Re: Natural stones(japanese)
david weaver
(to the detriment of others) I'm willing to talk about the stones as much as anyone wants to.
I think there is a lot of subjectivity about what the right hardness is, and when aoki thinks of something self slurrying, he might be thinking of something that slurries easily with knives or that slurries like a thick slurry from a soft nagura.
I have to pick up another stone this afternoon, after our discussion last week, and I'll see how it works and give you an idea based on his numbers.
As far as ohira vs. okudo, etc, there are basic characteristics of stuff from each mine, but there is overlap as there are noncharacteristic stones from each. There are soft suita from okudo and hard suita from ohira, and fast cutting suita from other mines faster than some okudo, etc.
If your local source will let you try the stones and you can work up a minor slurry on them without removing the label, that would be best.
Ohira tomae stones are fairly common because the mine is either still open or was until recently (same with ohira suita, a new suita with renge is usually going to be ohira). Thus the mellow tomae stone you have is a common one coming from a lot of different sellers right now (but probably originating from imanishi in most or all cases). It is a decent middle of the road stone (not scratchy, etc), but you'll find that trying to get into the type I'm describing will provide you with a much stronger cutter, and if one that doesn't self slurry too much, a stone that also will provide a finer edge.
My opinion here, if the ohira suita is soft, I'd pass on it. The old reputation that you can't get a fine edge on difficult steels probably has to do with compromises that you need to make to actually cut it, and a stone that self slurries significantly while you're using it will not make the biting sharp edge you're looking for. It'll instead make a gentle edge that's definitely sharp, but not one that will wow you.
If you get a stone that's just a little on the hard side, you can always refresh slurry a little bit with a diamond hone or diamond card, I'd rather have to do that than to have a stone that's too soft, because you can't tease a fantastic edge out of a softer stone.
As far as the tsushima, they are good low cost middle stones, my only criticism of them is that they're black, so you can't see how they're cutting. That aside, they can be had for $150 for a 5 or 6 pound stone, they have a fairly good range of grit sizes, they're reasonably hard and they don't leave any random scratches. The only other middle stone that you can get that's decent is probably a very large nagura, but they're also very expensive and can be scratchy.
I can't remember what hardness and fineness aoki said my okudo suita is, but I have one that I have to pick up at the post office that's described as 8.5 and 8.9 (hardness and fineness) on aoki's scale and I think my okudo was about that hardness and slightly less fine.
Anyway, still stick with the strong cutters that are a little bit harder, you can establish the bevel with other stone and bias the polishing only toward the edge and be better of with a harder stone than you would be working the entire bevel with a soft finish stone.