Re: Japanese plane competition
TomD
"Tom, thanks for the info. Can you expand on this:
"One thing that is not often understood is that each grade of fineness is worked longer than the preceding one, while in the course of regular sharpening one often observes the most time going into the initial setting of the edge, then every subsequent grit being breezed through."
I have just looked for a consistent scratch pattern that usually happens pretty fast at the courser grits and for a set time, about a minute, for the finer grits."
At the time the reporting was that they would spend huge amounts of time, hours, on some of these grits.
- First, I guess if they were using high resolution microscopes, they might be able to see the progression of the scratch pattern, and know that it had not fully removed the other grits.
- It would come down to cases, how big are the jumps between grits, how effective are different stones, it is my experience that every stone (mostly artificial) that I pick up feels different from other stones or same maker different grit. Do we know the grits exist as the perfect progression, or is it a case of certain grits being available. Are all grits equally efficient at clearing the waste.
- It's my feeling that a lot of finishing takes longer as one polishes to the lower grits. There is a point where one brings up the shine on the surface above the scratches, but to get every last vestige of the earlier grit out, takes a while.
- Seems like one can get really fine shaving off the kind 8K so I have never really felt the need to take it all that far.
- There are some beliefs that are not all that seemingly ration in the Japanese craft, like the idea that if one even once sharpens a blade on a man made stone, one looses the conditioning of years of sharpening on a natural one. I don't know where the evidence is for that, but I wouldn't be able to judge it. These competitions seem more scientific, but I don't know.