New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

logging for plane bodies and drawer sides

Posts

logging for plane bodies and drawer sides

#1

logging for plane bodies and drawer sides

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I'm posting here because while I am harvesting drawer sides the procedure is identical for plane bodies. In just a short time we had billets for resawing over 200 sq ft of quarter grained drawer sides, or had it been beech, dozens of plane bodies.

Step 1 is to locate a large tree and sturdy son in law. A neighbor took down this 33" poplar that had spent most of its 85 year life growing in a dense forest only to wind up too close to their house.

pic 1

Step 2 is to buck it into appropriate lengths.

pic 2


Step 3 saw a slab off each side. A chisel tooth chain does well here. Slabbing off both sides took 5 min or less.

pic 3


Step 4, split of saw out the center of the tree and discard it for firewood.

pic 4


Step 5 seal ends. I forget the Anchorseal so we used latex paint.

Step 6 put it somewhere to dry where it has good air circulation on all sides but not in direct sun. These billets will be ready to resaw for final drying at the end of summer next year.

Re: logging for plane bodies and drawer sides

#2

Re: logging for plane bodies and drawer sides

Steve Voigt

Looks good, Bill. The terminal problem of finding beech is really bringing me down--I just found out my next shipment is delayed two months. Harvesting from logs is looking more attractive, as a long-term solution.

One question: why store such thick material if you're using it for drawer sides? Why not split it into thinner pieces right away?

Re: logging for plane bodies and drawer sides

#3

Re: logging for plane bodies and drawer sides

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Lots of reasons:

Reduce part of the log to movable, eventually useable pieces quickly. The main objective was to cut the 1000 bdft of logs into firewood , 60 + blocks in all.

Dried as a billet it will not distort. I don't care if it takes a year or two to dry enough to get me out of the potential drying distortion problems.

A band saw cuts a 1/16" kerf. This chain saw cuts a 1/4" kerf (3/8ths plus some wobble).

If I was cutting these logs for plane billets I would do it slightly different to improve yield. I would strive for 4 billets per log section. What I whacked out would be made more narrow to leave two additional billets at right angles to the ones I took.

Re: logging for plane bodies and drawer sides

#4

Re: logging for plane bodies and drawer sides

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Is there a problem with drying rift-cut poplar? I have no experience with that, only the plain sawn stuff I get from local lumber mills that seem to cut everything through and through unless requested otherwise.

Re: logging for plane bodies and drawer sides

#5

no

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Drying any kind of poplar is easy.

However, if the goal is 7/16" finished drawer sides then it is less wasteful to dry as thick a piece as practical and slab it into thin sides when it is dry enough that there is little chance of it changing shape as it dries to final moisture content.

Nobody seemed to like how I approached this harvest but on the other hand nobody has yet offered an alternative of log to finished drawer side for consideration.

If I am sawing a log for drawer sides with a circle mill I split it, lay the flat side on the carriage and saw it through about 5/4 or 6/4 to be resawed after drying. The edges, yielding short drawer side stock, is a fairly stable rift cut, the wide center is quartered. And it is easy and not wasteful to saw it this way.

Re: logging for plane bodies and drawer sides

#6

Re: no

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I think a lot of them missed the point. Iunderstood what your goal was in milling the log and certainly am not questioning it. My question really is more rift sawn oriented in general: is there less cupping in drying rift sawn vs plain sawn? Then as a corollary, being as cheap as I am, I was wondering about increasing your overall yield from the day's labor by including that with the QS stuff instead of adding it to the burn pile.

Re: logging for plane bodies and drawer sides

#7

Re: logging for plane bodies and drawer sides

david weaver

If you could get a section of beech that was clear and looked like that bottom log you showed, that'd be just about ideal.

I'm sure I could troll southern ohio and convince someone to sell me a standing tree, but there is no way I could store it. I'd love to run the dehumidifer in my garage all winter trying it, though. I can haul sections 5 feet long and about 500 pounds, and you can bet if I could find some, I'd do it.

FWIW, I read something quoted on another forum that I believe was early 1900s, and it suggested that the beech should be sap wood only and the heart set aside for firewood despite it being perfectly fine for planes, which is not something I have much luck getting (most of my billets are half and half). what I've found thus far is that a try plane made of mostly heart will weigh a fair amount more.

I just made myself a second try plane to erase some of the sins I made on the first and so I wouldn't keep giving better working planes than I have to other people, and it is mostly heart with a bunch of odd color variation in it - and 8 pounds.

Anyway, that'a bit off the topic. I haven't seen a standing beech tree here, but most of the woods around me are either second growth hillsides or grown-up from farm land, and there is a lot of small junk with most of the larger trees being red oaks and pin oaks.

What are the railroad ties made of - any part of the tree, or do they like to have the pith like a porch post would?

Re: logging for plane bodies and drawer sides

#8

Indeed yes and plane blanks

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

A straight grained rift cut has less potential to distort than flat sawed lumber. But, even flat sawed lumber dries flat if stacked properly in a big enough stack. But one might get by drying s rift cut piece unsupported and it stay fairly flat.

A far as yield I was looking to get "cream of the crop" as quick as possible with least fuss. I would have cut it a bit different otherwise. I would have removed a billet from the center of all four faces, wasting the heart and the edges. As for the the rift corners I most certainly saved them when processing a log on a mill. While narrow they make dandy lumber. In the case at hand I rescued 100 bd ft of potential lumber from 1000 bdft of logs, but it didn't take up much time to do it. And no effort on my part :)

Cutting out quartered stuff is best done as part of a firewood operation. One can whack out the center portions quickly as illustrated, wasting potential quartered wood to save time. The remains becomes valuable firewood from otherwise valueless beech trees in the case of plane blanks, or near useless poplar in the case this weekend.

Re: logging for plane bodies and drawer sides

#9

Tie logs

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

They can be any hard wood but when there is plenty they only take oak. The cant must have the center of the tree in it.

I am drifting toward a generous mood and may offer you the few plane 4 x 4 blanks I whacked out many years ago.

Your observation on weight heartwood vs sap wood is not confirmed by any data or experience I have. There can be differences in tree to tree, especially in ring porous woods.

Re: logging for plane bodies and drawer sides

#10

Re: logging for plane bodies and drawer sides

TomD

I do the same thing Bill does except with a mill. Here the chain is 3/8. but it doesn't mater with found wood. I got enough for one large bench and several lifetimes of planes. I cut mostly 4 inch slabs and 2 inch slabs, and got a lot of rounds that I split out. Beech is the fastest and evenest drying wood I have ever seen, but even a lack of shadow the first few weeks would split it in the middle of a piece, normally if I loose anything it starts at the ends, even if they are waxed. Overall I get a good yield and don't worry too much about all the stuff people ask about, or the articles talk about. Seems like a pretty easy business, with some common sense. Get the wax or paint on right away, sticker, keep out of direct sunlight, let nature take it's course


I got a bunch of this stuff, and all the guy would take for it was the 50 dollar firewood price.


This maple was taken down up the road from my place. The trunk was perfect no rot about 3 feet, and it would have been worth had it been 100 percent sold in a proper yard, no deductions for waste, for 9000 dollars.


The plane wood is about 5 years old now, it seemed ready to go around 1 years. the stuff dried to a no change state in a mater of months, very unusual for 16/4 stock.


Re: logging for plane bodies and drawer sides

#11

Re: Indeed yes and plane blanks

TomD

Depending on how you cut the tree, a flat sawn piece cut out of the heart, heart aside, is quarter sawn/radial, and anything outside of that piece in slices above or below it is pretty much riffed.

Pictured is a flat sawn log. Depends on the scale, is it 24 inches, or 12. But on a large piece, there is plenty of usable wood to either side of the pith and the middle 20 percent vertical section.

If you look at the central pieces (the three to nine o'clock pieces) they are quarter sawn, other than some wood at the center. If you wanted to bother, you could also take out the vertical wood above and bellow the pith and get more radial pieces that are what we call quarter sawn.


In a quarter sawing routine the wood is handled so the radial material is taken out like a cross as described above, then the quarters, awkwardly shaped, are also radially sawn. (the diagram below incorrectly equates quartering with riff sawn wood)


But here is the point. When buying wood, radial (quarter sawing is a method that yields all radial wood, the resulting boards are radial) is either expensive, or often unavailable. It seems scarce as though nothing would be better than sawing all your wood into radial form. But if you can saw your own wood, the wood available that is radial when you flat saw, is usually sufficient for most purposes. It depends on the design, but most cabinets may have more "pretty" flat or riffed wood in them, than they have parts like stiles and rails that are best cut radially.

Here is the kicker. If you saw your wood flat, but as Bill says saw it THICK, then the flat sawn pieces that are outside the core and basically riffed on the outer edges but flat in the middle, can have the centers resawn so that they yield 2 inch radial wood for stiles and rails, etc... By keeping the wood thick, you set the wood up to dry flatter, and to allow you to decide what you are going to use it for longer. This works best if you can saw logs at least 16 inches in diameter. But the large stuff is a more efficient cut, and the resulting wood is more of a premium to those of us who work wood into solid wood furniture, with best results.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

While it may take a while to get the wood into a usable state, normally by the time you are ready to cut the wood, and have found a ready supply, you have so much wood that you will never get through it in several lifetimes. For the first few years as you wait, remember all the greenwood projects, bowls, rakes, etc... you always wanted to do. After that, the avalanch of wood can be more of a problem than how long any new stuff takes to be added to the pile.

By the way, the house I had a picture of and it's "9000 dollar log". Their neighbour has a similar tree. And I know that neighbour well. There was a truck parked out front of the tree with a massive chipper attached to it today, with a guy in the truck eyeing the tree while taking on his phone. Where it not for the recent bypass surgery, there would be a very real chance I would get so much wood out of that one tree, I wouldn't see the floor of the shop for a decade. :)

Re: logging for plane bodies and drawer sides

#12

Re: Tie logs

david weaver

It's entirely possible that the variation that I see is tree to tree and not heart to sap.

I have noticed, though, that the heart will take in almost no linseed oil (even on the end grain) whereas it can literally run from one end of the plane to the other in sap wood - just overnight.

I know beech sometimes doesn't age perfectly (it becomes very soft in the earlywood and looks a bit dry rotted in some old saw handles), so I can't really judge by old planes what they may have been like. I've had 24" try planes as light as 6 pounds (these planes are all the same size, about 3" tall and 3 1/4" wide) and a 28" jointer that was over 10. Most older planes are on the lighter side now.

If you have quartered blanks, I could of course use them, but Steve might have a much more pressing need for them than I do. I've got about 25 board feet of blanks left which should get me through to horizon's next shipment.

Re: logging for plane bodies and drawer sides

#13

Re: Indeed yes and plane blanks

david weaver

Exactly what you describe is what old texts say about beech (i'm repeating about the sap wood thing), they suggest just taking the good stuff in the context of processing the rest to burn.

Re: logging for plane bodies and drawer sides

#14

Re: Tie logs

Steve Voigt

That's thoughtful of you, Dave, but Bill obviously wants to give them to you, not me, so go for it.

Re: logging for plane bodies and drawer sides

#15

Re: logging for plane bodies and drawer sides

Steve Voigt

Tom, I'm looking pretty hard for bench plane-sized blanks to plug a short term supply problem. If you have any interest in selling any of those blanks (which look great, btw), I'd gladly pay top dollar. Feel free to email me at voigt.planes@gmail.com.

(I totally understand though, if you'd rather keep them to yourself. I would!)

Re: logging for plane bodies and drawer sides

#16

True, true and true

John K Jordan

>...you have so much wood that you will never get through it in several lifetimes.

>For the first few years as you wait, remember all the greenwood projects,

>bowls, rakes, etc... you always wanted to do.

When I have a tree down or given to me, I saw boards and slabs on my woodmizer and cut chunks for immediate and future woodturning. I think I now have three or four lifetimes of dry and drying turning blanks of all shapes, sizes, and species, some air drying now for 10 years. I have hundreds, maybe 1000s of board ft of cherry, walnut, poplar, cedar, etc. boards waiting for who knows what.

Someone should start a charity benefit organization for the wood hoarders to put in our wills to keep the excess from going to firewood when we kick off.

Looking back, I do find the thick slabs more useful in the long run so I guess I should make more of those. Can always resaw. I remember something from my pilot training about the runway behind and the air above...

Re: logging for plane bodies and drawer sides

#17

Re: Downloading

TomD

I met this guy who was working at Lee Valley's west side store back when I started this wood madness. He was mid 20s and had already filled three garages with wood, and was obviously up for more if he could find more space. It is the wood equivalent of downloading where people create a library of 5000 epub books, none of which they will ever read because they spend all their time finding new volumes to download. Of course the wood thing isn't illegal, and I do get to some of the wood.

Re: logging for plane bodies and drawer sides

#18

Re: logging for plane bodies and drawer sides

TomD

I'm early days yet post bypass, so I can't even get to the wood, or assess what my future use can be. I do really appreciate the offer, though I think I am a bit like those folks with 50 million dollars who when surveyed said they needed 300 million to actually feel safe.

When I cut this stuff, I was thinking of starting a business selling plane blanks, because getting it seems to be a problem. There are enough beech trees out there in great shape, but people don't seem to cut that wood for lumber. But I don't have any place to put the wood...

Re: logging for plane bodies and drawer sides

#19

Re: logging for plane bodies and drawer sides

Steve Voigt

That's right, I forgot about your bypass. I hope your recovery is proceeding apace!

Re: logging for plane bodies and drawer sides

#20

Re: logging for plane bodies and drawer sides

david weaver

It is burned around here in most cases.

Like red oak. Except you can find red oak, often for about a dollar a foot at mills (I just don't see much beech locally here, it's to the west in southern ohio in droves).

We burned a lot of walnut and cherry when I was a kid, too. Oops.

Re: logging for plane bodies and drawer sides

#21

Re: logging for plane bodies and drawer sides

TomD

I'm really pushing the sympathy card there. :)

Everything is good, I went to the first official exercise class today, and while just 6 weeks out, I was not setting any speed records. I was walking a a 4 mph pace, and doing some weight exercises that are well beyond what the average person out for their daily constitutional would undertake. The people who have been at it some time are really moving out. It is 14 laps to the mile on the indoor track, and I got lapped twice by one guy during my first half mile. It is quite the process, you really have to keep improving if you want to kick it up to the point where you get major advantages from the exercise. I have so many creaks and pains since the plane crash, that I am going to have to use a lot of creativity to keep up the pace.

Re: logging for plane bodies and drawer sides

#22

Long road back

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Having recovered from several stents, I appreciate the long road back. It's worth the effort, though. Do what they tell you.

What plane crash?

Re: logging for plane bodies and drawer sides

#23

Re: Long road back

TomD

In 97 I was in a commercial plane crash, regional jet. Saved by a tree, though also smashed up by it. The plane failed to go around, staled fell out of the air, then did some amazing break dancing, wild porpoising, and wing tip to wing tip gyrations. In the end we hit a huge tree, that came diagonally through the front of the plane, sweeping up the seats, and compressing people like a garborator. I didn't see the tree, because it was so plastered with people and seats. but it was right between my legs. If we hadn't hit the tree, we would have hit the woods behind, and probably there would have been a fireball. It took them 3-4 hours to get us out. I sustained a lot of injuries and had a core temp about 85. As my pal at work used to say: "tom, never let the tourists know you are cold".

There is always a little humour in these situations. Those of us piled up in the front had no way to get out. But the majority could just walk off. There was aviation fuel vapour everywhere, and this one guy gets to the door, and pauses to light a cigarette! He got yelled down pretty hard. Another couple from the passenger manifest disappeared, people were looking for them everywhere. Turned out they just walked out to the perimeter fence of the airport, in 3 feet of snow, and hitched a ride home.

Re: logging for plane bodies and drawer sides

#24

Uffda!

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I don't think I'd like your experience very much.

Re: logging for plane bodies and drawer sides

#25

Re: Uffda!

TomD

It was really bad, but it becomes part of who one is, and understandably a big part, for better or worse. I went to a Psych, routine part of the rehab. She figured I was so solid not much point in coming back. I'm thinking where is my PTSD. People get that diagnosis for being bumped from their flight. :)