New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Drawer bottom

Posts

Drawer bottom

#1

Drawer bottom

Svante

Hi,

I am working on a drawer unit for a desk. Normally I always have the grain direction of the drawer bottom parallell to the drawer front. In this case the drawers are approx 300mm (12") wide and 600mm (24") deep. Any reason to change?

Best regards,

Svante

Re: Drawer bottom

#2

Re: Drawer bottom

david weaver

What is the function of this overlay? That orientation is more commonly a mock door than a drawer front.

Re: Drawer bottom

#3

Re: Drawer bottom

TomD

There are two reasons for that orientation that both seem to apply in your case. One is that structurally you get the strongest drawer bottom, and the stiffest drawer bottom by carrying the grain across the shortest dimension, which in this case is the width. The other reason is that cross grain expansion is greatest, and in constructions where the back of the drawer is left open, that expansion can be accommodated by allowing the cross grain to move towards the back where the tolerances are more generous normally.

Such an approach is based on certain assumptions, so you can proceed differently if you wish. Plywood is an obvious choice for any drawer bottom, though it is less posh, it is in many ways superior. You can create frames. Lots of ways to go.

Re: Drawer bottom

#4

Kent B

Re: Drawer bottom

Kent B

Yeah - what TomD said.

Re: Drawer bottom

#6

Ellis Walentine

Not sure I understand reason #1

...structurally you get the strongest drawer bottom, and the stiffest drawer bottom by carrying the grain across the shortest dimension, which in this case is the width.

This is true, but if it were the only reason, we'd be making typical drawers -- which are usually wider than deep -- and then what would we do with the cross-grain expansion? I submit that solid wood bottoms really need to have breathing room out the back of the drawer, regardless of the ratio of width to depth. Sure, you could frame them in some kind of slip arrangement --or use plywood and glue them in if you really want a stiff drawer, but I always prefer to use solid wood and run the grain side to side on my best work. Plywood is a useful expedient on cabinets and built ins and office drawers.

Ellis

Re: Drawer bottom

#7

Re: Not sure I understand reason #1

TomD

As I said, there are dual benefits that both seem to apply in the OP's case. You don't get both in all cases, though one could argue as an editor, that I buried the lead, as I often do , and reason two is reason one, though I was not really selling the order.

The other way to get the stiffness advantage is to have dual panels separated by a middle divider. Basic structural principle is to use structure to divide into as many equal cells as possible with an eye to grain orientation. So in a boat or a fuselage, you have bulkheads, curvature, and grain orientation (and as Sponge Bob says "some other unspecified thing"), and you use them to create panel segments consistent with the structural properties of the skin.

I think some fine furniture is made with enclosed panels in the bottom, and am not sure why that is not more often done. My guess would be that the allowances that drawer sides provide are not sufficient to accommodate design goals. Some high end drawers may have frames glued to the bottom, which does a number of things including reducing rub wear. As one author put it in reference to some of the more common, high end methods: "They wouldn't even last 100 years".

Re: Drawer bottom

#8

overengineered drawers

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The English would tell us that we make drawer sides needlessly thick and similarly bottoms too thick. Short of storing one's gold collection in the drawer it is unlikely even a 1/4" bottom in a large drawer will fail. A light weight drawer becomes pleasant to use, sliding effortlessly in use. I suspect, if tested, the weak link in a drawer is the dado the bottom fits in. Given the at least 3 sided support the bottom receives even a thin bottom becomes stiff enough. I have come to emulate the English drawers I see in antique stores- thin, light weight solid wood bottoms. Pine and basswood make dandy bottoms. A caveat here.... some early English drawers had the grain running the "wrong way, no idea why, and they are invariably split.

Re: Drawer bottom

#9

Re: overengineered drawers

Svante

Thanks for all knowledge. I think I stay with having the grain direction parallell to the drawer front.


Svante

Re: Drawer bottom

#10

pretty wood

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

What is going into this piece? Is it a file cabinet?

Re: Drawer bottom

#11

Re: overengineered drawers

TomD

Light drawers may even hold up better as they put less stress on themselves and the case. It is something to look at drawers that are almost as light as cigar boxes.

As far as 1/4" plywood is concerned, while it is a very different world, but one can stand in a boat whose bottom is 1/4" plywood, and in the world of trimarans the planking is often in that range up to 35 feet. Strong stuff indeed.

Speaking of gold. I have seen silver drawers blow apart. Pay particular attention to the construction of the back, that is where they blow. Dovetails are good, but nails or biscuits are better than finger joints, from what I have seen.

By the way, the underlayment that in nicer version is often what they make drawer bottoms out of, currently is being made in sheets where the top grain is not aligned with the greatest strength or stiffness. Flex test it.

Re: Drawer bottom

#12

Re: Drawer bottom

Dan Rode

I always orient the drawer bottom grain parallel to the drawer front. The main reason for this is expansion. If the wood expands side to side, it has the potential to push the sides out causing the drawer to stick. In dry weather, it might shrink enough for gaps to show.

Since wood is stable in the grain direction, the drawer fit should be consistent through the seasons. It's pretty easy to allow for expansion toward the back where there is generally room.

I sometimes glue the panel into the front and use slot and screw at the back. Other times just the screw or it can even be left loose.

As for the thickness, I like 1/2" or 3/8" drawer sides and 3/8" or 1/4" bottoms. Mostly this is because these sizes are easy to work with. Nothing wrong with 5/16" sides and 3/16" bottom, I just don't use then often.