New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

OT FRAMING QUESTION

Posts

OT FRAMING QUESTION

#1

OT FRAMING QUESTION

TomD

I am building a room onto my summer place that will be framed first as a deck and then walls will be erected above the deck structure, and then a roof will be put on. Size is 8 x 14 feet. The deck is supported by a ledger at the wall, and the other side will be supported by a beam running about 7 feet out from the wall, there will be a cantilever of 1 foot, footings are in, and these factors are fixed.

The "room" will function as a screen porch but is being built to have full wall strength, and the capability to completely enclose the structure and later insulate it or whatever. The real intent though is that the porch needs to be secured many months of the year, and screens need to be as full as possible, yet the structure easily boarded in for security, so while I want a screen I also want secure walls. Probably the easiest way to get there would be to stick frame the structure, and sheet the lower walls while leaving plentiful and large window openings under conventional headers.

So here is the question. Notwithstanding the stick option I would like to frame the long wall pole style with 3 x 6"x6" posts on 7 foot centers, with a large header over the top. The only problem with this approach is that the posts would be resting on the deck edge with no particular structure under then. This is because the deck is joisted on 16 inch centers extending over the 7 foot support beam one foot. It should be easy to ensure that the post all sit above a joist, but the load transfer of a beam to 3/4 ply deck/to rim joist/and joist seems inadequate. My solution is to either pair two of the 2x10 joists at the corners and center point, so that the transfer is at least to that extent. Another option is to place a 2x12 girder notched into the base of the posts, along the base of the wall, this would transfer the load Across the whole surface just as the average pole structure use beefy poles and beams to carry roof or second story loads.

I have seen structures where the front rim joist was built up, but I don't really think that will make maters better in this case where the front rim joist is not directly supported by posts.

This Bob Villa piece shows the basic structural layout, though he is attempting a very different structure overall. Start at 1:40. He also has walls on two sides and the posts are set back enough to be almost over the beam.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VKMiCHKIIiY

Re: OT FRAMING QUESTION

#2

Ellis Walentine

Couple things

Ellis Walentine

It's not the ideal construction, but I think your joists should hold up those posts just fine unless you expect many feet of wet snow, which, if I'm not mistaken, could be the case up there in the north country. I do like the idea of sistering in a couple extra joists under the posts for added stiffness. You could also dig a couple piers under where the posts will go and build them up with concrete, bricks or stone and shims as necessary to completely support the joists at those locations.

As for the screening and enclosure, I recall a porch I built once where I framed between the posts and installed large double-hung windows in each opening. It has the dual advantage of allowing you to open or close the wall to the outside and providing a kick barrier at the floor level.

Also, don't forget to seal up the underside of the cantilevered floor to keep vermin and drafts out, assuming you'll be insulating under there for winter use.

2¢

Ellis

Re: OT FRAMING QUESTION

#3

Re: OT FRAMING QUESTION

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

The load path in the existing design does seem marginal, yes. Will there be a bottom plate? A double bottom plate would slightly help by transferring some load sideways to the other joists; but I agree with your idea of doubling, or even tripling, the joists under your posts. Also, make sure the beam on which the joists sit is fully supported directly in line with the posts. Your load path will then be down the posts, one horizontal foot to the beam, and down through the beam to the supports under the beam.

This should, of course, be engineered...but in this area, at least, that would cost lotsa money. Barring that, overbuild: bigger footings than you think you need, double/triple joists, etc.

Re: OT FRAMING QUESTION

#4

Re: OT FRAMING QUESTION

don stephan

Not part of your question, but make sure the ledger firmly bolted to house framing and flashed thoroughly so blowing rain through the screen can't get behind the ledger.

Re: OT FRAMING QUESTION

#5

Re: OT FRAMING QUESTION

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

I would not suspend the inner framing on a ledger. I would add posts at the ledger to prevent the load from being in shear. They could be right against the wall so as to not be an obstruction.

Joe

Re: OT FRAMING QUESTION

#6

Re: Thanks All

TomD

I actually meant to put this in the Messages forum, so I will cross post it there. But thanks for the useful suggestions all.

There should be significant snow loads, but in this case the wind is so bad, I have never seen snow on the roof (rarely here during winter). I intend to use standard window openings so that windows can later be included, though they may not get used due to cost at the moment,

There is a big drop off at the end of the deck, and some precious foliage, not to mention that the holes are dug, and it took a very long time. I feel I am engaged in the process of removing stacks of heavily set rocks till I reach a code enforced depth where there is nice solid sand to build my deck on. I might have been better off not to bother. :)

Don I will probably have removable screens, so that plywood can go in the window opening over the winter, for security, but I will keep that point in mind.