New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Spice box molding

Posts

Spice box molding

#1

Spice box molding

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

PIC 1



The bottom of the spice box has a bead and cover molding. I have a router bit that cuts this pattern, tried it and the result was not quite right. For reasons I can not put into words the effect of a two piece bead and cove molding looked better on this style box.

Making slender molding is a problem. The profile must be milled on something straight and level for the pattern to be uniform. To accomplish this feat the profile is milled on a larger piece of lumber. In the case at hand I milled the cove on a piece 3/4" thick and 2" wide.

PIC 2


PIC 3


Then I planed the board with a cove on each edge to a heavy 3/8" and ripped the 1/4 x 3/8" coves off the wider board. My preferred 40T 7 1/2" blade is so much better for cutting these small pieces ( and bigger ones too).

PIC 4


The profile was refined with a scraper made from the end of a bow saw blade.

In another post I hope to engage in a discussion of how to best wrap molding around a case and get nice tight miters.

Re: Spice box molding

#2

Re: Spice box molding

Warren in Lancaster, PA

This is a case where it would be easier to use hollows and rounds, more freedom to make adjustments.

The delicate fillet below the cove is what makes your moulding look good. Your cove and bead router bit might have been a little bland in this area, and the corners not so sharp. I think it would look better with a small fillet at the bottom of the bead as well. More like 18th century. Even a tiny quirk would help set the moulding off from the feet. See number 17 and others in the Spice Box book.

Re: Spice box molding

#3

Re: Spice box molding

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

" I think it would look better with a small fillet at the bottom of the bead as well"

In principle I agree except I ran head long into some constraints. I have spent more time on the bottom of this box than the rest of it. The fretting over the foot profile will be a topic for another discussion. Suffice that the directions for laying out a Cyma Curve as described in the past POP Woodworking led to a result I didn't like (too formal looking), and an asymmetrical arrangement arrived at by trial and error prevailed.

This box is about 1/2 the size of an original Spice Box. The originals are too big to sit on a dresser and hold jewelry. Shrinking the box shrinks the details and not necessarily proportionally.

I am not fond of clunky looking bases on furniture. Many Tall Clicks gag me in this feature. With that prejudice I arrived at a total bottom molding thickness of a bit less than 5/8". For reasons I no longer remember I made the decision to make the box with through dovetails. This decision led to massive complications at the bottom. Given that the bottom molding had to be tall enough to cover the dovetails and thin enough to accommodate my prejudices about fat bottoms the options down there became limited. One solution was to make the cove asymmetrical, hence the scraper refinement of the router bit profile. I simply ran out of room for a filet with the bead.

If I ever build something regarded as perfect I will quit while ahead. With the box now done I can get on with the doors, which I am anxious to begin. If I get the line and berry right on the door nobody will notice the molding.

Re: Spice box molding

#4

Photo of molding from end?

Chuck Nickerson

I'm having trouble following the design discussion you and Warren are having, and I'd really like to.

Re: Spice box molding

#5

Re: Photo of molding from end?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Chuck, here is a moulding from a router bit that is much like Bill's. The upper concave section is a cove and the lower an ovolo (or bead). There is a fillet, or small flat band, between the two elements. I think Bill's looks better because the fillet is more delicate and the cove is deeper, maybe a 90 degree arc instead of 60 or so. More stylish and less clunky. This moulding is a sort of transition between the bracket feet and the sides of the case. I think it would look better if there were a small step or a little quirk (indentation) at the bottom of the bead as well. This feature would set the moulding apart from the foot bracket and is usually seen on 18th century work.


Re: Spice box molding

#6

Re: Photo of molding from end?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I don' t have anything that would have cut the bead with a step between the bead and the vertical leg section, and fit in the space. Given the space it has to fit in the bead would have to be a shape other than a quarter round.

I have some practice sections of this molding element. I will try scraping a step. A tiny amount of material is all that would have to be removed and I have had good success scraping moldings. The lumber for this part was chosen to be dense and straight grain so it will scrape easily.

Re: Spice box molding

#7

Re: Photo of molding from end?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

One thing you might try is extending the curve of the bead to where it cuts back into the face. If the bead is now a 90 degree arc, you could make it maybe 110 degrees. Then your cut would be like a crooked V, straight in at the bottom, but slanted on the upper side toward the bead. That way you would not be upsetting your existing curve.

Re: Spice box molding

#8

Re: Photo of molding from end?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

That is something I can experiment with on the test molding pieces I have left over