New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Bench question

Posts

Bench question

#1

Bench question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


The club needs a portable bench to be used at meetings for demonstrations of all kinds- hand tools, power tools, who knows what. We are making one in my shop, inspired by a bench in the MESDA museum in Old Salem, NC. The largely novice woodworkers are doing a great job on the task executing the joinery by largely 1790 methods.

The bench is in 5 parts- a removable top, two leg assemblies held together with a bridal joint, a mortise and tenon and a dovetail, and two stretchers that span the legs and are held in place by tusk tenons (in the pictures held in place by two clamped boards). In the picture one can see the mortises for the stretchers.

The question is where to put the vise? On one the end as I have it in the picture? Spread the legs farther apart and put it inside the legs to one side? Or, spread the legs farther apart and put the vise in the middle?

Re: Bench question

#2

Re: Bench question

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

If I had but one vise on a bench, I think I'd put it on the face, and use stops on the bench to plane against for flat work. I'd put it on the end that you've got the vise sitting.

Incidentally, you refer to a "bridal joint." This is a bridal joint:


What your students are making is bridle joints, named, I believe, after the fit of the horse's bit (on the bridle) in the horse's mouth.

Re: Bench question

#3

Re: Bench question

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

The club needs a portable bench to be used at meetings for demonstrations of all kinds- hand tools, power tools, who knows what. ....

The question is where to put the vise? On one the end as I have it in the picture? Spread the legs farther apart and put it inside the legs to one side? Or, spread the legs farther apart and put the vise in the middle?

Hi Bill

Having been involved with demonstrations of handtool use at wood shows and club meetings over the years, my primary need with a bench is work holding and whether the bench will remain stable when used (i.e. not rack).

The questions to answer are how the bench will hold boards for jointing edges, for planing faces, and for planing mouldings, grooves and similar edge treatments.

This may be done with- or without a vise. The issue is not what type of vise is best, or even where it should be placed on the bench, but rather how you plan to hold the work. Then you will know where to place the vises.

In my case I wound up building a mini bench to place on top of a "table" (the club is geared to power tools). The table has a Record-type face vise, and I use this for planing edges (no bench stops). I add a bench that enables planing of faces and edge treatments to be completed (on boards up to 18" long).


Link: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ShopMadeTools/BenchInAWeekend.html

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Bench question

#4

Re: Bench question

TomD

That is a good solution to which I would add a raised bench with "leg vise" and hold downs as some use to speed up hand cut dovetails. Of course one needs a firm surface to attach them to, which Bill's vise is presumed to have though the configuration is odd.

Based on what we have here, I would put it on the left end, more or less where it rests in the pick. I think the idea of having it end on has some merit, but I would probably put it where it is, flush, and then one can use the vise to mount all sorts of end stops and so forth for planing.

Re: Bench question

#5

Re: Bench question *LINK*

Jim Matthews

I would put it on the open end, facing the long axis of the bench, rather than

on the side, as a face vise.

Bob Van Dyke's student benches are built in this manner.

Clamping edgework is managed with F-clamps, as needed.

If you need to cut dovetails, a couple of handscrew clamps,

held to the bench with F-clamps are sufficient.

I cut dovetails this way until I built my first Moxon.

(Which would be an excellent class project.)


CVWWS bench

Re: Bench question

#6

limitations

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

There are a couple of reasons your suggestion will not be practical. The vise is 16" long and would require therefore a 16" overhand at the end. The bench is no big enough to accommodate this much end overhang. And, the bench is for demonstration. The person working at it needs to face an audience.

Re: Bench question

#7

Re: Bench question

John in NM

It really depends on the intended use. Given the size of the bench, and what you've said of demonstrations, I'm going to guess that mounting it as a face vise is the only practical option. If an end vise is needed, it seems better to build it into the top, as done in the article that inspired the bench - that way you don't have the clearance problems of the underslung vise.

Re: Bench question

#8

Zing!

John in NM

Does not one visit the bridal joint to avoid vice?

Re: Bench question

#9

Re: Bench question

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I don't know actual dimensions, but the bench looks a little tippy to me. A little "light duty". A consistent problem I have noticed demonstrating on other's benches over the last forty years is that they are not sturdy and solid enough for hand work. The people watching can make allowance for the fact that you don't have the ideal vise or whatever, but they don't realize how much the ease, the speed, and the quality of your work is affected by the bench. To the viewer it looks a lot clumsier and slower than it really is; some klutz in the audience is saying "why doesn't he get a table saw?"

Another important consideration is the size of the work surface. When doing actual work we often do perhaps 10 joints at a time, then get tools for another operation. But when demonstrating we usually do one of something then move on to something else. With a small surface we are either constantly putting tools away or bumping into clutter. A large surface allows us to lay out tools ahead of time and put them out of the way after use. A lower shelf is also helpful in this regard. It is no fun watching someone root through boxes for the next tool.

Re: Bench question

#10

good idea

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Will add a shelf across the stretchers.

The bench top is 43 x 19".

Our program chairs are typically retired, or at least not weight lifters. They must be able to load the bench parts into a car, haul the bench to a meeting place and assemble it for what ever the meeting entails. Assembled, the bench will weigh nearly 200 pounds, with the parts all weighing less than 50 pounds. The splayed legs make this bench amazingly stiff. It is sturdy just with the clamped legs.

A club member has the bench of the famous cabinet maker Robert Emmett. His every day working bench is similar to what we are making, but 2.5 feet longer. Our program chair could not pick up the top of Robert's bench, so a larger bench top was not an option.

Re: Bench question

#11

shelf fabricated in todays bench making session

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Also made the deep angled mortises for the tusk tenons. Stressful getting the angles oriented correctly and tenons fit properly with all else that was going on with seven people learning and doing. The joints all look good, especially so for the novices making them. Finished up by planing all the surfaces but the top, which I will sand with belt sander. Remains to make more fancy tusks than the ones used for test fitting. Will post picture when done and its assembled.