New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

diamond paste plate

Posts

diamond paste plate

#1

diamond paste plate

Jerry Gibbs

I have an old cast iron band saw table 12" square ( I have trouble throwing things out). Will this work for diamond paste sharpening? How flat does the plate have to be? Should I cut the table in pieces or just mark off the different grits? Thanks.

Re: diamond paste plate

#2

Re: diamond paste plate

John in NM

It only needs to be as flat as you want the biggest thing you will hone or flatten. So for chisels and blades, less flat needed than plane soles.

I would cut it, contamination will probably be a problem if you do not. If you plan to do some flattening, wait until after you cut it as it could move as a result of cutting.

Re: diamond paste plate

#3

Re: diamond paste plate

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I have an old cast iron band saw table 12" square ( I have trouble throwing things out). Will this work for diamond paste sharpening? How flat does the plate have to be? Should I cut the table in pieces or just mark off the different grits? Thanks.

Hi Jerry

Cast iron is excellent for diamond paste.

Flatness is important when restoring chisels and plane blades, such as when lapping their backs. Flatness also makes it more predictable and, therefore, easier to move from one grit to another.

If you can, cut the table into 3"x8" (even 10") pieces, and then lap these on sandpaper on a flat surface (as you would a plane). I think that nothing longer would require professional (surfacing) services and then not be a cost saving.

This may give you some ideas: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/WoodworkTechniques/Castironhoningplatesfordiamondpaste.html

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: diamond paste plate

#4

Re: diamond paste plate

Jim Matthews

Table saw castings are ideal for lapping plates.

That said, put today's date (or whenever you 'officially' start)

in bold Sharpie marker on the casting.

If you haven't used it in a year, it's just another clutter magnet.

FWIW - There are less fussy, quicker methods to sharpen the blades seeing daily use.

I'm after 10 minutes or less, from hauling things out to cleaning up afterwards.

I'm not sure that diamond pastes could be handled that quickly.

Jim

Re: diamond paste plate

#5

Experience that refutes your assumption

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

When I was researching how to abrade (sharpen) abrasion resistant tool steels the universal recommendation from abrasive manufacturers was to use diamond. For a given grit size nothing cuts faster. Comparing diamond to aluminum oxide, the most common abrasive used by woodworkers for sharpening, the difference is huge. But, as you imply, there are factors in addition to rate of material removal that must be considered in judging the overall time to sharpen a dull tool. What several years experience in my shop has demonstrated is that fresh loose diamond charged onto cast iron cuts any steel used for woodworking tools blazing fast.

The problem to be solved is how to use loose diamond on cast iron the most effective way. Some will disagree, but my experience and that of machinists who have used this technique for decades has concluded that there is carryover of coarser particles to the subsequent plate used for the next finer size abrasive. Plate contamination will eventually require resurfacing the plate. Grit carryover, if you believe in it, limits the use of loose diamond to one grit size in a sharpening sequence. So, where is the best place to use this one opportunity to use diamond paste to cut really fast?

Back flattening, old tool pit removal, and other "high volume" material removal needs are a substantially different topic than sharpening a dull plane blade. I can describe the use of loose diamond for these annoying tasks if there is interest. The technique uses much coarser particles on plastic substrate.

My tool sharping arsenal incudes a grinding wheel employing a soft bond pink aluminum oxide wheel, various cast iron plates and diamond pastes, a grade "fine" fixed diamond plate and leather charged with the green stick.

For years I hollow ground on the wheel as needed, refined the edge on the fine fixed diamond plate and finished up with 1 micron diamond on cast iron. This approach easily meets your 10 minute target even for a very dull edge on a highly abrasion resistant tools steel like CPM 3V, M2, A2 or one of the 440 high performance steels. The problem with this sequence is that the highly effective loose diamond is being used in the place where speed is least needed. Also, for my needs, it may not be necessary to refine an edge to 1 micron.

To that end I have been experimenting with using some grit size of loose diamond after hollow grinding followed directly by green stick on leather. I have not come to a conclusion of what loose grit size is best but it will be around 10 micron +/-. Also I have not come to a conclusion whether this new approach is preferred. I hope others will experiment with this use of diamond paste.

Re: diamond paste plate

#6

Re: Experience that refutes your assumption

Jim Matthews

"My tool sharping arsenal incudes a grinding wheel employing a soft bond pink

aluminum oxide wheel, various cast iron plates and diamond pastes, a grade

"fine" fixed diamond plate and leather charged with the green stick."

" This approach easily meets your 10 minute target even for a very dull edge on a highly abrasion resistant tools steel... "

Two oil stones and a coarse diamond plate for me. All three fit beneath my bench.

Like I said - less fuss.

Re: diamond paste plate

#7

Re: diamond paste plate

Tony - Memphis

I've been using the Sharpie theory for boxes in the attic too!

I agree with you. I don't have space for a dedicated sharpening area, so I tend to put off sharpening becuase of the effort and the space required. And using dull tools is no fun. I am using waterstones at the moment. I keep them in small plastic boxes full of water. To haul them out and keep water off the bench and current project(s), can be a pain. I'm no micron chaser, I just want decently sharp edges.

Tony

Re: diamond paste plate

#8

A question for you Bill

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

"My tool sharping arsenal incudes a grinding wheel employing a soft bond pink aluminum oxide wheel, various cast iron plates and diamond pastes, a grade "fine" fixed diamond plate and leather charged with the green stick."

What does this mean? I think I have one of those green stick things that is some kind of polishing compound. I don't remember when or why I bought it, but it was a long time ago.

How is it used? What is the procedure?

Thanks!

Re: diamond paste plate

#9

Re: diamond paste plate

TomD

Scary sharp sandpaper system. I started using it when I was doing demos and I didn't want to schlep my waterstones everywhere. Normally I might not need to sharpen, though it depends what style of tools I show up with, but I took two pieces of sandpaper and glued them to either sides of some very flat and stiff plywood. What stunned me was how long the paper held up, I figured I would be lucky if they lasted the demo, but was still using one of these jigs for touchups a few years later. I started using the system a lot because it is too cold for water in the shop during the winter, and it was less hassle than the oil stones.

I have since moved to diamond for this kind of thing, not sure it is better because my particular surfaces are softer. I find it is dynamite on leather, but not so nice to use on iron, and I have some very nice iron scraps left over from a restoration expert.

In summer I throw 4 stones in a bucket. I have two of my starter stones, and I rub them together to keep them flat, I think they are King 800s, then I have a mid and fine. I rub the mid against the starter, and the fine on the mid. Very simple and traditional system and it works great. Since I have hundreds of Japanese tools waterstones are a good fit.

Re: diamond paste plate

#10

the stick

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

As I understand it the green stick is a mix of aluminum oxide and chromium oxide. rubbed onto leather it provides a fine abrasive format.

Re: diamond paste plate

#11

Green Sticks

Bruce McCrory

Like a "green thumb", but for steel.....

The diversion to how one sharpens has my interest, since I don't have a spare saw table to chop up.

I think my .5 micron paste on steel plate creates a nice reflection. A quick lesson from a turner (different steels, different abrasive needs) discouraged me from using leather. That, on top of dulling chip carving blades on leather strops.... Those things are best for childhood education. But the leather age is a little before me.

Re: diamond paste plate

#12

Re: Experience that refutes your assumption

TomD

"The problem to be solved is how to use loose diamond on cast iron the most effective way. Some will disagree, but my experience and that of machinists who have used this technique for decades has concluded that there is carryover of coarser particles to the subsequent plate used for the next finer size abrasive."

Not being a prick about this, but I am not sure I have ever heard of a machinist who used diamond sharpening, or for that mater much sharpening at all. I am weak on cutter history, but I would guess a large part of the post war world has been devoted to insert ooling where it gets tossed or rotated when it gets dull. Sorta like arguing over sharpening methods for spiral cutterhead planers. Yeah somewhere there is a dude with a lot of time and a really small jig sharpening all those inserts...

Now hobbyists like myself still enjoy the HSS tooling, and sharpening in 99% of cases, would be grind on green wheel, polish on oil stone. I polish with diamonds, but only due to the expertise of people like you here.

"Plate contamination will eventually require resurfacing the plate. Grit carryover, if you believe in it, limits the use of loose diamond to one grit size in a sharpening sequence. So, where is the best place to use this one opportunity to use diamond paste to cut really fast?"

I think the choice you suggest is rational if every resharpening is accross te full seven ages of man. But what I first started using diamond for was leather tools and so forth. Just happened to be what I had in hand at the time. So let's say you want to cut out a holster. Typically the head knife would get sharpened once or even twice during that process. The moment you start to hear the cutting action it is back to the strop. Head knives are like razors and sythes, they are made soft to be thing so the edge can be set, but they need constant sharpening.

Anyway, my vote is to use the diamond paste that most rapidly gets a rocking edge, the honing step, then just refresh the edge every time it stops cutting. The two main tool types are the chisel type tools and planes. To make this work for planes you need to have a plane you can cycle really fast otherwise you won't want to stop to sharpen it. If you have a plane where the cycle time is 5-10 seconds it is a non-issue.

Re: diamond paste plate

#13

Some data

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You post was a bit murky but making a guess of its direction I will provide the following observations.

Professional turner ( he turned parts in an English factory as well as eventually ran his own furniture and architectural parts making shop) Alan Batty kept a leather strop hung from his belt whilst turning. The factory sharpened tools at the start of the day and at noon, and rubbed them on leather in between, I was informed.

A professional carver here in town only sharpens his carving tools by rubbing on leather as he carves. (the leather may be charged , I didn't ask).

Re: diamond paste plate

#14

Re: Your flairs are back in style.

TomD

Basically the green compound LV sells, one piece lasts a very long time.

I made a claim (I think because Tag Frid sharpened this way) here several years back that with certain simple steels you could go directly from the power grind to the power buff and get a razor edge. I forget the context, but it may have been the modestly expressed war over threads that asked why anyone would sharpen with anything other than diamond. A few people reproduced the experiment, though I don't believe it is anything like the ideal edge, the point at the time was merely that if you want fast, put power into the equation, the cutting medium is secondary.

So now we have a new discovery, the diamonds aren't perfect, and maybe we should sharpen with power. Wow. My main comment on the bridge grit is that it really won't mater what you use. if you power grind and are going to buff, or strop, 95 % of the work is done, and the middle process can be anything you want. In my shop there will be a lot of factors other than performance that will determine that. Sandpaper might be the trick or mono diamonds, whatever is least messy.

Re: diamond paste plate

#15

Re: Fast

david weaver

Fast is old steel and a washita stone. I just can't think of anything faster, total time included and all.

Anything that doesn't love natural stones, a 1k diamond hone and pretty much anything following is almost as fast.

i've found that okudo suita cuts almost anything if the bevel is small, including the high speed steel that comes in mujingfang planes. Okudo can be had in koppa for small pieces for about the price of a synthetic hone, but it's nicer to use and gentler on the steel (which has a side benefit, maybe a topic for another day).

I've timed myself grinding, which is also part of keeping sharpening time down, and when I grind every 4th or 5th time I fully hone something, it takes about 30-45 seconds total. On a stanley plane iron, I grind as soon as the bevel is about 1/3rd the thickness of the iron, and the harder the steel the more often I do it.

If I am sharpening an older paring chisel, I will use the washita and chase the burr with jasper (which costs almost nothing). I have never gotten a better edge off of anything, and it is kind to the geometry because it doesn't really do anything other than refine the very tip.

(I don't use many things that require the diamond hone now).

Re: diamond paste plate

#16

Re: Fast

TomD

"(I don't use many things that require the diamond hone now). "

Well fancy that.

I like the diamond... I never have to break off a fresh dollar store Olfa cutter, or change a carpet knife blade. I also use it to sharpen sewing machine needles.

Re: diamond paste plate

#17

Re: Fast

david weaver

I haven't sharpened a sewing machine needle, but most of the knives out there sharpen pretty well on the washita.

I sharpen everything I can get my fingers on, including cheap utility knife blades. You'd be surprised how long one will go in a utility knife before the geometry becomes a problem. I got a small box of cheap blades from HF a few years ago to cut up recyclables, and my two knives both have their first blades in them.

Japanese marking knives like a washita, too. So do the iyoroi level of japanese chisels. Anything run up to 65 hardness is a bit too hard, but I have a set of kamaji backed (mokume design, i guess) chisels that iyoroi makes, and they are white II. They're harder than western chisels, but not as hard as they claim to be and they work a treat on everything.

The side benefit is that it's an even fight between washita and chisel so the edge is better than it would be on a softer steel - similar to good quality suita. The kamaji cleans off the surface of the washita, too.

Re: diamond paste plate

#18

Re: Some data

Bruce McCrory

No critique intended, Bill. Some don't find leather stropping useful; me for one. If it works, great. The turner in my earlier comment uses HSS (I think most do, now) and only a fine diamond card for the hone, after a CBN wheel. As I noted, it's a different tiger.

Way back, I looked into a different sharpening regime and read where green sticks had to be dark green, not just green, to be useful. Then, I needed a flattening plate, and then ceramic, then water, not oil, blahdy-blah. One trip through four stones and a strop on japanese steel was the end of stinky wet stones.

My method with diamond paste works. For me. A dab of paste, a drop of water, a few swipes, then a *dedicated* paper napkin and the next plate is put onto the pad--with it's own dedicated napkin. There are only three abrasives (at most) to hassle with. If I didn't have an axe, the rarely used grinding wheel would probably go.

Sharpening used to be fun with a pocket knife. Now, I would rather watch paint dry.