New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Gluing- the perils of Forum learning

Posts

Gluing- the perils of Forum learning

#1

Gluing- the perils of Forum learning

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Clarification: What follows is not a criticism of how Derek assembles panels. Rather it is a caution of not exactly following an example without understanding the details of the process.

If I glued panels like Derek glues panels I would have a disaster when the stain went on. Two differences have crept into the process that might not be recognized by someone inexperienced trying to learn from the discussion. I use yellow glue. It repels stain. I stain most everything I build. Your results may differ.

I strive for the most minimal squeeze out on a panel. Ideally the yellow glue is allowed to dry to its rubbery stage and then the tiny balls of squeeze out are scraped off, or fully dried and scraped off with more difficulty. Wet wiping will put stain-repellant yellow glue into the pores where it will remain for ever.

That said, I don't understand wet wiping under any circumstance. I never saw it done in the professional shops we sold to.

Re: Gluing- the perils of Forum learning

#2

Re: Gluing- the perils of Forum learning

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

Please note that I do not use stain.

Perhaps there is a difference in the absorbance of woods we use. I have wiped off excess glue with water for years (with a damp cloth, not one soaking in water, and repeated several times until the beading is removed), and never experienced any contamination of the finish.

I generally finish with either a Danish Oil, Shellac, Shellawax, and Organoil. These have all been problem-free.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Gluing- the perils of Forum learning

#3

Point made

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

We all gravitate to something that works for how we work and what we work with. The problem for someone learning is sorting out what will work for them, especially when the details are not revealed or understood.

For those learning with porous North American woods glued with yellow glue and eventually stained, learn to use glue with moderation and keep it off places where it doesn't belong.

Re: Gluing- the perils of Forum learning

#4

Current example

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

One of the finishes I have begun to use increasingly is Ardvos Universal Wood Oil.


Here is a picture of one of the panels after wiping down ..


... scraped ...


... and 2 coats of oil (more will be done at a later time. This is simply to keep all clean). No signs of blotching ...


Note that the timber here is Makore, which is from West Africa.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Gluing- the perils of Forum learning

#5

Re: Point made

Sgian Dubh

"For those learning with porous North American woods glued with yellow glue and eventually stained, learn to use glue with moderation and keep it off places where it doesn't belong."

Or do like many woodworkers frequently do, but not necessarily always, myself being one, and Derek too I guess.

Glue-up, clamp up, wet wipe where possible, and after the clamps have been removed, plane, and/or scrape, and/or sand the surface to remove enough wood to get below any wood fibres that have absorbed the diluted glue. This technique also works, although it's nice to lift glue off at the rubbery stage, if you remember to get back to the assembly at just the right time, or if you're not tied up with other tasks that prevent you getting to the rubber glue lifting phase.

As ever, there's more than one way to achieve a good end result, in this case, a glue free surface satisfactorily prepped prior to wood finishing. Slainte.

Re: Gluing- the perils of Forum learning

#6

Re: Gluing- Use hide glue

Paul in NJ

One of the advantages of hide glue versus pva (yellow or white) is easier clean-up. A little hot water and a rag and it is easy to remove any smeared glue. If you smear some yellow glue, you need to wait until it hardens and scrape it back to bare wood, never fun once you begin staining. I never have surprises with stain when using hide glue. One of several reasons why I like hide glue.

Paul Dzioba

Re: Gluing- the perils of Forum learning

#7

Re: Gluing- Use hide glue

TomD

1) Bingo, hide glue is where a lot of the wiping stuff comes from.

2) Cold hide glue is a common glue in serious furniture "factories" in the US. May be why Franklin makes the stuff.

3) while there is a lot of chest beating about not using too much glue, why would one use too much of anything... With Hot hide glue, there can be reasons to load up and it isn't bad technique which is another one of those things that works in one situation and may have lead to misconceptions in another.

Re: Gluing- the perils of Forum learning

#8

A quibble

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You are not removing it, just diluting it. The glue will have no more affinity for a wet rag than wet wood so some of the diluted result remains on the wood. Fortunately hide glue accepts most finishes and dyes, so it matters not.

Re: Gluing- the perils of Forum learning

#9

Clint Searl

Re: Titebond

Clint Searl

Once the joint has been clamped. a sopping wipe-up will remove all squeezeout without interfering with later stain.

Re: Gluing- the perils of Forum learning

#10

Cascamite

David Charlesworth

I was surprised to see small halos of this urea formaldehyde glue round virtually every mortice and tennon , on a Barnsley chair which I was copying for a client.

This was on English Walnut and appeared to be the result of sloppy wet rag wiping.

The joinery was immaculate.

I came to the conclusion that the joinery had been done by his best makers but the glue up done by apprentices!

Halo can be avoided by scrubbing with old toothbrushes, but is much better avoided by careful glue aplication strategy, such as I describe in one of my books.

best wishes,

David

Re: Gluing- the perils of Forum learning

#11

Amen to that thought

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"Halo can be avoided by scrubbing with old toothbrushes, but is much better avoided by careful glue application strategy"

One of the most important of the many things I learned in the Headley Shop was proper, meaning just enough, glue application.

Re: Gluing- the perils of Forum learning

#12

bridger

Re: Amen to that thought

Bridger

One thing that often works for me is to apply just the right amount of glue to both sides of a well fitting joint, then allow it to tack just a bit before assembly. Squeezeout will be almost nil. Won't work with joints that slide to assemble, like mortise and tennon joints, though.

Re: Gluing- the perils of Forum learning

#13

Re: Amendments to that thought

TomD

I'm not worried about squeeze out in all situations, and I don't want to manufacture a thick glue line. but I will keep the thought onboard, as they all help at some point.

My favorite technique is to apply glue to both surfaces and immediately assemble and apply modest clamp pressure. Then come back a little later and pump up the clamps. AS Bill said, there isn't enough force to move all the glue... unless you give it time to move. The worse result is to put on the force, then leave it, and the glue seeps out, then it ends up without enough pressure.

In lutherie there are many situations where glue gets around, particularly in the binding process. One option is to use a little shellac as a mask. It comes off with the excess glue, easily. These include techniques where the joint is made up dry and the glue is then wicked in. I see some people are using this approach in furniture joinery now also. I prefer conventional methods often on furniture, because sometimes if the wicked joint isn't absolutely perfect the glue will define the bad areas.

Re: Gluing- the perils of Forum learning

#15

kinda sorta

Paul M

just make sure that blue tape doesn't get trapped in the joint. I've done this before where a little bit of blue tape rolled over and went into the joint. That thin blue line is quite visible!

Re: Gluing- the perils of Forum learning

#16

Re: kinda sorta

TomD

With the various colors one can get tape in, you may have invented a new form of purfling stock, zap it with glue and you are done.