New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

1st GOOD plane

Posts

1st GOOD plane

#1

1st GOOD plane

Russ

considering 1st good plane for small home shop doing medium to small projects in hard/exotic woods

Any recommendations on type of plane and mfg would be very helpful. There is a lot of info out in cyberspace, but first hand, experienced users know best

Re: 1st GOOD plane

#2

Re: 1st GOOD plane

BrianMonumentCO

Block plane.

Re: 1st GOOD plane

#3

Re: 1st GOOD plane

TomD

sizes and purpose built types. And then you need a bench or beam to support your work.

Do you have a big budget, and can buy new, or do you want to spend a lot of time tuning up old stuff. If you have a decently well equipped shop, or access to some tools, one can make one's own planes rather quickly and get a product at least as good as what is sold for hundreds of dollars. 45 minute ought to get you cutting.

The three most useful planes are a bench plane like a Lie nielsen number 4, a jointer, and a blcok plane. P

Re: 1st GOOD plane

#4

Re: 1st GOOD plane

Russ

Thanks to all!

Especially Mark, but certainly the group has rallied to provide insite and direction.

I am only making small items like cutting boards, toys and boxes

Re: 1st GOOD plane

#5

What plans do you have for the plane?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

The difficulty in recommending one plane is that planes best work as a team, and if purchasing just one plane, it will always be a compromise.

Chris Schwarz has a good video out called "Rough, Medium and Smooth". It is worth getting when you are starting out.

Roughing out is done with a Jack plane (15" long - such as as a Stanley #5) with a strongly curved (radiused) blade. An 8" radius is typical. This enables one to take thick shavings and remove waste quickly. The key factor here is the curved blade. A straight blade cannot plane as deeply.

A Medium plane is one that levels the work and gets it flat. This would be a jointer plane (#7), which is set up with a fine camber. For smaller work (not more than 30" long) one could use a #5 as well (rough rule being that the length of the work is limited to half the length of the plane), but now you need a second blade with the appropriate radius.

The smoother comes in as the final plane. Ideally, this plane just takes the minimum of material (making it the least used of the three planes mentioned). A #4 or a #3 are good choices. The blade is now almost straight with just a minuscule radius to avoid tracks.

Block planes are very useful for relieving edges or trimming end grain.

The jack is followed by the jointer, and finally by the smoother. Do it right (most of the work is done by the jack) and there is little smoothing to do. Do it wrong (leave most of the work for the smoother) and you could be planing more than necessary.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: 1st GOOD plane

#6

Re: What plans do you have for the plane?

Russ

Excellent reply! Just what my simple mind reed to hear!

Much appreciated

Re: 1st GOOD plane

#7

Moses Yoder

Re: 1st GOOD plane

Moses Yoder

Before buying any hand tools I would recommend buying and studying extensively the book "The Anarchist's Tool Chest" by Christopher Schwartz. It is the best $50 I ever spent on hand tools.

Re: 1st GOOD plane

#8

The Schwartz advice....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

.....indeed depends on what you intend to do. The advice has no relevance to my work or that of any of my furniture building acquaintances.

What is "best" is revealed when the choices are equally available and without thinking a plane is reached for. In my case it is an old Bailey #5. I like its weight and balance and I use it where ever I can. I resort to a block plane where the #5 won't fit, or a #4 on the annoying occasions where the #5 bridges over some depression.

I don't see "collections" of planes in mixed power/hand tool shops making furniture . What seems to be out and available is a block plane and a #4 or #5, or occasionally 4-1/2 .

Re: 1st GOOD plane

#9

Yep...

John in NM

It matters more how you intend to use it than how some guy says you should use it (or them in this case).

If one is going to use hand tools alone, and wants to spend the minimum time on a task, then Schwartz is giving good advice.

If one is a hybrid machine/hand tool sort of builder, which most of us are now, then you do just need a block plane and maybe a bench plane or two.

If one is a hand tool only woodworker, with more time than money, then you can get by with probably a #5 and different blades of different cambers to substitute for different planes. Going to be more work, but there is vastly less investment in tools if can't find some inexpensive old Stanleys (perhaps none are inexpensive any more either).

Getting back to the OP, I find a block plane most useful in general. Probably a #5 jack after that or a #5 1/2 jack, depending on use. I used to use one of those a lot in a shop with many users and marginal equipment - it was handy for evening up rails to legs before putting a top on. Easier in that place to even things up than fix whatever machine alignment caused the problem. In a pinch either can do the smoother's job too, though I rarely find actual need for a smoother.

Re: 1st GOOD plane

#10

Rough, medium smooth in.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

.....the mixed tool shop

Rough- thickness planer and jointer

Medium- hand pane

Fine- sand paper, or plane when fitting.

Re: 1st GOOD plane

#11

Re: Rough, medium smooth in.....

TomD

Obviously correct in the main, but there are many uses for the range of planes in any shop. I often have pieces far too big to move, and they need to have a plane brought to them. I do have a small Makita plane but rarely get around to using it as it seems to struggle with hardwoods. There are also pieces too odd shaped or small to process in machinery. There is also endgrain, which I can't safely machine on the planer type tools, though routers can handle it but take a lot more set-up and clean-up.

One of the main uses is squeezing a dimension or grain alignment out of boards. It can be done on machines, but is often easier to do by hand (bandsaw is always at the ready).

Re: 1st GOOD plane

#12

Re: 1st GOOD plane

TomD

Russ,

Size of work has some bearing, but planes are more about the cut than they are about a size matching a size of project, and even where that is the case the basic bench set is already size selected to some extent for the stuff that comes off a bench.

When getting a range of responses, some of these are coming from the perspective as Bill mentioned, the shop that is mostly power, but uses hand tools for that which can't be done any other way.

Some people here use hand tools exclusively (or to the extent they can manage that). For that kind of use you need all the different tools that allow you to nibble away at the wood as efficiently as possible. A planer takes rather small shaving, but with a 3hp motor it takes a lot of them, in pure hand work, you start with splitting or the axe, if need be, then work your way down to.

Of those who work exclusively with hand tools, you have folks who use the latest metal stuff, or who are recreating a historical period in their tool use, or who are recreating a cultural typ, like Japanese chinese, german, etc...

As you say, you make small precise things in your shop, which pretty much describes hand planes. I know when I heard the best hand planes were wood (as was often the belief back in the 70s), I was really happy, because I wanted to go in that direction, at the other extrem, there are people waiting for a Rali review that says that replaceable blade plane is the best there is (you can come close to making that case). If you can't imagine making your own plane, or wanting some cheap piece of junk made out of wood, as many woodworkers seem to feel, then at least you can reduce the universe to one form, the metal ones (or the wooden ones).

If at the end of the day you reduced your choice to one or the other material stream, and then bought a basic plane like the number 4, you would never really have to regret it because no matter what style you pursue in the future, you will always have a use for it, and in the meantime you can learn how to use one and what it does.

One other point about the bailey 4 (actually not a super big proponent of this style) is that it can be used as a number of different types of plane, from roughing to smoothing. This is not really practical as a substitute for other types of plane, but it will allow you to gain a lot of experience with just the one plane and learn more what planes can do.

Re: 1st GOOD plane

#13

Re: 1st GOOD plane

north of the border

If I were you, I would simply go for a medium size plane like the Lee Valley's low angle smoother or the small BU smoother. I would not spend my first dollars on a book or dvd to find out what I should buy. Why? The money spent on the publication would better go towards buying a good quality plane. Secondly, whether you get a block plane, a low angle jack or the planes I suggest, it won't be wrong as long as you use it, develop your skills and keep it in good shape. Chances are you are going to expand your collection to suit your work which may change.

Buy a plane and forget about books and DVDs (which may be good, but not for the purposes of buying your first plane).

Re: 1st GOOD plane

#14

The sharpest one!

Bruce McCrory

I have various sizes of planes. However, the ones I use are the sharpest. The sharp ones work, do what they are expected to do, and make life far more pleasant. Trouble is ... they get dull. So...

... Far more important than that first plane is get some decent sharpening items. I have everything from Arkansas to diamonds: and what works... A cheap blade guide, three steel plates from Lee Valley, and Diamond paste. About $150 invested in maintenance, plus the tool. Save money and use the Library for books. I hand cut the bevels, so no grinder to f*** a blade. If you have trouble, and can't get a fine shaving, you didn't sharpen the blade.

Some people are tinkerer's. I am not. Old Stanleys need a lot of tinkering, so mine are from someone who did tinker. But all the Stanleys I use have modern blades and cap irons. Don't expect a beat hunk of junk to grow glass slippers. Get a new plane.

Size is sort of whatever scratches the itch best. I use sissy #4s because my next surgery is a new shoulder. But blocks and #5s work, too. However, the key is "sharp". Sharp. But don't count on building a bedroom set with it. They perform best with your little projects. I need to change the cutters in my DeWalt planer.

Re: 1st GOOD plane

#15

Re: The sharpest one!

david weaver

Most of the old stanley planes don't take much to get working well. The trouble is we're told the wrong things to get them working, and too much of it (lap this, lap that, frog needs to be mirror finish, mouth filed, iron needs to have a mirror polish up to the slot).

Some of the success in minimum preparation is in the buying, or maybe most. But it takes little patience (as in maybe buying the 50th plane you browse instead of the 5th).

I only buy planes now if I break something, but I did break the handle on a 4 earlier this year and bought another one. It took, I think, about 12 minutes to prepare it. Less time than most people probably spend on setting up a premium plane.

I put it on video, too, and have been using the plane since with no additional setup. It did all of the finish work (and a fair bit of penultimate step work) on both of these planes:

http://s30.postimg.org/djgi9kstd/P1080387.jpg

Re: 1st GOOD plane

#16

Re: The Schwartz advice....

Charly

Well said. True, too.