New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Lingerie Chest - Mortice and Tenons

Posts

Lingerie Chest - Mortice and Tenons

#1

Lingerie Chest - Mortice and Tenons

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

There are a couple of techniques regarding tuning of the mortice and tenon that hopefully are worthy of discussion.

The next chapter of the build is here: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/Furniture/LingerieChestMorticeTenons.html

For those who just want the update on the build progress, here it is ..


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Lingerie Chest - Mortice and Tenons

#2

Re: Lingerie Chest - Mortice and Tenons

RK near Boston

Nice tutorial on your website!

Which float do you prefer for this task?

Thanks.

Re: Lingerie Chest - Mortice and Tenons

#4

Thanks! NM Re: Lingerie Chest - Mortice and Tenons


Re: Lingerie Chest - Mortice and Tenons

#6

Clint Searl

Re: HNT Gordon making Tenons

Clint Searl

Noticing on the video that when he pulls the plane back, it sounds like the blade is sliding. Yes? And if so does it have any dulling or other effect?

Re: Lingerie Chest - Mortice and Tenons

#7

Keeping the blade down

Jim Matthews

If anything, it strops the blade.

Steel is much harder than the wood it's cutting.

This method keeps the scoring blade (the nicker) engaged to keep the track

square and level.

There's no reason to lift you plane off the work, unless you want to stop the cut.

When I started, I lifted the plane at the end of each pass, and placed it back down

at the beginning of the next. This lead to bowl shaped surfaces as the plane

was cutting more in the middle of each pass.

Re: Lingerie Chest - Mortice and Tenons

#8

dulling

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"And if so does it have any dulling or other effect? "

You bet it does. Steve Elliot has demonstrated that dulling as we experience it is due to a loss of clearance on the blade bottom. Friction causes dulling which ever direction it is occurring.

Re: Lingerie Chest - Mortice and Tenons

#9

Ellis Walentine

Hmm. Abrasion?

Ellis Walentine

Friction itself wouldn't seem to cause dulling. Abrasion would. I wonder where the truth lies. Is there some measure of abrasion in every contact between wood and steel? And, if so, does it necessarily result in a degrade in planing performance?

I use a hardwood strop to put the final mirror edge on plane irons. Is the difference that I strop with the bevel flat on the strop, while a plane iron is canted up by whatever the clearance angle is? Does that put a microbevel on the cutting edge parallel to the sole that degrades performance?

Splitting hairs here, but Jim's post has me wondering?

Ellis

Re: Lingerie Chest - Mortice and Tenons

#10

Ellis Walentine

Question for you

Ellis Walentine

You mention in your blog post that you will add bow-shaped fillers to the front blades. Is this preferable to cutting the blades oversize and shaping them to fit?

Ellis

Re: Lingerie Chest - Mortice and Tenons

#11

Re: Question for you

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Ellis

Good question ... AND this gives me an idea (no doubt you have already considered this! :) )

I went back-and-forth on this a while back. The advantage of one piece (front blade shaped to fit inside the drawer front), is obvious - all in one piece. The disadvantage is that the projection on the sides (into the legs) is less easy to judge. I want the exterior of the drawers to end 1mm inside the legs. The bow on the drawers will become less as the drawers become narrower.

Here is the bow for the lower drawer (the same curve is for all the drawers, calculated from the centre) ...


What I had planned to do is add a filler to each drawer - just make one or two thick pieces and slice off enough for all the drawers.

What is also possible is to add the bow to the existing front drawer blades, extend the sliding dovetails by the 2mm at the ends I planned to add on the filler pieces, and slide them forward into position. That would be easy. However, the bow is about 5mm at the centre (from memory) on the large drawer, and there will be shifting back-and-forth to get the projection the same for 22mm thick drawer fronts.

Your thoughts?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Lingerie Chest - Mortice and Tenons

#12

false premise

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"Friction itself wouldn't seem to cause dulling"

Quite the opposite. Friction always results in loss of material at the rubbing surface, more or less, by one mechanism or another, or combination.

In the Kato and Kawai papers they revealed substantial loss of metal (wear) on the top side of the blade just behind the tip when the cap iron was working. This wear was at the point of greatest contact pressure of the shaving sliding up the blade surface ahead of the "dam" created by the leading edge of the cap iron. Loss of metal at this point as a result of the sliding friction of shaving against metal is functionally no different than the case of dragging the plane across the wood surface in the return stroke of planing.

But it is a simple hypothesis to confirm. Sharpen up a blade and only drag it backwards across a wood surface for the equivalent of 2 or 3 hundred meters and look at the result.