New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Adjusting a plane.

Posts

Adjusting a plane.

#1

Adjusting a plane.

John Pappas

Based on an article I read many years ago, I adjust a plane by sighting from the rear of the plane, not the front as is always shown in books, articles, etc. By time you see the blade when sighting from the front, it is extended too far. When sighting from the rear, the first glint of reflection sets the blade for a fine shaving. So, I am left wondering why sighting from the front seems to be the standard procedure.

Re: Adjusting a plane.

#2

Re: Adjusting a plane.

Chuck Bjorgen

The sighting of the blade along the sole has never worked for me. i simply move the plane along the work to be planed until the blade starts cutting. i generally retract the cutter when I'm done working with the plane.

Re: Adjusting a plane.

#3

Re: Adjusting a plane.

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have been sighting from the front for both iron planes and wood planes for more than 40 years. I think it works well. I don't know your age or experience, John, but maybe if someone is around retirement age and just beginning he would have trouble seeing the iron.

Re: Adjusting a plane.

#4

Re: Adjusting a plane.

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Sighting from the front works for me, but I think it should work from either end.

The sole of the plane does need to be moderately reflective, to pick up the hairline of the iron as it peeks through.

Re: Adjusting a plane.

#5

Re: Adjusting a plane.

TomD

There are several adjustments that can be made.

1) If it is depth of cut, I am a push it along guy, though for that to work you may need a board that is post planed since you often don't get a true example if the board hasn't been planed already, or one simply makes some adjustments as the truth reveals itself. I also find that the fingers over the blade method works for this. There isn't any one way since planes are quite variable in how they are adjusted, for instance japanese planes, one can feel the tension in the adjustment increase as the blade reaches the set point.

Another variable is whether one is going for a working cut, or a specific cut. There are situations where one needs say 1 thou cut and nothing else will do.

A few years back I did a test where I measured the cycle time to take the blade out and reset it. The results are on here somewhere. It was like 9 seconds to get a usable cut, and maybe 20 to set to a particular thou. All I remember is that the fastest method is easily realized under the clock.

2) The other type of set is for an angle or a parallel shaving. I sight from the front for that. The darker shadow is more effective from the front, than glints from the back. The actual height of the blade doesn't mater, I just get a good exposure and then check it for the angle or parallel. Fingers can also work for this, but a visual check is normally required, and in the extreme. callipers may come out to check the shaving.

Re: Adjusting a plane.

#6

Dale Lenz

Re: Adjusting a plane.

Dale Lenz

Started using a plane, an 07 when I was 30 YO. Never could sight down the sole of the plane. Taught myself to use my fingers, point and middle finger as I lower the iron, never did cut myself, :).

Last few years I pull out a small piece of wood and shave the corner off of both sides of the iron to check for a level and even cut. If the shaving appear about the same thickness, call it good and go to work. After checking my wood's edge with a square might need some small adjustment.

Re: Adjusting a plane.

#7

Ditto

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I even keep a straight grain piece of wood on the plane shelf for this task.

Re: Adjusting a plane.

#9

Re: Adjusting a plane.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Based on an article I read many years ago, I adjust a plane by sighting from the rear of the plane, not the front as is always shown in books, articles, etc. By time you see the blade when sighting from the front, it is extended too far. When sighting from the rear, the first glint of reflection sets the blade for a fine shaving. So, I am left wondering why sighting from the front seems to be the standard procedure.

Hi John

Are you referring to a woodie without adjuster or a steel plane with adjuster? Also, a smoother, or a jack? All these can require a different technique.

I use my fingers to feel for blade projection. However I also find it easier to set the plane for less projection and add more, than have to retract the blade. This is especially so with woodies without adjusters.

To set up a woodie, or any other plane without an adjuster, I use a glass setting plate ..


Example: setting up a HNT Gordon Smoother ...

Place plane on glass setting plate.

Insert blade and hold it flat against the glass.

Insert wedge and continue to ensure that the blade is still flat against the glass.

Firm up the wedge.

At this point the plane should take very fine shavings.


The glass will not damage the edge of the steel blade.

Extend the blade, as needed, with the hammer.

With a plane using an adjuster, I tend to set the projection by finger feel, then extend the projection with the adjuster as I take a test shaving. Fingers also tell me if I am in the ball park with cutting balance, but this is also adjusted after a test shaving. I prefer to use a small jeweller's hammer for this type of fine adjustment. Even Bailey type adjusters are too coarse when making fine lateral adjustments ...


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Adjusting a plane.

#11

Re: Priceless

Jim Toews

No, Bill, not priceless: only $17.98. At this price you could get one for each plane! Or at least one for each family of planes (coarse, medium, and fine, to borrow from Chris Schwarz). Sheesh, what will they think of next. Reminds of the old adage about a fool and his money...

Re: Adjusting a plane.

#12

In all fairness...

John in NM

That's some kind of machining height gauge re-applied by the vendor :D

I've seen the depth measuring kind often enough, but not that particular type.

I've also seen them used for measuring tire tread, for those who are more comfortable with a number than a glance at the molded in wear indicator bars, or for cheapskates like me, the increasing frequency of flats! :D

Re: Adjusting a plane.

#13

Same here....

John in NM

Feel and test for me, especially with wedged planes. Got plenty of scraps anyway :D

Re: Adjusting a plane.

#14

If you just have to have one...

Neal in San Jose

A friend approached me at last month's club meeting and offered me one of these at a serious discount. I am the "hand tool guy" after all, and known to have my head turned by a shiny bit of gizmosity. I passed, but I bet he still has it. Some shipping costs would be involved, but I'll see him at this month's meeting.

Re: Adjusting a plane.

#15

Re: Adjusting a plane.

John Pappas

Thanks to those who took the time to respond. However, I apparently didn't express my question well, or the subject title was misleading. I was not seeking advice on how to adjust a plane, but rather seeking comments on the idea of sighting a plane from the front vs sighting from the back. Warren, I am sure if I had the good fortune to visit your shop you would be able to point out what you do in a way that I would have one of those 'aha moments'. This morning I took a wooden plane and a metal plane and removed the blades, backed off the adjuster on the metal plane, replaced the blades and had each one taking a very good shaving in less than half a minute. I remain puzzled why sighting from the back never gets mentioned. Apparently only me and the guy who wrote the mentioned article are the only ones using this method. LOL

Re: Adjusting a plane.

#16

Re: I'd get it for jointer knives setting


Re: Adjusting a plane.

#17

Re: Adjusting a plane.

TomD

Then what you are talking about is sighting for depth. If it works for you that's fine, but other methods work just as well, and in something like setting up a plane to take a specific shaving I am going to have to measure the shaving. That might seem fancy, but it is necessary in stuff like making bamboo rods (again depending on your method to some extent). Also for accurate thicknesses over rails where blade projection is part of the issue. On the other extreme, the dull plane that is still working, the degree of plane blade extension that is still working depends on sharpness, so I don't try to measure it by eye. I mainly use the eye to judge parallelism. Basically it is just a flow, whatver plane I pick up, whatever job I do, there is a method and it just flows out, I have to sit back and figure out what it is I actually do in most situations.

Re: Adjusting a plane.

#18

Re: Adjusting a plane.

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I was one who did respond directly to your question. You asked why anybody would sight from the front, given that one could not see the iron very well from the front. I think your premise is false because I have had no trouble adjusting while looking at the front. It is apparently a skill shared by many, including Japanese. I think one could learn to sight from either direction.

Re: Adjusting a plane.

#19

Near and Far sighted

Bruce McCrory

I need the proximal distance of the forward end. But recently, even that doesn't help. I play the tiller, screw back to no shaving, then screw down and catch what I want on the way.

To summarize: There are more near-sighted people than far-sighted. Therefore, you see less stern adjustment in literature.