New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Sawing a Tenon

Posts

Sawing a Tenon

#1

Sawing a Tenon

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Most of us have cut a good many mortice and tenon joints over the years. It occurred to me today to ask a question about something we likely take for granted: Do you saw the cheek first, or the shoulder, and how far to the intersection do you go?

For myself I saw the cheeks (as close to the markings as possible) ...


.. and stop a smidgeon short of the shoulder line.


Having created a knife fence on the shoulder line, I saw the shoulder close to but a smidgeon short of the cheek line ...


Then it is a case of back-and-forth to sever the bit between ..


It will eventually pop off nice and clean ..


The vanity cheek may now be sawn. This is 1/8" (3mm) ...


.. or the haunch created. The haunches are for the upper side of the panels, with the blind M&T at the lower end (as they do not go all the way to the bottom) ..


I am now ready to measure and fit to mortices, and then complete the mitres for the coves, and fine tune the shoulders ...


Ready for the weekend ...


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Sawing a Tenon

#2

New term to me

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

What's a vanity cheek, besides the cheeks on a supermodel's face?

Re: Sawing a Tenon

#3

I chisel the shoulders

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It is the only way I can reliably get them to come up tightly. The extra time it takes to chisel to the shoulder line is compensated by making the other cuts with a band saw.

Re: Sawing a Tenon

#4

Re: I chisel the shoulders

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

.... but you must still saw the shoulders (before you use a chisel on them, which is just a fine tuning method). So which comes first, the cheeks or the shoulders, and why?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Sawing a Tenon

#5

Darrell in Oakville

Re: Sawing a Tenon

Darrell in Oakville

Derek asks one of those no-right-answer-no-wrong-answer questions:

Do you saw the cheek first, or the shoulder, and how far to the intersection do you go?

I saw the shoulders first, and I go right to the line. I usually don't saw the cheeks, I split them off. If I have to saw them due to bad grain, I will. I would use very straight grained bland stock for the rails and stiles, and save the pretty wood for the panels. And the bland stuff usually splits very nicely.

Darrell

Re: Sawing a Tenon

#6

Cheeks then shoulders

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I don't know why. Maybe because it is harder and I want to get the harder part over with first.

Re: Sawing a Tenon

#7

Re: Sawing a Tenon

William Duffield

I saw shoulders first. If I were to oversaw a cheek, it would show. If I oversaw a shoulder, it doesn't show, but I still need to be careful, because it weakens the joint. I stop sawing the cheek when the waste falls away. It's a lot more precise than watching it closely and guessing when to stop.

If I'm doing it on the table saw, I saw the cheeks first. If I were to saw the shoulders first, the end of the tenon has a lot less support on the saw table, and could drop into the slot in the insert. Also, I like to have my hands farther from the waste block when the saw blade kicks it out.

If I'm using a "Festool drone,"* I don't saw the tenons, and a bench plane on the shooting board takes care of cleaning up the shoulder :D

* http://benchcrafted.blogspot.com/2015/05/handworks-2015-video.html (About 7:00 minutes in)

Re: Sawing a Tenon

#8

Re: Sawing a Tenon

David Charlesworth

Cheeks first for me.

I like to use my large bandsaw and would have waste trapped between blade and fence if shoulders were done first.

Best wishes,

David