New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Question for David

Posts

Question for David

#1

Question for David

Bruce Mack

David - You posted on oil stones in 2010 and then recommended a soft Arkansas and a surgical black. I have both A-2 and O-1 irons and chisels. Are these still your oil stone recommendations? Is surgical grade equivalent to True Hard Arkansas, Black Arkansas, or Translucent? Does it matter? Do you recommend Dan's as the go-to vendor? Have you found other reliable sources? Sorry for the grilling. Thank you.

Re: Question for David

#2

Re: Question for David

david weaver

I thought that was a term back then (surgical black) because it was used by a couple of vendors, but a hard black arkansas should be good as long as it appears to be poreless or almost completely poreless.

I think if I were going with two stones, i'd still get a good quality soft. Here's what I'd buy after more buying.

Soft stone (assuming that I'm going to abrade it with a diamond hone from time to time) - from natural whetstone, either what they label soft or hard, both are really like a soft stone.

Black and trans stones, of the new stones, I Like dans the best. They're very good quality stones and prepared very well. They are expensive, so I've gotten mine off of their specials page - the cosmetic issues their specials/seconds have never amount to anything for actual sharpening, they're excellent stones and from time to time you can find an 8x2 of either type on their page for about $90.

Another alternative if you're impatient is the "black trans" that natural whetstone sells. It's not a black stone, but rather a gray translucent stone. Surface prep and finish is not quite as good as dans, but it is a very good quality piece of rock.

AT the time I said something in 2010, I had gotten a huge piece of black ark from halls (but from a knife vendor, halls always wanted to sell at retail price, but their vendors sold things dirt cheap), and it was not very flat, but for the price I could tolerate the lapping. I hear the stones are flatter now, but it looks like the ownership is changed and they're expensive and there are still people reporting here or there that they have stones way out of flat when they get them. For that kind of money, I'd stick to dans.

It's almost impossible to get a vintage black norton/pike stone for decent money, I've seen them go for $200.

Last option is the 8x3 translucent that norton has. Quality is not as good as the dans stone (it's not quite as fine), but I guess some people like the format. They're $79 all the time, but only 1/2 inch thick and need to be put in something. I like an 8x2x1 stone a lot better both because it's easier to keep it flat without lapping, and because the 1/2 inch height difference makes it much nicer to use. I got one of the 8x3 norton trans stones NIB off of ebay a couple of weeks ago for $55 -they come up cheap once in a while, but I won't use it for tools because the width makes it hard to keep flat laterally without lapping it. I don't personally see the point of having a translucent stone and abrading it with a diamond hone.

I think warren will tell you he doesn't see the point of lapping any of the stones, but I don't think I use the stones the same way. I am too lazy.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G85B6iVCyMo

I'd use the same two stones for A2, the strop becomes more important (I think it's important no matter what), and the grinder more. If I felt like the soft was getting graded too much by A2, then I'd add a norton fine india (they're cheap and capable). To the extent the A2 holds a stronger wire edge, I'd flip it back and forth for light strokes on the stones to thin it a little bit more before going to the strop.

Re: Question for David

#3

Re: Question for David

Bruce Mack

Thanks a lot David. I have a set of Shapton Professional stones that do everything I need but my use of a small shaped Norton translucent for carving gouges introduced me to the pleasure of oil stones.

Re: Question for David

#4

Re: Question for David

Chuck Bjorgen

The terminology used in marketing these stones can get pretty confusing too. I had ordered a translucent from Halls and was informed their recent trans products had lots of defects in them. They offered the same size stone in what they call "Sapphire Translucent" for the same price as the regular trans. So I agreed to take it. It seems very good although if one defines translucent as being able to shine a flashlight through the stone the way it's done in photos, this one does not have that translucency. The stone does have a bluish quality and seems very fine. I'm using this for finishing my kitchen knives although I have done a couple plane blades with it. Curiously Halls does not list stones by this name in their online listings.

Re: Question for David

#5

Re: Question for David

david weaver

Density rules over whether or not light passes through. I've had stones that were 2.6 specific gravity that passed light, and stones that were slightly above that that didn't pass light.

Generally a stone that doesn't pass light is a bit less expensive, though.

Most stones that don't pass light all the way through still pass it through a good portion of the edge.

I haven't seen any true finishers from anyone of the translucent or true hard white that were less than 2.6 specific gravity. Dan's sent me their regular hard stone and it was right at 2.5, and even with that little of a difference, it has some bite and porousness that you don't find in a true finisher.

Re: Question for David

#6

Re: Question for David

John Aniano in central NJ

David,

Nice video - thanks. Can you let us all know what exactly are you using to lightly "lap" or flatten the larger, soft Arkansas stone you use in the video? SiC or similar paper glued to glass or something else? If abrasive paper, what grit typically?

I assume the liquid is WD40?

Thanks,

John

Re: Question for David

#7

Re: Question for David - strop?

John Aniano in central NJ

David,

I forgot to ask - what compound do you prefer on your strop? And as for the strop, flesh side of the leather down or up?

Thanks,

John

Re: Question for David

#8

Re: Question for David

david weaver

It's a worn out DMT 220 bench stone (that I'm using to lap). It looks funny because it's the "bench stone" goofy style with a tall plastic base on it.

You're right, the liquid is WD40. Long term use of a stone without lapping would probably benefit from using something thicker like light mineral oil, but I always lap coarse stones and never fine ones (not even washitas).

As far as leather, the smoothest bovine leather that I can find cheaply. No compounds. If an edge is fine enough to be finished by compound, it doesn't really need it, bare leather does the trick. If it needs the help of compound, then compound has an effect on geometry that I don't like. I realize it can be used with good effect, but I don't do it very much. I like the trueness that bare leather leaves and only strop off of stones where it's beneficial (i.e, I wouldn't strop coming off of a medium diamond stone like paul sellers does, I think part of that is the job of a stone and I like to control what's going on out of laziness - it makes the next sharpening much easier if I don't have to overcome any geometry issues).

I leave the smooth side up and oil it for two reasons:

* smooth side up and slick so that I can see any little particles or bits of metal that may be left on the strop. That stuff is easy to lose track of in the fuzzy side of leather

* the smooth side shows tiny lines if the edge is incomplete. I don't actually shave my arms to test irons, if the strop leaves no lines and stays perfectly clear, I know the edge is good. I always use leather backed by something hard, too. You'd be surprised how good of an edge you can tease from it - literally off of an oilstone, you can strop with light pressure for a minute and hang a hair on the edge of a chisel and sever it.

Re: Question for David

#9

Gritty strops round flat srufaces

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I was of the habit of giving chisel bevels and backs a few rubs on leather with some green stuff. I had a session of tuning up the set of chisels that has not seen a tune up in years. I found that this gritty strop has rounded the back of the chisels, for better or worse, over time. I reflattened on diamond plate, assuming this was a good idea, and perhaps it was. Truthfully, I don't do any operation with sufficient intensity and duration that I can notice small differences in edge preparation. I'm usually fully devoted to fretting over some design issue or applying a newly acquired technique.

Re: Question for David

#10

Re: Gritty strops round flat srufaces

david weaver

I used to use it, too, but not much on the backs of things unless it was on a hard surface. I just got better at using a bare strop, I guess, or learning what needs to be done before the bare strop and then noticed that the green stuff is making my edges a little less keen now and not more, and it's hard to spot contamination in a strop that has it on.

Re: Question for David

#11

Re: Question for David

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

I have a couple more questions:

Why do you recommend against using a lap on a translucent Arkansas? I have an old one that was slightly dished when I got it, so I flattened it with a blue DMT "stone". It was slow, but I didn't have much to take off, and the process didn't seem to harm either the Arkansas or the DMT. I haven't needed to flatten it again, so at least from the point of view of a new stone that was lapped at the factory, you would have to use it for quite a while before you needed to lap it.

Why do you think you get dubbing using CrO2, but not with an uncharged leather strop? It seems to me that it is not the polishing compound, but the strop that is flexible. Why would polishing compoound such as CrO2 or even diamond on a hard substrate result in rounding over the edge, while a flexible strop, either with or without compound, not?

Re: Question for David

#12

Re: Question for David

david weaver

I wasn't that clear about that, I guess. I flatten every stone I get, at least to some extent. But the fine stones, I never touch again after that. I don't like the way they cut when they're scuffed up by a diamond hone.

The washitas, if I ever feel like I want a bit of cutting power, I rub two together, but I usually remind myself if I'm dying for cutting power, I probably need to use the grinder.

As far as the compounds, the green wax compounds that are colored by chrome oxide but that are 70% al ox cut pretty fast. I'm not getting an extremely visible dubbing, but rather just a little bit of rounding at the very edge. In the same effort or less that I'd need to use to go over a green strop (that I can't see contamination on), I can just use the trans stone.

The leather doesn't dub the edge (leather without compound) because 1, it's oiled, 2) it's completely worn in (I recognize that you can sometimes get new pieces of leather that are not quite as smooth and are quite naturally abrasive), and 3) I keep the angle just slightly steeper than the bevel.

I guess it took sharpening razors for me to totally get the use of a bare leather strop, but if one is clean, it should do so little cutting that 300 laps on it would have no effect on geometry.

I don't really think about these things that much until a question comes up, if I had to sum it up, I'd say "I went to stropping just with leather and then when I went back and tried compound again earlier this year after a hard arkansas, I realized that my edge off of the bare leather was actually better and the result more consistent".

I never strop with loose leather, but even leather that is not loose can round an edge. It's got quite a bit of give to it.

Re: Question for David

#13

Re: Question for David

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

Much clearer. I hadn't considered the change in surface quality that would be caused by the diamond lapping. Now, I'm going to have to pay more attention to that difference, and especially to how long it takes for the effect to be worn away. The center of my translucent stone still has a miniscule dish, so I think I can experiment with the difference between the center and edges, because the diamond never touched it. I have noticed a slight difference in color and lustre between the center and edges.

Re: Question for David

#14

Re: Question for David

david weaver

I don't know if there's a specific test for quality, but I figure I can palm strop off any wire edge that remains on a stone that's been touched by the translucent.

When freshly lapped, I can't (not to mention, you can tell that the stone is cutting more slowly and finely).

The razor people get nutty about lapping their stones, one because they feel the need to lap everything, but two because after that, they have a fit if the surface quality left doesn't provide an ideal razor edge.

I don't mind a little bit of out of flatness on the final stones, though I try to avoid it like anyone else does.

When I used to lap everything I had, I would always be disappointed how big of a wire edge the finish stones rolled up, and then I'd figure "the particles aren't fine", but it wasn't the particles, it was the little troughs cutting harshly.

As to direct ill effects of lapping marks, I've only had them from tiny mill marks on a razor edge on a piece of jasper.

All of my opinions don't amount to much if you like the way your stones are working, though.

And even so, if you're addicted to lapping, make the last lapping strokes in the same direction you'll be honing, and the effect will be minimal. It's the circles and figure 8 type stuff that causes a big wire edge.

Re: Question for David

#15

Re: Question for David

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have used a bare strop since 1966. I tried a powder for a short time around 1979, but I did not think it as good. I guess if one lacked a fine stone he could use a charged strop instead to polish the edge, but using a fine stone and a dry strop makes a better job.

Abrading an Arkansas stone will degrade the polishing ability of the stone. And depending on how well it is milled, a new Arkansas will take some time to wear to a fine surface. Arkansas stones are used for edge refinement, not so much steel removal.

Re: Question for David

#16

Re: Question for David *LINK*

Chuck Bjorgen

I found an old thread here for calculating the density of a stone. It dates back to 2006. I followed the instructions as well as I could and the density of my Sapphire Blue Translucent did indeed come out to 2.6. Here's the link for that old thread in case anyone wants to try it. Thankfully my old postal scale was able to get the weight after installing a fresh battery.


Stone density calculation

Re: Question for David

#17

Re: Question for David

david weaver

Should be a good stone. The novaculite itself is somewhere around 2.7 SG, and I think the stones are somewhere around 99% novaculite, so the good ones all have about the same density.