Re: Advantages are
TomD
"I don't get the idea of a tool tray, AKA repository of stuff."
I don't prefer them, but I have one on my Frid bench, and I never notice a problem.
- It could be an advantage in your case because it is lighter as has been said;
- Stuff put there that is less in the way than it is on the surface of the bench, and less likely to get knocked on the floor. This would be good in a situation where you are likely to be in the open and not necessarily surrounded with other benches and lockers.
- While neat freaks who would probably not get into trouble in the first place seem to object to them, in this case, since you need to move it after every use, there won't be time to get into trouble. Associated with the German bench, and those guys are organized...
More generally:
-Probably part of the advantage was in pre-lamination times the main bench was often heavier, and made of a single piece. I have such a bench at the country, it is just an oak beam, the tractor could barely shift it, it isn't all that much fun, or necessary to have a heavier beam;
- Less costly in the above sense or if you are paying cash for wood;
- More texture to clamp or work stuff on, so for instance a clamp across the bench only need to reach 12 inches and is much easier to handle.
- Less surface area to flatten or have stay flat, less potato chip effect.
- You can store the stuff you need on the surface without affecting work area, or having them fall on the floor.
I just have the one bench with a trough. my other 5 benches don't have them, but I don't see a downside.