New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

A problem needing a solution

Posts

A problem needing a solution

#1

A problem needing a solution

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


I finally found a spare(if and when needed) "cruiser" sized handle for my favorite ax. But, it is so fat that it would destroy the balance of the ax. It is too wide by 1/4" and too thick by 1/8".

The problem is how to spoke shave it to match the handle in the ax while preserving the shape and symmetry about the handle axis.

It would seem that if I could mark the depth of the wood to be removed, 1/16 from each face and 1/8 from each side I could then spoke shave to this depth mark and thereby preserve the symmetry. Or there might be another solution. Or I might hope that I was better spoke shaving symmetrically than I think I am and just go for it.

Any idea on how to proceed?

Re: A problem needing a solution

#2

Re: A problem needing a solution

Larry Barrett

First, with a pencil, draw the centerline on all four sides. Next, pick a dimension to work on, thickness or the width. Your choice - but complete one before starting on the other. Next, draw the profile you want for that dimension. The centerline will help you get it even on both sides of the centerline, and on both sides of the handle. Use your spokeshave to shave down to the profile. Complete one dimension, then the other. When this is done, you will have a handle with four flats that need to be smoothed. This can be done by eye, or draw more profiles to help your eye. When the handle feels smooth to your hand, you are done. Use a handfull of dry shavings to burnish the wood.

It might help to practice on a scrap piece that looks like this handle.

Re: A problem needing a solution

#3

Re: A problem needing a solution

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bill and all,

Larry's approach is certain of working, as it gives you a full length reference centerline at all times.

If it were me, I would mark the end grain of the new handle with 'cross-hairs' to mark the two centerlines, and then lay in the shape of the old handle on the end grain. Then shave the handle down progressively by eye, using the cross hairs to maintain symmetry, until you arrive at the shape oval on the end grain of the new handle.

I think you'll find that your eye is an excellent judge of contour, and your hands are more discriminating yet as to the correct feel. You could even pick a point or two along the old handle to mic as controls, and use these points in conjunction with your eyeballs to maintain control.

Wiley

Re: A problem needing a solution

#4

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: A problem needing a solution

Jack Guzman from Maine

Or: Take your coarsest rasp and rough the whole surface. Shave til all the roughness is gone. Should be pretty close at this point.---Jack

Re: A problem needing a solution

#5

can't mark end grain.

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The end of the handle is at the size it needs to be.

Re: A problem needing a solution

#6

unsure of a step

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"Next, draw the profile you want for that dimension. " Unsure what I am drawing and where.

I get working on say the thickness, getting it right and moving to width. Good tip

Re: A problem needing a solution

#7

Re: unsure of a step

Larry Barrett

You are not taking much off, so it will be a little difficult to mark the profile of the new shape because it will be close to the centerlines. Maybe try this - draw the width profile on a piece of cardboard (and do the same for the thickness on a separate piece of cardboard). Lay the cardboard on the oversized handle and trace the desired profile. At least mark the lowest point and a couple of others. Shave away. Pick it up frequently and look for symmetry, using the cardboard pattern. You will get the best results if you shave downhill, so you may need to shave from each end toward the lowest part of the profile.

I have made many handles this way, starting with a stick of firewood.

Re: A problem needing a solution

#8

Re: A problem needing a solution

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Don't round the handle right away. Instead measure the target width of the handle at various points and spokeshave a flat on both edges of the handle. The width of the flat will help you be more uniform; at a given point the flat should be the same width on both edges. This flat will help you judge how uniformly you are removing material.

When you are happy that width is right, then spokeshave a flat on each side of the handle, again using the width of the flat to judge uniformity. When the thickness corresponds to the thickness of your old handle, your main work is done and you can just round the handle to get rid of the flats.

I think this will give a much more uniform result than rounding right away and trying to be uniform.

Re: A problem needing a solution

#9

Re: I agree with this..

david weaver

..it's essentially how tool handles are made by hand without the curved portions looking like a set of pantyhose filled with sawdust and stood on end.

I'd leave the flats 1/16th shy (in total) of where they would be in the final rounding, you'll take a little more off as you put the curvature on and scrape or sand the final finish.

Re: A problem needing a solution

#10

I understand the strategy suggested

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I think I can successfully do what you suggest. It seems like it will ensure that the handle stays symmetrical, and that is my main concern. I am not concerned about my ability to fair the cross sectional shape. One can "feel" this attribute and get it right. Now we will see what spoke shaving dry hickory is like.

Re: A problem needing a solution

#11

Re: I understand the strategy suggested

david weaver

At the risk of showing you something you don't need to see at all...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g-IKwR5o1kE

Somewhere around 20 minutes is where I started on this, putting the facets on the handle.

You have a 99.99% chance of success with this method if you cut facets in where you want them. Rounding them off is less than trivial and takes only a tiny fraction of the time.

Not a totally appropriate video for this case, it was done in excruciating detail because I want a person who chances upon it to be able to make a good handle on their first or second try, and not some lumpy uneven awful looking thing that ends up getting sanded to death to try to hide poor shaping.

Re: A problem needing a solution

#12

Re: I understand the strategy suggested

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

20 min of video download would exhaust my monthly quote of megabytes. Megabytes are not essentially free out in the country.

Re: A problem needing a solution

#13

Re: I must be in the weeds today..

david weaver

I sent this response back to the email from WC, and got the dummy message that told me I responded in the email instead of on the forum: :b here's what my response was, though.

Better skip it (the video) then. Just do facets until the last second, I guess. The rounding of the facets is then trivial and the shape always comes out nicely. You can sight right up the handle to make sure your facets are good and card scrape any tool marks out faster than you can sand (though if you like a sanded finish for hands, you can do that as a last step).

Card scrapers work really well and have great durability when the surface is narrow - far better than surface longevity when smoothing. they work fabulously for handles.

Re: A problem needing a solution

#14

Re: A problem needing a solution

Gary B

This may be an unconventional approach, but I think it'll work for what you need. You say you need to take 1/4" off in width. Setup a quality drill bit and stop to just under 1/8"; and drill a few depth "gauges" into the surface. When you take them off, you're there.

Re: A problem needing a solution

#15

Re: A problem needing a solution

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I like the idea of a target and that suggestion would provide it.