New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Shelf spacing

Posts

Shelf spacing

#1

Shelf spacing

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

We're closing in on later stages of a remodel of one of our rooms. The room will have built-in cabinets and bookshelves, and I'll be using pins in holes for shelf adjustment. I'm thinking of getting fancy and using the pressed-in sleeves that Lee Valley (and, I'm sure, others) offer, looking like this:

.

The pins come in bags of 100, which sounds like a bunch, until you start thinking about all the holes involved; so I'm mulling over shelf spacing.

I think 1" spacing makes the most sense for the bookcases, starting and finishing at 6" from the bottom/top. We don't have nearly enough bookshelves in our house, and I want those bookcases to be as efficient as possible.

The cabinets will be five feet high, and used for bulk storage, with some display shelves above them. There, I'm thinking 2" spacing may be more than enough, starting/finishing a foot from the bottom/top.

Thoughts appreciated.

Re: Shelf spacing

#2

Re: Shelf spacing

John in NM

Your spacing scale sounds good for the two purposes. One thing I've done before is put in 3 or so on the desired spacing and then skip 6-8 inches and do three more. This gives you some adjustment range without having to put in huge numbers of those little sleeves.

I've used both those ones in your pic and the machined ones LV sells. The pins stay in better with the machined ones, but still not as well in a simple hole in the wood. If the shelf is flat either sleeved ones stay in fine and the sleeves do look nicer than a hole.

Re: Shelf spacing

#3

Why use "Part A"

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have hundreds of "book shelf" holes in the house that are largely empty, with some filled with 1/4" shelf support pins. I space the holes at one inch but only put pins in as needed. The pins support closet shelving and book shelving. The empty holes are hardly noticed when in dark wood.

Re: Shelf spacing

#4

Thanks

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

The cabinets/bookcases will be white, so the holes will likely be a bit more noticeable. Maybe, given John's experience, I will go with just plain holes. The cabinets will have doors, and the bookcases will of course be filled with books, so holes are less significant for those two components. Maybe I'll just put the sleeves on the display units.

Re: Shelf spacing

#5

strongly suggest

TomD

You consider the 5mm pins for 5 mm holes. The effect is most elegant, and the pins are extemely strong because they are a very tight fit. I have the LV 32 mm system, so putting in a ton of holes is not an inordinate chore, but the numbers do add up to the extent that I was watching this build on Youtube, and the guy was naking maybe 20 feet of bookcases, and one worker spent 2 days drilling all the holes.

My preferred method is to place the books intentionally, drill the holes for them. Then make up a little ply jig so that you can use any existing hole to place an accurate adjascent hole. Mostly you never will, but it takes away the feeling that can't commit to a particular thing when in all likelyhood you will be stuck with it for life. An example is knock down furniture, built lots of it, never disassembled any of it, particularly for a move.

How to place your books. I always used to place books so that they were grouped by logical subject. I noticed when looking at my father in law's books that they are all grouped by size. Admittedly I have many craft subjects, he has mostly hard cover new yorker type fiction, so he really doesn't need to group them, though he could choose to place them by some other random order like by author. His book shelves always look more restful to the eye than mine because there aren't all the jagged ups and downs in size, and gaps. And to boot, one gets more volumes in a given space, and they collect less dust.

So if you want, you can order all your books by size, and then measure off the number by shelf lengths times tallest book, and you will pretty much end up with a distribution that makes a lot of sense, and will never need to be shifted. If you are likely not going to fill the cases, then you may want to leave a little space on each shelf, so that future random, by size, acquisitions will have a place to go.

If it bothers you not being able to group by subject, I discovered I could for the most part anyway. Publishers tend to make their books the same size, so a grouping from Taunton press may fit together, or New Society, etc...

http://www.leevalley.com/en/hardware/page.aspx?p=40189&cat=3,43648,43649

The steel paddles at top are the ones I use. The first piece of casework I made used ebony pins in tiny holes, which didn't look all that strong, but 35 years later they are still doing just fine. The were wide shelves for the

Re: Shelf spacing

#6

Ellis Walentine

Two alternatives

Ellis Walentine

I second the 5mm pin idea. The holes are much smaller than the ones you need to drill for those big pins and sleeves. Another cool trick is to rout little pockets in the underside ends of your shelves to cover the pins. These keep the shelf from pulling out.

Frankly, though, magic wires are my favorite shelf support. The holes are *really* tiny and the magic wires are totally invisible and very solid.

Ellis

Re: Shelf spacing

#7

Re: Thanks

Tony - Memphis

I used those on my bookshelves. I painted the sleeves white. Looks nice and works quite well.

Tony

Re: Shelf spacing

#8

Re: OT a little.

TomD

I guess the smaller hole thing mostly sounds like an advantage relative to the look. But the small holes also seem less prone to tear out. That is something you might want to check out on scrap though. If you can't get a perfectly clean hole, some of those hardware inserts cover up a minimal amount of tear out, though a small hose from a sharp bit should be fine.

With the small holes, I make no attempt to have them all functional. I paint over then, which makes them slightly smaller. I use a roller, so it doesn't fill them in. I don't chamfer them which would reduce the chance a client blows them out removing a pin. And I don't chase them to make them the perfect size of the pin. If one wanted to do the latter, a chucking reamer of correct size would be an asset. When it comes time to use a new set of holes, I just take a set of pliers and press them in, works great, but again, it's the sort of thing one can get away with on one's own furniture, but certainly not a clients.

One thing in all this is the question of what constitutes the right approach from a high end perspective. I have made a few high end (well call it Shaker level) book cases. One had fixed shelves. The other had two fixed and one variable, but it had only one or a few holes. In general my shelving is built-in grade; maybe some ply; as nice as I can make it, but not high end. I don't really care about holes in that stuff. But are holes acceptable in high end? Particularly if you make your own shelves and could punch in any other holes you really need? Should one make furniture using the same approaches as the big box stores just because that is what one sees.