New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Natural stones(japanese)

Posts

Natural stones(japanese)

#1

Natural stones(japanese)

Allen Fulmer

Hey guys, I'm hoping to get some insight on some japanese natural stones. I currently have an ohira Tomae, however I don't feel I'm getting the best edge from it. But I don't know for sure, as I've never used another stone to compare to. The tool vendor I usually use has an ohira suita, Okudo suita and a Nakayama asagi(two stones I was kind of debating between. One of the things I need to consider is what I'm sharpening. I have a set of ichihiro, as well as a set of kiyotada and kiyohisa. David (Weaver) (if you see this) we talked a few weeks back and you mentioned your okudo suita just barely cuts your kiyotada chisels, so I was hoping to get some insight on that as I'll need to cut both sets of Tokyo chisels. You gave me Takeshi's information and after talking with him, he said he didn't have anything that matched what I asked for(cuts super hard steel, no nagura). Anyway, the vendor says the ohira suita will be better than okudo suita because its softer allowing me to cut the super hard steel better. All the stones are a reasonable price. As I know many of you are much more knowledgable than I, I was hoping for some more insight.

I was also interested in a medium stone, he's offering me a Tsushima, saying its a very good medium stone, at ehat seems like a very reasonable price. He says the grit is about 2000. I would like to use this as a starting stone, then finish with one of the above stones.

Re: Natural stones(japanese)

#2

Re: Natural stones(japanese)

Allen Fulmer

Just saw there was a discussion about natural stones going under my kiyotada thread but for some reason I wasn't getting notifications for it. I'll also read through that

Re: Natural stones(japanese)

#3

Re: Natural stones(japanese)

david weaver

(to the detriment of others) I'm willing to talk about the stones as much as anyone wants to.

I think there is a lot of subjectivity about what the right hardness is, and when aoki thinks of something self slurrying, he might be thinking of something that slurries easily with knives or that slurries like a thick slurry from a soft nagura.

I have to pick up another stone this afternoon, after our discussion last week, and I'll see how it works and give you an idea based on his numbers.

As far as ohira vs. okudo, etc, there are basic characteristics of stuff from each mine, but there is overlap as there are noncharacteristic stones from each. There are soft suita from okudo and hard suita from ohira, and fast cutting suita from other mines faster than some okudo, etc.

If your local source will let you try the stones and you can work up a minor slurry on them without removing the label, that would be best.

Ohira tomae stones are fairly common because the mine is either still open or was until recently (same with ohira suita, a new suita with renge is usually going to be ohira). Thus the mellow tomae stone you have is a common one coming from a lot of different sellers right now (but probably originating from imanishi in most or all cases). It is a decent middle of the road stone (not scratchy, etc), but you'll find that trying to get into the type I'm describing will provide you with a much stronger cutter, and if one that doesn't self slurry too much, a stone that also will provide a finer edge.

My opinion here, if the ohira suita is soft, I'd pass on it. The old reputation that you can't get a fine edge on difficult steels probably has to do with compromises that you need to make to actually cut it, and a stone that self slurries significantly while you're using it will not make the biting sharp edge you're looking for. It'll instead make a gentle edge that's definitely sharp, but not one that will wow you.

If you get a stone that's just a little on the hard side, you can always refresh slurry a little bit with a diamond hone or diamond card, I'd rather have to do that than to have a stone that's too soft, because you can't tease a fantastic edge out of a softer stone.

As far as the tsushima, they are good low cost middle stones, my only criticism of them is that they're black, so you can't see how they're cutting. That aside, they can be had for $150 for a 5 or 6 pound stone, they have a fairly good range of grit sizes, they're reasonably hard and they don't leave any random scratches. The only other middle stone that you can get that's decent is probably a very large nagura, but they're also very expensive and can be scratchy.

I can't remember what hardness and fineness aoki said my okudo suita is, but I have one that I have to pick up at the post office that's described as 8.5 and 8.9 (hardness and fineness) on aoki's scale and I think my okudo was about that hardness and slightly less fine.

Anyway, still stick with the strong cutters that are a little bit harder, you can establish the bevel with other stone and bias the polishing only toward the edge and be better of with a harder stone than you would be working the entire bevel with a soft finish stone.

Re: Natural stones(japanese)

#4

Re: Natural stones(japanese)

david weaver

So, I got my stone today. It was 8.6 hardness by aoki's estimation, and it's not very regularly shaped, so I can't give it a good test other than to notice that it's got a tendency to release particles a little faster than okudo. (the slurry on the ends of the stone isn't indicactive, it was raised with an atoma while lapping the stone. )


It was also what aoki called 8.9 fineness, and has a very slick non-scratchy feel.

It's in a holder in plaster now, and once the plaster is dry tomorrow, I'll know a lot more.

It's hard to judge a stone based on what's just on the surface, usually they get a bit softer, but while you're lapping them and a bunch of fresh slurry is rolling around, sometimes they can also seem like they're releasing particles fast.

I'll put a kiyotada chisel to the stone tomorrow and see what absolute sharpness is. Even with its awkwardness, I sharpened an ouchi bench chisel on it before putting it in plaster, and the result was a very pretty kasumi finish, no random scratches at all, and a very keen edge.

So, aoki does have stones that are hovering around what we're talking about, but he may not know it because his opinion of things is different than ours.

I wonder how brian is making along with is shinden suita. It's similar fineness and hardness, and it'll be interesting to see what he thinks about it after a month of having it.

I would like a stone that releases particles a little less fast than mine, but some use of it will probably make me familiar enough that I'll reverse my opinion and like it quite a bit.

Re: Natural stones(japanese)

#5

Re: plaster's dry enough..

david weaver

..it just barely cuts ouchi and kiyotada, the edge is very good. I didn't slurry the stone but that would help a little at only a little cost to the edge.

As the stone gets toward dry, it does a better job, but so does every stone.

Okudo suita is the only natural stone that really cuts those two quickly and leaves a fine edge. I don't know what the difference is between it and my other stones, but it's really a remarkable stone.

Re: Natural stones(japanese)

#6

Re: plaster's dry enough..

Allen Fulmer

Thanks David! This is really helpful, actually. So your new stone, is a hardness of 8.5 and a fineness of 9.2?(or somewhere close) and it barely cuts...So not being sure exactly what your okudo suita is, and based on your testing, which direction on the scale do you think I want to be? I can just give Aoki numbers instead of a description since he may be looking at things differently than what I'm asking for.

Re: Natural stones(japanese)

#7

Re: plaster's dry enough..

david weaver

the current one is 8.6 and 8.9. I'm not sure what the okudo was, but it was probably a couple of clicks harder, but it's definitely no finer and maybe not quite as fine.

I don't think the particle size, the second number, has too much to do with whether or not the stone cuts, just a matter of how finely it cuts - probably when slurried.

I guess as good as my experience is with the okudo, I'm unlikely to buy anything else, and I hate to say "bite the bullet and buy one" given that ony expensive relatively regular shaped stones are left, but that's probably what I'd do.

The edge that comes off of the okudo with the ouch and kiyotada chisels is slippery sharp in a paring cut. To be fair, it is with the nakayama suita, too, it just cuts much more slowly and slurries more (strange that it does, but it's definitely slower, even on slurry).

I notice some of aoki's okudo aren't that fine. I'd defer to his expertise, but I gather you want something that's fine first and then fast .I'd stick to the finer ones that area bit harder.

The okudo of mine slurries only when there is jigane involved. If only hardened steel is brought to it, it doesn't slurry. And the slurry with jigane involved is very light and slow to develop, but the stone cuts strong, anyway.

Re: Natural stones(japanese)

#8

Re: Natural stones(japanese)

Brian Holcombe

Nice, can't wait to see how the Kiyotada's turn out.

I received mine friday, unpacked it, then promptly drove my wife to Triage, we were admitted, and by saturday evening we had a brand new budding woodworker. He's got big hands and a strong grip, so I think he will work nicely into chisels and planes.

It may be a few days until I can try out the stone, but I should have some initial thoughts later this week.

Re: Natural stones(japanese)

#9

Congratulations, Brian!!

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Just the start of many a sleepless night, for the best reason in the world. There's nothing better than welcoming a new GIT into the world (except maybe a new grandchild, due in June).

Re: Natural stones(japanese)

#10

Re: Congratulations, Brian!!

Brian Holcombe

Thanks Bruce! I got about 2 hours of sleep last night (maybe) and still I couldn't be happier. Congrats on your Grandchild!!

Re: Natural stones(japanese)

#11

Re: Natural stones(japanese)

david weaver

Congratulations, Brian!

The stone probably has been in existence for a couple of million years, I'm sure it can wait!

Re: Natural stones(japanese)

#12

Re: Natural stones(japanese)

Brian Holcombe

Thanks David!

Re: Natural stones(japanese)

#13

Re: plaster's dry enough..

Allen Fulmer

Thanks for all of your help David. I contacted Takeshi, linking him to a few stones listed on his website, based on the scale we talked about. He said any of the stones I linked will work for what I'm looking for. I guess I wasn't clear enough, or chose the wrong words when describing what i was looking for.

Re: Natural stones(japanese)

#14

Re: plaster's dry enough..

david weaver

Natural stones are a subtle thing, I guess. I think sometimes when we ask very specific things, dealers may assume that we're particular, but with natural stones, we're just trying to improve our odds of getting a good one.

My nakayama suita is very marginal on kiyotada chisels, but on softer tools (iyoroi) it is fine. Okudo cuts the kiyotada, but nothing natural is going to cut kiyotada's steel fast - the trade off being that the edge will be better than it would be if the stone cut the chisel aggressively.

It's funny how the steel makes a big difference, though. The nakayama suita is a very nice stone for my old western irons, and it cuts them very well leaving a bright polish, but doing so quickly.

I remember years ago when warren said he'd get the stone that the steel was designed for, and I thought that sounded overly particular at the time, but as time has passed and I've gotten my hand on more things, it really does play out that way.

That sounds a bit contrary when I mention that the natural nakayama suita doesn't cut kiyotada's stuff well, but I doubt there was much out there historically that was as hard as kiyotada's chisels.

Re: Natural stones(japanese)

#15

Re: Natural stones(japanese)

Brian Holcombe

I had a moment to try things out yesterday. The stone was pretty convex but I flattened a good bit of it, not edge to edge from front to back but enough to use it well.

I found that the nagura was not required but it helped get things moving on for blue steel Koyamaichi's that I was honing.

I left one as is off the Snow White and finished one on the Shinden suita. The Shinden suita created a very nice matte finish on both the hard and soft steel, it also allowed me to see the weld line very nicely. I honed aggressively to get the flats to the finished look, then backed off to light pressure to refine the edge.

The result is a super keen edge, I went to a big block of hard maple and shaved a 1-1/4" wide shaving off of the edge grain leaving a bright finish. I also chamfered the edges of the block and it breezed through the cuts.

I can do both of these things with ease off the Snow White, but what I'm finding is that the resulting edge moves through a cut in a much smoother fashion. The stone also cuts with a very nice consistency that the Snow White can have, but often if the soaking is not perfect it will loose.

Re: Natural stones(japanese)

#16

Re: Natural stones(japanese)

david weaver

I think you'll like the edge that the stone makes in use. For lack of a better way to put it, it seems a little more controllable and even in a cut (light vs. not light). Paring seems regulated a little better, easier to avoid overcutting when you're not doing something typical where you can't really overcut.

You're right, too, about the action. The natural stone will have the same excellent action all the time without having to fiddle with soaking or not soaking, and it won't load like some non-soaking synthetic stones do. Just generally nicer to use.

It all comes at a price, though!!

Re: Natural stones(japanese)

#17

Re: Natural stones(japanese)

Brian Holcombe

Thanks for recommending me to take this approach, this has been an eye-opener for me. I initially wrote off natural stones upon seeing the prices, but I'm glad to have made the leap. I will continue to refine my ability to use the stone as well and the combined result should be quite good.

I had the same instinct initially with Japanese tools because there are sooo many facets, each with their own specialty, but delving into them has been quite rewarding.

Re: Natural stones(japanese)

#18

Re: Natural stones(japanese)

david weaver

sorry to be an enabler :)

It's important, I think (I know, I guess, not I think) to be able to get a good stone to start with and there are a lot of oddball people selling stones that are green and look nice that have a bunch of claptrap around them. I think way more than half of the stuff out there is high priced junk, more or less.

All of the various natural stones are good enough that I haven't used an artificial fine stone in a long time. Too bad some of them are so expensive!!

Re: Natural stones(japanese)

#19

Re: Natural stones(japanese)

Brian Holcombe

I think it's good to skip a lot of in-between steps and just get something really good right away. It ends up being significantly less expensive then to acquire alot of test stones.

I'll do a better write-up once I have some mileage on this stone with a few different steels and a few different brands of chisels.

By the end of the summer I will have been able to test blue steel #2 and white steel #2 from Koyamaichi, White steel #2 from Ouchi, and Tasai's Yasuki steel. So I should have a good perspective by then.

I'll see how it does with A2 and o1 as well, but they're not as important.