New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

A question about minimilist finishes

Posts

A question about minimilist finishes

#1

A question about minimilist finishes

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

There is no question that an expertly planed surface coated with what I call a minimalist finish- wax, thin layer of shellac, etc- is attractive.....when it is new. Krenov and his students often used this finishing approach to good effect with lighter colored woods.

We know that the lustrous appearance of the freshly planed surface will dull(oxidize and darken) and become dead looking if not finished. It will retain its luster if finished with some technique that will build the finish layers, which in turn provide protection from mechanical assault as well as light and chemicals(broadly defined).

The minimalist finish lies between these extremes. I saw a piece of furniture made by a Krenov student some years after it had been put in service. It looked dead, if not unattractive.

My question is, what is the experience with these finishes as they age? The question is relevant because these minimalist finishes are becoming poplar as more people become skilled at planing and gurus advocate them. But are they a good idea long term for furniture, or whatever? Are they a copout for woodworkers that haven't learned to apply shellac, varnish , lacquer?

Re: A question about minimilist finishes

#2

Hmmmm....

John in NM

How many aphorisms could I apply to this? Probably could spend all day on thinking of them (beats working right?)

I'll just stick with the obvious one - there is no such thing as a free lunch.

I would be that the minimalist finish works pretty well over the years if one waxes it on a regular basis. This is just supposition of course, I tend to go with either an oil or film finish that does not require much maintenance.

So, one can put the work into a finish that is low maintenance, or one can put the work into long term maintenance of an initially easy finish. One way or another, one has to put some work into it.

Re: A question about minimilist finishes

#3

Re: A question about minimilist finishes

Brian Holcombe

Finishing is the most difficult part of the project for me, so for quick stuff around the house, like my two frames I will wax them. They will not experience UV and will probably go un-touched by people so I have few concerns with them.

For anything that sees use, and most stuff that doesnt I do think that a good finish is going to be sturdier and better than wax or similar minimal finish.

Re: A question about minimilist finishes

#4

Re: A question about minimilist finishes

Hank Knight

Bill, I don't know if what I'm about to relate is of any help at all, but your question tickled a curiosity I've had for a long time.

When my wife and I were first married, we were dirt poor and had almost no furniture to speak of. A friend of a friend gave us an old Victorian "dresser base" I think it's called. It has a marble top and carved drawer pulls. The top has holes for a mirror or a second level drawer case, or both; but whatever was supposed to be attached through the holes is missing. The piece was pretty dirty and disreputable when I picked it up, but it had functioning drawers which we needed desparately. I took it home and started refinishing it. I applied some kind if finish remover and sanded it down to the bare wood which revealed itself to be very nice walnut. Then I put a sanding sealer on it which I'm pretty sure was shellac. If I recall correctly, I put on a couple of coats of sealer and sanded each coat with fine sandpaper down to what looked like bare wood. That's as far as I got; the wood was so pretty, I never put a final finish of any kind on it. That was almost 50 years ago and the piece looks as good today as it did then. It has the look of well sanded, bare wood with a soft, velvety sheen, no gloss at all. We still use the piece in our house. I've often wondered if a couple of coats of thinned shellac to seal the bare wood is all you need, except, of course for pieces that will see abuse or moisture. That finishing regimen has certainly proved to be more than adequate for our old dresser base.

Hank

Re: A question about minimilist finishes

#5

Re: It's the wood

TomD

"My question is, what is the experience with these finishes as they age? The question is relevant because these minimalist finishes are becoming poplar as more people become skilled at planing and gurus advocate them"

Is that true, much of the skill in planing is not at that level, and to really do it right, one needs to blend in a variety of surfaces, like Krenov's file work. I haven't observed this trend, but then I gave up buying any woodworking magazines a long time ago.

Krenov carefully selected his woods, and largely absent among them were the majority of woods we normally use, the Walnuts, cherries, mahoganies, and American oaks. I used to have around a small offcut of maple that I had hand planed, and that had no finish, it was not a special piece, just beautiful tan ink lines and shades of cream. It did not require any finish. I also had a jar of Macasar ebony shaving as an ornament. Stuff like the pegs on violins made of ebony can just be buffed, as can fingerboards, though they sell oils for those, I don't use them.

I have a Jara bowl that Richard Raffan sold me, and it had the usual Raffan finish of oil and wax, it looks fine 20 years later. I must say, my exploits with oily rags and wax, are less ideal in the main.

Softwoods can be planed, and they will glisten or look like polished bone, they do not require finish, but then can end up grimy.

Another major factor is one's objectives, while high gloss finishes can be both necessary, or beautiful, they do not look natural. One has to think of wood in a different way for different finishes. Most of us accept that a hand worn antique can be beautiful and shouldn't be stripped and shot with conversion lacquer, but we can't accept the finish that starts out as that piece did a few hundred years before, in every case.

I would be curious to know how Krenov finished his marketry pieces. He was off on a different tangent there, and I would be a little surprised if he hadn't adapted his finishes. Anyone know?

Re: A question about minimilist finishes

#6

Ellis Walentine

Krenov's finish

Ellis Walentine

I could be wrong, but JK used thin, wiped-on shellac for most of his stuff.

Re: A question about minimilist finishes

#7

Ellis Walentine

Aspects to consider

Ellis Walentine

The two big ones are appearance and function. I sometimes think that the great appeal of simple wiped finishes is ease of application, because often they aren't the best solution for the requirements at hand. On the other hand, simple, matte, close-to-the-wood finishes are very attractive to me. How they hold up depends on what they are. Wax doesn't last long and offers little protection from anything except fingerprints, but it imparts a nice feel. "Danish oil" finishes are fine for things that don't get a lot of handling or abuse, as they're soft and don't build. Oils and varnishes saturate the color of the wood and make it richer looking; wax and shellac don't. For surfaces that get a lot of wear or handling, film finishes are usually best, and you can mimic the minimalist look by adjusting the film thickness and sheen.

I guess the upshot is to pick a finish that offers the best combination of looks and protection for its intended use.

Ellis

Re: A question about minimilist finishes

#8

Re: Krenov's finish

TomD

That is what he said in his books, which were mostly written in the 70s, before the CR program got started. In his last book, the students and Krenov, seemed to have moved to a stage where a lot of marketry was being made. Maybe one can finish a marketry door with renaisance wax, or shellac, but I wouldn't do it.

Also, almost 40 years went by, did he change nothing?

Re: A question about minimilist finishes

#9

Alight edit

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If the people in our club are any indication I would change your wording as follows....

"I guess the upshot is to[learn to apply] a finish that offers the best combination of looks and protection for its intended use."

Re: A question about minimilist finishes

#11

Ellis Walentine

Polish

Ellis Walentine

JK was still talking about "polish," meaning wiped shellac, when I last saw him around 1999. At his critiques, and in his classes, it was the de facto finish, and it works. French polish is the extension of the polishing idea. Krenov didn't take it to that extreme. I don't know his exact rationale.

Ellis

Re: A question about minimilist finishes

#12

Re: Polish

TomD

Thanks Ellis, that takes it forward 25 years. He had a whole section on his Shellac, and I think the main reason he didn't use French polish is he just didn't want that level of finish. He just wanted the slightest layer, as you mayt have already mentioned. Of course, with Krenov (or the Krenov of the books), the skill level was not that high. The design and intentionality level was very high, but the tools he had (we all had back then), and the skill implied a bit of a workaround. French polish is tough sledding. In the guitar world there was this duo who were renowned polishers, but they always used an underfinish. They dropped five minute epoxy with credit cards, then they moved on to crazy glue. In short, all they really polished was the top of plastic. No wonder it was a separate craft at one time.

Re: A question about minimilist finishes

#13

Re: Aspects to consider

david weaver

I use either oil and wax or light shellac and wax. On the rare occasion I make something for other people, I assume that they should have lacquer.

I finished a lamp base for someone once with wipe on polyurethane and I have to admit that after applying and sanding, etc, until the final coat, it actually turned out nice. But until the final coats were in place, the interim coats looked pretty hideous.

(plus, i got the sense that the wipe on poly was a way to sell regular poly at a higher price. I use it seldom enough that it doesn't much matter).