New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Green wood; A question or two and froes

Posts

Green wood; A question or two and froes

#1

Green wood; A question or two and froes

Patrick Gibbons

Cut down five Native American Elms in the backyard and intend on using the wood for green projects and chair parts. Coating the end grain with a sealer.

1) Do I need to debark?

2) can I store the logs outside or do I need to bring into the garage?

Anyone have any experience with the Froe Lee Valley sells that they would care to share?

Re: Green wood; A question or two and froes

#2

Re: Green wood; A question or two and froes

Steve Voigt

You need to get the parts split or sawn into billets ASAP. Drying outside is preferable to inside, provided you do it right--stacking the billets so there is plenty of air circulation and covered with ply or roofing, so they're protected from sun and rain. Storing inside is OK if the pieces are split into leg- and spindle-sized pieces; otherwise, I would dry them outside. Bottom line, leaving in log form is the worst thing you can do, unless you have a pond you can submerge the logs in.

Re: Green wood; A question or two and froes

#3

Elm can be impossible to split

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Have seen many elm Windsor chair? Or anything made of elm? Read up on elm before getting too excited about using this wood for projects.

At the very least you must quarter the logs sections for drying and seal ends . If you are serious about using this wood hire someone with a portable mill to come saw it up for you.

Re: Green wood; A question or two and froes

#4

Re: Green wood; A question or two and froes

Larry Barrett

I have no experience with elm. Here in Maryland I mostly use oak, hickory, cherry. As Steve says, it is important to get a log split into smaller pieces - quarters or even eighths depending on the size of the log. Once a log is on the ground, bugs love to hide under the bark and go to work on the sapwood, so taking off the bark is one of the next things to do. Sapwood too, unless you plan to use it. Drying outside is better than garage if your intent is to work the wood when it still contains considerable moisture.

As Bill says, elm has a reputation for being impossible to split. But even if it does split, I always start with steel wedges and a sledge to break the log down to quarters/eighths. After that I use a froe, or sometimes an axe, setting the axe edge on the line and hitting the back just like a froe.

I have not used the LV (or LN) froe. The main difference is how the handle is attached. The LV froe looks like it uses a more traditional handle, tapered at the bottom. The LN froe handle is held in place with a capscrew and large washer. With all the bashing and abuse that a froe takes, it is very nice to have the handle remain in place. I think you could easily modify the LV froe handle this way. I have two froes, both acquired years ago, and have modified the handles this way. Works well.

Re: Green wood; A question or two and froes

#5

Re: Green wood; A question or two and froes

Steve Voigt

Just a couple more thoughts:

Elm is a traditional wood in Windsor chairs, but air-dried for seats, not worked green for spindles and legs. I've made elm seats, and it worked out very nicely, though it's a lot tougher to carve than pine is.

The other thing is, even if you can split this stuff, it will be impossible to use up 5 trees before most of your stock is drier than you want for green work. Even the professionals typically do this one log at a time. Your best bet may be to saw (or have it sawn) into planks, some of it 8/4 for seats, and save the green woodworking for when you can get ONE log of a more suitable species, oak for example.

Re: Green wood; A question or two and froes

#6

question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

How did these trees escape the disease that killed them elsewhere?

Re: Green wood; A question or two and froes

#7

Dale Lenz

Re: question

Dale Lenz

Mature elms are quite common here in E. OK...

Re: Green wood; A question or two and froes

#8

Re: Elm can be impossible to split

William Duffield

I have seen Windsor chair seats made of elm, and there are probably a lot more that are painted and therefore not so easily identified as elm. If you like your Windsors with clear finish, to show off the different woods, elm makes a much more interesting seat than pine or tulip poplar. While it is difficult to work, due to the interlocking grain, the advantages of being very difficult to split after it has been turned into a product can easily outweigh the workability issues. A good example is wagon wheel hubs, which were almost exclusively made from elm. Nothing else would do before the invention of the processes for making iron wheels. Another appropriate candidate is tool handles, where the use of elm in certain situations may obviate the need for a metal ferrule.

Re: Green wood; A question or two and froes

#9

Re: question

William Duffield

There are still a very few American Elms alive on Ye Greate St. in Greenwich, although well past their prime. We've lost a couple recently to storms. Also, I have two small ones in my back yard, one planted from a seed from one of the trees on the main street, and one a seedling from the Dutch Elm Disease resistant "strain," Ulmus americana 'American Liberty.'

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ulmus_americana_%27American_Liberty%27

The Wikipedia article explains why I put the word "strain" in quotes.

Re: Green wood; A question or two and froes

#10

Re: question

Patrick Gibbons

Knock on wood, literally, I've not seen any disease here. I live across the street from Buffalo Bayou and elm is quite common here in the riparian forest, along with live oak, pecan, post oak, loblolly, cypress and eastern red cedar. Chinese tallow has been taking over for years. It's a dangerous tree that chokes out everything else.

Re: Green wood; A question or two and froes

#11

Re: Elm can be impossible to split

Patrick Gibbons

It's interesting people have assumed I meant Windsor chairs. I've read that elm bends well and I'm thinking about something more modern. I'm aware of elm's interlocking grain and was worried it wouldn't split. The logs are not large; 12"-16" on average tapering down to much smaller quickly. I'm afraid that treenware is the most probable use for my stock, other than firewood. Any good ideas?

Re: Green wood; A question or two and froes

#12

Re: Green wood; A question or two and froes

Patrick Gibbons

Elm sapwood is supposed to be as strong as heartwood. I'm so pressed for time that I'm probably going to waste most of this. Getting it processed will require more time than I have so I'll just do what I can.

Re: Green wood; A question or two and froes

#13

my point.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

.....was if it could be split and it had any strength one would see it in Windsor chair parts that were traditionally riven. One does not have to be building Windsor chairs to learn from the wood traditionally used in them, if the goal is riving and strength. There were certainly abundant elm trees to be had before 1960 if the wood was useful. Some commented on bottoms. I believe the conversation was riving pieces. Indeed with elm the exceptions confirm the rule. Elm doesn't have much value in furniture no doubt because of its properties.

Elm has no commercial value. I have never seen an elm log on a yard or elm lumber mentioned in the hardwood market reports. This fact means it has some serious limitations for building stuff, what ever they are, the occasional chair seat not withstanding.

That said I once sawed a large elm log. The wood had a lovely grain and pink hue, changing to a warm brown with age. It was light in weight and seemed weak. And apparently it has a huge response to changes in humidity for a panel split in a situation where I have never experienced a panel splitting.

Re: Green wood; A question or two and froes

#14

Re: my point.....

Sgian Dubh

Interesting comments Bill. I suspect your point of view is coloured by the American market, and the local elm available. Here in the UK, native elm, aka Dutch elm, was long a favoured wood for a wide range of uses, stretching through furniture, boat work, harbours and docks, and on to the boxes people were buried in (coffins).

I remember working the stuff for Windsor chair seats, tables and cabinetry back in the 70s when it was still plentiful, just at the time Dutch elm disease was decimating the large numbers of trees that could previously be found all over the place in England. Scotland on the other hand, still has a decent stock of living elms, but here too the disease is spreading its tentacles northwards year by year. Slainte.

Re: Green wood; A question or two and froes

#15

Re: my point.....

John Veerkamp

I like to turn elm. In fact I'm just finishing an American Elm crotch bowl with beautiful color and flame figure. American Elm while not common here in Western Missouri, it is not rare either, I have 17 acres, about 1/2 wooded . Had an 18" tree blown down in high winds earlier this week. Some great turning blanks and a lot of firer wood. It burns hot with very low ash residue.

Re: Green wood; A question or two and froes

#16

Re: question

William Duffield

Knowing absolutely nothing about Buffalo Bayou, I checked out Google Maps. There's not much "riparian" remaining; a lot more petroleum tanks than elm trees, I suspect.

Re: Green wood; A question or two and froes

#17

Re: my point.....

TomD

It certainly isn't because it isn't strong, it is a very strong wood, and it is rowed, so it does not split in situation where other woods do. We used to have a large elm, pre elm disease. It was horrible to split, and it was heavy, but weak was not the problem.

------------------------------------------------------------------

Speaking generally, splitting is not necessary for green wood working. It works because it is the most efficient means to an end. Whenthat stops being the case, a bandsaw if one has one is great. It is a myth that splitting yields straighter wood than sawing, though it work very well for that purpose at times. In any case, elm is so strong and hard to split, a little run out wouldn't affect the end result, though it would complicate some working.

Re: Green wood; A question or two and froes

#18

Re: question

TomD

There are elms all over the place even after the genocide. That is part of the plan. Some are resistant, or somehow escaped the main assault, and now the pickings are so sparse the disease or pest can not easily exploit the population. Not all infected trees die.

http://www.extension.umn.edu/environment/agroforestry/elm-trees.html

Re: Green wood; A question or two and froes

#19

Clint Searl

Re: Green wood; A question or two and froes

Clint Searl

I have a recently downed elm that's available to whomever takes it away.

Re: Green wood; A question or two and froes

#20

Re: question

Patrick Gibbons

I'm on the west side of town. I didn't mean to imply a large untouched forest, just the wooded river bottom. Where I live was a ranch 25 years ago.

Re: Green wood; A question or two and froes

#21

Re: Green wood; A question or two and froes

Barney Markunas

Growing up our driveway was lined with big elms (>3' trunk diameters) that all succumbed to Dutch Elm Disease and my dad thought me turning them into firewood was a good use of my time. Looking back, the only thing good about it was that it was close to the house and I didn't have to haul it far. It was a lot of work for a pile of pretty disappointing firewood.

Its reluctance to split is the reason that they used to use elm for the blades of hockey sticks back before they were all space age composites. It was miserable going after them with a chain saw, axe and a pile of wedges; I cannot imaging being the OP and trying to make headway with a froe.