New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

More on Don Williams and the tool chest

Posts

More on Don Williams and the tool chest

#1

More on Don Williams and the tool chest

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Don was a presenter at SAPFM and in the informal session he provided more insight, and pictures, into the now famous tool chest.

Going back in time, Don let it be known that he would like to see it. The anonymous owner contacted Don and made an invitation for him to see it. Don convinced the owner to display it. The transportation and display requirements imposed by the owner, who insisted on anonymity, became what would be typical of any exceptionally valuable art. The crating, insurance, transportation, security, display preparation, etc costs were substantial. Hence, the viewing fee.

Don said that 25,000 high resolution pictures were taken of the chest and its contents. It is an interesting tool chest, but personally, I don't get why in the woodworking community it has achieved rock star status.

Don said that the Rubo book on furniture will be out in September. Don provided more insight into that effort as well. Having participated in the translation of the Kato and Kawai papers I could relate to the difficulty of translating technical terms from one language to another. Both a language and a technical expert are required, and even then some guesses are made.

Re: More on Don Williams and the tool chest

#2

Rock Star Tool Cabinet.

BrianMonumentCO

If I were to hazard a guess as to why the Studley has achieved the status of a "Rock Star" it would come to two things; The quality of the cabinet is by far the most elaborate cabinet that I have ever seen in a working shop.

The second is that the cabinet has not been seen often, FWW magazine and a poster, New Yankee Workshop and Toolbox book.

To me the Studley tool cabinet is to an anarchist tool chest what an antique philidelphia high boy is to a shaker dresser.

All are quality pieces to one degree or another and in one way or another.

The high boy is ornate and involved. The shaker dresser is simple in its lines.

The Studley tool cabinet is simply amazing.

These are my opinions are not intended to offend anyone.

Re: More on Don Williams and the tool chest

#3

Fitting things in

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Because my shop is small and I suffer from the habit of finding stuff at yard sales, some of the drawers in my various toolboxes require that the tools be put in the drawers in specific ways, oriented just so. I think part of the Studley chest's rock star aura is that he took that way, way beyond anything I might ever hope to (or want to) achieve. It's a monument of design as attention to detail.

How workable it was as a daily toolbox, I don't know; seems like there'd be a lot of time devoted to opening up this clever latch and that little door to get to a tool you might need.

Re: More on Don Williams and the tool chest

#4

Lee Valley's worst customer

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

There is no room in the box for any new tool. Free shipping promotions would have no effect (yes, I suckered into the latest one too). That in itself would seem to be a fatal disadvantage. Who among us doesn't want one more tool! :)

From the presentation I gather it was meant to show off design and execution skills, not work out of. Don indicated that its 3 dimension design was its most amazing attribute. Stuff fits together not only side by side but front to back, something not readily seen in pictures.

Personally, I know of many pieces of furniture that more deserve rock star status for design, complexity and execution, but they have never been as heavily promoted and likely not as readily "understood" by woodworkers.

Re: More on Don Williams and the tool chest

#5

Re: Lee Valley's worst customer

JDK

"From the presentation I gather it was meant to show off design and execution skills, not work out of. "

I have the book in front of me, and it's quite clear from the text that the tool chest and its contents (as well as the bench) were what Henry Studley used while practicing his craft as piano and organ maker while at the Smith American (1873-1898) and Poole (1898-1919) piano manufacturing companies.

They were decidedly not simply for show.

Re: More on Don Williams and the tool chest

#6

Re: Lee Valley's worst customer

William Duffield

The tools were acquired and used while he was building organs for Smith. While well taken care of, they how definite signs of extensive use. The tool box was built later, when he was building piano actions for Poole. It also shows signs of wear from use, but not as much as the tools themselves. Studley definitely worked out of the tool chest.