New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

What angle C/B front edge

Posts

What angle C/B front edge

#1

What angle C/B front edge

David Charlesworth

We have just had an excellent discussion about closeness of C/B setting but no one has referred to the angle honed and polished on the leading edge.

I'm sure the Japanese professors had this at about 70 or 80 degrees?

Does any one else?

Best wishes,

David

Re: What angle C/B front edge

#2

Re: What angle C/B front edge

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It will take some time to go back through their papers to see what the typically used. I will report later..... Information on how the planing machines are set up could also be useful.

There is a common misunderstanding that the video recommends an angle. Not true. Some angles are demonstrated. There is a tutorial they prepared for teaching the technique. I would suppose that would contain the recommended angle. I will check later.......of to buy son in law a used table saw this AM

Re: What angle C/B front edge

#3

Re: What angle C/B front edge

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi David

The initial implication from the video was that 80 degrees should be used since that was the most successful angle used. However, as I recall, the planing was successful down to 50 degrees. Consequently 50 degrees became the number. Keep in mind that the planing angle was 40 degrees.

My own experimentation tentatively suggested that there would be a relationship between bed angle, the angle of the chipbreaker's leading edge, and the distance from the edge of the blade. Kees went further with this and demonstrated something along these lines (I am not sure of the exact findings - the excellent article is on Steve Elliott's website). Kees recommended a 45 degree angle at the leading edge.

I think that one is safe using something around 45-50 degrees. One has to play around anyway. There is no exact recipe for perfect results.

The angle at the leading edge of the Stanley is around 45 degrees (it is rounded as you are aware), while the LV and LN both 25 degrees.

I add a 50 degree leading edge, regardless of bed angle (BD planes range from 42 - 50 degrees).

Of the chip breakers on the market, my personal preference is the LV. The LN looks similar but it has a significantly smaller "ledge", and one must be careful how much steel you remove when honing the angle at the leading edge. A microbevel of about 1.0 - 1.5 mm is about all one can add to the LN ...

LN at left, LV on the right ...


Others prefer the Stanley. However I find the examples I have to be very flexible, and one runs the danger of their creeping over the blade. No doubt experience helps here, but the more modern LV and LN hold their placement more easily.

One of the criticisms of the latter is that they lack the curve of the Stanley. I have added a curve to a LN chipbreaker, and will report on this later.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: What angle C/B front edge

#4

Re: What angle C/B front edge *LINK*

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have written many times that the cap iron should have a rounded bevel. A flat bevel like you are imagining will not work as well. Here is what Nicholson wrote in 1812:


I have used this system for controlling tearout for forty years. It has been more than thirty years since I brought a new cap iron into service; I don't know that they are all exactly the same and in any case it is difficult to measure an angle. I wrote recently that the tangent at the juncture was closer to 80 degrees than 50. In an email to Bill Tindall (7/19/07) I wrote:

I remembered experimenting with the cap

iron angle back in the 1970's. Monday morning in the

shop I got out a magnifying glass to look at the

juncture of the two irons on my planes ... I think my angles are

about 105 degrees between the cutting iron and the cap

iron, and polishing this surface also helps.
That would be 75 in today's terminology.

Here is something I wrote in 2012:


Limited data

Re: What angle C/B front edge

#5

80 degrees was never recommended

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have all of the Kato and Kawai publications which I will review when I get some time. But I have been through this issue before and they never recommended 80 degrees as optimum. People have inferred this 80 degrees from the video . The video is not a report of their research efforts, or part of their research efforts. It was made as a demonstration of the planing machine they built to be shown at a technical conference on dulling.

Re: What angle C/B front edge

#6

If 80 degrees was never recommended

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

I understand that the video was for training and was not recording ongoing research. Nevertheless, there is a preferred chipbreaker setting implied by demonstrating what works best.

The idea that there may be a recommended angle for the leading edge of the chipbreaker seems reasonable. There are a multitude of variables possible as a result of a working setting being a combination of distance from the edge of the blade, angle of the bed, and angle at the leading edge. Two of these will always remain adjustable, but the latter can become a fixed setting.

There appears to be a wide range between Kees' recommendation of 45 degrees and (if I have understood correctly) Warren reporting 75 degrees (which is close to the mythical 80 degrees of K and K). Is the latter a truer measurement for the Stanley chipbreaker (which curves)? Then, does this represent the ideal setting for a bed around 45 degrees, or is can it be improved upon? Those with non-Stanley chipbreakers need to know.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: What angle C/B front edge

#7

Re: What angle C/B front edge

TomD

"My own experimentation tentatively suggested that there would be a relationship between bed angle, the angle of the chipbreaker's leading edge, and the distance from the edge of the blade. Kees went further with this and demonstrated something along these lines (I am not sure of the exact findings - the excellent article is on Steve Elliott's website). Kees recommended a 45 degree angle at the leading edge."

Probably everything can be tuned even further, but my excuse for not bothering is that the concept is that the SB is capturing the shaving and compressing it it in line with the surface of the blade. This works because the shaving initially follows the angle of the blade and then gets turned by the SB in such a manner that it is under longi compression. So how much is to be gained by fritzing the angle if the shaving approaches the SB at the same angle and under similar conditions regardless of the bedding angle.

Of course, getting the angle of the SB right is still important, but how much it needs to vary is another mater.

Initially there is a lot to be gained in understanding by coming up with as many distinctions as possible, of course they have to be real. Then mastery can involve peeling back to as few essentials as one can. The fundamentals.

Re: What angle C/B front edge

#8

Re: If 80 degrees was never recommended

TomD

The sub blade often has a micro bevel if I am not mistaken, and it is steep (in the wilderness without any tools to check so I may be wrong).

Since the Green Hornet study involved machinery and different rates of change than we get with hand tools it may not be entirely instructive. Japanese hand planes are normally worked very briskly, though they work just as well slowly. But in any case, there are limits to machines, and there are advantage, You can't radially plane a knot with a machine, but you can run it with high energy cutting power.

Re: What angle C/B front edge

#9

Re: What angle C/B front edge

TomD

Nice data Warren. I am not convinced about the rounding. It is convex, so as you point out, at the point of blade contact it is relatively radial, 80 deg in your case. But if the shaving doesn't follow the rest of the cap curve, as it does not seem to, then what does it mater whether it is convex or not after the initial point of contact. Conceptually any point of tangency is at a given angle, and acts like a flat, unless the shaving follows many such surfaces, it is for all intents a micro bevel.

It is easier to polish a bevel, so that has it's merits. Of course there are other chip breaker use models, and having a nicely polished streamlined surface may be superior there. In the case of the the Japanese plane that does not depend of the breaker for blade retention and adjustment when not it use I pull it.

What does you experience suggest?

Re: What angle C/B front edge

#10

Re: If 80 degrees was never recommended

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

My communication skills must be failing. The video was not intended for training. It was not made for a planing audience.

I spoke to Kato who told me that he made the video to show at a technical conference here in the US. He was presenting a metallurgical paper on dulling. He never said why he made the video for the conference but the implication was that it was an incidental part of his presentation and may have been shown in an informal part of the conference, again, perhaps to demonstrate the research planing machine(my speculation).

Re: What angle C/B front edge

#11

Re: What angle C/B front edge

Steve Voigt

A couple thoughts. Holtzapffel wrote "the top iron is not intended to cut, but to present a more nearly perpendicular wall for the ascent of the shavings…" which on a common pitch plane would imply 45 for the CB angle.

I round the bevel, but I polish a small secondary bevel of around 55°. I'm not too fussy about the exact angle. I agree with Tom that what matters is the angle at the point of tangency, and that the rounding doesn't have an effect on surface quality. I suspect, but cannot prove, that the rounding can help with shaving ejection in certain cases. Sometimes in old woodies, the shaving can accordion, and perhaps a rounded bevel gives it someplace to go and reduces the likelihood of clogging.

Regarding the effects of different angles, my opinion (based on entirely informal and unsystematic experimentation) is that as CB angle increases, small changes in distance have more drastic effects. With a very high angle, it's a bit like riding in a sportscar. You have the CB set back a bit and you don't even notice it, then you move it just a little and wham!--it's like you're pushing a 60° single iron plane. Whereas with a CB angle in the 50°-60° range, things are a bit smoother. I must be getting old, because I prefer smoother. ;)