Re: PMV-11: how good do you find it to be?
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
Given all the hoo-ha about PMV-11 in the other thread (and whether Bill T should reveal it's chemical makeup), I'm wondering, are any of you head over heels for PMV-11? If you own some, what is your subjective opinion of it?
There are areas in which PMV-11 excels. In particular it is excellent for its impact resistance. Combine this with the very nature of PM steel, that is, the fine grain structure that is dialled in, PMV-11 is a superior steel for chisels and plane blades for end grain. I have tested this and the results - clear as day and night - are on my website.
Of course, I have chisels in O1 as well, and they also get sharp and work as well. I probably would not notice that I am sharpening them more often, or grinding out chips more frequently. One gets used to what one has.
I believe that most woodworkers rarely get to test the potential of their handplanes. The question is not so much whether PMV-11 is a better steel, but whether it will be appreciated. For those, like myself, who work with especially hard and abrasive timbers, it does show an advantage. I do not believe that it has twice the longevity of A2 as first suggested, but it is certainly as much as 50% greater and has a finer edge than A2. Compare it instead with O1 steel, which has a similar edge, and the gap widens. Again, this is only as easily apparent on hard, abrasive woods.
The question that you are really asking is whether drivers need the extra horsepower when commuting around the city?
Regards from Perth
Derek