New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

coopered box lid

Posts

coopered box lid

#1

coopered box lid

Bruce Mack

I have made coopered box lids but cannot make end caps for the lid that fit nicely into the concavity. While the convexity has a fair curve, pleasing to the eye and touch, the concavity is faceted. This is esthetically acceptable, but contributes to the difficulty of scribing the inside curve and trying to make an end cap to match. I could use filler or apply the end cap to the edge of the lid, planing to match the curve. Neither prospect feels right. Any suggestions please?

Re: coopered box lid

#2

Re: coopered box lid

Bob Entwisle in NJ

You could build up the end caps out of wedge shaped pieces that match the bevel of the staves.


Bob in NJ

Re: coopered box lid

#3

Re: coopered box lid

Steve Voigt

Scribing should not be a problem--just set the coopered lid on top of your end cap blank and scribe away. From there, I would just cut close with a band or coping saw, and then chop to the lines with a chisel, the same way you would chop DT baselines. You ought to be able to use a chisel that's slightly wider than the maximum width of your staves, which will give a nice clean look.

An alternative route is to fair the inside of your lid. Get a piece of of scraper material and grind it to the desired radius, then scrape away. I guess that route depends on how big your facets are, and what kind of wood you're using.

Re: coopered box lid

#5

Re: coopered box lid

TomD

Is the lid a compound curve? Or cylindrical? If cylindrical then it should scribe well enough. Compound is another mater. One method that is often used is to use the end pieces as forms over which to assemble the staves.

Re: coopered box lid

#6

Re: coopered box lid

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I would make the end pieces slightly larger than the opening, by maybe 1/8 inch or up to half the thickness of the coopered top. The top of the end piece can be round or faceted. Then scribe onto the coopered piece for a small rabbet on the edge for the end piece to fit into. Set marking gauge to thickness of end piece and mark out the rabbet on the inside of the coopered top. Chisel out the rabbet.

I think this is easier than trying to make a regular curve on the inside of the top or trying to scribe onto the the end piece.

Re: coopered box lid

#7

Re: coopered box lid

Bruce Mack

Thank you all. Scribe, saw and file has not worked well for me; scribe and chisel sounds more precise. Warren's suggestion is appealing as the end caps have a mortise in addition to glue to hold them in place.

Re: coopered box lid

#8

Query re 'mortise'

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi all,

I haven't done a coopered top. But in reading this thread, and set to thinking by Warren's suggestion, I am wondering whether one couldn't line up the to-be-coopered top pieces while they are still square--before they are beveled--and cut dados across them to make a housing for the side pieces. The dados would be near the ends, and of a width to receive the side pieces.

Of course in the smoothing of the coopered top after glue up, some of the dado depth would be lost. And the top would have to be thick enough to take, say, a 1/4" deep dado. And the presence of the dados would make gluing the top an even more precision operation, probably requiring the side pieces to be inserted as keys during glue up in order to ensure the dados stay aligned.

So it would create complications. But could save quite a bit of fiddly work at the end. Just a question.

Wiley

Re: coopered box lid

#9

Why the facets?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


"the concavity is faceted" ....Why. it is as easy to smooth he insides as the outsides, especially if you build using the Will Neptune approach that leaves so little smoothing that it can be done with 80 paper on a curved block.

Re: coopered box lid

#10

Re: Why the facets?

Bruce Mack

Bill - I don't mind the facets if they are regular and clean of glue squeeze out. I would have the same problem of fitting the end caps to a smooth i.e. curved concavity. I expect I'll get better with repetition. (That's beautiful work, by the way.)

Re: coopered box lid

#11

What is easier?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I can't imagine solving the problem of fitting facets. It is so much simplers to scribe the curve to the end board and nibble away with a spoke shave to get the fit. I'm not very good with hand tools but I found it easy to do successfully.

Re: coopered box lid

#12

Re: What is easier?

Bruce Mack

I have follow up. The coopered top has 7 boards 1 3/16 " wide. I left the interior with facets and used Warren's suggestion of a recess for the end caps, which are heptagonal. The top was clamped vertically to the end piece and I used a 0.5 mm mechanical pencil to get into the recess and "scribe" it. The pencil lines were then truly scribed with a chisel. Using a disc sander I removed wood just to the scribed line resulting in good congruence. The fit is quite good, way better than past efforts. Thanks to all who replied. (I'm not proud of using the disc sander, but my first effort with chisel and saw left irregular edges. With practice I could do better).