New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

MF 15 1/2 mitrebox rebuild and Groves saw build

Posts

MF 15 1/2 mitrebox rebuild and Groves saw build

#1

MF 15 1/2 mitrebox rebuild and Groves saw build

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I've wanted a small mitre box for sawing mouldings forever. The Miller's Falls #74 I have is a HUGE beast, a carpenter's tool. Had my eye on a Miller's Falls #15 1/2 several years ago, but then it got Schwarzed, and I watched the prices climb. Finally I just built a small mitre box, the Steam Punk Mitre box, which was fun and functional, but I doubt that it has the fortitude to take it into the next century.

I kept an eye on eBay, and a #15 1/2 would come up every now-and-then, but starting at silly money. Damn The Schwarz.

Finally one came up that was reasonable, not cheap, but reasonable (with low shipping - that is the killer to Oz) .. and there looked to be little interest from others. Not too surprising as it had issues. I put in a snipe bid, and won it. Of course the Seller miscalculated shipping costs, but was good for the amount .. however sent it on a slow ship. It arrived ... eventually.

It looked like this ..


The # 15 1/2 is 12" long. Here it is with the #74C and its 28" long x 5 1/2" deep saw ...


The issues? Well, the rear guide had broken off (must have been dropped) and been brazed. It was a good job insofar being straight ...


The shell was stripped down, and one of the repairs was to smooth over the weld before repainting ...


I discovered that the blade holder (that runs inside the guide) had also been welded at the lower end, and then the weld carefully filed flush. However it removed some of the steel, and now the fit was a little sloppy.

To tighten this up, I tapped both sides of the guide and made set screws in nylon ..


The other modification I made was to add more nylon inside the blade holder, where the saw back runs, to create tighter tolerances and a smooth action. It works really well ..


Now I needed a saw. The original saw was 16" long with a depth of 2 1/2". Here is the one I made - more info in a short while - together with the 28" beast for comparison ...


The saw plate and brass back came from Isaac Smith (Blackburn Tools). The plate is filed 13 tpi crosscut, and is 0.20" thick. The brass back just needed draw filling and polishing. I chose not to go with a folded back as like the clean look of the slotted back, as well as it being a more reliable construction. Isaac does a fabulous job. The saw cuts as cleanly as a Japanese saw.

The saw handle was inspired by a Grove tenon saw handle made by George Wilson, whom I consider to be one of the finest craftsmen around, whether tools or musical instruments. George built the saws for Colonial Williamsburg. Here are two of his saws, a dovetail and the tenon saw in question ...


The detailing on these handles is exceptional, in particular the crisp, defined lines. This was my aim (only, of course, the proportions for a mitre saw will be slightly different).

This is the boring shot of the completed mitre box and saw ...


The wood used throughout is Fiddleback Jarrah. I had a few scrap pieces left over from the Wegner Chair build. I should have remembered that carving it was a nightmare: beautiful but hard and brittle, especially brittle at the edges. A lot of careful work went into the shaping here.

This is the money shot ...


The last issue was that there was a missing depth stop. Consequently, I made two new ones from brass. I thought that would help in matching to the brass in the saw.


I had never made a lamb's tongue like this one before. In looking at photos on the Internet I became aware that no one posted a picture of the underside. So here is mine ...


One other modification was allowing sone of the cast iron to remain unpainted at the front. Here is the combination sawing a mitre. It performs as well as hoped ..


Thanks for looking.


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: MF 15 1/2 mitrebox rebuild and Groves saw build

#2

Re: MF 15 1/2 mitrebox rebuild and Groves saw buil

Ron in Sterling, CT

What a great rehab. Thanks for sharing.

Ron

Re: MF 15 1/2 mitrebox rebuild and Groves saw build

#3

Thanks Derek!

Stuart Hough

Great looking rehab. Only problem is that once this gets out, we'll have a new problem. Now, the 15 1/2 will suffer from the Cohen Effect! :)

Re: MF 15 1/2 mitrebox rebuild and Groves saw build

#4

Re: MF 15 1/2 mitrebox rebuild and Groves saw buil

Gary B.

Derek,

That is simply beautiful! Thanks for sharing! I remember sometime ago, you had posted on your website about a handy miterbox you had made...did that not live up to its purpose? I'm curious, because I just found a great 16" crosscut saw, and I'd like to have something to make it my cross cutting station. (I have a power miter saw, but I love how the handsaw cuts, there is something tranquil about it to me.)

Essentially, I want to be able to mark the piece for length, then cut it reliably square and straight. I can with a scribe line and knife cuts, but that's a bit slow for me for every single crosscut.

Re: MF 15 1/2 mitrebox rebuild and Groves saw build

#5

Re: MF 15 1/2 mitrebox rebuild and Groves saw buil

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Derek,

That is simply beautiful! Thanks for sharing! I remember sometime ago, you had posted on your website about a handy miterbox you had made...did that not live up to its purpose? I'm curious, because I just found a great 16" crosscut saw, and I'd like to have something to make it my cross cutting station. (I have a power miter saw, but I love how the handsaw cuts, there is something tranquil about it to me.)

Essentially, I want to be able to mark the piece for length, then cut it reliably square and straight. I can with a scribe line and knife cuts, but that's a bit slow for me for every single crosscut.

Thanks Gary

First off, I did make a mitre box a while back, which was at the time I was cutting mouldings I made for the skirting of a blanket box. It was easier to saw to the line with a carcase saw than use the large Millers Falls 74C, with its dedicated 28" long and 5 1/2" deep plate. Like trying to swat a fly with a canon. It was the difficulty in finding a #15 1/2 at a decent price that inspired me to build this one (first pictured with the other mitre boxes) ..



If you wish to copy this, the details are here: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ShopMadeTools/SteamPunkMitrebox.html

Now that 16" saw you have, if the same size as the one I built for the #15 1/2, will be ideal for this task. So far I have just used the #15 1/2 to saw tenon shoulders (a bit of practice with setting up for 32 tenon shoulders needed to be sawn in my current build). The saw cuts like a dream and much easier to use than the 14" carcase saw. 2" does not seem much, but it is very evident when wanting a smooth action. I have heard from others that they used a 12" in theirs, but it is too short. Chris Schwarz blogged about getting LN to make him a 16" saw, having found the 14" replacement saw too short as well.

The last item is whether a mitre box is really important in the grand scheme of things. Well, it is not a "must have" tool, and I have not needed one to date. It is useful, and I see it predominantly for preparing mitres on mouldings - but I can saw these freehand. In the end I shoot them anyway (particularly when one realises that nothing is perfectly square anyway). Is it faster to saw tenon shoulders on the mitre box? Again, I can do this perfectly well freehand, and I have discovered that one cannot simply add a stop block and expect the saw will cut equally on each side (as one might do with a table saw). The saw plate is not that rigid. It is still important to create a knife wall. This done, the saw cuts are impressively square, and a little less fine tuning later is needed.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: MF 15 1/2 mitrebox rebuild and Groves saw build

#6

Re: MF 15 1/2 mitrebox rebuild and Groves saw buil

Bill White

Derek, Your work is beyond reproach. Excellent job.

Bill

Re: MF 15 1/2 mitrebox rebuild and Groves saw build

#8

Re: MF 15 1/2 mitrebox rebuild and Groves saw buil

Steve Voigt

Derek, I keep meaning to comment, and then forgetting. Beautiful saw. Love the clean shadow lines of the saw handle. I bet it works a treat!

Re: MF 15 1/2 mitrebox rebuild and Groves saw build

#9

Re: MF 15 1/2 mitrebox rebuild and Groves saw buil

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Thanks Steve.

Please post some photos of your planes here, along with some description of their features. There are many here who will be interested and impressed.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: MF 15 1/2 mitrebox rebuild and Groves saw build

#10

Re: Very Nice Crisp Work, Derek

david weaver

Very Nice and Crisp Work, Derek. I was puzzling about why I didn't see this on the first go around, but I think it's because it has the word miter box in it, which usually isn't something I look for.

Sorry for not commenting earlier, it's very attractive.

Re: MF 15 1/2 mitrebox rebuild and Groves saw build

#12

Re: Thanks David

david weaver

I think you're leading the party with that work!!

....of course...the real party leader has been George, who has single-handedly used his influence to make us worry more about design related parts of our works in a way we never would've considered (I wouldn't have) in the normal forum environment of high fives for all no matter the result.