New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

How did the British do this excavation in 1800

Posts

How did the British do this excavation in 1800

#1

How did the British do this excavation in 1800

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

First, my sorrow. I applied for a job helping to build a Rose Parade float and was accepted. I was to be building it in clear 65 degree weather in the Rose Bowl parking lot. But United cancelled my flight and could not reschedule that day or the next (ice storms from Houston to Chicago), or even guarantee the 2nd day to get me there. So I cancelled the trip I was most looking forward to.

So I am home, 45 degrees and drizzle, working finishing the table.


We had a spirited discussion some time back on cock beading with the English leaning workers claiming the only way to cock bead was a partial bead on the bottom. I vigorously defended the American practice of a full cock bead there. However, in the case at hand a partial cock bead makes sense. To squeeze all the drawer height possible I have the bottom of the groove perilously close to the bottom drawer edge. Removing more material to do a full bead would substantially weaken the bottom of the groove for the drawer bottom.

One great advantage of power tools is that they remove wood with alacrity. They also remove wood from unwanted places at the same or greater rate if an error is made. More and more as I get substantial time invested in a part I turn to a slow secure hand tool method of wood removal, in this case the rabbits for the cock bead. But how? I can't think of how to make a rabbit on the curved drawer with any hand tool I own.

When I get the table top on I will then address the critics that faulted the drawer design. In the mean time they can be thinking of how they would have handled putting a drawer in a half moon table inspired by but not meant to be a Federal Reproduction, but rather to meet a client need for a table with a drawer to fit a confined space.

BTW, there is a Gallery with substantial collection of English furniture in Shelbyville, KY. I always stop to snoop when near by (daughter lives there). They actually had a demilune with a drawer. I must say that my drawer support engineering is greatly more elegant and robust than the design in that antique.

Additionally, the veneer was continuously wrapped around the skirt and the drawer cut our of the skirt with the matching veneer for its face. The drawer gap around the drawer focused the eye, in spite of the matching veneer. And the veneer edge had predictably chipped. I was satisfied that my choice of framing the drawer with cock bead was both better construction and better looking. If you can't hide something make it a design feature.

Re: How did the British do this excavation in 1800

#2

Re: How did the British do this excavation in 1800

John Pappas

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PCX6RZGmiRE

Could you possibly adapt what he does here? About 6 minutes into the video.

Re: How did the British do this excavation in 1800

#3

Re: How did the British do this excavation in 1800

Warren in Lancaster, PA

In 1800 they would do it quickly. The trouble is that it takes skill.

I would first mark the arc on the bottom of the drawer with a marking gauge or trammels or awl and a pattern. You might be able to scribe from the bottom rail with the drawer sticking out 3/8 or whatever. A lot nicer if the line is something you can put a chisel into rather than pencil.

Then I would sharpen a marking gauge or a cutting gauge and cut the veneer (1/8 from bottom or whatever) part way or all the way through. If not all the way through, finish with a knife. Then remove the strip of veneer (you did use hide glue?)

I would then mark another line with the gauge just short of the remaining veneer (1/32 or 1/64) so you have a safe line to work to. With the drawer upside down use a chisel and mallet to make cross grain chops short of your safe line and a little away from you curved line on the bottom. Maybe every 1/4 or 1/2 inch. Then chop lightly along the curved (back) line, again with a little left for buffer.

Pare along your safe line to remove the bulk of material, then chop right along the back line and pare right along the veneer line. It is possible you could use a finely set rabbet plane to do the final paring.

Re: How did the British do this excavation in 1800

#4

Re: How did the British do this excavation in 1800

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I had considered this possibility. The "joint" between the back of the cock bead and the drawer is often not that tight in the English drawers I have snooped in so that seems a likely way they quickly proceeded.

My concern was the "joint" between the cock bead and face veneer. This surface will need to be flat to get a tight fit. But the rabbit plane may be the solution to flattening this surface. I am unsure I can pare it flat but maybe with a wide chisel it will not be that difficult. Cock bead to veneer on the bottom is the intersection that most shows.

Re: How did the British do this excavation in 1800

#5

Fitting cock bead to  the arc line

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I puzzled a bit over fitting the cock bead to the arc of the rabbit. Duh! Easy, fit the rabbit arc to the premade cock bead arc.

To provide back up in case of a screw up fitting the cock bead I am making duplicate cock bead pieces. The arc on the back, which only needs to approximate the arc of the drawer, will be established with the duplicates temporarily fastened together to get an exact duplicate of the arc. The cock bead will them be placed on the drawer and the arc for the cock bead rabbit scribed from the cock bead piece.

I don't have many carving tools but I do happen to have a large shallow sweep that will do for chiseling to the scribe line.

Re: How did the British do this excavation in 1800

#6

It turned out satisfactorily, but tedious

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

A large #1 gouge would have made the task of establishing the rabbet easier. It was a bit tedious with a small #2, the closest I had.

The unanticipated stress was dealing with the frail, partially cross grained, cock bead piece. All's well that ends. The pieces all fit and the drawer is done. I concluded that British cock beading should be avoided, especially on shaped drawers(see discussion above)