Walentine

You're right....

Ellis Walentine

I searched, the GI website, downloaded their entire catalog and their Fall/Winter promo flyer and I can't find a trace of the miter saws you mentioned. Excellent catch. I have a call in to the head of GI's US operations and should have a better explanation for you soon. Stay tuned.

Ellis

Re: General International Brand

#10

Re: You're right....

TomD

It is interesting because the label looks like the GI label, but is missing, for instance, the globe.

Re: General International Brand

#11

Re: You're right....

david weaver

Is the saw referenced the one that's a SCMS that goes for about $140 right now?

Re: General International Brand

#12

Re: You're right....

Clifton C

Tom, as you say, No globe, but it does have "since 1946". Not in the market, but it is kind of interesting... Staying tuned for "breaking News" from Ellis...

Re: General International Brand

#13

Re: You're right....

david weaver

The dynamic of having to expand into various sources of the market is an interesting one.

Remember how much everyone used to love delta? 10 years ago when I started woodworking, they were going through some growing pains, but a lot of their goods were still expensive, and some not (some were visibly very roughly made).

I guess Norm put delta firmly in the hobbyist's mind as a trusted brand.

When I see a saw like GI has made here, I'd admit it would give it a bit of credibility to me that I wouldn't have if it was GMC brand or said Harbor Freight on it, but at the price I see the saws around ($140 for a 15 amp SCMS), if it could do construction type work I'd be pretty happy with it. If it had some wobble otherwise and didn't match an old US made dewalt fixed saw in terms of cut quality, that's just life.

I never knew general completely stopped making things in canada. I don't buy big tools any longer, but it's still a bummer.

Re: General International Brand

#15

Re: You're right....

Dick Coers

I'm confused about what you are saying about Delta. What did Norm have to do with the establishment of the brand? Delta was so well established and respected by the time Norm was born. I just saw some beautifully restored 30s machines. Fantastic machines and just beautiful Art Deco castings!

Re: General International Brand

#16

Re: You're right....

david weaver

I could be off the mark, but I gather where I grew up (rural area where people weren't big spenders), there was some introduction of delta to a much wider audience through Norm's show.

The folks I'm thinking of bought craftsman tools before that (people who did DIY work, but not professional work).

Re: General International Brand

#17

Re: You're right....

Dick Coers

Norm did add sales for Delta and Porter Cable. They had his face plastered all over their ads and shows. But Deltas good name was already set as quality product. I'd say he single handedly established the hobby air nailer industry. Before Norm, only expensive professional nailers were available.

Re: General International Brand

#18

Re: You're right....

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Craftsman tools were more popular in the 1950s and 60s. By the time New Yankee Workshop started in 1989 Delta was very popular, I would think more than today.

I only ever saw one episode of Norm's show. In 1991 our family stayed at a hostel in Vermont. My son, 7 years old, was hot to watch TV because we didn't have one at home. There were only two channels, so we ended up watching the Workshop. After about 10 minutes my son said "Dad, this is horrible. How can they let this guy on TV?"

Re: General International Brand

#19

Re: You're right....

TomD

Thanks Clifton, nothing to say they don't have a different logo for this line. Is or was a Canadian company, but I haven't seen these for sale up here, must have a look next time I am in a Home Depot.

Re: General International Brand

#20

Re: You're right....

Clementine

Yes. There are three models ranging from 120 to 240. The few reviews look mostly positive. I'm sure if General of Canada "supervises" this product that it is a decent product. I'm not from Missouri, but I want to see if General of Canada is actually the original source--Just "show me;" that's all I ask.

Re: General International Brand

#21

Why not ask them? *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I have no idea how responsive the corporation is, but, hey, they're Canadian; they'd probably think it's rude not to respond quickly. Link below will offer you some e-mail addresses.


http://www.general.ca/contact.html

Re: General International Brand

#22

Answer-- I Think

Clementine

I asked. Here is their response:

"Thank you for your inquiry. The miter saw and other red tools you are referring to, are part of our General International Power Products lineup; a separate division of our company.

You can find more information about all of the products in the GIPP line-up on the dedicated website here: http://www.gipowerproducts.com."

The link works and it looks like a pretty complete line of tools--REALLY RED!

I still wonder why the website took a company email to find it, but I think I'll just get on with life.

Re: General International Brand

#23

Ellis Walentine

***Here's the scoop***

Ellis Walentine

I spoke with my old friend Scott Box, the US manager for General International. The General International brand name was bought by a Chinese company called D&D. The red tools you saw on the Home Depot website are General International in name only and are only available online. There is no manufacturing or distribution connection between these dirt-cheap handyman tools and the professional quality General International machinery that you see advertised here on WoodCentral and elsewhere.

Bottom line: You get what you pay for. Caveat emptor.

Ellis