New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Do I need a smoothing plane?

Posts

Do I need a smoothing plane?

#1

Do I need a smoothing plane?

Don Emmerling

I am liking the use of hand tools more and more. I like to make small boxes with differing joints and wood. Of late I have been finishing the wood surface using an old Stanley plane *Baily No. 4) because I like the feel of the finished surface, although some sanding still is used. The Stanley plane is in good condition and I keep the blade sharp. I obtained the plane after my fathers passing and he bought it some time in the 50's. I keep seeing on Youtube that people using hand tools always seem to say that they always use a smoothing plane for surfaces. I have googled searching for any differences between my Stanley and smoothing planes. What are called smoothing planes come in a variety of sizes, some of which are the same as my Stanley. They never say if the blade angle is different than the Stanley so I have no way of knowing. So, before I spend money on a plane that I might not need, let me ask if my Stanley would work just as well as a smoothing plane.

Thanks in advance,

Don

Re: Do I need a smoothing plane?

#2

Re: Do I need a smoothing plane?

AlanWS

Your #4 is a smoothing plane. If set up well, it can do an excellent job.

Re: Do I need a smoothing plane?

#3

You've got to watch that Internet

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

There's a lot of information, some of it confusing, out there.

Smoothing planes are distinguished by shortish bodies, allowing them to tuck down into any long irregularities in the work. As Alan indicated, your No. 4 is considered a smoothing plane. In the Stanley numbering system, bench planes in the Nos. 1 through 4 sizes would be considered smoothing planes.

The No. 5, four or so inches longer, is described as a jack plane. If you have lots of planes, the jack is generally sharpened for and used for rougher work: knocking the high spots off a surface or edge, taking width off a piece of stock by planing the extra away, etc.

As you get into the longer planes, Nos. 6 through 8, you're headed toward planes most often used to get true (straight) edges and surfaces. Their length leads to them hitting high spots and skipping over low spots until the high spots are the same height as the lows.

If you learn by reading, you might see if your library has "The Hand Plane Book" by Garrett Hack, or invest in your own copy of that and "Planecraft" (out of print, not expensive at the online booksellers; get the Hampton and Clifford version, not the later re-do). Those two will give you a good sense of the use of planes in woodworking; their only hazard, really, is that they can leave you with the impression that there are no other necessary tools in woodworking, when, in fact, skillful use of other tools can accomplish things planes can't.

While you're at the library, get out all the books you find on hand tool woodworking. By the third one, you'll be skimming over the repetitive information, but you'll find each other has his/her preferences. Realizing that there are often multiple ways to do things is a good lesson to learn.

I'm an old man, I guess; I think the kind of learning you should be doing now is better done with books or reliable videos. One trouble with the Internet is that there are no editors; another is that people often assume you know things you don't yet know, which can lead to confusion, as it did here. There are, yes, bad books out there; but the good ones give you an organized approach to the subject and sound information.

Re: Do I need a smoothing plane?

#4

Re: Do I need a smoothing plane?

Curt Putnam

Sounds like a trick question to me. But, taking the bait .....

If you are making small boxes then most of you final smoothing can be taken care of with a block plane. A lot depends on what your are doing to get to box sized pieces of stock. If you are milling before cutting to size from rough stock or buying S2S, S3S or S4S is the 1st fork in the decision tree. If the former, you may well want several different size planes; if the latter you need nothing more than a block plane.

Regardless, i would keep your Dad's plane and look into a low angle block plane(s).

Re: Do I need a smoothing plane?

#5

Re: Do I need a smoothing plane?

TomD

There are always ways of making a given plane more attuned to a particular task. The main thing though is the form of your plane rather than what it is specifically called, or matters of size and position in a range. An unsurpassable plane can be made with a block of wood and a blade, so long as the basics are properly configured for the task. And the flip side is that no matter the qualities of the plane, if it is not set and maintained properly, what it is called, or designed to do won't mater much.

Re: Do I need a smoothing plane?

#6

Re: Do I need a smoothing plane?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hello Don and all,

As the others have pointed out, all the Stanley No. 1 through 4 are smooth planes, whether Bailey or Bedrock design. I happen to think Leonard Bailey a genius of design.

I am sensing though, that simply telling you that your father's plane is a smooth plane, does not fully answer your question. It may be that what you're really getting at is whether the ubiquitous Stanley is enough, or whether you should look at planes with high-angle frogs, super-tight mouths, and so on, that are dedicated to the single task of smoothing.

I've changed my mind on this matter over time--I think you're in good shape with what you now own. You're in good company with the Stanley. There are many photos of the Federal furniture craftsman Robt. Millard using his, and if I'm not mistaken, Warren uses a stock 45-degree factory Stanley (if I'm wrong, please correct me). I have seen other photos of professionals using these tools.

I own dedicated smoothers, and wouldn't give them up. Not entirely because of their performance; more important to me is the personal relationships with the makers. But your familial relationship is with the Stanley.

The great opponent that the smooth plane is up against at every use is tearout. High angle/tight mouth planes make it a pretty simple matter to avoid tearout, provided you can sharpen (and you don't even have to be a real good sharpener with some of these planes). But with the 45 degree Stanley, you need the skill to get the result you want. Sharp blade. Make sure front of plane mouth is sitting right down on the work and is not 'in the air'. An advanced subject which has gotten a lot of recent attention is using the cap iron to defeat tearout. Here is an excellent WoodCentral article by David Weaver on the subject:

http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/readarticle.pl?dir=newarticles&file=articles_935.shtml

If you get tearout with a supersharp blade, then you might try to get the chip breaker into play.

Wiley