New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

How to repair a cracked plane

Posts

How to repair a cracked plane

#1

How to repair a cracked plane

Rick Snyder

What is the best way to repair a through crack on my scrapper plane? It is a Union #60. The crack is on the right side of where you would install blade. As you tighten down the blade the right side pulls away.( I hope I,m explaining the problem correctly. Who would be able to repair something like that ?

Thanks, Rick

Re: How to repair a cracked plane

#2

Re: How to repair a cracked plane

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If the cast iron casting is cracked it must be welded to stick it back together. Welding cast iron is difficult, a job for an expert welder.

Re: How to repair a cracked plane

#3

So, there is a chance?

CJ in MPLS

What would you say to someone with a cracked 605, some silver solder and a new torch? Just asking for a friend of course . . .

Re: How to repair a cracked plane

#4

And the preparation is as important as the welding

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

My uncle repaired the crack in the side of my No. 10-1/2 rabbet plane, after a friend messed it up. The friend had welded it without clamping it, and the sole, on the side where the crack was, wound up 1/8" or more higher in front of the mouth than behind. My uncle ground out the weld, clamped the plane firmly to a known flat surface, and let the weld cool to room temperature before unclamping. Works fine, and has for nearly 40 years now.

Re: How to repair a cracked plane

#5

maybe some steps left out....?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have access to some expert certified welders. On occasions I have asked them about welding a cast iron crack. For the cases I had they dissuaded me from pursuing the repair. The problem is the cast iron can warp and crack as it is heated up to begin welding. They spoke of a preconditioning step where the part would be carefully heated prior to beginning the weld, careful welding and then an annealing cool down. I was left with the impression that success is not assured even for an experienced welder. (or maybe they just wanted to be rid of me)

Re: How to repair a cracked plane

#6

Re: maybe some steps left out....?

Bruce McCrory

I know nothing of metalworking, beyond the good information of people more knowledgeable. I will experiment, gleefully, in my own specialty knowing that failure (or, success) is the ultimate challenge. As a backyard hobby we are more accepting of the grotesque and invalid fruits of our own labor.

I am in Bill's camp. Not the desired ascension but, throw it on the boat to China and poison our air in 6 months, with near-obsolescence returning in 12.

Re: How to repair a cracked plane

#7

Yes, but...

John in NM

You'll find that certified guys have probably never done much cast iron welding, they tend to do structural welding, stuff on hydraulic cylinders, fancy aluminum jobs, etc, and repairing cracked cast iron is a very back yard kind of thing to do.

I've seen it done and heard of it being done, the job is pretty routine for someone with experience at it. The guys with book learning and no experience will tell you how hard it is. The ones who have done it don't seem to have any trouble though.

I suspect those guys are getting pretty hard to find these days when so little seems worth repairing. A cousin of my dad's used to weld cracked pot metal parts in the 1950's, can't imagine anyone bothering with that now.

Re: How to repair a cracked plane

#8

Here's a good article on it... *LINK*

John in NM

Goes into some detail on those left out steps.

This is very much the scientific way of approaching it, which is a fine thing if one has the resources.

The other route is to learn by trial and error, the way so many backyard mechanics did when stuff was worth fixing. Once a guy has learned this way, it's about as good as the scientific approach - kinda sucks if one's cracked plane body is part of the learning curve though :D


Welding cast iron

Re: How to repair a cracked plane

#9

Re: Here's a good article on it...

Brian Holcombe

If you have a local machine shop that does a lot of repair work on older or very important engines they will probably be capable of welding cast iron.

The machine shop that I worked in as a youth used to weld cast iron on the regular. However the head machinist would not offer guarantee of success, and the work was particularly expensive since it involved preheating the engine blocks prior to welding and magnifluxing afterward. It was generally reserved for rare, expensive, usual or a combination off all three.

Re: How to repair a cracked plane

#10

Re: Yes, but...

TomD

I agree, the metal guys in different trades all act as though what is common knowledge in another field is magic, yet they are full of misinformation about the problems.

I think the info Bill got is largely accurate as far as some of the process and results, but brazing should yield good results. Welding is knitting the crack together with the material in the plane or parent metal that is more of the same, we are taking white hot in the heat affected zone. Brazing of the hard type is over 800 degree use of flux and bronze of silver braze to flow into the crack and pores of the metal, to create a strong bond, it should be OK for this kind of repair. Often guys who weld on the farm are proficient, because a lot of old tractor crap is cast.

Certified in welding terms is more limited than it may sound. My understanding is it means they have a ticket for a particular process, like welding a pipeline pipe, an aircraft frame, or a nuke tube. Passing these test is some serious skill, but you might find an advanced hobbyist who is more generally skilled on a wide range of materials. There are a lot of welding gurus out there who through a career have multiple certs, and an inquiring mind that leads them to ask a lot of question and become very broadly knowledgeable, which is always and interesting conversation when you get one. I remember a guy a few years back who claimed to have cracked the code on welding overthick materials with a Dynasty 200 tig. That is a rocketship of a welder, but nobody believed him, and I never heard the end of it. But the discussion was so far above my head I couldn't see them talking on the other side of the clouds. It can get seriously complicated, and the processes are a lot more complex than a sharp thing in a bed, with a crack over it.

That said there are specialty areas that break the rules. Hand built bikes are essentially made of aircraft chromoly tubing. It is dogma that you can't braze that stuff, and for good reason, yet the bike guys traditionally brazed their frames, but they didn't crack as a rule. There are many examples of that kind of thing, and we have had research scientist level metallurgists on some of these boards telling use stuff we do every day can't happen.

Re: How to repair a cracked plane

#11

Re: How to repair a cracked plane

Dale Stansbery

If you're not too concerned about the aesthetics, brazing is a lot easier than welding thin cast iron on planes, but you still have to keep the piece uniformly heated. I've seen a number repaired this way. I've arc welded a number of cast iron machinery parts here on the farm, but they were heavier and a little more forgiving. I wouldn't try a plane body.

Re: How to repair a cracked plane

#12

Re: How to repair a cracked plane

Gary B.

I seem to remember a good article on brazing a plane body. That really seemed like the way to go. Hopefully someone has a link.