New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Cupped Boards

Posts

Cupped Boards

#1

Cupped Boards

Gary B.

I'm slowly getting into hand tool only woodworking (My Career has been Industrial Woodworking). My 2nd ever Hand tool project will be a Saw Till to organize my growing collection. I purchased some 4/4 poplar, and cross cut to rough length last weekend. Yesterday I noticed that 2 of the 3 cross cuts (same board) have cupped substantially. I ripped them in half, jointed the edges and will re glue. In my past, I've always flipped glue ups, so that the growth rings are opposite on adjoining boards...For experimentation, (and aesthetics), I'm tempted to glue it back up the same way it was originally....Thoughts??

I had some pics I intended to post with this, but not sure how we attach them anymore?

Re: Cupped Boards

#2

Re: Cupped Boards

TomD

I think the flipping thing is not necessary. When I built my trestle table aeons ago, I came across contradictory advice on how to manage the table top, one theory was that the alternating boards was less likely to make a big warp, but the problem with that if they cup across a short distance normal hardware will never hold them flat. On the other hand the big cup can sometimes be held down.

So I called Michael Fortune up, who is one of the top makers in NA, and I asked him. He said that he never gave it a thought, he simply arranged the boards for the best color and figure. Which is what I did, and the top is laser flat 30 years later.

Wood is wood, and there is, as you know, only so much you can do to work with it if one can't provide a fairly normal environment for it. Furniture of the classical/fine type, like musical instruments, requires some basic care or it will not survive, but living in a world where summers are humid, and by the water, and winters are heated with forced air, my stuff still stays flat so I have had good results with MF's advice. Whether that would hold if I had was forced to relocate to Texas is another mater.

Re: Cupped Boards

#3

Re: Cupped Boards

Sgian Dubh

Gary, I extracted a section from a larger text I wrote that discusses this issue which can be found at this link. You'll find the discussion of that specific issue about two thirds down the page. Slainte.

Re: Cupped Boards

#4

Re: Cupped Boards

Gary B.


Re: Cupped Boards

#5

Re: Cupped Boards

Gary B.

Thank you both for your advice. I was able to post the pictures this time. The one with the clamp on it is dry, no glue as of yet. I believe after your help, I'll glue it up as it was, and see how it goes. It is just a saw till; after I dovetail it all together, hopefully that will hold it.

Re: Cupped Boards

#6

Re: Cupped Boards

mdclor

Gary, I'm curious why 2 cupped any one didn't. Had you planed the board? Did you leave them flat on a flat surface or did you sticker them? Was there exposure to sunlight or a draft?

Re: Cupped Boards

#7

Re: Cupped Boards

Gary B.

mdclor,

I too am curious about this. All I know is all 3 came from the same board. I rough cross cut the boards last weekend, and they sat on my bench as shown in the photo until yesterday , when I noticed the cup. The top two cupped, while the bottom one didn't. They definitely weren't cupped before (at least to that extent).

When ripping the one shown in half by hand, I noticed some tension in the wood. The kerf closed up on the end after I was in about 18". I plan on gluing them back up in the morning.

Re: Cupped Boards

#8

Re: Cupped Boards

William Duffield

Whenever I dimension lumber (it matters not whether by hand or by machine) and I cannot complete the joinery and assembly the same day (or week, or year :( ), I always stand the boards on end, with stickers under them and between them to allow free air movement around all surfaces. It is usually also wise to do your dimensioning a little over size, so you can adjust for any small amount of warpage when you are ready to do the next step. Also, try to remove approximately equal amounts of wood from both faces.

Re: Cupped Boards

#9

Re: Cupped Boards

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Gary

Looks like the boards are not quite as dry as you expect.

You could turn them over and leave them a while and see if they return to flat.

Or you could just clamp a straight edge across the ends to straighten them, then dovetail the ends together. They should remain flat and square. There is often a very mild degree of cupping that occurs with wider boards and/or panels when left for a while. After they are dovetailed, I have not seen any longer term issues.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Cupped Boards

#10

undue fretting over cupping

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Boards cup for only one of two reasons.

1. There was internal tension that got relieved more on one face than the other, typically as a result of surfacing or resawing the lumber. Cupping will occur quickly after surfacing or resawing, in minutes not days.

2. One face picked up or lost moisture more than they other.

You did not say, but I presume you purchased this board surfaced. Hence it sat days or weeks without cupping. Hence, in your case one side of the cupped board gained or lost moisture more than the other.

There is too much fretting about perfectly flat boards. What you show is a piddly amount of cupping. I would have mashed the board flat with some clamps and cleats, marked and sawed the dovetails and assembled the box. The dovetails would have held the box sufficiently flat.

To answer your other question, I never consider growth ring orientation in assembling a panel. I go for best looks.