New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

"Shaking up shaker"

Posts

"Shaking up shaker"

#1

"Shaking up shaker"

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Under the headline in this title there followed a piece in the March 7 Wall Street Journal page D11 about contemporary designers producing furniture inspired by Shaker designs. Some of these designs are to be found at thefutureperfect.com, Egg Collective, O&G Studio and surprisingly the Shanghai China studio, Ner&Hu.


I have always thought I lacked any talent in design. Maybe that is because I thought that a successful new design ought to improve upon the function or appearance of something that was already available. I have seen little ability to make such improvements. Perhaps this is a bar set too high. Some of these "inspired" pieces only had to rise to the level of being different from what inspired them. Guests would not dither with their dinner sitting on that chair. Shakers dined in comfort by comparison.

Re: "Shaking up shaker"

#2

Comfort?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

That thing will collapse backward and eat you like a cracker if you even sneezed. It's hilarious.

Wiley

Re: "Shaking up shaker"

#3

It's $1100

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

And likely will be pitched in the next remodel.

Re: "Shaking up shaker"

#4

Clint Searl

Re: It's $1100

Clint Searl

The demographic to which it appeals will hang it and five or seven like it on wall pegs adjacent to the Nakashima dining table.

Re: "Shaking up shaker"

#5

Re: It's $1100 - the ideal client?


Re: "Shaking up shaker"

#6

Re: "Shaking up shaker"

TomD

MY parents used to play these guys to whom we refer with amusement whenever we see anything too silly in the world of design.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wHuc_Nutv-s

Re: "Shaking up shaker"

#7

Re: All that bad?

TomD

1) shaker chairs are not a model of comfort, the post that protrude at the front do catch the legs of the muscular and over 6 foot set. And the seats can cut into the back of the legs unless the tapes are really packed, which they normally arent. The backs are also upright, and the trannsverse slats do not adapt widely to body types, and cut into the spine. I have spent a life in such chairs, and an used to sitting on them, and like sleeping on the floor it is possible to be comfortable.

Safety wise, their own rockers requite care. The rear legs are designed to "discourage" rocking back. And some of the detail are not all that rugged.

2) I don't find that chair particularly ugly, and the influences seem Asian, Esheresque, and not particularly shaker. Though it is in some ways simple, which seems the only connection.

3) practically it looks stable and the seat looks comfortable enough. It is all pitched back like a rocking chair though, which does not seem practical for dining, unless you are one of those souls who needs help being fed their soup. I had thought from your photo they might have managed to escape a purely square layout, though in does look more like an Adirondack chair from the side, rather than a dining chair.


I don't think comfort is the only criterion in part because it isn't always the best thing. For instance chairs that nobody wants to leave can be a detriment to social situations, or conversation. You want to keep people moving and changing their situation. And for healthy people there can even be a delight to assuming interesting positions, as one might while sitting around on boulders. The lazy boy chair pointed at a TV, illustrates the converse in which a person is fixed and isolated.

Re: "Shaking up shaker"

#8

Adam of Oakland

Re: All that bad?

Adam of Oakland

I hear ya, Tom -

I guess i straddle both sides, i ddon't want to poke sharp sticks at kids trying to reinterpret something. but it'd surprise me if that aft rail/stile peg joint on the base holds more than a docile guest with a fighting weight below a buck-fifty...

Re: "Shaking up shaker"

#9

Can youngsters ....

Bruce McCrory

.... sit in this? That seat shape and design is favored by schools and libraries; which explains my opening. If nothing else is available, the case in the last 20 years, I stand, then leave. I find comfort motivated by aches and pains after the basic principles of design are met.

The braces are fantastic shin, ankle, and toe killers. An efficient use of wood above eight inches from the floor.

This is a critique, right?

Re: "Shaking up shaker"

#10

Re: It's $1100

Brian Holcombe

I was at the MET in the Japanese wing last wing and there is a Nakashima low table and lounge chairs. These were built in what Nakashima considered his own peak (according to his writing), both were something to behold.

They also had a Noguchi sculpture that is awe inspiring, a basalt boulder turned Japanese fountain...it is incredible.

I don't think anyone tops Juhl and Wegner when it comes to contemporary design in wood based on historic models. (technically 20th century, but they're contemporary when compared to the time period of the original designs).

Re: "Shaking up shaker"

#11

Re: All that bad?

CJ in MPLS

I hear you. Clearly, furniture must function well to really hit the mark.

But I'm a fan of this type of design for a couple of reasons. First, it is a handsome chair. As an objet d' art, I find it to be very pleasing. Second, I like the fact that it pushes the boundaries of design (aesthetic and functional). While this or any other nice piece may not work for my needs, it may work for some. Even if it doesn't work, some of the design elements may well be used at some point in the future.

Third, while this may not work from a functional point of view, all of you have probably thought, at least in passing, about how one might actually pull this off. One of you may even figure out how to do it, at which point we may all benefit.

Re: "Shaking up shaker"

#12

Re: All that bad?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

There's a fourth point, at least for me, and that is stuff like this gives me ideas that I can incorporate into other things I work on. I'm not a fan of federal (maybe because I sat in a federal office with federal furniture for ten years) or any of the queens or louis something or past styles like those.