New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

PMV-11: how good do you find it to be?

Posts

PMV-11: how good do you find it to be?

#1

PMV-11:  how good do you find it to be?

Lars Parrington

Given all the hoo-ha about PMV-11 in the other thread (and whether Bill T should reveal it's chemical makeup), I'm wondering, are any of you head over heels for PMV-11? If you own some, what is your subjective opinion of it?

Personally, I've got 4 plane irons of PMV-11. One a LV shoulder plane, and the other 3 retrofits into stanley planes (#4, #7, and #62). I've been using these irons for almost 2 years now and still am not sure whether they really hold an edge any better than the original stanley irons.

I don't have any A2 or O1 irons to compare to. Also I don't have any PMV-11 chisels.

Re: PMV-11: how good do you find it to be?

#2

Excels  for chisel durability.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

see comments below under the steel thread

Re: PMV-11: how good do you find it to be?

#3

Two Cherries

Warren in Lancaster, PA

A dozen days ago I had hopes of learning the composition of Two Cherries chisels. If you follow the Two Cherries link at the bottom of the Woodcentral advertizement, you are told that they are made of "the finest steel", with a "long lasting edge", "unsurpassed for strength and durability".

Sound familiar? I remember thinking thirty five years ago that this act, put on by nearly every company, was getting old. I remember realizing that "finest Solingen, Sheffield, Swedish" or whatever was code word for "we don't want you to know." It is insulting.

This evening I looked up Survival knives and found an article listing the five best. They were all well over $100; I was able to find the steel for every one of these in just five minutes. For the most part these are not even tools used by professionals. For years I have sharpened hunting knives for neighborhood boys; I am able to look up the steel on line for all but the junky third world manufactures.

Re: PMV-11: how good do you find it to be?

#4

Amen

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Two Cherries has a composition consistent with 0-1. I was told by someone that visited the factory that Hirsch and Two Cherries are made on the same line, same steel. I find the Two Cherries to be a very good chisel, better than any of the "inexpensive" chisels I have owned.

I looked at a K-Bar at the Smoky Mountain knife works and asked what it was made of. Without hesitation I was told. Obviously they expect to be asked. My son-in-law's high priced knife has the steel name stamped on the knife blade. They are proud of the steel they use.

Re: PMV-11: how good do you find it to be?

#5

Re: Amen

david weaver

Presume Kabar's are still made of 1095? I have a kabar stockman that rusts on a whim, I'd suspect it's 1095 because they've said that's what they use.

I read on a knife forum that it's "out of date and bettered by" some kind of 0.6 carbon medium steel. I don't know what the test was, maybe chopping concrete blocks. It makes a very lovely knife steel for actual cutting and with the thought of sharpening and keeping sharp.

I'm kind of surprised that two cherries is similar to oil hardening steel. I figured it might be something closer to a chrome moly or chrome vanadium tool steel.

I remember thinking "they don't rust", but I think that's because the hirsch set I had had lacquer on it. They were decent chisels, but nothing stood out about them to me.

Re: PMV-11: how good do you find it to be?

#6

Re: PMV-11:  how good do you find it to be?

Greg DeCosta

That's a disappointing investment to have made not to notice much difference. These days, it's almost courageous to have admitted it.

Re: PMV-11: how good do you find it to be?

#7

Re: PMV-11:  how good do you find it to be?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Given all the hoo-ha about PMV-11 in the other thread (and whether Bill T should reveal it's chemical makeup), I'm wondering, are any of you head over heels for PMV-11? If you own some, what is your subjective opinion of it?

There are areas in which PMV-11 excels. In particular it is excellent for its impact resistance. Combine this with the very nature of PM steel, that is, the fine grain structure that is dialled in, PMV-11 is a superior steel for chisels and plane blades for end grain. I have tested this and the results - clear as day and night - are on my website.

Of course, I have chisels in O1 as well, and they also get sharp and work as well. I probably would not notice that I am sharpening them more often, or grinding out chips more frequently. One gets used to what one has.

I believe that most woodworkers rarely get to test the potential of their handplanes. The question is not so much whether PMV-11 is a better steel, but whether it will be appreciated. For those, like myself, who work with especially hard and abrasive timbers, it does show an advantage. I do not believe that it has twice the longevity of A2 as first suggested, but it is certainly as much as 50% greater and has a finer edge than A2. Compare it instead with O1 steel, which has a similar edge, and the gap widens. Again, this is only as easily apparent on hard, abrasive woods.

The question that you are really asking is whether drivers need the extra horsepower when commuting around the city?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: PMV-11: how good do you find it to be?

#8

Re: PMV-11:  how good do you find it to be?

Greg Dacosta

Almost all of our work is done in tropicals (nature of the beast with boats) - veneers and solids and we haven't noticed a significant difference between A2 and the PM steel. We had hoped to notice a difference but on a workaday basis haven't really.

It's quality steel please don't get me wrong but it's not a daylight to dark kind of thing.

Re: PMV-11: how good do you find it to be?

#9

Re: Two worlds

TomD

On the knives there are significant differences in the steels given that there are stainless and non-stainless categories, and those have a fairly predictable escalation of cost/"quality". But the steel itself has little real world effect on the knifes in use compared to woodworking tools. Beyond the baseline the issue is largely bragging rights. Having a crucible 154 blade marks you as a discerning owner, even if you have to send it back to the factory to have it sharpened. ROTFL

People do discuss steel ad nausium on the knife boards, but one very rarely finds any real users. They invent testing routines that increasingly have a destructive element. The most casual woodworker has more real world time with an edge his first week than all the members of a knife club put together. One well know knife maker actually worked in a slaughterhouse, in part for the money, but also so he could develop real world feedback on his hunting knives. That is the exception. The knife world is largely a fantasy world.

Even if you look as something really worthwhile like the ABS program with all the gifted people who go trough the process to qualify as jouneyman or master smith, the edge criteria is largely fantastical. It combines cutting power, edge holding and the ability of a blade to be bent 90 degree without suffering damage. It is an interesting series of characteristics, and at one time before it was so well understood, a challenge to achieve.

In contrast, the main tools plane blades and chisels are very similar at the edge, and see really heavy uses in woodworking, if someone has a steel that performs better than another that is a valuable thing. The funny thing is that despite all the science, day in and day out, Japanese tools come out on top in pretty much every test I have ever seen. Whether one needs the capabilities of those tools is another mater. But the formulas for the steels are well known, doesn't seem to be helping all that much.