New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

supermarket hardwood

Posts

supermarket hardwood

#1

supermarket hardwood

Bruce Mack

I posted this on another forum. No reply. Maybe my dumb question, but seriously the wood looks usable for carving spoons and the heterogeneity of species could give interesting figure. I'll check that it has the government badge indicating proper heat treatment for emerald ash borer.

At least 2 big supermarket chains in the Minneapolis area have bundled heat- treated, plastic wrapped firewood which is stated to be hardwood. I see no bugs and each 5 dollar bundle will be ample for many spoons. I think I'll get a bundle, unwrap it and leave it in the garage. Has anyone used this resource for carving? Am I nuts? Comments please.

Re: supermarket hardwood

#2

Re: supermarket hardwood

Paul in NJ

If it is ash, then it is not well suited for spoons or treen. It is too open grained. You would be better served with a closer grained wood like birch, cherry, maple, or beech.

It probably will be drier than optimum, fresh green wood works better with hand tools, the difference is unbelievable. I imagine even in your area there is plenty of "roadside" branches available, especially after storms. It pays to keep a small pruning or bow saw in your vehicle to take advantage when the opportunity presents itself. Cut to length, split in half, and paint the ends with shellac or glue if you are going to store it for a while. It will keep quite a while longer if you put it in a freezer.

Paul Dzioba

Re: supermarket hardwood

#3

Re: supermarket hardwood

Bruce Mack

Thanks Paul. That's a good idea about being prepared to gather found wood. I think the bundle of wood is several species as the hue varies considerably. I have carved spoons from kiln dried wood. It's a bear. I have a local source for the occasional felled tree but let the cherry logs dry too much with consequent deep checks discovered when I was working the spoon bowl. Reinventing the wheel..duh.

Re: supermarket hardwood

#4

drying your own

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If you are going to rescue local wood for your carving immediately split or saw it through the middle of the stick to make two halves or better yet quarters. Then seal the fresh cut ends with anything that will retard water evaporation. You will have no checking if you follow this advise (except see the rest).

The center of most trees is wood that grew when the tree was getting a start on life and this wood is useless, with cherry the worst. Figure on discarding the inner 2" (approximate) diameter. It will likely split under the best of circumstances.

Find a local saw mill. their slab pile will yield a bonanza of stock, likely free if you return some spoons..

Re: supermarket hardwood

#5

Possible source of wood

CJ in MPLS

Bruce:

Have you checked out the MPLS city tree dumping lot at Fort Snelling? You might be able to pick up a few chunks of logs as well. I don't know for certain if this will be kosher, but it is worth a shot. I believe everything there is eventually chipped, no matter the size. Some of the elm logs are pretty impressive.

CJ

Re: supermarket hardwood

#6

Re: Possible source of wood

Bruce Mack

I didn't know about that. Thanks.

Re: supermarket hardwood

#7

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: supermarket hardwood

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

We have a local farm market, with orchards. They usually have a huge bin of apple, peach, and pear wood pieces from their prunings, which they sell as firewood. Ought to be plenty of spoons and ladles in those piles.

Re: supermarket hardwood

#8

Re: drying your own

TomD

True particularly with anything in a size you would want to use for spoons. But an often overlooked source for other things are heart centred logs. For instance the handles on Japanese chisels are often heart centered twigs off various local trees. The pith is so small as to be of no consequence, and the stick when turned has an even grain of a type and restful character not found on other cuts. It is also posible to exploit the core if it is weak as one can find pieces that are "pre-drilled" for file tangs and so forth. With luck one can select a piece that has integrity where it will be hit. I have not had a problem with splitting, or there are means of handling it.

If the Chinese have sprayed, I am not sure I want the wood anywhere near the house. They have ag regions where the insect life has been so stunted pollination occurs by hand.

Re: supermarket hardwood

#9

Re: supermarket hardwood

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Also, do a search for Tom Dunlap, currently an arborist for Mpls or St Paul. He mostly hangs out on the main board here. There's also a good source of high quality wood north of Howard Lake. Let me know and I'll come up with name and number.

Re: supermarket hardwood

#10

Re: Possible source of wood

Ray

While working at the VA regional office in St. Paul, I would take walks around the area (dreary building to spend 40 hrs a week). I think there was a wood chipping site within a few blocks of the building. This was approximately 2 years ago.

Re: supermarket hardwood

#11

Another idea

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Somewhere a part of a day drive from Minneapolis there will be a logging operation going on. After they skid the logs out of the woods some logs will be upgraded by cutting ends off. These ends, often 2' of so, are ideal for splitting billets of wood for eventual use.

Re: supermarket hardwood

#12

Re: Another idea

Bruce Mack

I appreciate all the suggestions.

While at the supermarket today for English muffins I bought a heat treated firewood pack. Using my hatchet to remove exterior wood I found a tight ring structure with medulary rays. I think it's oak or ash. Don't yet know if all pieces are the same. I believe treen ware was made of oak, so will pursue this for now. A lot of excellent suggestions for me to follow in the future. My small material need probably makes me a nuisance to a forester so may first try the Minneapolis tree dump.

Re: supermarket hardwood

#13

Thats the one. nm


Re: supermarket hardwood

#14

Re: Another idea

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Treeware was made of treen, not necessarily oak. What nearly everyone here is saying is that you shouldn't have to pay for something as short as a spoon.

Re: supermarket hardwood

#15

Re: Another idea

Doug Trembath

To add to what Bruce is saying, almost everywhere trees are routinely removed and cut up into relatively small portions to facilitate throwing them into the back of a truck for disposal. These would provide way more treen than you may be ready for today, but in the future?

Look in the phone book for tree services, call and explain that you would like to help reduce the lifting, and take a few rounds. They might think of you and call. Better to show up with a few complimentary spoon sets. Your chances will go up a mile. Been doing it with bowls for years, so...

Just sayin'...

Re: supermarket hardwood

#16

Re: supermarket hardwood

Bruce Mack

This thread is incomplete without photos of the completed supermarket spoon. I'm too 20th century to post them but can forward them to someone willing to do so. Thanks.

Re: supermarket hardwood

#17

I can show you how...

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

if you are using a camera. Trivial.

If using a cell phone I have no idea. I regard cell phones as the worst thing that ever happened to photography.

Re: supermarket hardwood

#18

Re: I can show you how...

Bruce Mack

Cell phone. I used to walk around NYC with a Hasselblad and black and white film which I developed and printed. It has come to this.

One of the other forum members has offered to host the pictures, so I hope to have them posted today.

Re: supermarket hardwood

#19

Bruce's Spoon Pics

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Not me, Bruce Mack. Easy to confuse since he lives only about 45 miles or so from here.

Nice job on the spoons!



Re: supermarket hardwood

#20

Re: Bruce's Spoon Pics

Bruce McCrory

That is one authoritative looking workbench!!

Re: supermarket hardwood

#21

green wood, great experience

Bruce Mack

First, I thank all who provided suggestions to me. In search of sources of green wood I went to Ellis' Woodfinder and found Courtland Hardware and Hardwoods in Courtland, MN, a beautiful winding drive from where I live. Mary and her sawmill manager/sawyer were gracious and helpful and I acquired a trunkful of hard maple and walnut log material. Though their pile was recently depleted by the wood chipper, there were still chunks of primal size. I chose those within my puny strength limits and with chainsaw assistance filled the hold (2003 Accord trunk). I did not want to waste their time looking at their dried hardwoods as I have no need to buy, but was told they have lots of butternut and basswood. I recommend Mary and her mill to those within a comfortable driving radius. Call first to see what they have and whether Mary has time to take you to the mill, which deals mostly with volume customers.

Re: supermarket hardwood

#22

Re:  green wood, great experience

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I came through Courtland just yesterday on my way back from New Ulm. 'Course, there isn't much cargo space on my Goldwing. It's good to know of another source.

Re: supermarket hardwood

#23

Re:  green wood, great experience

Bruce Mack

We spent the lunch hour at Plaza Garibaldi, New Ulm. I ate very well (too well) as a vegetarian :)

Re: supermarket hardwood

#24

Re:  green wood, great experience

Bruce, a MN Galoot

We were at the Kaiserhoff, which is where we normally go when I ride with my normal riding buddies.