New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Our club needs a portable bench

Posts

Our club needs a portable bench

#1

Our club needs a portable bench

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

We can't leave a bench at our meeting spot so someone has to haul one in a van, SUV etc. Can anyone recommend a design? I have been steered to a design in this link. The bench needs to be heavy enough to be useful. We will attach a modern metal vise to it.

http://www.shopwoodworking.com/building-the-portable-moravian-workbench-with-will-myers-dvd/?lid=MFpwbl030515

Re: Our club needs a portable bench

#2

Re: Our club needs a portable bench

William Duffield

It looks like a good design. I will offer a couple of observations:

It needs more dog holes. :D

Personally, I don't prefer tool trays, but making the back half solid has the disadvantage of making it heavier.

If you put a steel vise on it, it will make the front half of the top significantly heavier, and probably too heavy to be practically handled by one person.

I would make the dowels behind the leg vise larger diameter. The leg vise puts a lot of pressure on them. (Not an issue with a steel vise attached to the bottom surface of the top).

You might consider a split top design, for added versatility. If you add a front board to your tool tray, you could flip it over, and instantly convert to a flat top bench without a tool tray. You would need to reposition its alignment pins.

In this video, Mike Siemsen shows hand tool techniques to use a bench without any vise at all. You might find the part about using the split top useful.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yvhn-PAfEW4

Re: Our club needs a portable bench

#3

Agree

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I don't get the idea of a tool tray, AKA repository of stuff.

The dowels looked frail. I would use a short tenon

What ever we build will have a steel quick release vise, probably a small Jorgensen.

What is your guess on the size of the leg?

Re: Our club needs a portable bench

#4

Re: Our club needs a portable bench *LINK*

David Bassett

I book-marked several posts Chris Schwarz made about "knockdown" and portable benches. The folding transportable version Mike Siemens built might match your needs:


Mike Siemen's Folding Bench

Re: Our club needs a portable bench

#5

Re: Our club needs a portable bench *LINK*

David Bassett

(Couldn't figure out how to do multiple links in a post)

Here is the Caleb James' Version.


Caleb James' Version

Re: Our club needs a portable bench

#6

Re: Our club needs a portable bench *LINK*

David Bassett

... and Chris Schwarz's version (with follow ups & long discussion of hardware):


Chris Schwarz's Version

Re: Our club needs a portable bench

#7

I like that one...

John in NM

It looks sturdy without being overly massive. While balance might be a problem with some vise options, as William points out, the design itself does not leave you specifically wedded to a single kind of vise.

I believe I would prefer a larger top, but it would have to be in pieces to keep from getting stupidly heavy.

Bill Houghton was just telling me I may need a portable bench for my rental house that goes with the new job. I didn't give it a huge amount of thought at the time, but I do really like the look of that bench - so thanks for the timely post :D

At the moment I even have no less than two spare steel screw vises..... so I would likely go that route as well.

Re: Our club needs a portable bench

#8

Requirements

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It needs to have an overhand for clamping stuff to and be able to have a steel quick change vise attached like the Jorgensen or Lee Valley. Most users of this bench will not be doing hand tool work. Who knows what they will be doing so it must be versatile. I am thinking that a flat top with overhand is a must.

Re: Our club needs a portable bench

#9

A thought...

John in NM

Since it's not going to be a purely hand tool bench, perhaps a big torsion box top would do the trick? Light enough to move as needed, while extra big with plenty of overhang. Vise weight would be more of a problem if the top is light, but you could probably mitigate that - keep the top off center for example, so the weight of the vise was closer to over the leg - with all the overhang on the other side of the bench.

Re: Our club needs a portable bench

#10

Re: Agree

William Duffield

I call it a "tool ditch". :D

My best guess on the size of the legs is 3" x 3-1/2" x 34". They look like SYP, so I'm guessing they started with one Home Center 36" stair tread for each leg, which is 1" thick and 11-1/2" wide. You rip off the bull nose and rip it in thirds and glue it back together, and that's what you get.

Re: Our club needs a portable bench

#11

Pennsylvania Dutch

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Here in Pennsylvania we call a bench like that with slanted legs a Pennsylvania Dutch bench. The North Carolina settlement was started by Moravians from Pennsylvania. In the 18th century the Moravians picked up many converts among other Pennsylvania Dutch, so it might be hard to trace an origin for the bench.

Re: Our club needs a portable bench

#12

Re: Advantages are

TomD

"I don't get the idea of a tool tray, AKA repository of stuff."

I don't prefer them, but I have one on my Frid bench, and I never notice a problem.

- It could be an advantage in your case because it is lighter as has been said;

- Stuff put there that is less in the way than it is on the surface of the bench, and less likely to get knocked on the floor. This would be good in a situation where you are likely to be in the open and not necessarily surrounded with other benches and lockers.

- While neat freaks who would probably not get into trouble in the first place seem to object to them, in this case, since you need to move it after every use, there won't be time to get into trouble. Associated with the German bench, and those guys are organized...

More generally:

-Probably part of the advantage was in pre-lamination times the main bench was often heavier, and made of a single piece. I have such a bench at the country, it is just an oak beam, the tractor could barely shift it, it isn't all that much fun, or necessary to have a heavier beam;

- Less costly in the above sense or if you are paying cash for wood;

- More texture to clamp or work stuff on, so for instance a clamp across the bench only need to reach 12 inches and is much easier to handle.

- Less surface area to flatten or have stay flat, less potato chip effect.

- You can store the stuff you need on the surface without affecting work area, or having them fall on the floor.

I just have the one bench with a trough. my other 5 benches don't have them, but I don't see a downside.

Re: Our club needs a portable bench

#13

Re: Advantages are

TomD

I don't really see the problem with the crap accumulation angle. I'm messy, FK doesn't apper to be. My tray is loaded, his is clean. I guess somewhere in the middle there could be some weak willed individual that a tool tray converted into a hoarder, though I doubt it. For me, I cover every level surface, the tray is one I don't normally have to clear to work. For FK he is perfectly organized (and I would be too if it was a job) and he uses the tray as a tool. There isn't anything stopping one from adding a lid to the tray, for the best of both worlds.

Re: Our club needs a portable bench

#14

Re: A thought...

TomD

That is a very good idea. I have one bench that is made out of a maxed out from a sheet of 3/4 ply beam. It is really strong, and light, and it is dead flat and never moves. One just makes a box out of it with bulkheads every foot, and some doublers over the area you want to mortise above the rear leg, and where you want your vise.

I showed this pic in the bridge crane thread a while back. The major bench components are above the hole; supports at either end and the beam across.


Oh, and the clamp thread:


Beam resting on two Japanese horses.

The nice thing about it is that one can get home depot to cut the ply. I used their paint grade "maple". I prefer to use other ply generally, but they have good panel saws that make the job a lot easier.

My wood turning club moves bowl turning lathes. One option to making things light is getting gear to move stuff that is heavy