New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Wiley's Pattern..

Posts

Wiley's Pattern..

#1

Wiley's Pattern..

david weaver

...yeah, nothing new. Another one of a similar plane, and last one for a little while maybe. I can't stop trying things, but sometimes they don't turn out the way I want.

I call it wiley's pattern because wiley made a generous gesture and put a spare matheison jack of his in my possession which gives me both a handle to copy and the right proportions and locations of things.

Maybe copy isn't the right word, it's not a dead copy, but heavily influenced by.

I thought since this isn't going to be my plane, that I'd make the wedge a bit laterally undersized at the top, but tight at the tips of the fingers. I think it just looks like it's the wrong size. I made it short so it would be a while before it had to be cut to adjust the iron. It doesn't look terrible, but a lot of these planes have very bold wedges that are square all the way to the top and large. I'd make it taller and wider if I did it again. You can see from above, having the gap just doesn't look right.

Also, a stray float stroke made the mouth not as tidy laterally on the bottom as I'd like, but that picture didn't come out right, so it's not shown. It's got a couple of things like that are the kind of things that torture you when you just want to make one just right, but I'm sure it will work fine.

http://s3.postimg.org/71f62gk03/20150926_143229_1.jpg

http://s21.postimg.org/elw3ln15z/20150926_143241_1.jpg

http://s14.postimg.org/4zu7sstch/20150926_143256_1.jpg

http://s27.postimg.org/arvt3cymr/20150926_143330_1.jpg

The light stripe down the middle is the transition from heart to sap, sometimes it's really distinct like this. I think it looks neat, but over time it will all become the same color.

Thanks, Wiley! It's so nice to have a decent plane to start from.

Re: Wiley's Pattern..

#2

Re: Wiley's Pattern..

TomD

"I thought since this isn't going to be my plane, that I'd make the wedge a bit laterally undersized at the top, but tight at the tips of the fingers. I think it just looks like it's the wrong size."

Working more in a vacuum up here, I don't get to copy good planes, I just make the fingers wider because it makes sense to me. My wedge wouldn't fit in laterally but I take a shaving or two off the sides so the fingers are sprung to the side and one hopes a shaving never gets jammed up there.

Re: Wiley's Pattern..

#3

Re: Wiley's Pattern..

david weaver

I don't think I did a very good job of describing that. I spring the fingers a little bit but have generally left the rest of the wedge pretty tight. On old planes I've looked at, the wedge or iron have split the cheeks out of a lot of them.

On my try plane, which I made in march, I noticed that the fairly snug wedge is laterally snug. I have to figure over time after looking at some moulding planes I made a while ago, of kiln dried woods, that the whole plane will shrink some, but I don't know how much.

I thought it might be a good idea to build the wedge a little loose except for the fingers, as the fingers can flex if the top of the plane shrinks (the top should shrink the least). I got carried away and it's probably too loose looking.

I just tested the plane, it works fine, it's more of an irk because some of the first planes I built had some sloppiness around the wedge laterally. Now I did it on purpose, but it really shouldn't ever be a problem unless the plane ends up with a user that ignores it for a period of time only to find that it's gotten tight on the wedge and iron. This one has enough room that won't happen, but I'm sending it to Brian Holcombe, who uses hand tools a lot, so it shouldn't get neglected.

Of course, he could also easily make another wedge if he didn't like the way it looks.

Re: Wiley's Pattern..

#4

Re: Wiley's Pattern..

TomD

I'm not really sure why the wedge splits planes if it is made of the same stuff. I have seen the same damage, though it is often on the side of the mouth where the wedge has little influence. The blade would seem the obvious culprit but it normally just drops out.

Re: Wiley's Pattern..

#5

Re: Wiley's Pattern..

Steve Voigt

A very nice looking plane, David. Lovely crisp details. I like the stripe on the side actually, but as you say it will all become the same color rather quickly. Amazing how beech does that.

One small question/quibble. Do you usually leave sharp corners at the front, where the long and stopped chamfers meet? It definitely looks good, especially when they meet so nicely, but I always knock off the corners with a chisel because they dig into my hand, maybe not so much on a long plane but definitely on jack, where my hand will certainly find that spot. Just a thought.

Wiley is the man! Just a couple weeks ago I had some very specific and arcane questions, and he was a huge help with photos and very precise measurements. What a great guy.

Re: Wiley's Pattern..

#6

Re: Wiley's Pattern..

david weaver

I would guess blade, too, as I've had trouble getting both out of a seized plane, but the wedge may have a little bit of compression whereas the iron has none.

I recall hammering planes pretty hard to get the wedge out, but never near muscle pulling events like you can have trying to get an iron out of a plane that hasn't been used in a century. My only single iron plane had not been used and the iron was almost impossible to get out. It's as if the plane had grown around it with a grip.

Two good things about this plane, one is that it's going to be a jack plane and all of the details about the fingers affect something like a try or smoother plane working a chip on the edges, but no chips should get to the edge of it. The second is that any skilled woodworker can make a second wedge if they don't like the first. QS beech in thicknesses that wedges are made out of can be had pretty easily.

Re: Wiley's Pattern..

#7

Re: Wiley's Pattern..

david weaver

Thanks, Steve - i leave them on as I haven't gotten my hands into them on my own keeper jack plane. My front hand is always just somewhere around the top of the escapement in use, but not past the front.

I have broken the edges all the way around on some planes (except where the chamfer meets the top - I guess that's already a broken edge via the chamfer), but more out of fear of damage - not that the damage has ever been that small.

I was reminded tonight in testing this plane, sort of a formality with a jack plane, how nice it is to use them, and how slick they are. I don't know if anything was ever written about grip on these, but I tend to grip the jacks with a mostly open grip and the front hand stays on. I'm assuming since a lot of the nice jacks have pretty short grips, that the makers assumed the users would have some fingers draping over the side of the plane at least. Have you run across anything that suggests anything regarding the steeper forward angle on the jacks, and the sometimes shorter handles (but not as short as the types George Wilson mentions where the user is only intended to get two fingers on the handle)?

Re: Wiley's Pattern..

#8

Re: Wiley's Pattern..

Steve Voigt

I am with you on the pleasures of using these. This weekend I am face-jointing 14 boards of 2 x stock, 6' long, a thankless task if there ever was one, but being able to quickly rip off most of the waste with the double iron jack makes the going a lot better.

Regarding handles, I assume you are talking about the plane equivalent of "hang" angle on saws? No, I haven't really strayed from the typical early to mid-19th c. handle in terms of angles, length, and shaping. One thing that caught my attention last week was when Chris Schwarz posted some pics of the Seaton planes, pics that are not in the book. There was a good look at the handles and I was struck by how the type of handle that I think of as 19th c. was already full blown in 1796. It suggests to me that handle evolution reached a peak in the late 18th c. and stayed there until very late in the game.

Re: Wiley's Pattern..

#9

Re: Wiley's Pattern..

Brian Holcombe

Veeerry much looking forward to putting this plane to use :D David has been kind enough to make these planes for me ( this jack and try plane) After some discussion on the merits of wooden soled planes, which at the time was only in the abstract for me. I had been yearning for a combination of planes that would make my work on panels and tables a bit easier to accomplish. The try plane zooms through the work and without a heavy camber or waxing every few passes. So after having put that to work I was definetly wanting to experience that same effect in every aspect of the process.

Another interesting thing I've noticed in using these planes brings me back to a discussion of 18th and 19th century handle ergonomics. The Try plane is one of the few planes in my shop that does not tire my palms after some hours are put on it. I have a feeling that the jack plane will be very similar.

Re: Wiley's Pattern..

#10

Angle, like hang. Yes

david weaver

I took another picture of this handle, I don't know if it's any more useful than the face on picture in the original thread. I haven't deviated from what most of the makers did except at the end of the 18th century and early 19th, a lot of them ran the top curve all the way to the top (that's how George put it to me) and the handles were fairly straight up to that point.

I use the term "tucking the curve in" for enlarging that cut in for the web of the hand, which changes the angle a little, but not much. On mathiesons, I haven't had to do it at all, the two that I have are exaggerated there (they are both jack length planes) and they put a big hump in the palm jutting out from that.

My try planes, i measure the prevailing angle at a little more than 60, and the jack planes a little less than that. I measure this jack about 57.

http://s30.postimg.org/kg17lagnl/20150927_094330_1.jpg

I don't know if there's anything about holds on planes, but I've come up with this as the most comfortable with the jacks, which may explain why a lot of the older ones have very short handles, but not the two finger type handles george talks about which are extremely short. The mathieson I copied has a handle 3.5" to the top of the horn (so less room than that under it).

http://s23.postimg.org/va34neoqz/20150927_094136_1.jpg

I made this one a bit bigger than that, but i don't know that it has to be. In actual use, I think it's more like I just pull the plane back with my first two fingers and the rest of the time, my hand is open. It just seems to be the most comfortable.

re: the seaton planes, they look a lot like everything made up to the mid 1800s or later for the english planes, though the handles look just a tiny bit blocky.

It's interesting that even at that point, the sides were rounded over instead of chamfer. I wonder why they did that, because the way the roundovers are blended together on the back of the one plane in the picture on CS's blog ( I looked) appears to be carefully done. I still like the look of chamfers better.

The finest saw handles I've ever seen were on some saws out of that chest. They are on one of wiktor kuc's pages, but I can never find them when I look.

Re: Wiley's Pattern..

#11

Re: Wiley's Pattern..

TomD

"I was reminded tonight in testing this plane, sort of a formality with a jack plane, how nice it is to use them, and how slick they are. I don't know if anything was ever written about grip on these, but I tend to grip the jacks with a mostly open grip and the front hand stays on."

Based on my competitive archery experience I use a grip where the nuckles are around 45 degree, and the life line is more or less centered on the backstrap of the grip. This is the zero torque position, and also fairly powerful.

" I'm assuming since a lot of the nice jacks have pretty short grips, that the makers assumed the users would have some fingers draping over the side of the plane at least. Have you run across anything that suggests anything regarding the steeper forward angle on the jacks, and the sometimes shorter handles (but not as short as the types George Wilson mentions where the user is only intended to get two fingers on the handle)? "

Another thing is how cheap and nasty jacks look in comparison to the jointers etc.... Why don't they have the fancy closed totes, though boatbuilder's planes often did. Makes one wonder if the jack planing was being done by apprentice boys or something. Our tendency is to look for a solid technical reason for everything when the explanation could be social.

I made a plane similar to the jack plane that C&W used to make and ended up with a huge handle on the thing. It came out too large, but it is perfectly usable.

Re: Wiley's Pattern..

#12

Re: Wiley's Pattern..

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi David and all,

Really glad to see that you and Brian have put that pattern to good use. (Also am endlessly grateful you didn't post a pic of the original beater I sent along :) ; you did fantastic in your adaptation.) David's revival of the olden tyme woodies is a great contribution, and one which will last.

Incidentally, I have a great liking for narrow models (like 2 to 2-1/4" irons at 20-27" lengths) for edge jointing.

I'm still following the forum each day and would be contributing, but I have a personal commitment right now which doesn't allow time or loss of focus to really get involved.

Best wishes to all,

Wiley

Re: Wiley's Pattern..

#13

Re: Right one wrong..

david weaver

Thankfully, of all of the things you could have to redo, a wedge is about the easiest.

This one might be a bit long, but brian can cut it down if he runs through 1/4" of iron, and it's not lacking in width (which will be much better for the abutments in the long run as they'll size to the full width wedge instead of part of them.

I hate the idea of a possible abutment split, even though I don't think it would've occurred, I'd rather not remake a plane for it.

http://s2.postimg.org/cmhrvgue1/20150927_134752_1.jpg

(white overhead light is terrible for pictures. It hardly looks like the same plane.)

Green cordless drill may look suspicious in the pictures, but sometimes the kids wander around the shop and bust the ends off of my pencils - more than just the tip. The easiest way to get all of the pencils back in shape is a cordless drill and one of the inexpensive little Kum sharpeners that David Barnett pointed us to a while ago.

Re: Wiley's Pattern..

#14

Re: Wiley's Pattern..

david weaver

Yeah, I don't know the answer to that. One thing I'm not good at is being attentive enough to actually look at the history for history's sake for anything.

The very first open handle jack I had was an ohio jack, and the handle was tall and I could feel it spring as I pushed the plane. I was sure it would break if I used it hard, but it probably wouldn't have. It was such a junk plane (combination of how it was made, and the fact that it was well worn with a gigantic mouth and wedge that had shrunk considerably).

Anyway, I've got one old open handle jack and one old closed handle jack. I've cut up the rest. I don't know if I've got a great preference, but a 17" plane with a full handle doesn't leave much room off the back of the plane. By that, I mean that on a closed handle, the iron needs to clear the handle to be struck, so a handle that's really short can be fairly close, but the taller the handle, the further it has to be from the iron and it can end up right on the back of the plane (a closed handle already is). When it's open, you don't have to abide by that so the handle can be closer to the iron, and even if not, there's no loop in front of the handle to clear so the handle can still be further ahead.

My closed handle jacks (I've copied the old one, too) are 2 1/2" wide, something that doesn't make a lot of sense on a jack plane, but you do get extra weight. The open handled jacks are narrower, so it's really hard to tell what's what (in terms of what seems nicer to use).

I think I might like the open handle better, but it's a luxury choice since either works well, and most of the cuts with a jack plane are not the kind of hard cranking that a really heavy try plane shaving is.

I don't know anything about the demands of boatbuilders or reform planes, because I just can't get along with the look of a razee plane, and the old lignum and rosewood boat planes are usually pretty beat and look like they were intended for very rough work.

Re: Wiley's Pattern..

#15

Re: Wiley's Pattern..

david weaver

Wiley, if you want something like you're talking about in double iron (a long plane with a narrow iron), let me know later in the winter. I could send your double iron set from the matheison jack right back to you surrounded by different wood.

I've got to take a short break from building now due to work, and some other things I should finish up, but I've still got a lot of wood left.

Thanks again for the generosity, I can't complain too much about the plane condition given that there's plenty there for me to take measurements off of (and it could easily be used).

The handle profile is the nicest of the open handle style that I've used (in terms of comfort). I posted it here in case anyone wants to make a jack handle and needs a good template to print. (for anyone using one, they can, of course, be scaled to any height using the print setup function and printing any % of the original size.)

http://s10.postimg.org/do8q3h2s9/P1080379.jpg

Re: Wiley's Pattern..

#16

Seaton chest planes

Warren in Lancaster, PA

By measuring pictures in the Seaton chest book and comparing with published dimensions, I was able to compute 3.53 inches high overall for the jack plane handles and 3.75 for the trying plane handle. Similar measuring for Dominy try (1809) and jack planes(1792) yielded 3.97 and 3.95 respectively. None appear to be two finger grips.

A few years ago I was talking to Jane Rees and Jay Gaynor and mentioned to them how helpful it would have been to have measured drawings of the Seaton planes. (Jay made some of the measured drawings in the Seaton chest book, Jane edited the book.) Jane, who is from England, said it wasn't very important because there are so many Gabriel planes around. I still don't have a Gabriel plane. I have made a very comfortable saw handle from one of Jay's fine drawings.

Re: Wiley's Pattern..

#17

Re: two fingered grips..

david weaver

...i don't think the two fingered grips were around by the time we're talking about, either. I don't know when they were prevalent.

There's a lot of variation in jack handles (in terms of height), and to some extent, try plane handles that I've seen, too, but I don't have any planes before 1820. The one that I have that is around 1820 has a handle that would look pretty nice today except the top curve is pushed up high (as george had described being common) and the front of the handle (it's a closed handle) has a style that does look a bit old.

At any rate, not suggesting that anyone should build true two finger grip handles, just that on the more modern handles that can be a bit short, it's more comfortable sometimes to work with a looser grip.

I have only built one plane where the handle was in fact very short and even a cramped grip won't fit, and I didn't like it very much - maybe because I'm not used to it, I don't know. I've also built one jack with the handle offset (it's the one I use), and I'm used to it I guess, but I like the jack I built for brian, and the other that I put on here (went to Chris Griggs) better. Of all of the planes that I've made, the ones that I have kept are the worst of the bunch for various reasons.

Re: Wiley's Pattern..

#18

Re: Wiley's Pattern..

david weaver

Same story with the handle- just more downward angle on it and a little bit less height. It should be something that you can get fatigued using, but never be put in any pain.

As nice as the old planes work, I'd hate to fish with any of the patterns at all!!

Re: Wiley's Pattern..

#19

Re: two fingered grips..

TomD

"Of all of the planes that I've made, the ones that I have kept are the worst of the bunch for various reasons."

That is so true and may have something to do with the technical models we are trying to figure out. I remember once looking at my record collection and realizing it contained what were to me some highbrow choices, but also a lot of earworm stuff I bought because it appealed to me, but was not the more standard stuff because you could always count on Hotel Californian droning on in the background somewhere. I bought the stuff that was more oddball because otherwise it would have been lost to me. Someone looking at the collection as either typical of my taste, or more generally the taste of people of the day, would be seriously misled.

Sometimes one ends up with the stuff that one couldn't even shift on Ebay. My main jointer these last 35 years is a Record from a bad period in their production, but it always worked great, and even though I don't like the type it gets the job done and was bought for me by my dad.

Re: Wiley's Pattern..

#20

Re: two fingered grips..

david weaver

In the case of my planes, they were generally just the first ones I've built, so they have cosmetic compromises. but they work well. What could I do with them? I doubt I could sell them for the cost of materials and I'd hate to put them in the hands of someone who really needs a plane with one iron and nothing more complicated.

I hear you on the music, too, and for me, the sharpening stones. There are times I've gotten all of my money back on an oddball sharpening stone, but not many.

The unfortunate truth in planes is that #15 is likely to be better than #1-5, but that doesn't help me figure out what to do with planes #2 and #3 if I make better versions for myself (#1 was a 10 pound 28 inch jointer - I couldn't ever expect to use it often enough to be worth making another one - the first one works fine, I can just do a better job cosmetically now).

I guess we all sit back and deal with the stuff that we have that we think we would probably appreciate more than others would. The difference between us and shysters is that a shyster just oversells the stuff they have that's not that good so they can get rid of it.