New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

wenge infill questions

Posts

wenge infill questions

#1

wenge infill questions

Bruce, a MN Galoot

A long time ago I got the St James Bay infill smoother kit, really just a casting and associated parts. It comes rough and everything needs to be done to it. I think most of the metal work has been mostly finished except for drilling some holes for pins and figuring out how to mount the lever cap.

Last week an ugly question reared its head. I've been working on a wenge infill for this thing because that's what Woodcraft had at the time and I thought it looked nice. It was fairly heavy and moderately dense, but what did I know...

Anyway, I was doing some fairly heavy-duty sanding-shaping and later that evening sat down to an extended period of mild abdominal cramps, which, it turns out, is one of the prominent features of wenge. Yippee!

Okay, here's the first question:

Is there any finish that can be applied to wenge to prevent further reactions? If so, what. If not, am I likely to encounter such a reaction again if I will only be holding it and not inhaling sanding dust?

Second question:

If the wenge needs to be scrapped, is it copacetic to use glued up stock for an infill? Turns out I have a nice piece of inch-thick cocobolo, also allergenic but I don't seem to react to it (at least not yet.)

Bear in mind that this is not a showpiece, just a nice smoother for home use.

TIA

Re: wenge infill questions

#2

Re: wenge infill questions

david weaver

You'll want a solid piece for the bun in the front, but you could do perfectly fine with your cocobolo laminated in the rear of the plane.

I have only made three infill planes, so I'm by no means an expert on it, but my preferred method for the back of a plane is a solid billet cut and then reglued so that you can match the sides of the plane well and then have a nice handle, too. Pieces of cocobolo for a bun are probably not that hard to come by, though maybe coming by them dry is a little taller of an order.

All of that said, you could still laminate the cocobolo for the bun, too, and stain or oil it very dark and it should look classy. I've glued mine (cocobolo and bois de rose) with hide glue and had no issues. It's confined and pinned, anyway.

Re: wenge infill questions

#3

Re: wenge infill questions

E Snow

I too have weird toxicity issues with some woods, so bad that to complete one project I had to buy a space suit. Hood, gloves, forced air, the whole nine. That piece is still in my house and I touch it daily since it holds my keys and wallet, no further issues. The finish is just shellac and wax, mostly wax to tell the truth.

The culprit was the dust and the oils sticking to me as well as breathing it. Eventually, my poison oak like symptoms went away and my eyes opened back up.

Once you've shaped and waxed/oiled it there is not going to be a whole lot of opportunity for either to attack you again.

My experience is anecdotal but I'd be tempted to suit up, finish up, and roll with it.

Re: wenge infill questions

#4

Re: wenge infill questions

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Thanks for that info, David. I haven't decided whether to stick with the wenge or change to cocobolo, yet. I have a lot of work already into the wenge one, but there's no disputing that the cocobolo would look better.

Re: wenge infill questions

#5

Re: wenge infill questions

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Thanks for the good report on any followup problems with the wenge. I was really surprised by my reaction to it and certainly don't want to risk any further problems. I also don't know if my reaction to wenge portends any potential problems with the cocobolo. Walnut dust causes problems for me, too, entirely of a bronchial and sinusitis nature, mostly like getting an instant cold. I appreciate the help.

Re: wenge infill questions

#6

Re: wenge infill questions

David Charlesworth

I would advise caution with Cocobolo dust.

It is renowned for causing nasty allergies.

After one handle and bun, I will never touch it again.

David

Re: wenge infill questions

#7

Re: wenge infill questions

CJ in MPLS

While it is yet another anecdote, cocobolo bothers me, but wenge makes me ill. I just used cocobolo to handle a knife and I was reminded why I went out and bought a respirator that is better than those disposable face masks. The respirator is enough for that stuff.

The one time I made something from wenge my eyes, sinuses, throat and lungs burned. At this point I'd go so far as to say the stuff is ugly too, but I may be a bit less than objective in this opinion.

Re: wenge infill questions

#8

Re: wenge infill questions

david weaver

I forgot to make a comment on the second part of the question - what to do if you keep the wenge.

I'd probably seal it with shellac and call it good. It would be easy to refresh in the future if you need to.

You could choose something entirely different than either, too, but as you've probably found out, getting good stock over 2 inches wide is not necessarily easy. KD walnut blanks might be another option.

Re: wenge infill questions

#9

Re: wenge infill questions

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Is it the silica content that does it? I have had no exposure to cocobolo yet. I bought a chunk to make a tote for a backsaw that came with an ugly one but that has remained on my round toit list for some time. Given your warning and my experience it might be a good idea to use apple or some other domestic hardwood. Oops, not walnut - that gives me respiratory problems, too.

Re: wenge infill questions

#10

Re: wenge infill questions

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Thanks, Chris. It's interesting to me that the end grain of this wenge actually looks better than the side grain. Anyway, it's mostly done so I will have to weigh the negatives. Cocobolo looks better, but they're both nasty.

No more of this exotic stuff. Domestic hardwoods for me from now on, yessirree Bob!

Re: wenge infill questions

#11

Corroboration

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Bill Clark of Clark & Williams developed a severe allergic reaction to cocobolo. Multiple trips to ER. He sold me his cocobolo smoother; allergy went way beyond simply milling it. Once he was sensitized, he couldn't touch the wood.

Wiley

Re: wenge infill questions

#12

Re: wenge infill questions

Paul M

Beyond the wenge sensitization, I would question the wood being used for an infill. Wenge is the nastiest splinter generating wood I've ever encountered. Splinters literally leap off that wood to attack you. It splits easily during weather changes too, so it is not a stable wood. I'm not sensitized to wenge, but I despise it due to the awful qualities of that wood.

I used a little bit of cocobolo exactly once. I used it for the binding edge of a guitar. When I was leveling the exposed binding to the sides of a guitar with a scraper, I was repeatedly rubbing my wrists against the freshly scraped surface. I had poison ivy like lumps up and down my wrists. Luckily it went away rather quickly with a dose of benedryl and did not require an ER trip. I gave away the couple of small boards of cocobolo I had and won't touch that stuff again.

Re: wenge infill questions

#13

Re: wenge infill questions

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Your response, coupled with everyone else's, makes me think I should use pine for the infill :O . I get very nasty reactions from cedar splinters, too. You should've seen my hands when I finished building my canoe.

Re: wenge infill questions

#14

Re: Pine

david weaver

I mention this half as a spoof. There are two woods that I know I have sensitivity to, cocobolo a little bit, and cherry dust (in the rare times that I sand cherry, I have a reaction that feels like bronchitis).

Cocobolo varies for me with how oily the blank is. If the blank is very oily, then it's worse than blanks that are more dry.

But, anyway, the point was pine. In my youth, there was a local toymaker who sold at the same craft shows my mother did (long deceased now). He was sensitized only to one thing to his knowledge. Pine! He switched toys to walnut and maple back then.

(Not that I think it's likely most people will ever become sensitized to it - I've never met anyone else who developed a sensitivity to pine except those who are allergic to it from the start. The aforementioned toymaker wasn't, and became sensitized to it due to overexposure, I guess)

Re: wenge infill questions

#15

Question?

Tony - Memphis

I've been building a cabinet for my wife for Christmas and I think I may be reacting as you did. About a month ago, I was diagnosed with bronchitis (around the time I got started on the cabinet). Yesterday, I did lots of sanding on said cabinet (I wear an N100 mask, run the air clearner, etc.) and about 4am I woke with a nasty cough. Just wondering if it couold be the woood - figured sappele (not sure about the spelling). I've never had a reaction to any wood that I was aware of. I have an appointment with the doc today. What did they do to treat you?

Working the wood for the last month hasn't bothered me that I noticed, but the sanding may have done me in. My clothes were covered in dust.

Thanks,

Tony

Re: wenge infill questions

#16

Re: Question?

david weaver

I've had asthma all my life (but only symptomatic in adulthood when some sort of sickness is present), and my cough calms down with an albuterol inhaler. Sometimes with severe bronchitis, the breathing restriction stops with albuterol but the cough persists, and you need a cough suppressant, too.

I'm no doc, and I may not be remembering everything, but if you have colored phleghm after a few days (and not just irritation), it's typical for actual bronchitis to get an antibiotic.

I've never gotten full blown in-need-of-antibiotic bronchitis from wood, just the cough that propagates and restricts breathing because of my history of mostly childhood asthma.

If you get breathing restriction and it's acute and uncomfortable, I'd ask for albuterol.

(I have nearly stopped sanding things and will only do so if planing and scraping won't suffice - and I hate to say it, but I also bought a fein vacuum a couple of years ago and a festool small finish sander - ETS 125 or something - for the rare times I'm sanding something I really didn't want to make in the first place, it is a nice combination and I don't get an asthmatic response).

Re: wenge infill questions

#17

Re: Question?

Tony - Memphis

Actually, I just got back and she gave me the inhaler. I had a similar bout about a month ago. She also gave me a roid shot for immediate relief. Mine is a bit different. Just the cough. No repiratory issues (no wheezing, shortness of breath, etc.). I am allergic to lots of stuff and get a shot weekly. My cough is not productive, but I feel like it would help if it was. Anyway, I'm no much of a sander either. This was all by hand, but I did make a lot of dust anyway. If the wood is the culprit, it is the first time ever. I hate sanding anyway, so it would behoove me to learn to live without it for multiple good reasons!

Tony

Re: wenge infill questions

#18

Re: Question?

david weaver

Ditto that on the sanding, what got me in trouble was doing it by hand - all of that dust just ends up wafting up under your nose. Thus the ROS - I would personally rather sand by hand, it's more satisfying and with fresh paper, it's just as fast.

Ditto also on the cough, it's not productive after you first wake up (it might come up with something), and all day it just keeps happening without ever amounting to anything. That's just the way it is with the post-sickness part of bronchitis. You have the cough, it does nothing but make noise and possibly give you a headache and muscle aches in the ribcage and sternum, and it can last several weeks. Sucks!!

My wife gets annoyed because it's like undesirable background noise to her.

Hope yours subsides soon. At least you have an idea now what might be triggering it.

Re: wenge infill questions

#19

wood toxicity

David Charlesworth

Somewhere there is a good page on wood toxicity.

I would not be at all surprised if Sapele was on that list.

Cocobolo is near the top !!

best wishes,

David

Re: wenge infill questions

#20

Re: Question?

TomD

When I was building guitars, an activity that seems to kill practitioners rather young, I had a cheap Shopvac QSP with goretex filter that I imagine is the equal of a Fein. one of those box purifiers, and an airmate helmet. In the main though, if it needs sanding it gets done outside the shop. When you think of the time some people spend on hobbies, in some cases a whole other job, and the spaces are often much less airfull that pro spaces, filling them with dusts is not a safe option. It's the gift that keeps taking.

For a lot of people woodworking is a seasonal activity, in the winter, and so they "can't" wait to sand stuff out of doors, though you don't always have to wait. But I just won't do it indoors.

Re: wenge infill questions

#21

Re: wood toxicity

david weaver

I have seen versions of that table, I'd imagine that many places posting it are scavenging it from an original source (i.e., that there is probably one or two original sources).

In the ones I've seen Cocobolo is near the top, only squeezed out in scare letters by sassafrass, oleander and yew.

I've never worked any of the latter three, but the first piece of oily cocobolo I used smelled nice and made me cough. It took quite some time to get sensitized to cherry dust - several years, I guess? But it is as bad as cocobolo is for me (100x as many exposures, probably).

Robert ___ (can't recall his last name), the toymaker I referenced who was extremely sensitized to pine only became so sensitized after decades of carving it and making toys from it.