Re: Kanna, shoulda, woulda...
TomD
"For the most part I enjoy the work, but they're certainly more work initially than getting a western plane ready."
A Japanese pro, can by hand, with a roughing machine make six planes in a morning, set and ready to cut. I remember a time, and still hold some resentment when it took forever, or never to get western planes to cut even decently. Today we have Planes that will work right out of the box from many makers, because the people using them demand it, and in many cases are not up to doing the work themselves anyway. The reason Japanese planes are not done that way, since really over the last thirty years that was more a Japanese trademark, delivering the good experience, Miyata vs K car kind of deal, is because the culture of pros doesn't demand it.
"For the Yokoyama I setup, I had to remove twist from the blade and tap out one corner. Not a big deal, but slightly unnerving to a new user. The Dai scraper kanna from Kikuhiromaru required similar work. Probably a hair overboard in both cases, but I wanted the uraba and the ashi to be right."
Blades do require work, because that is how the carpenters want them, they want to do the work on their gear and stones. There are very cheap blades that work great, and even HSS, so one can just grind out flaws. I remember doing it on the floor on the 600 stone, and I did not like it, though I probably got the best results that way. One does not have to spend big money on a blade, it is just that is all that is being sent our way at the moment.
"Resetting them, I think both have their pros and cons. For the chipper on a woody I set it in the sweet spot and fine tune if need be, for the kanna I can keep tapping until I find the perfect spot."
Most of my work does not require a breaker. If people wanted breakers that could be instantly set on Kannas, that would be a trivial design issue. But without that, I find setting the breaker on a Kanna fiddly. I can cycle a Kanna, remove remount blade, in about 10 seconds. An extra 10 seconds to hit a particular number like 1 thou shaving. I can't do that on a western plane, though one probably could if it had all the right bells and whistles, like a clifton breaker, a fine adjuster, and thumb screw to release the blade.