New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Left handed planes

Posts

Left handed planes

#1

Left handed planes

joe in a Cleveland suburb

Hi all.

Just curious, are any of you left handed and using wooden beading planes?

I just bought a 3/16" beading plane from somebody on a FaceBook hand tools group pretty cheap.

I have been interested in trying one for some time and the price was right.

It seems all these old molding(?) planes are designed for right handed people.

I can do some things right handed, but not everything. If I can't get the hang of it, no big loss.

Any leftys have anything to say?

Thanks.

Re: Left handed planes

#2

Re: Left handed planes

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Haven't used wooden beading planes, but I have used right-handed planes, mainly the fenced planes (rabbet, plow), Until Lee Valley started offering leftie planes, that was what there was.

Mostly, it was practice to get used to them. But people vary in their degree of handedness, and if you're severely left-handed, it could be awkward.

Can you pull the planes, and would that help?

Re: Left handed planes

#3

Re: Left handed planes [???]

Bruce McCrory

"Can you pull the planes, and would that help?"

Bill, are you saying Asian woodworkers are Lefties? :D

But, ya, I can see the advantage of "left-handed" [reverse direction] tools, and still refuse to acquire them because I am too "right-handed".

Re: Left handed planes

#4

Re: Left handed planes

Warren in Lancaster, PA

We occasionally have to use a moulding plane (like a round) in the left handed direction, the opposite of usual, which is kind of like your problem, Joe. I sometimes wrap my left hand around the back of the plane and pull it towards me. Sometimes I put a hand on each upper corner, hold it directly in front of me and push sideways.

This morning I tried something I don't remember doing; I planed as if I were left handed, mirroring my usual stance. Surprisingly, this was the easiest thing. So I think at the least you should get some scrap and give it a try planing right handed; it might be the easiest solution.

Re: Left handed planes

#5

Agree

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

I'm left-handed, and do as Warren suggests--use molding planes right-handed.

It's not a problem. I liken it to fielding a ground ball in baseball using both hands. The proximity and coordinated action of the two hands sorta takes the awkwardness away.

Wiley

Re: Left handed planes

#6

Re: Left handed planes

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Thanks for the feedback.

Of course my next question(s) will be:

How do you sharpen these, and how do you adjust the blade...

Looking forward to giving it a try.

Joe

Re: Left handed planes

#7

Re: Left handed planes

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Hi guys.

Just wanted to follow up on this and ask a couple questions.

I received this little 3/16" beading plane last weekend. Without cleaning it or sharpening it, I put a stick of pine on my bench and tried pushing the plane right to left using my right hand to push and it was no big deal. Then I tried left to right on the far side of the stick pushing with my left hand; same thing, no big deal. So my worry of being left handed is nothing to worry about - seems I can do it with either hand. Just like batting. I stunk batting left or right btw....

So last night I cleaned the grime off and flattened the back of the iron. I took a bit of (I think it is) 15 micron paper wrapped around a drill bit to try to sharpen it a bit. Seemed to work ok although there is a small chip in the profile I noticed.

When I put the blade back into the body I noticed there is a lot of side to side play. In other words the iron is much narrower than the body. Is this normal?

As I looked closer I also realized the profile on the iron does not match the (boxing?) profile of the plane. The profile on the blade is larger than the profile on the plane itself. Not good, right?

I would guess trying to make a new iron is not worth the effort. That and I have zero metal working knowledge or skill.

I guess you get what you pay for. At least now I have a better idea of what to look for when buying an old beading plane.... Oh, and I learned using my right hand should be an issue. So its not a total loss.

Thank you.

Re: Left handed planes

#8

Re: Left handed planes

Doug Trembath

Well, Joe, I have a small cabinet area which is home to my orphans. Those I picked up along the way, and found later they were generally worthless. I've only thrown one away whole, and I keep any parts I may find helpful somehow...

I feel your pain, been there, done that, even got the T-shirt.

All hope is not lost, you may find an orphan iron which would be fairly simple to re-grind to fit the plane. PM or email me and I will elaborate.

I presume it's a tapered iron, right? I may even have something that would work.

Doug Trembath

Re: Left handed planes

#9

Re: Left handed planes

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Thanks Doug. I will email you shortly.