New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Romanillos on planes and breakers

Posts

Romanillos on planes and breakers

#1

Romanillos on planes and breakers

TomD

Jose Romanillos is a well know classical guitar builder from Spain who has lived off and on in the UK, where he taught himself to build guitars from an American book. In the English language he is know as one of the most articulate exponents of the Spanish style, though in Spain there are many guitar makers with a long history behind them.

Romanillos has been building since the 1960s, and a few years back he published a book about his method that is more generous than most in exposing his methods. He is a teacher and author, but he is not a specialist tool theorist who can argue all details of plane construction and meaning. The sections in his book on planes are short, and made up of irrelevant details like the mixture of planes he uses and details that relate to badly made planes he is making do with. But he makes a living in hand tool woodworking and as we all know the easy way there is to use planes for accuracy tasks.

Guitar making is also a mish mash of very expensive and difficult woods, put together with many instances of grain reversal or mixtures of end grain an side grain, hardest woods and softest woods. So planing is an interesting task.

And what is the kernel of his technical advice. Set the breaker close. For him an open breaker for easy chip passing in rough work is .4mm-1mm he doesn't say how tight he sets the breaker but from that point forward it has to achieve a result for the woods in question. He will bail at times and use a toothing plane.

He recommends that beginners experiment with breaker positioning, and says the following:

"The corollary is as follows; for planing wood against the grain or surfaces with potential lifting configurations, back irons should be set as near as possible to the cutting blade of the planes [sic]..."

His book was published in 2013.

Re: Romanillos on planes and breakers

#2

Re: Romanillos on planes and breakers

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Thanks Tom. Interesting that Jose wrote about using the close set chipbreaker in 2013. I wonder if (although I assume he was) using this setting before 2012, when discussion started up here and on other forums.

By coincidence, Paul Sellers (whom I read with very mixed feelings) posted today on his blog how he sets up his #4 smoothers. The chipbreaker is best set 2-3mm from the edge. I can only assume that he is working very different woods to Jose.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Romanillos on planes and breakers

#3

Re: Romanillos on planes and breakers

Sgian Dubh

Derek, setting the cap iron (chipbreaker) at different distances from the cutting edge of the iron in hand planes has been standard operating procedure for as long as I've worked wood. Presumably this has been standard for a few generations, if not longer, because I learnt it from old craftsmen that in turn had learnt it from old woodworkers, and so on.

Coarse cuts call for setting the cap iron back a bit and a wider mouth to prevent clogging, fine cuts require setting the cap iron closer to the cutting edge. Wood with a significant tendency to tear out because of reversing grain, etc often means setting the cap iron as close to the cutting edge as possible, perhaps supplemented by closing up the mouth, e.g., adjusting the frog. I wasn't really aware there was much mystery to these blade/ cap iron adjustments a user might make to a plane, until messages about the subject started appearing in woodworking forums just a few years ago.

Here's quite a good way of setting the cap iron close you might try. Sharpen the blade, attach the cap iron set back a few millimetres from the cutting edge, but leave the screw slightly loose, hold the blade and cap iron together vertically, rest the cutting edge of the blade on the wide face of a piece of wood on the bench, slide the cap iron down to touch the wood, tighten up the screw. If the setback isn't enough, push the blade into the wood a little harder before adjusting the cap iron and tightening it in place, or find a softer wood species on which to rest the cutting edge. You can also affect the setback by orientating the loosely assembled blade/ cap iron combination either with the grain or across the grain, especially in wood species with distinct differences in hardness between spring growth and summer growth.

As to the precise setback measurement this technique results in, I really can't say, but it does work for those times when 'close' is required. It's possible some might wince at the idea of jabbing a cutting iron into a piece of wood, but I really can't see a legitimate objection, because the follow up to setting up is edge dulling planing. And with the cutting edge of the iron slightly buried in a piece of wood during the set up, it certainly prevents the cap iron overlapping the cutting edge and damaging it one way or another. Slainte.

Re: Romanillos on planes and breakers

#4

A suggestion that deserves wider exposure

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I will try that suggestion at the next setting session. Suggest you submit to Popular Woodworking tips column. This magazine seems to be receptive to this idea that the cap iron is useful beyond holding the blade in the plane. Never could understand the hostile attitude of the plane sellers.

Re: Romanillos on planes and breakers

#5

Re: Romanillos on planes and breakers

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Interesting that Jose wrote about using the close set chipbreaker in 2013. I wonder if (although I assume he was) using this setting before 2012, when discussion started up here and on other forums.

We were discussing the double iron on this forum long before 2012.

Re: Romanillos on planes and breakers

#6

Re: Romanillos on planes and breakers

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I've seen early 20th century literature - "Planecraft," for instance - discussing setting the chipbreaker as close as possible to the edge for hard/difficult woods. The recent research on the subject seems to have provided clear visual proof of something tradesworkers knew for years/generations.

Re: Romanillos on planes and breakers

#7

To be clear....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The objective of the "recent research" ,that is Kato and Kawai, had nothing to do with mitigating tear out by close cap iron setting. They were varying the cap iron distance to investigate edge life for planing machines. It is clear from discussion with these professors that the cap iron effect was common knowledge and something taught in the Japanese trade classes.

The now famous movie was made as a novelty for a conference here in the US. I suppose they also used it in classes.

Re: Romanillos on planes and breakers

#8

Re: To be clear....

TomD

It's mostly inevitable with the Japanese design, as there is no fixed position. I have set the the cap iron ahead of the blade on the odd occasion when getting the feel of a new plane. It isn't a proud moment... As I have said here on several occasions there is a point where the shaving goes straight up which is indicative of a correct set. When planing like that the shavings may ultimately lie down over the board in the wake of the plane like a blanket. There are pictures of this activity going way back. You can be sure they knew the effect on edge retention since there are hundreds more experiments on that front with hand planes than with machines designed to do more prosaic tasks.

Re: Romanillos on planes and breakers

#9

Re: Romanillos on planes and breakers

TomD

Books rarely go into print the day they are written, though this is at least technically feasible today.

As far as origins are concerned, I remember stories from Williamsburg where they got to a need, had the tool unknown to them) built in the smithy, then later a tool of the exact type was discovered and they were delighted to see the cycle of need and invention had repeated itself.

Today some start with an existing tool, figure out it's uses without asking those who have been using it for decades, then claim invention of the tool as a result. Times change.

Re: Romanillos on planes and breakers

#10

Re: Romanillos on planes and breakers

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I wasn't really aware there was much mystery to these blade/ cap iron adjustments a user might make to a plane, until messages about the subject started appearing in woodworking forums just a few years ago.

Hi Richard

We won't go there, suffice to note that for many/most of us the use of the chipbreaker to control tearout really only took off around 2012. Yes Warren, it was discussed here before that time, but serious discussion, and subsequent enlightenment, where most sat up and took notice, began with examination of the effects demonstrated by the Kato video (whether it was meant for that purpose or not).

Here's quite a good way of setting the cap iron close you might try. Sharpen the blade, attach the cap iron set back a few millimetres from the cutting edge, but leave the screw slightly loose, hold the blade and cap iron together vertically, rest the cutting edge of the blade on the wide face of a piece of wood on the bench, slide the cap iron down to touch the wood, tighten up the screw. If the setback isn't enough, push the blade into the wood a little harder before adjusting the cap iron and tightening it in place, or find a softer wood species on which to rest the cutting edge. You can also affect the setback by orientating the loosely assembled blade/ cap iron combination either with the grain or across the grain, especially in wood species with distinct differences in hardness between spring growth and summer growth.

Interesting method. Just goes to show that there are many ways to skin a cat. One tip published in Pop Wood was to use a feeler gauge. I just eyeball 0.4mm and use that for smoothing or jointing.

Richard, I am curious to know which make chipbreaker you use for this, or perhaps you do so with all chipbreakers? I suspect it is one of your infill planes, which are nice and stiff. My preference on the Bailey plane is for the Veritas chipbreaker over the Stanley chipbreaker, and the latter is rather flexible and apt to creep towards and over the blade when tightened.

As to the precise setback measurement this technique results in, I really can't say, but it does work for those times when 'close' is required.

Yes, I doubt that one can use a recipe here. I know that when we were examining the chipbreaker effect, there was a focus on looking at the number of fractions of a mm from the edge. I was one that did so in a couple of experiments. That is understandable when something is under the microscope - one tries to be as clinical as possible. However, once past the beginner stage, there is less a need for obsessional reliance on setting things "just so". There are so many variables that it is not possible. I included my comment earlier on Paul Sellers simply as an illustration of someone with a very different view to setting up and using a smoother (noting that his set up - chipbreaker set 2-3mm back - is what I might use for a jack plane).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Romanillos on planes and breakers

#11

Re: Romanillos on planes and breakers

TomD

"Thanks Tom. Interesting that Jose wrote about using the close set chipbreaker in 2013. I wonder if (although I assume he was) using this setting before 2012, when discussion started up here and on other forums."

There are probably millions of people who knew that info prior to 2012, so it would seem unlikely that Jose learned it at random from here. That said, while he is a very traditional builder, he does incorporate some rather new ideas so the source of his ideas is not limited to the 19th century examples he clearly admires.

"By coincidence, Paul Sellers (whom I read with very mixed feelings) posted today on his blog how he sets up his #4 smoothers. The chipbreaker is best set 2-3mm from the edge. I can only assume that he is working very different woods to Jose."

Jose's method is a lot like traditional woodworking of the past the raw material was often cut to near usable size, but the worker had to do all the rest by hand. This puts a premium on getting the waste off fast, but every shaving can be your last if it tears out badly enough. It isn't the land of the one finish pass. Most people use abrasives to plane guitar backs and sides.

Sounds like Sellers is mostly using a single blade approach which has it's pros and cons. The main thing there is what determines setting the edge in that 2mm range. I can dream stuff up, but it would be interesting to know what he is thinking.

Re: Romanillos on planes and breakers

#12

Re: Romanillos on planes and breakers

TomD

""I wasn't really aware there was much mystery to these blade/ cap iron adjustments a user might make to a plane, until messages about the subject started appearing in woodworking forums just a few years ago.""

"Hi Richard

We won't go there, suffice to note that for many/most of us the use of the chipbreaker to control tearout really only took off around 2012. Yes Warren, it was discussed here before that time, but serious discussion, and subsequent enlightenment, where most sat up and took notice, began with examination of the effects demonstrated by the Kato video (whether it was meant for that purpose or not)."

It's a significant signpost in the history of the teachable moment, there needs to be a critical mass to get past the blind leading the blind effect. Apparently. But we are talking about how a few hundred amateurs in the best sense of the word, got the message, nothing more.

"However, once past the beginner stage, there is less a need for obsessional reliance on setting things "just so". There are so many variables that it is not possible."

That is one model, the other is fire to effect. The Japanese plane has an independently adjustable breaker, hands up if we all get that. You just keep tapping it forward until it does what you want. This eliminates the need to have a theory or a lot of data. You can come up with a lot of yack yack on how to outrun a dog on a bike, or you can just pedal faster and faster until you hope it is left behind. The data has some purpose, I got a surprise the first time I tried to outrun a dog on my much heavier loaded touring bike...

Re: Romanillos on planes and breakers

#13

Re: Romanillos on planes and breakers

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

The Japanese plane has an independently adjustable breaker, hands up if we all get that. You just keep tapping it forward until it does what you want.

... on the assumption, Tom, that you are aware of this effect. I wonder what percentage of Western woodworkers using Japanese planes understood this, and used it as part of plane set up?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Romanillos on planes and breakers

#14

Revisionist History *LINK*

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Derek, I think you are revising history to obscure the fact that you came out on the losing end of the argument. There was a "serious" discussion of the double iron in 2007, a thread with over 60 posts. I wrote:

Adam, the double iron is a sophisticated instrument. For things to work well everything has to be just so. There is no shame in having trouble with it. If the idea of learning to use hot hide glue turns you off, the double iron is not for you. It takes a fair amount of practice to get a good feel for it. I can say that the benefits of learning are well worth the effort and I would not want to be without it.

Stephen Shepherd wrote:

I have one bench plane a small coffin smoother that is a single iron all the others are doubles. I sharpen them both make sure the cap is real close to the end of the blade. Why do I use cap irons, because all of my old planes have them, it is simple as that.

Steve Elliott mentioned the Japanese cap iron research; Derek Cohen wrote about 60 degree planes.

Here is a discussion from 2011 which resulted in David Weaver learning to use the double iron before the video was available.


2011 discussion

Re: Romanillos on planes and breakers

#15

Re: A suggestion that deserves wider exposure

Sgian Dubh

"Suggest you submit to Popular Woodworking tips column."

I can't see me doing that Bill. You're welcome to do so though, ha, ha. Slainte.

Re: Romanillos on planes and breakers

#16

Re: What Actually Happened on the Forums

david weaver

I don't post here much, anymore, but a cap iron thread is worth a post.

I vividly recall all of this, because the thread warren linked I vehemently defended the ease of using a single iron plane set with a tight mouth, or a back bevel. I didn't know how technically superior a common pitch stanley bailey or vintage wooden plane was at the time - because I didn't know how to use it, and also because I wasn't working wood from rough exclusively using hand tools as I often do now (the interim step is maybe the step where the double iron distances itself from the inferior single iron design the most).

I'm embarrassed about how wrong I was about the double iron - but I'm more than willing to admit how wrong because most people were wrong about it. The plane I made and referred to in that discussion with warren is at the end of this video (last five minutes or so). https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kOQ_fXPzosc

(someone requested I make this video, or I wouldn't have ever shown a video of infill planes with a long drawn out warning not to buy them if you're just looking for capability. Warren's long ago comment of playing ping pong with a cast iron pan is dead right).

Warren was right (about infills and the double iron...both) - clearly, and what's not in debate is that Warren has for more than a decade described the double iron as the complete solution that it is. Nobody else did. Nobody, and I don't even remember *anyone* else suggesting that it was a better alternative for tearout reduction or elimination. I still see people saying they know how to set the cap iron, and then suggesting other methods for difficult wood when the cap iron doesn't work. Which of these woods would someone actually make furniture out of? I suspect it's just advice from people who don't actually know as much about setting the cap iron as they think they do - which is strange itself, because it's not very difficult after a week or two.

Perhaps there were people using the double iron before then, (I'd gather stephen was), most of us didn't know enough to pick up anything from a comment like stephen's. Warren's very straight up comments like "I haven't had tearout since 1977" (pardon Warren if I didn't do a perfect job with the paraphrasing there) are more thought provoking, and even then many accused warren of trolling. I probably did it, too.

The rest of the folks talking about how well it was known and how widely it was known need to bring up a reference where they didn't leave Warren hanging out to dry while he was getting insulted by contemporary makers, bloggers, etc. There must be something out there.

I have seen more inaccurate discussion about this and what was actually going on on the forum than almost any other topic (I can't think of one, but I'm sure I could given time). From being told that I only started talking about it after seeing the video Bill put up, to the assertion that I or Bill or anyone claim to have discovered something (the very first post I put up after learning to use the iron was something like "warren, you were right", not the kind of thing someone claiming they "discovered something" would post).

So, the rest of you folks other than Warren can surely on some forum (there are several with archives) pull up a historical post where you actually suggested using the cap iron when someone was requesting information on buying an expensive plane just to plane some relatively pedestrian wood like curly maple. I never saw it, aside from the folks who say "make the shaving very thin and sharpen often". That is not a very practical solution to actually getting something done, especially from rough lumber when a cap iron set plane can eliminate the tearout with any shaving thickness all the way until the clearance is gone and it won't stick in the cut.

I DID assail one group as not being honest, and that's the bloggers and folks who hit the road "teaching" classes who dug up the K&K stuff and started suggesting it without crediting where the discussion originated (the forums) - all the while decrying the forums as troll ponds. They did not credit where the discussion bloomed, I never once saw any of them say "warren" (the only one carrying the torch long term) or "bill tindall" or "steve elliot" (who actually did the leg work to find the video that would actually convince people who can't do anything with their own two hands. And not a single one of them apologized for misleading people and wasting their money with bad advice.

I probably could find an email to Bill Tindall from three years ago where we were pointing fingers at each other saying someone should write an article (and I refused to write one for a print magazine because that should be professionals doing it). In it, both of us said that we knew that as soon as one of us wrote an article, there'd be a gaggle of people who said "I already knew that, you're not saying anyone anything new", even though those folks can't seem to produce anything in support of Warren in print - which would've been awfully easy.

So, someone other than warren go to the archives and show us. There was no shortage of opportunities where people were advised to buy infills, high frogs, steep angle planes, etc.

Re: Romanillos on planes and breakers

#17

Re: Romanillos on planes and breakers

Sgian Dubh

"Richard, I am curious to know which make chipbreaker you use for this, or perhaps you do so with all chipbreakers? I suspect it is one of your infill planes, which are nice and stiff."

I adjust the cap iron on all my planes according to the work in hand, Bailey pattern, infills, and Bedrock. The cap iron itself is whatever came with the plane. Basically, the cap iron for a No 5 and upwards tends to be set back about a millimitre or maybe a bit more, and for the smoothing planes, set close to the cutting edge for final prepping, although perhaps further back for something less critical. I tend to use at least two planes when I'm smoothing - an old Spiers that's set up a bit coarse (cap iron maybe 0.5 - 1 mm set back from the cutting) and a Clifton with the cap iron set closer. Final prepping is done with the Clifton, or sometimes a block plane, and if those fail, there's always scrapers and abrasive paper. Slainte.

Re: Romanillos on planes and breakers

#18

Let's not forget Kees

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

A few lines below this entertaining discussion I describe how I smoothed a door panel I had spent many hours decorating with Line and Berry. The inlay was one of the largest investments in time I have ever devoted to a furniture element. To recall, I fearlessly planed it with no concern I would mess it up.

It was not long ago that my meager collection of panes sat unused because of fear of unanticipated tear-out. After the fact I have found numerous vintage references to setting the cap iron and no doubt there were modern woodworkers using this set up. But who was teaching the set up procedure to those in the wilderness that hadn't discovered it? In my case it was the Kee's video that encouraged me to try it and showed me how to do it. Planes have become a useful part of my wood working ever since.

Re: Romanillos on planes and breakers

#19

Re: Let's not forget Kees

David weaver

Yes, kees, too. I don't remember kees' chronology as well as mine, but I believe he started fiddling about the same time, and Bob Strawn also.

Your comment about fearlessness is perfect. The same applies in the penultimate step on dimensioning, as that step is where a non user of the cap iron will choose slow or risky, but a cap iron user will have no risk.

Re: Romanillos on planes and breakers

#20

Re: What Actually Happened on the Forums

David weaver

Re: The infill - while I think they are completely unnecessary for any practical purpose, and they slow me down due to their weight, I want to add that the makers I talked to while pondering mine were top notch and generous with advice (specifically Raney Nelson and Ron brese.). Whether or not I favor the type much doesn't change the fact that they are top shelf and doing fine work.

The misdirection came not from them, but from less than competent enablers.

Re: Romanillos on planes and breakers

#21

Re: How much force is exerted to cut?

Bruce McCrory

Since no one will commit to how little the set gap is I will throw out the answer:

I posted once that .020" (less than 1/32") was the thinnest set I wanted to use. I determined that based on blade crown, finished surface, and ease of force used to cut somewhat-soft figured Big-leaf Maple. A mob of crows (fellow hackers) attacked me immediately.

I was dead wrong! The set had to be blah, blah. I think .005", roughly a sheet of copy paper, was thrown at me.

No, I made very clean, easily cut shavings of about .002" and slightly thicker. Keep in mind my blades are crowned, always, so a shaving thickness varies. Smoothing is whatever is needed, whether 1/32" or 1/64". Starting points. Any finer is tempting problems; but go for it anyway. Orthopedic surgeons need patients who insist on plowing wood with back irons.

The gap setting varies based on ease of cutting and efficiency of material removal without tearout. That's all there is to it.

Re: Romanillos on planes and breakers

#22

Some have other needs and other settings

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I keep a Stanley plane up with the cap iron as close to the straight edge as I can see. At this setting it doesn't cause tear-out under almost any condition I ever used it and that is the primary capability I am looking for. A minute of planing would be a long time for me so pushing resistance is irrelevant, though I don't notice any difference.

I have a large industrial planer and jointer and I used them in any situation I can. I hand plane when I need to accurately remove a shaving of wood here and there in the course of fitting furniture parts together and rarely for edge or face smoothing. Picking the plane up and removing some shavings reliably now and then is all I demand of a plane. Close cap iron equals reliable. For my needs setting it is easy and I have no need to vary the setting. I suspect for many needs setting does not have to be complicated nor require much experience. I certainly have little experience and it works for my needs building stuff.

That said Kato and Kawai wrote a tutorial on setting the cap iron. They advocated to set it closer until the shaving length compressed. When the shaving compressed it was too close. Back off a bit.

Re: Romanillos on planes and breakers

#23

What's the name of his book?


Re: Romanillos on planes and breakers

#24

Re: What's the name of his book? *LINK*

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

I think the one TomD is referring to is "Making a Spanish Guitar"

http://www.romanillosguitarbooks.com

Google found it easily.