New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Breast drill question

Posts

Breast drill question

#1

Breast drill question

Dave (Arlington, VA)

I have a Miller Falls No. 112 breast drill and I have a question and was hoping that someone might have some insights. When I chuck a drill bit into the drill and turn the handle the bit does not turn coaxial to the drill frame. Instead the bit is somewhat off center and the tip makes a small circle in the air when the handle is turned. I try to carefully make the bit seat correctly, but always ends up being off-center.

I haven't tried drilling with it because this didn't seem right. I assume if I did try to drill with it the drill would torque some as I turn the handle....and that didn't seem like it would be good for me, the drill, the bit or the hole.

Am I right that the bit should line up coaxial to the drill frame (as it does in my powered hand drills)? And if I am right has anyone seen something like this before and have any suggestions as to what might be wrong so I could fix it?

I appreciate the help.

Thank you.

Dave

Re: Breast drill question

#2

Re: Breast drill question

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I assume you've tried this with more than one bit, to rule out a bent bit. If it's not the bit, the jaws may be damaged.

Pictures might help to sort out the problem. Assuming you have a digital camera and appropriate software for downloading to your computer, it's not hard to load pictures to a post. E-mail me if you need some help.

Re: Breast drill question

#3

Detective work starts with....

Brian Roberts

Depends on the type of jaws.....alligator jaws?

Has the chuck been disassembled, cleaned, and checked for damage?

What type of drill bit are you using....and is it bent?

Re: Breast drill question

#4

Re: Breast drill pictures

Doug Wolf

Here are a couple of drawings. The jaws look like they are not that precise and at the speed of a breast drill probably okay that the bit isn't exactly centered.


Re: Breast drill question

#5

Ah

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

That chuck type is designed for square tapered bits, like auger bits. Mostly, they don't work so well for straight round shanks, such as you find on jobber's (regular twist drill) bits.

By haunting garage sales, you can find high-carbon-steel twist bits with square tapered shanks.

Re: Breast drill question

#6

success with hand operatied drills?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I use manually operated drills for most drilling of holes less than 1/8". I have had poor experience using these drills with larger bits in wood. Even at 1/4" they seem to bounce around on hardwood and not drill a clean hole. My technique or is this size limitation something that is a fact of life with hand operated drills? I am using commercial twist bits no doubt sharpened for metal and a power drill.

What sort of bits were these drills designed to use in their day? Perhaps not what is readily available now days.

Re: Breast drill question

#7

Re: success with hand operatied drills?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

It's my impression that breast drills were used more commonly for metal than for wood; for wood, a brace and auger bit would be far more effective.

Re: Breast drill question

#8

Re: success with hand operatied drills?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have owned a brace and a set of bits for 40 years and never had any occasion to use the combination in furniture building. Out on the farm, however, it was a handy tool until powerful battery driven drills were available.

Re: Breast drill question

#9

Re: Breast drill question

Dave (Arlington, VA)

Thank you, Bill, and my apologies to you and the others who have replied for my tardiness in responding. It was a long day at work.

I will try to take some pictures but I'm not very good at that. I have posted a picture or two in the past but have forgotten how to do it and now, I am embarrassed to admit, my bench is so cluttered from the 3 or 4 other projects I have in process that it will take a bit of work to clear it so I can take pictures.

If you can bear with me a couple days, I'll try to figure it out. Thank you.

Dave

Re: Breast drill question

#10

Re: Breast drill pictures

Dave (Arlington, VA)

Yes, Doug, you've got it. Nothing special. I just wanted to see if I could get it working. I think you may be right, I should take a piece of scrap wood and see what happens.

Thanks.

Dave

Re: Breast drill question

#11

Re: Ah

Dave (Arlington, VA)

Thanks, again, Bill. I do have the square tapered bits and that is what I am using....a mixture of old Irwins and Jennings and an assortment of others.

Dave

Re: Breast drill question

#12

Re: Detective work starts with....

Dave (Arlington, VA)

All good questions, Brian. I have partially disassembled it....enough to see and handle the alligators jaws. That may be the problem. Is there supposed to be a fair amount of grease in the chuck and base of the jaws? Also there seemed to be a fair amount of grit in the grease but (without further disassembly) I could see that it was affecting the operation of the jaws. I was a bit anxious about taking the jaws apart knowing there was a spring but not knowing how it was connected.

Any further thoughts? Thanks.

Dave

Re: Breast drill question

#13

Re: success with hand operatied drills?

Dave (Arlington, VA)

Hi Bill -

These are the kinds of bits this kind of drill takes (but cleaned up some :) :

Dave


img

Re: Breast drill question

#14

Re: success with hand operatied drills?

Lars Parrington

I find a bit brace pretty handy in the shop. With it I can drill a hole the is reliably perpendicular to the surface of the workpiece. The same is true for an eggbeater drill. With a cordless drill my anglular accuracy is embarrasing.

As Bill says, eggbeaters don't work so well above 1/8". And, I've never seen a brace bit smaller than 1/4". So, I suppose a breast drill would be a good hand power solution for the 1/8" to 1/4" range.

I have a nice old millers falls breast drill that I cleaned up. But, I find it awkward to use, at least in the workshop, so it just collects dust.

Re: Breast drill question

#15

For Lars

John Sayles

Now you can say you've seen a square taper auger bit smaller than 1/4" dia.

Here is a Millers Falls #3 (3/16")


img

Re: Breast drill question

#16

Re: Detective work starts with....

Brian Roberts

I wouldn't worry about it too much.

Get it clean...even flushing solvent thru it without disassembling will help....followed by air blast.

A good spray with an aerosol grease and running the jaws open and closed several times will suffice.

The fact that some bits designed to be used in those drills may not run perfectly true really won't hurt the end result.

Re: Breast drill question

#17

Re: For Lars

Lars Parrington

Well, I've seen the butt of one now at least. Does it work well? Is this size hard to find?

Re: Breast drill question

#18

Re: success with hand operated drills?

Steve Voigt

Bill,

Plagued by childhood memories of a horrible, red-plastic eggbeater, I avoided manual drilling for years, even as I embraced most other hand tools. But in the last couple years, I've been gradually converted. I still use a drill press for a lot of precision drilling, and always will. But I now generally prefer manual drills to the portable electric variety.

For holes up to 1/4", I use this Millers Falls that Dominic Greco sold me for $30.


I think it makes a difference to use a substantial drill. This one is 15" long and has a beefier crank than many eggbeaters. The large flat on top is perfect for resting chin or forehead. This makes it much easier, for me, to drill at a precise angle than with an electric drill. I generally use brad points, unless I need a tweener size.

For holes 1/4" and over, I use a Stanley/ Yankee 2101A. Again, having a quality tool makes a big difference. Previously I used a budget Stanley with the alligator-jaw chuck, and was not very happy with it.

I like the brace for two reasons. First, just as Lars suggested, I can drill angled holes much more accurately than with an electric. On a recent chair build, I drilled the crest rail holes on a drill press, but all other holes with the brace. I know Pete Galbert uses an electric for this, but I honestly can't imagine doing that accurately.

But I think the most important thing for me is the ability to easily re-sharpen traditional auger bits. For something like chairmaking, you really need to be able to drill clean holes with absolutely no tearout at the entrance point. With an auger bit, all it takes is a 2-minute touch-up with the file; with power bits, sharpening is more of a hassle (especially brad points).

Chair pics if you are interested:

http://blackdogswoodshop.blogspot.com/2015/06/my-fanback-turned-into-birdcage.html

Re: Breast drill question

#19

Re: For Lars (business end)

John Sayles

Works just like any other auger -- and yes, I can safely say that, after about 25 years of rust hunting, this is the only one I have personally come across.


img

Re: Breast drill question

#20

Re: For Lars (business end)

Lars Parrington

Thanks John, I'll have to keep an eye out for one. I've only been rust hunting for about 5 years now, so I've got a couple decades to go ;-)

Re: Breast drill question

#21

Took me more like 35 years to find one

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Too