New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

drawknife

Posts

drawknife

#1

drawknife

Bruce Mack

I've recently acquired two, an Arno convex and a Two Cherries straight knife for spoon making from cherry logs. The Arno is better built but the 40 degree angle of the cutting edge causes a fair amount of resistance in a slicing cut. I may try to alter the bevel but for now I'll use the Arno for the resistant areas such as grain reversals at which it does well.

The knives surprise me with prodigious wood removal from dried stock, walnut and 2x4s albeit with some tear out. I'm considering using them to thin the long edges of 5/8" thick wood panels, gradually approaching the centerline, in effect creating convex surfaces. The panels will be made into small boxes.

Question - what if any use have you found for drawknives in other than green woodworking?

Re: drawknife

#2

answer

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

When a spoke have is too slow and a band saw doesn't work, the spoke shave might work for stock removal. In experienced hands, eg. Curtis Buchannan, it is a surprisingly precise tool for refined work. In my hands it makes wood go away quickly, and mostly reliably.

But I think answers to questions like you posed reveal themselves while pursuing doing something. Have a well stocked "tool box" and go make stuff. When the need arises find something in the tool box that does the job. Likely what you find will differ from what I find, and for that reason me offering advice may not be useful.

It is told that the now famous Brian Boggs used a sharpened screw driver to cut chair mortises when he was a poor lad starting out, for that was the best tool he had on hand for the task.

Re: drawknife

#3

Re: drawknife

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

As you're thinking about, and as Bill T. has mentioned, I've found them great for working edges. I've used mine for both hogging out and smoothing on an edge. The transition from hogging out to smoothing is almost Zen-like: I can't tell you exactly what I do differently, but my body responds to what my mind wants, most of the time.

In spite of the length of the cutting edge, they have not, in my hands, been as effective in removing wood from the face of a board (that is, wide slices of wood).

Re: drawknife

#4

Re: drawknife

Rum

I found the wide cutting edge mostly useful in the sense that it allows a cross "slicing" cut on difficult wood which helps reduce tearout in some difficult grain.

I'd have to say that the most hours I've spent behind a drawknife was for pealing the bark off of fence rails.... Not exactly precision work.

Re: drawknife

#5

Re: answer

TomD

"It is told that the now famous Brian Boggs used a sharpened screw driver to cut chair mortises when he was a poor lad starting out, for that was the best tool he had on hand for the task."

I wonder if he was trying to find something like the tool illustrated in the Alexander book that showed a very long chisel one could push with one's shoulder. Didn't seem to still be around when the tape was made.

Re: drawknife

#6

Re: drawknife

TomD

And of course one common farmside use was making shingles for which the wide blade was also useful.

Re: drawknife

#7

Re: drawknife

Rum

Works pretty well for trimming shingles, but doesn't have enough leverage to easily split them off of a block imho. For that we used a froe.

Re: drawknife

#8

Re: drawknife

TomD

I use for for all kinds of thing, and I find getting good accuracy is a snap. What I notice about the guys who do repetitive tasks like our CB up here is John Robinson that he has the process for doing a spindle down to a specified number of cuts and his tapering formula is all math and automatic. I'm sure his control is better, but that is not the material difference it is the approach.

I use them for anything they seem the right tool for, which comes down to whether they will bust off the chips I want. One use I will be getting to this week or so will be a guitar neck. I haven't selected the wood yet, and if it isn't perfect I will probably use a bandsaw followed by a spokeshave. But for the quality of wood one normally uses, the neck profile is basically a half ellipse or a parabola, depending on the style I am making. On classicals the neck profiling is almost the last step so one has a big investment in the project by the time one is brandishing the knife. I lay out some lines pinching a pencil and then just remove the material to the lines in the most efficient number of strokes. As usual the final cut needs to have enough beef in it that the shaving holds the knife reliably in the cut. Being too tentative and leaving a smidge to remove is not conducive to good work. Then I work the facets down, and after that is is on to other tools.

But while it all looks very expert to do it this way it is completely safe if the material is as perfect as a guitar neck needs to be. The draw knife is a very easy tool to use if the wood is good. That is why the chair guys get veneer grade logs.

Re: drawknife

#9

Re: drawknife

TomD

For sure, never suggested that. Some of my antique knives have dents where someone obviously tried to split something with them, which I guess keeps the price reasonable. :) But they were used for tapering the shingles, if that is what is meant by trimming.

Re: drawknife

#10

Re: drawknife

Rum

Hmm, I'm not sure what you mean by "taper" (this is definitely one of the cases where a couple of beers and a piece of paper would make the conversation a lot quicker :D).

We did use a drawknife to shave a bit off of the top of bottom to get them to a more consistent thickness (this was mostly for shops/chicken coops though so never got to carried away).

The sapwood (and ratty edges) were (if I recall correctly, its been a longish while) were mostly shaved off with a hatchet or split off with a froe (I seem to remember doing both but can't recall why). We might have tapered the bottom of the shingle to be a smidge narrower than the top while doing that as well but I just don't remember.

Prying with the drawknife is sort of a crime, unless its not to bad and enables me to get one on the cheap ;) I have been guilty of hitting a knot a bit to hard and nicking the edge, there's no real valid excuse for that either (and as a youngster I got me ears boxed for it as well).

Re: drawknife

#11

Re: drawknife

William Duffield

There are also ergonomic reasons for the shape and size of the drawknife. If you used a shorter one with the handles closer together, when working on a shavehorse, your elbows and upper arms collide with the sides of your rib cage and belly. This either shortens your stroke or moves some of your force from your biceps to your back and shoulders. The shorter shaves are still useful for exacting work and shorter stock, but for shaping spindles and especially bow backs of Windsors, you want to use as long a stroke as possible.

Re: drawknife

#12

Re: answer

Ken Martin

I admit I don't use one much but in addition to the length you need to look at the profile. Just more to look for.


Re: drawknife

#13

Re: answer

Bruce Mack

"When the need arises find something in the tool box that does the job."

So true. I have used diamond hones, arkansas slips, and ceramic stones to shape and hone the curve of my Mora hook knife. Results iffy. Yesterday I looked at my granite flat plate, said "duh" and with a sheet of 320 wet/dry managed to do the tricky hand roll shown by Del Stubbs on his excellent Pinewood Forge site. A lot of problems can be addressed with what you own or can make if you loosen your mind set.

Re: drawknife

#14

Curtis Buchanan *LINK*

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Mr. B is a wizard with the drawknife, as Bill suggested. Take a look at this


Carving a seat

Re: drawknife

#15

It's even better in person

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

He did a whole chair bottom, with commentary for a club program. The chips did fly.

Re: drawknife

#16

Re: It's even better in person

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Now I'm officially jealous :D

Re: drawknife

#17

Re: answer

TomD

That is an interesting poster. Not much there that I have seen availalbe. I like a plane wing section a bit like one of the one in the center. And the carpenter one is functionally like the planer blade ones that are common.

Handle to section affects a lot also.

Re: drawknife

#18

Re: Curtis Buchanan

TomD

The clear ruler he has is a sewing ruler for applying seam allowance, if your not all that spacial, though in this case he is just using it as a straight edge.

Re: drawknife

#19

Re: Curtis Buchanan

Bruce Mack

It must depend on the species. I have a piece of riven cherry that fights me for possession of the drawknife.