New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Wooden Planes

Posts

Wooden Planes

#1

Wooden Planes

Ron Harper

I am finding that I more and more gravitate to woodies. I know David is out there and is enthusiastic about it. Are there others out there who have made this switch? Share your experience with us please. I still find my 604 my most used tool in my shop,but more and more I use a wooden scrub, jack, and joiners. I am a little grey and long in the tooth to make such a switch,but I get so much more feedback from wooden planes.

I really do not need any more planes, but i have a 1/4 in thick iron that I am dying to build into a krenov smoother. Have some bizarre curly maple for tge body.

Ron

Re: Wooden Planes

#2

Never too old to learn new things!


Re: Wooden Planes

#3

Re: Never too old to learn new things!

Ron Harper

Agree Bill, but some things seem a little harder to get than tgey used to be, at least for me. Be assured, I intend to keep growin.

Ron

Re: Wooden Planes

#4

Re: Wooden Planes

david weaver

I'd like to hear from more such-motivated folks, too. I'm convinced that the appreciation for wooden planes goes along with doing more than smoothing wood.

I don't know that there are too many people doing that, though (really doing much without a power planer and jointer).

I think it will become more popular, but if it's 1% of people working wood terminally, that'd be a lot.

re: the 604, I haven't found anything more practical for smoothing than stanley's smoothers with their fabulously designed cap irons and the older irons are excellent, too.

Re: Wooden Planes

#5

Re: Wooden Planes

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I still find my 604 my most used tool in my shop,but more and more I use a wooden scrub, jack, and joiners. I am a little grey and long in the tooth to make such a switch,but I get so much more feedback from wooden planes.

Hi Ron

I have preferences with woodies which you may care to explore.

Firstly, nothing glides across wood like wood. Rarely do I need to lubricate the sole of a woodie.

I am a fan of razee styled or low-slung woodies. These offer the best feedback as you are closer to the work and there is less thickness to absorb vibrations.

I have not built any woodies for a few years. If I were, however, they would all have a double iron and a common angle bed. There is much versatility using a chipbreaker with jointers and smoothers. All the ones I built were single irons and high beds for tearout. They continue to work well, but a lower bed would be less effort to push.

The only plane that still only needs a single iron is a jack used for coarse work. This is the one I built, and it is very sweet ..


Have a look at the HNT Gordon range for low slung/razee woodies. Terry Gordon builts them with single irons and high beds (high cutting angles suit Aussie woods), but I would like to see them perform with a common angle and double iron.

Here is a HNT Gordon Trying Plane I modified with a handle. It is used as a short jointer on narrow boards ...


The Gordon is closest the camera. At the rear is a 28" razee jointer.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Wooden Planes

#6

Re: Wooden Planes

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have used steel smoother and jointer and wooden jack and trying plane for almost forty years. The biggest factor is how much time I use these planes. Almost all the work is done with jack and trying plane which are much more comfortable and less tiring to use than the iron counterparts.

The smoothing plane is used just to clean off dirt, pencil marks, scuffing after joinery, just one or two passes. The jointer plane likewise is used for very little actual work after the edge is trued with jack and straightedge. For these I find the ease of adjustment of the Bailey design is helpful. I haven't seriously experimented with wooden smoothers since the 1970's; maybe I will yet go that direction.

Re: Wooden Planes

#7

Re: Wooden Planes

Brian Holcombe

My setup is pretty similar to Warren's, wooden jack/trying plane metal smoother/jointer and just the same I'm using the jack and try plane more than any other planes in my shop.

With the David's guidance (and planes!) and having studied many of Warren's posts I've made my routine quite practical, quick and I can work all day without tiring to the point of exhaustion...and work with minimal touch up (almost nothing for tearout usually)

I have a wooden Kanna as well, love using that, but basically I use it for putting a final bright finish on parts...it does a fine job of that.

The Kanna is awesome, i really enjoy using it, but it has not taken the place of my bronze 4, which is just a super easy plane to use and tune. The kanna can be involved to tune.

Re: Wooden Planes

#8

Re: Wooden Planes

TomD

If you started in the 70s like I did, there was a prevailing view that wooden planes were better than metal, which was a lot more tenable back then with the junk that was being made at the time. I think it is still a tenable view, but not because you can get a better surface or finer shaving with a wooden plane as was claimed back then. Because of all the planes you could need, only a very few are available in metal. They are very expensive for what is a fast to make and simple tool. Wooden planes are faster to cycle through sharpening; lighter; there are more fundamentally different designs available (not talking type, but very different versions of the same thing), so more choice; They have less drag; are warm in the hand; if you make them yourself, they will fit you and your work; they don't rust in normal shop conditions, or have other bad habits; And so forth.

One thing I like about making my own tools is that they are satisfying. While I have repeatedly made the same tool as I grew as a maker, I do not ever feel like just making something because I read about it in FWW, or saw it here. I sometimes make tools that are better than what could be bought, but I always make tools that are more fitted to my work, and more fitted to me. It is the same as making one's own furniture or boats (as designed by oneself). The whole process is better, you use stuff that is available, you make it to fit your work, and you. Custom made clothes, furniture, or tools are all better than what is available mass produced, a lesson we have largely lost in a world of millionaires with jeans, though probably a lot of those jeans are tailored. Levis has a custom shop, you know.

Re: Wooden Planes

#9

Re: Kanna, shoulda, woulda...

TomD

Kannas normally require some woodwork to set up, but once they are ready, they are the easiest to set and use of any plane I know. And they are far more useful in roughing, relative to polishing, than other wooden planes, they will rip wood off like an axe. They are easy to make. I made my first 45 years ish ago, and there was little information other than Odate, which did not cover making. I still use that plane today, and the class I attended about 15 years ago, everyone there made a working plane is little time, and they all did very good work.

That original plane of mine has never been right, and I have another just like it in that respect. The blades were always a little loose, and have stayed on average a little loose with shavings added, and so forth. Both still work like champs. There is a myth that everything about a Japanese plane has to be perfect or it won't deliver perfection. The second one I made way back took a 4 tens shaving, and people basically thought I was lying years ago when I brought it up. Though now that everyone is doing it, the whole thing seems quaint. It was made out of white oak, and the bearing on one side was looser than the other, and it was shimmed up with maple shavings.

Re: Wooden Planes

#10

Re: Wooden Planes smoothing.

TomD

David. In general I think you are right about the reason people choose wooden planes today. But originally the Krenov and Japanese planes were pursued because people thought only those planes were capable of the results in smoothing. To some extent that is still true with Japanese planes, though with all the effort put into smoothing people are getting what they want in all types of planes. Infills are also taking a similar hit. Also, I think the german planes have largely been forgotten in the US market, and they do some interesting smoothers.

Re: Wooden Planes

#11

Re: Wooden Planes

TomD

"I have not built any woodies for a few years. If I were, however, they would all have a double iron and a common angle bed. There is much versatility using a chipbreaker with jointers and smoothers. All the ones I built were single irons and high beds for tearout. They continue to work well, but a lower bed would be less effort to push."

Having seen your woods, I can see why you would do that. And it is consensus. But there are many useful single bit smoother applications out there. And there are certainly low angle uses for different bedding angles, and being wood, it costs one virtually nothing to have different types.

Re: Wooden Planes

#12

Re: Wooden Planes smoothing.

david weaver

Yes on the continentals. I keep two, but I didn't make them (I will make one at some point). Both of mine are chinese made, and they are a smoother but a capable two handed plane when working heavy, too.

Re: Wooden Planes

#13

Re: Kanna, shoulda, woulda...

david weaver

I've got a little of both, I like flattening work with western planes. Jack work is about the same speed with either type, but western irons are more convenient to sharpen and reset if the set matters.

The enticement for a bright surface finish is always there with a japanese smoother because of how bright they can leave an unfinished surface - especially on a softwood.

I haven't noticed much speed difference between the two types of wooden planes in use, though, just that my western woodies are better set up and quicker to resharpen (and have more clearance).

Personally, I think a japanese jack (which you rarely see anyone talk about) is a very useful plane for a white collar woodworker to have around. I doubt most white collar woodworkers can work three push planes in heavy work for too long, but if one of the planes that does a lot of work is pulled instead, you can extend your working sessions by a very long time - indefinitely, I guess, and it builds dexterity and familiarity for pulling other planes (like continental smoothers).

Re: Wooden Planes

#14

Re: Kanna, shoulda, woulda...

Brian Holcombe

For the most part I enjoy the work, but they're certainly more work initially than getting a western plane ready.

For the Yokoyama I setup, I had to remove twist from the blade and tap out one corner. Not a big deal, but slightly unnerving to a new user. The Dai scraper kanna from Kikuhiromaru required similar work. Probably a hair overboard in both cases, but I wanted the uraba and the ashi to be right.

Resetting them, I think both have their pros and cons. For the chipper on a woody I set it in the sweet spot and fine tune if need be, for the kanna I can keep tapping until I find the perfect spot.

Re: Wooden Planes

#15

Re: Kanna, shoulda, woulda...

Ron Harper

I kniw nuthin about kannas, but I find it hard to believe that they can get pine any slicker thay my Spiers infill can.

Re: Wooden Planes

#16

Re: Kanna, shoulda, woulda...

david weaver

I don't know about slicker, but brighter. the softer the wood, the bigger the difference.

It's so bright though (reflective) that it has to be absolutely perfect. Any edge defect stands out (small chipout, whatever).

Hard to believe that there's anything to it until you see it.

Probably no difference in brightness once you wax or finish a surface, though.

Re: Wooden Planes

#17

Re: Kanna, shoulda, woulda...

TomD

I don't know if I made that claim, though the basis of it would be 3 fold:

1) they tried. Western woodworking does not to my knowledge try to make a lot of natural finish pine polished to the point where it doesn't need a finish. You are lucky if the mill marks are out. If you don't try you don't get. But today we have people doing all kinds of things, probably inspired by the Japanese example directly or indirectly, that the western planes were never intended to do, and they probably can, ish.

2) There really is nothing to compare to Japanese blades or sharpening or integration of the two, in the western world. You would be getting to the point well past diminishing returns, but the gear is there. The Spiers is based on the idea, the blade is along for the ride, and the Japanese on the idea the body is along for the ride.

3) The way the bottom is done on a Japanese plane is probably superior for results, but can be done on any plane, and probably doesn't add anything visible.

4) Japanese planes are light, the lightest of all. They are specifically designed to be worked very fast. Velocity means more cutting power, a spears is not so designed.

5) Much wider blades are commonly available which has advantages for finish. And is part of the whole "they are actually doing it and have been for a thousand years" deal.

Go to a competition and see how you do. Particularly since they are slow, the odds are higher than around the jobsite.

Re: Wooden Planes

#18

Re: Kanna, shoulda, woulda...

TomD

"For the most part I enjoy the work, but they're certainly more work initially than getting a western plane ready."

A Japanese pro, can by hand, with a roughing machine make six planes in a morning, set and ready to cut. I remember a time, and still hold some resentment when it took forever, or never to get western planes to cut even decently. Today we have Planes that will work right out of the box from many makers, because the people using them demand it, and in many cases are not up to doing the work themselves anyway. The reason Japanese planes are not done that way, since really over the last thirty years that was more a Japanese trademark, delivering the good experience, Miyata vs K car kind of deal, is because the culture of pros doesn't demand it.

"For the Yokoyama I setup, I had to remove twist from the blade and tap out one corner. Not a big deal, but slightly unnerving to a new user. The Dai scraper kanna from Kikuhiromaru required similar work. Probably a hair overboard in both cases, but I wanted the uraba and the ashi to be right."

Blades do require work, because that is how the carpenters want them, they want to do the work on their gear and stones. There are very cheap blades that work great, and even HSS, so one can just grind out flaws. I remember doing it on the floor on the 600 stone, and I did not like it, though I probably got the best results that way. One does not have to spend big money on a blade, it is just that is all that is being sent our way at the moment.

"Resetting them, I think both have their pros and cons. For the chipper on a woody I set it in the sweet spot and fine tune if need be, for the kanna I can keep tapping until I find the perfect spot."

Most of my work does not require a breaker. If people wanted breakers that could be instantly set on Kannas, that would be a trivial design issue. But without that, I find setting the breaker on a Kanna fiddly. I can cycle a Kanna, remove remount blade, in about 10 seconds. An extra 10 seconds to hit a particular number like 1 thou shaving. I can't do that on a western plane, though one probably could if it had all the right bells and whistles, like a clifton breaker, a fine adjuster, and thumb screw to release the blade.