New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Cheek Floats

Posts

Cheek Floats

#1

Cheek Floats

Steve Voigt

Hi All,

Can someone who owns a cheek float help me out with some dimensions? I have some 4140 left over from my last float-making venture, and this seems like an easy one to add to the collection.

Specifically, the Old Street site gives a dimension of 3/4" wide with 1 1/2" of teeth, but since the width is tapered, I'm not sure what the 3/4" refers to.

Thanks in advance,

Steve

Re: Cheek Floats

#2

Re: Cheek Floats

TomD

I have a gauge that represents the wedge in a plane, that I use to layout my marks. I made my floats to the same size. I would make any float to the same size I need it for in the plane. I'm not making old street planes. Though I like them.

Re: Cheek Floats

#3

Re: Cheek Floats

david weaver

1 7/8" of teeth, 5/8" wide at the fat end toward the tang and a fat 1/4" at the tip.

1 7/8" is from the tip of the first tooth to the back of the last tooth. As in, that covers the entire milled area.

A thin 3 3/4" of total distance from the tip to the handle.

Re: Cheek Floats

#4

Re: Cheek Floats

Steve Voigt

Perfect Dave, thanks very much! Filing 2" of teeth doesn't sound bad at all--much easier than making the edge float was. :)

Re: Cheek Floats

#5

Re: Cheek Floats

david weaver

Yeah, it's one I'd file if I were buying. I have most of the LN floats only because my parents are fairly generous with Christmas gifts, and I was about halfway through a side float getting to the wider area and they called and said "what do you want for Christmas?" :b

Admittedly, I don't use most of them on any given plane, but I think I have used each in earnest at least once.

It's nice to have a hand made edge float, the LN edge floats are a bit aggressive with their teeth which can be annoying opening up small mortises.

How do you find the 4140 holds up in use? I've gotten to the point that I lightly touch up the LN floats all the time, especially the bed float. They have tough teeth that don't chip, but they're still saw temper and benefit from frequent filing.

Re: Cheek Floats

#6

Re: Cheek Floats

Steve Voigt

Dave the 4140 (or maybe it's 4142, I don't remember) has held up perfectly fine. The only LN float I have is the bed float, and I don't really notice a difference (although that's a bit of an unfair comparison, because IMO the bigger the float, the more it needs to be at tip-top sharpness). I definitely don't regret making them.

For that matter, the little custom abutment float I made, out of unhardened 5/16 high-carbon "key stock," has also held up fine, and that one is softer than the 4140.

My issue at the moment is, I am using the bed float on the cheeks (that is, below the eyes), but it's too big and cumbersome. I am thinking of making it a little finer--say 10 tpi, and also making the angle between the teeth and sides slightly acute, maybe 80*, so I can get into the corner where the cheek meets the front ramp. Any thoughts ?

Re: Cheek Floats

#7

Re: Cheek Floats

david weaver

I've made all of the finishing cuts in those spots with a 1/2 inch paring chisel across the grain. I couldn't get satisfaction with the floats, and they tend to scuff up corners unless you're really careful, but I think your idea sounds like a good one.

the first few planes I made, I finished all of the inside surfaces with floats, but now only the endgrain surfaces. I tried the bed float and the cheek float, but it always feels awkward. The cheek float gets everywhere, but if you go fast, you'll end up with uneven surfaces and lines. Something between the two in size where there was an extremely slight radius on the tooth edges would be nice because it wouldn't leave witness lines everywhere.

I have lower visual standards to adhere to than you do, but I think your idea of a finer float is a good one, and the corners will definitely have to be relieved to make the cut. I'm going to continue just chisels and scrapers on the cheeks, I'm getting better results leaving the floats out of crossgrain cut.

on the subject of hardness, my edge float is only hardened on the last two inches, and those teeth are too hard to file, I've left them that way. after a couple of dozen planes, they are a little bit dull and the rest of the teeth obviously are, too. I like the way that plane works for opening things up, it cuts but it doesn't grab - you can keep it in motion the whole time and not fight it. Opposite of the bed float, which works miles better (faster) on a slight drawing cut if it's totally sharp.

Re: Cheek Floats

#8

Re: Cheek Floats, O1 and cut quality

TomD

My floats are made out of O1, so far they are holding up OK from occasional use. It is a little surprising that it works as well as it does. Though most of my planes over the last 30 years have been made without floats. If all one needs is to get the shapes without the finest finish, then hack saw blades work really well. Doing initial roughing cuts with hacksaws saves a lot of filing. And once the parts are clean one can get the remaining finish otherwise.

The other thing I like about my home made float, though this could easily be adapted to the lee nielsen ones is that I cut them the full 3/16", and then just tapered the end enough to make them fit through the mouth. This makes the float nearly 4 times stiffer, and helps a lot with chatter.

Maybe you can get your hardened teeth sharp by grinding 2 faces off a 3 sided file and using diamond compound to cut the teeth. Probably would also be necessary or anneal the file.