New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Card Scraper Problems

Posts

Card Scraper Problems

#1

Card Scraper Problems

Don Emmerling

I have a set of 3 card scrapers from Crown Tools (Sheffield) that I purchased recently. I have used card scrapers in the past with no problem. My problem is that I cannot raise a bur on the scraper. I lost my burnisher some time ago and am using a screw driver to raise a bur. After repeated attempts I cannot even raise the suggestion of a bur. This should be an easy task but somehow it is just not working. Any suggestions on what to use as a burnisher. I had a nice bur on these scrappers before so I know it is not the metal.

Regards,

Don

Re: Card Scraper Problems

#2

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Card Scraper Problems

Jack Guzman from Maine

A screwdriver is probably too soft. You need hardened steel or carbide. It has to be harder than your scraper. Some chisel handles work. I use a carbide rod I got from Andy Lincoln. He may still sell them. A router bit would probably work also.---Jack

Re: Card Scraper Problems

#3

Re: Card Scraper Problems

Bruce, a MN Galoot

The shank of a large drill bit will work, too.

Are you prepping the edge by filing and honing it first? I know some people don't bother honing, but I always do and have found that it makes a difference.

Re: Card Scraper Problems

#4

Jack Guzman from Maine

chisel handles?

Jack Guzman from Maine

Correction,chisel shaft. I doubt that a chisel handle would help much.---Jack

Re: Card Scraper Problems

#5

Re: Card Scraper Problems

Jerry Roberts

Bruce, I used a large drill bit as an auger too. I could never raise a burr either and I used files to even the edge and flat surfaces. Do I need a true auger or what am I doing wrong . Ive read a lot about sharpening card scrapers But Ive never been able to.

Re: Card Scraper Problems

#6

Re: Card Scraper Problems

TomD

Obviously there are carbide bits also, both drills and all carbide router bits, but also carbide edges on some bit that would work in a pinch.

As you know, some scrapers are used very delicately or powerfully after nothing more than sharpening direct off the stones or power set up. It isn't necessary to burnish them at all, though it would be necessary if you wanted to re-raise the burrs. But the point is that it sure helps if the edge is really sharp or drawn out from sharpening. One of the problems people have with sharpening is not taking the earlier steps like grinding, or working the mid-stones, far enough. Say to the wire edge point. Same thing with burnishing. Basically if it was these very cards you previously burnished with those very screw drivers, but all of a sudden it no longer works, I would say the "sharpening" step is at fault.

Re: Card Scraper Problems

#7

Re: Card Scraper Problems

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I've never used an auger bit, only a twist bit. If that doesn't work then I suggest getting a regular carbide burnisher. It's worth the expense. A sharp card scraper is a wonderful thing.

Re: Card Scraper Problems

#8

2 steps to sharp *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

As Tom notes above, it is important to obtain clean, square edges before proceeding. This is the first step to preparing a scraper. A rounded edge cannot be turned into a hook.

It is possible to scrape with just a square edge and no hook, however this will not last long since a hook is needed to cut. A honed corner will scrape briefly but not cut. (The exception is a draw-filed or edge off a grinder. These create a burr that acts as a hook).

The second step is to create the hook. To do this effectively the burnisher needs to be harder than the scraper's steel. I use carbide (rod, router bit shaft), but HSS should work as well (drill bit, router bit shaft). Turning a hook is done in three stages: drawing out the edge, turning a shallow hook, and then extending the angle of the hook further (see below for link to my pictorial on this).

Regards from Perth

Derek


Preparing a Cabinet Scraper

Re: Card Scraper Problems

#9

Unflat sides

David Charlesworth

I recently did some checking of new scraper stock.

The surfaces are surprisingly not flat.

This may lead to only two edges touching a flat stone and becoming sharp!

The screwdriver shaft is highly unlikely to work. I think this is a very misleading tale, possibly from ancient days when scrapers were very soft indeed.

David

Re: Card Scraper Problems

#10

Re: Unflat sides

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I recently did some checking of new scraper stock.

The surfaces are surprisingly not flat.

This may lead to only two edges touching a flat stone and becoming sharp!

Hi David

That's not surprising! ;)

I recommend taking the time to flatten all sides. Also why I suggest marking the edge to ensure one catches the highs and lows.

Chris Schwarz has applied your Ruler Trick to scraper edges as a short cut to flattening. I am not sure about the validity of this method - how does the slight backbevel affect the ability to draw out the steel? I would assume that it would make the process more difficult to achieve.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Card Scraper Problems

#11

Re: Card Scraper Problems

JDK

Gary Rogowski once pointed out that when raising the burr, use no more pressure than when buttering untoasted bread. This piece of advice has always worked for me, and I've never had trouble raising a burr since.

Re: Card Scraper Problems

#12

That may be an

Brian Roberts

exaggeration.....

Even my smallest, thinnest, most flexible, curved (for violin work) scrapers require more force than that to form a burr.

The burnisher needs to be polished and lubed....and the process involves several strokes at increasing angles ....the final angle depending on the intended use ....that is...the wood species and whether for shaping or cleanup.

Just what I was taught in violin repair school....and it has served me well.

Re: Card Scraper Problems

#13

Re: That may be an

Bruce, a MN Galoot

In one of Tage Frid's books, he suggests that no more than 3 ounces of pressure is needed to turn a burr. At the time I was having a problem getting a decent burr and tried his suggestion. While it might actually be more than that, I found that only a light touch was necessary. Too heavy a hand resulted in a burr that didn't work for me.

Re: Card Scraper Problems

#14

Re: Unflat sides

David Charlesworth

Derek,

Ruler technique, (we are going upmarket!) is purely a way of helping to get the corners sharp. I have found it very useful over the years.

David

Re: Card Scraper Problems

#15

Re: That may be an

JDK

It might be an exaggeration, but I've had great success turning burrs with very light pressure.

Preparation is important, as has been noted above, but I can turn a burr many times on a properly tuned card scraper before I have to once again joint and hone its edge.

Re: Card Scraper Problems

#16

Re: Unflat sides

TomD

Scrapers are fundamentally not precision tools dimensionally. Scraper planes in contrast can be used to create the very fussy dimensions of bamboo fly rods; but card scrapers, do we really need to go all coo coo obsessive. Push them up against a sander and you can get burrs the size of handle bar moustaches.

Re: Card Scraper Problems

#17

more on this pressure thing....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The hand pressure will depend on the shape of the burnisher. The tighter the radius the greater the pounds per square inch on the edge for the same pressure from the hand. I have to use what I would describe as modest force with a 1/4" carbide rod on a Sandvick scraper metal.

Re: Card Scraper Problems

#18

Re: Unflat sides

David Charlesworth

Some scraper prep is more precise than others!

If you lay a new cad scraper flat on a stone, you will generally find that only two edges make contact.

David

Re: Card Scraper Problems

#19

Re: Unflat sides

TomD

That sounds right, as in those dimensions it probably comes off a roll. But I wonder why I care. One thing I do with drywall tools, which are also rarely flat, is pick and edge. You could get a naturally convex edge, which can be an advantage.

But even baring that, the stock is usually pretty shiny, and it only really needs to be ground down on the edge. But of course your method will work superbly, my only point is that so does a faster approach in almost all circumstances, it depending on the result one wants, I guess. Will there be any sanding used after the scraping, as one issue. But I have seen people advocate sharpening all three side of the edge. Through multiple stones. Just seems like the long way around. If there is a more efficient way, unless it provably doesn't actually work, may be worth a try.

Re: Card Scraper Problems

#20

Re: Unflat sides

TomD

"Some scraper prep is more precise than others!"

Do you mean more time is spent to achieve a more precise tool, that yields no better result. Or do you mean you get a tool capable of more precise work. If the later (which I assume is your claim), what is this work? If one spends a lot of time making a more refined plane it will do things, like more precisely shoot an edge, or allow the taking of a finer shaving for improved surfaces. But what exactly is the yield on a tool like a scraper? One can get very refined cutting, but I rarely find it necessary, normally scraping gets final sanded, when I use it, there is no difference in methods of scraper prep. I do believe more refined prep yields a longer wearing edge, but I can go from bone dull to cutting in say 10 seconds. I don't see where the advantage lies in more careful prep, and the tools are cheap, so even a little more wear is no big deal.

Re: Card Scraper Problems

#21

Re: More accurately....

TomD

In two dimensions, a point of tangency is always a point. So there is no difference in psi for a given force. Once you exceed the yield point of the metal in the scraper, you get an area that you are bearing on and the arc of the circle of your burnisher, will have an impact. Keeping in mind that some burnishers are actually flat and have significant area, some are compound curves, and so forth.

Of course in that model you pretty much exceed the yield point at any level of pressure...

It is interesting to speculate how the flat ones with significant area actually work. I think some burnishers may be pulling and not just rolling or deforming the edge through penetration. But I don't know if that actually happens. Can there be an adhesion?

Re: Card Scraper Problems

#22

Re: Brass rod test.

TomD

Some have suggested that a burr can't be formed with a softer metal than that in the knife, which sounds reasonable enough. There is a test for knives in which a brass rod is used to deflect the edge, if it breaks, back to the drawing board, if it flexes back, then on to the cut testing. The brass rod is used probably to minimize damage to the edge, and to stick it to the rod a little. It is interesting that brass can roll the edge of a hardened blade, which is a lot harder than most scrapers. Not sure that translates to this case, but in addition to the fact that screw drivers are often referred to as capable of forming a burr, makes me wonder about dismissing the possibility.

Re: Card Scraper Problems

#23

The need for a polished side

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

On my last few projects I scraped some molding profiles. To cut quickly, it became clear that it was essential to have a refined surface ("polished") on the sides as well as the edge. Somehow I only recently realized that his same requirement should be true for a card scraper. I discovered it was not a trivial task to get the sides of my Sandvick scrapers "polished". On the micron scale they are certainly not flat.

We need to be careful of the interpretation of "polish" . One can have a shiny surface that is not scratch-free, which is why I prefer "refined" as a descriptor.

Re: Card Scraper Problems

#24

Drill bit?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The top (round) section of my twist drills are not very hard. If I get a burr on them it is easily removed with a file, which suggests too soft for scraper preparation. I doubt router bit shafts are very hard either to preserve their toughness. Stuff that is hard (Rc60 and greater) that can be found around the shop would include chisels, blades of most any kind, jointer and planer knives, lathe tools. If it isn't brittle it likely isn't hard enough. But, given how trivial it is to go buy a section of carbide rod from any machine tooling business (MSC, Travers, Enco etc.) or a solid carbide router bit, I don't see the need to recommend anything else.

Re: Card Scraper Problems

#25

Clint Searl

Re: Card Scraper Problems

Clint Searl

I like the look of an ogee edge on a table, so to clean up and finish the profile after several passes with different router bits, I made a detail scraper out of an old Stanley chisel. It was perfect for the job, and the handle made it comfortable for extended use.

Though I used a retired chisel without modification, it's a great opportunity to evaluate the concept under varying bevel angles and steel types. Nyuk nyuk