New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

saw plate cleaning advice

Posts

saw plate cleaning advice

#1

saw plate cleaning advice

Eric

I've started heading down a more serious hand saw road. Learning to sharpen. That sort of thing. I've picked a couple of nice Disston cross cut saws and would like to clean the plates. They aren't very rusty or pitted. Mostly just need to clean them up. These are user saws but I don't want to wipe out the etching. I've done some searching on Youtube which usually works for me but found nothing but bad advice there.

Can anyone recommend a thorough yet gentle cleaning protocol?

Thanks,

Eric in Los Gatos

Re: saw plate cleaning advice

#2

Re: saw plate cleaning advice

Ron in Sterling, CT

Hi Eric

I like to use very fine grit paper and WD40 as a lubricant. In your case I would probably start with 320, or maybe 400 and work up through the grits to 600. I use a rubber block to support the paper. I have used steel wool and the Scotch brite pads, but prefer the paper approach. Start on the back side to get a good feel for how it goes, then clean the etch side of the plate. That way you have a better chance of not messing up the etch. After a final rinse with mineral spirits, I usually apply a coat of quality paste wax. Some frown on this, but I like the protection it gives the cleaned plate. Good luck.

Ron

Re: saw plate cleaning advice

#3

Re: saw plate cleaning advice

Neal in San Jose

I've pretty much come full circle on this. I started out with Naval Jelly (sorta like Napalm!) and some other chemical rust removers which turned the blades gray on heavily rusted blades and sandpaper/steel wool on lightly discolored blades. I now don't do anything. I just let the wood on the first few cuts remove what will come off easily and don't worry about the rest. The sanding made the blades look a bit "unnatural" if you know what I mean. It takes off the patina along with the rust and is very difficult to get right up next to the handle. One note of caution: the wood on the first few cuts will probably be discolored by the rust as it cleans the blade.

Re: saw plate cleaning advice

#4

Saw plate cleaning advice

tom

What I've had success with is what someone recommended years ago in a Badger Pond post. And that is to use a plane iron in a scraping mode. It does not go into the plate but it levels everything down to the surface. If you want to use fine grit paper my recommendation would be a hard block for backing.

For cleaning the handle itself a long time poster, named Todd, recommended WD40 and some steal wool. I tried that on some handles and it cleaned the surface crud off but left all the other battle scars in tact. 'Hope this was helpful, Tom.

Re: saw plate cleaning advice

#5

Re: saw plate cleaning advice

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Saw plates work better when they are shiny. This enables one to use the reflection to calculate angles, such as square.

Cleaning a saw plate of light rust simply require a blade to scrape off surface rust and tarnish, and then degrees of sandpaper to build up a clean surface.

Getting a polish is another matter. A couple of years ago Christian Castillo posted a method on the WoodNet forum that many now swear by. This involved a balled up piece of aluminium foil and a metal polish (such as Autosol or Brasso). Lots of elbow grease.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: saw plate cleaning advice

#6

What advice have you seen that's bad?


Re: saw plate cleaning advice

#7

Re: saw plate cleaning advice

Eric Kuehne

Derek,

I didn't say it but I am going for shiny for the reasons you stated. Won't the technique you describe take the etch off?

Eric

Re: saw plate cleaning advice

#8

Re: saw plate cleaning advice

Peter Evans

Eric, the scraper will not take off the etch. Sandpaper will. So in the area of the etch, use a higher grit with a hard block (a bit of wood with a sheet of cardboard glued to the face works well - also glue the sandpaper to the cardboard to ensure it stays flat and does not move around) to determine whether there is an etch. If not just go for it with paper starting at 80 or above, depending on condition of plate (I use WD40 as a lubricant). If there is an etch quarantine the etch area (cover with blue tape) and clean the rest of the plate to about 400 grit.

Then remove the blue tape and carefully sand the etch area, starting with 400 until as shiny as you can get it. When as far as you can go, use a Klingspor Fine sanding block over the entire plate to remove sanding scratches, this should not noticably impact the etch, but worthwhile to be careful in that area.

Then use scrunched up alum foil with Autosol (bettter than Brasso in my opinion) to polish the plate. This does not abrade any metal is my understanding, but sets up a chemical reaction to polish the steel. Wipe off with a paper towel, then use a solvent to completely clean the plate (no solvent on etch area). Then repeat this step just with foil, and your plate will be about as shiny as it is ever going to be. The pits will still be there. You will note that a black deposit from the foil reaction remains in the etch, don't know how long this lasts.

The steel is now subject to rusting again, so a wipe on of microcrystaline wax designed for metal will protect the plate. I have also found that a light oil (3in1) wiped onto a heated saw plate (hair fryer, placed in front of heater, or out in sun) keeps rust away, wipe off extra oil while still warm.

Re: saw plate cleaning advice

#9

Re: saw plate cleaning advice

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

No idea what it would do to the etch, Eric, since it is untried for me. However, it comes after sandpaper, and I would imagine that the damage would be done by that, rather than the foil. It comes down to whether you want a user or a collector tool.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: saw plate cleaning advice

#10

Re: What advice have you seen that's bad?

Eric Kuehne

What really pushed me over the edge was the guy who used and angle grinder. Seeing all of the sparks flyingoff the plate and the obvious grinder marks....

Then he tried an flapper sanding wheel on a drill. Not quite as catastrophic but not pretty.

Eric

Re: saw plate cleaning advice

#11

Re: saw plate cleaning advice

Eric Kuehne

Thanks all for the advice guys. I'm looking for user tools not collector but would still like to keep the etch just because. Looks like I've got some experimenting to do. Should be fun.

Eric

Re: saw plate cleaning advice

#12

Re: saw plate cleaning advice

Corey

I always thought Mark's advice is pretty good:

http://www.badaxetoolworks.com/cleaning-a-sawplate.php

I'm no expert saw guy, but I think his protocol seems reasonable for renewing a saw without ruining the value.