Re: Question for David
david weaver
I thought that was a term back then (surgical black) because it was used by a couple of vendors, but a hard black arkansas should be good as long as it appears to be poreless or almost completely poreless.
I think if I were going with two stones, i'd still get a good quality soft. Here's what I'd buy after more buying.
Soft stone (assuming that I'm going to abrade it with a diamond hone from time to time) - from natural whetstone, either what they label soft or hard, both are really like a soft stone.
Black and trans stones, of the new stones, I Like dans the best. They're very good quality stones and prepared very well. They are expensive, so I've gotten mine off of their specials page - the cosmetic issues their specials/seconds have never amount to anything for actual sharpening, they're excellent stones and from time to time you can find an 8x2 of either type on their page for about $90.
Another alternative if you're impatient is the "black trans" that natural whetstone sells. It's not a black stone, but rather a gray translucent stone. Surface prep and finish is not quite as good as dans, but it is a very good quality piece of rock.
AT the time I said something in 2010, I had gotten a huge piece of black ark from halls (but from a knife vendor, halls always wanted to sell at retail price, but their vendors sold things dirt cheap), and it was not very flat, but for the price I could tolerate the lapping. I hear the stones are flatter now, but it looks like the ownership is changed and they're expensive and there are still people reporting here or there that they have stones way out of flat when they get them. For that kind of money, I'd stick to dans.
It's almost impossible to get a vintage black norton/pike stone for decent money, I've seen them go for $200.
Last option is the 8x3 translucent that norton has. Quality is not as good as the dans stone (it's not quite as fine), but I guess some people like the format. They're $79 all the time, but only 1/2 inch thick and need to be put in something. I like an 8x2x1 stone a lot better both because it's easier to keep it flat without lapping, and because the 1/2 inch height difference makes it much nicer to use. I got one of the 8x3 norton trans stones NIB off of ebay a couple of weeks ago for $55 -they come up cheap once in a while, but I won't use it for tools because the width makes it hard to keep flat laterally without lapping it. I don't personally see the point of having a translucent stone and abrading it with a diamond hone.
I think warren will tell you he doesn't see the point of lapping any of the stones, but I don't think I use the stones the same way. I am too lazy.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G85B6iVCyMo
I'd use the same two stones for A2, the strop becomes more important (I think it's important no matter what), and the grinder more. If I felt like the soft was getting graded too much by A2, then I'd add a norton fine india (they're cheap and capable). To the extent the A2 holds a stronger wire edge, I'd flip it back and forth for light strokes on the stones to thin it a little bit more before going to the strop.