New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Report from SAPFM

Posts

Report from SAPFM

#1

Report from SAPFM

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If one's woodworking ability needs humbling this is the meeting to accomplish the task of seeing how far the top of the learning curve is from where most are at. This piece was started in September and finished in time for the June meeting. And the day job of Dr. Moon is OBGYN.


I doesn't fit my lifestyle but this jewelry case does by Al Hudson who is 90 plus years old and still cranking out furniture of this quality.


Re: Report from SAPFM

#2

Re: Report from SAPFM - Wow

Bob Entwisle in NJ

Thanks Bill,

Both of those pieces are fantastic.

Bob in NJ

Re: Report from SAPFM

#3

Amateur woodwokers

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I think the best Period furniture ever made is being done now days by amateur woodworkers. Some have the skill, time, and resources to strive for perfection in these "show off" pieces. And, if they are not wedded to exact reproduction, flaws in construction revealed through the ages can be corrected.

Re: Report from SAPFM

#4

Re: Report from SAPFM

William Duffield

Some other trivia about the highboy:

How Jim Moon could have constructed it in only nine months totally amazes me. It is mostly mahogany (probably African), with the carving in walnut. The side boards were salvaged from the burn pile of a veneer manufacturer. Three years ago, he exhibited this tea table at the same conference. It is a reproduction of one built by Robert Walker in the 1750's. The original is at MESDA in Winston Salem, NC, which is where the 2012 conference was held. The new one compares very favorably to the original. Dr. Moon got the crotch mahogany board for the top from the same burn pile.


There were several other remarkable reproductions exhibited by SAPFM members.

Re: Report from SAPFM

#5

Re: Amateur woodwokers

Bruce Mack

The gift of human memory is that you can see these beautiful pieces and still not recall them when you look at

your own pathetic efforts.

Re: Report from SAPFM

#6

Ellis Walentine

Re: Report from SAPFM

Ellis Walentine

Thanks, Bill. Yes, Dr. Moon won first prize in one of our Excellence in Craftsmanship awards competitions when I was at American Woodworker magazine about twenty years ago. I believe it was a secretary desk, of similar mind-boggling complexity.

What I wonder is how many of these pieces were made entirely with hand tools, like the originals, or whether the end justifies the means.

Ellis

Re: Report from SAPFM

#7

Period techniques at SAPFM

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I know some of these people and they are result oriented, not process oriented. They are building stuff to get it built, to show it off or use, or sell. They don't build to compliment a life style. Everyone I know uses powers tools where they offer an advantage. And they color wood to achieve effects not attainable with uncolored wood. I have never seen an uncolored mahogany piece.

One of the famous builders was standing by a pie crust table some years ago at the meeting and an audience of admirers were ogling the table. Someone asked, expecting affirmation, "is it French Polished". "No, this is a table we use. It is finished with polyurethane". This discriminating audience couldn't tell the difference. Another builder allowed that he varnished all his table tops for durability, while yet another used lacquer for tops, even if the body was padded shellac.

Al Breed demonstrated carving the edge of a tea table at a meeting. Someone asked how he lowered the interior field. He replied that there was a nearby shop with a CNC router and that was a dandy way to establish the recessed field. He went on to say that he liked to carve and making the recess was boring grunt work. It wasn't hat he lacked the skill to do it. Rather it was work he didn't find rewarding so he found a better way, for him.

Re: Report from SAPFM

#8

Ellis Walentine

Confirms my suspicions. Thanks.