New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Thoughts about Steel - and shaving thickness

Posts

Thoughts about Steel - and shaving thickness

#1

Thoughts about Steel - and shaving thickness

david weaver

I could be accused of starting a pointless discussion, but that's most of what I do these days :b

Usually, I do a pointless rambling and it's hard to find out what point I'm trying to make, but I'll make it first. I think if the steel used in a plane is a significant concern, then the size of the shaving is probably too thin. In general for everything. I'll concede that in single iron planes or shooting, sometimes subpar steel can be a bit more of an inconvenience because single iron planes are more sensitive to dullness than double irons, but probably the statement is still the case. Shooting can partially be worked around by leaving it only for small items that you can't plane.

In the grand curiosity below about PM V11, but also more about what we want to know or not know, 5 years ago I would've been really into the technical data (I am still sort of a beginner...well, compared to rank beginners I'm not, but compared to people who do this stuff for a living) and concerned about edge holding. I've tested irons before (which turned out to be a waste of time, but it satisfied curiosity and gave me some input on what an iron feels like through various stages, from just starting to lose clearance all the way to leaving literally a fuzzy surface).

I remember being dissatisfied with the edge holding on stanley irons and all of the various modern versions of the same (softer chrome vanadium steel). And at times thought "ghee, I wish A2 would stay sharp longer".

But I don't notice longevity issues at this point with any non-defective iron, for two reasons:

1) the double iron make sit so that you don't get in trouble with an iron that is losing or has lost clearance

2) more importantly, I'd assume that the average shaving thickness 5 years ago vs now is probably x2 or x3

The former is important because you can stay out of trouble if you set the plane to a too-thick shaving by accident, the plane will just stand you still if you get too aggressive, but not ruin whatever the workpiece is. The latter because a thicker cut continues further into removal of clearance angle and just by definition, you're removing 2 or 3 times as much wood per push of the plane.

This all occurs to me because no matter what I try now, the planes that I avoided early on are the ones I go back to. Wooden planes with soft-ish (relative to the new premium stuff) and a stanley 4. Including a couple that I thought from behavior on the sharpening stones the irons couldn't ever be fit for work.

I don't often make the same thing twice, but sizing plane billets from rough has been something I've done half a dozen of on the large ones now, and it's given me a chance to form my thoughts because I have an easy relative comparison.

Another errant thought I had early on was that thick shaving means coarse inaccurate work and a chance for a lot of problem. I don't think that any longer, though it is easy to get going with a jack and overshoot a mark if you fall mentally asleep while planing. A good try plane makes removing material in the flat easy enough that you don't have to take great risks with the jack, though, working right next to the line.

I would never have come to this conclusion if using power tools to do a lot of dimensioning still, there's no need for speed comparisons when all you have to do is smooth. But what you learn dimensioning saves time even when you're doing stuff just like flushing joints or planing panels that have mouldings attached to the edges in a perpendicular direction.

If there was a spectrum about whether or not the shaving is heavy enough to be productive, I'd say that it's figuring out what steel you can plane with until you're tired and still have it working acceptably. When I started, I could plane A2 until I couldn't tolerate its dullness and still not be tired. Now I can use water hardening steel and be pretty exhausted before I need to resharpen, despite having "better planing muscles" and being heavier.

I've put this thought through the wringer first thinking that I probably wouldn't be able to work harder woods this way and still have to drop back to a "better" iron (harder like hard maple), but have had no trouble even sizing a few large cocobolo blanks from rough sawn with a *smoother* - with a stanley stock iron. sizing cocobolo blanks for a few infills 5-6 years ago is what had me high on HSS irons in muji planes, and it's not the worst thing in the world to plane, but it's bad enough and it's the endpoint of hardness of things i'm likely to plane.

Just thought I'd bring it up. I don't see a lot of stuff like this discussed on blogs (OK, admittedly, I don't really read them unless someone links to them on a forum). Feel free to curse my name and tell me that I'm totally in the weeds!!

Re: Thoughts about Steel - and shaving thickness

#2

Re: Thoughts about Steel - and shaving thickness

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I am not sure I followed everything, but I do agree that efficient work is much much more important than edge longevity and that learning to dimension from rough with planes pays dividends in all plane usage.

I remember you doing a series of tests with planing an few years ago. When we had the Pmv11 discussion I noticed this on a Veritas site:

We took over 5600 digital microscope photos to measure and evaluate blade performance

We created wood shavings that, if connected end to end, would stretch 1.6 miles (2.6 km)

We chopped through a total of 10 feet (3 metres) of oak

1.6 miles may seem like a lot, but for 21 different alloys, it is only 403 feet per alloy. If they were tested with 4 different woods, that is only 100 feet per test, and if tested for different sharpening angles or different cutting angles, a lot less.

It seems to me you did a lot more testing than this, David. Maybe the Veritas figures are way off.

I reported testing a cast steel chisel cutting black walnut end grain on this forum on 1/8/2013. In all I went through 21 feet of end grain without sharpening and still pared white pine end grain nicely.

Re: Thoughts about Steel - and shaving thickness

#3

Re: Thoughts about Steel - and shaving thickness

david weaver

I tested A2 irons at the time, because I did notice while the shaving was thin, the various A2 irons lasted longer before losing clearance than a hock O1 iron. Those were what I was using at the time.

In testing A2, I was able to:

* use a 2 thousandth shaving and measure it every 50 or so to make sure it was still 2 thou, and advance the iron if needed

* joint 1050 feet of hard maple with at the least

* joint 1650 feet with another - as the endpoint

I was trying at the time to determine if any of the various similarly hardened and tempered A2 irons performed any differently, and I couldn't conclude that they do (despite some of the packages saying that they lasted longer than others), but could conclude that any maker's iron that was more chip resistant was likely to last a lot longer - especially where surface quality is important.

I also learned that I generally resharpened at about a third of that, and that I had previously often thought a plane was getting dull when the sole ran out of paraffin. I waxed the sole religously for that test and learned after that to wax the sole once before resharpening to make sure it's the iron and not the sole. That sounds strange if you use stanley planes a lot, but the super flat premium planes that are out there have much more friction than a plane that's not quite as flat. I don't think that's a positive thing, but most people buying the planes won't use them enough to know that the friction is due to a "perfect" metal sole.

Anyway, back to my original topic - I know some of my ramblings are a bit difficult to follow. Discussing how to use a plane instead of letting someone learn to feel it is a discussion that is as if it runs up a tree trunk. All of the branches are the different things you perceive (the weight of the plane, the shaving resistance, the safety to the mark, the visuals like how the shaving is coming out of the plane, etc) and it's easy to diverge off of the trunk of the discussion and then jump from branch to branch which is confusing. Unfortunately, that's how my brain works rather than in an organized way.

I do think there is a lot of merit in a newbie trying to work their shaving thickness upward from the "wood show" toilet paper creation type stuff, and the cap iron should help them make it risk free. Only a couple of thin passes need to be made at the very end. Something i think beginners also avoid is learning how to start a plane that doesn't weigh 7 pounds, thus the preference for the premium heavy planes that are out there - you can set them on the end of a board with a thin shaving and start them instead of skewing them a little bit and easing them on with a shot of force. The problem with the heavy plane and the thin shaving is that it's counterproductive to getting anything done.

I suspect a lot of the wear tests are done with very thin shavings, and they don't mean as much in the context of working wood from rough because the relative longevity of the various steels seems to me to be closer when the shavings are thicker.

My two surprise irons are Dwight and French, and a P. Freres french carbon steel iron. The french have a reputation for making knives of carbon steel that are a bit soft, and my iron is similar, but it's not saw hardness or anything - it's harder than that. A very tired oilstone abrades both of the above very readily, surprisingly so. Something that doesn't happen at 60 hardness. Both probably wouldn't make very good smoother irons, but they work great in a try plane and jack plane, respectively. Nicer to use than something that is very hard, actually. Not advocating extremely hard for smoothers, either, I think vintage stanley are right on the money, and most of the tapered stuff that comes from england is about that hardness, too - both old and new.

Another random thought, I guess there is some time to generate the skill in placing a brisk stroke with a plane, too - if dimensioning. Most beginners probably can't get the plane where they'd want it to go on a shaving that is both wide and thick.

Anyway, this kind of stuff is what changes working with planes from a bore and slow to a productive physically satisfying activity. It is the subtlety that is difficult to discuss but easy to know when you let the work at the bench solidify knowledge rather than reading blogs or going to tool shows.

Re: Thoughts about Steel - and shaving thickness

#4

Re: Thoughts about Steel - and shaving thickness

Brian Holcombe

It's interesting that you guys bring up the topic. I used to feel the need to resharpen my plane blades almost daily, and have found that a heavy shaving does make my life easier, my project to move quicker and my planes to stay sharp longer.

Typically I'm dimensioning by hand, very typically, and until I'm right ontop of the number I really take a heavy cut. I back it off for a few passes at the end to take out any persistent ugliness.

Once I got my chip breakers dialed in and could begin to take a heavy cut with success I found that I wanted more often to take a heavy cut.

I'm not over the moon about A2, I think it is rather lame, but I just increased the bevel angle to 33 degrees or so and the plane cuts for a long while before needing to be resharpened. I havent really noticed a downside to increasing the bevel to this number on a bevel down plane, they cut about the same as when I was shooting for a low angle.

Re: Thoughts about Steel - and shaving thickness

#5

Re: Thoughts about Steel - and shaving thickness

Steve Voigt

David/Warren/Brian/Anyone…

A question. Is the claim here that you can actually take more shavings when the thickness is greater; for example, you can take 100 sub-thou shavings with a given iron, but 150 if the shavings are in the 2-4 thou range? Or is the claim that you can take approximately the same number of shavings?

I have no feel for this; it's been a long time, maybe a couple years, since I sat there taking sub-thou shavings all day. Interesting topic though.

Re: Thoughts about Steel - and shaving thickness

#6

Re: Thoughts about Steel - and shaving thickness

Hank Knight

David,

I think you and I have arrived at the same place.

I am very greatful to Wood Central for teaching me a lot of what I've learned about this craft, but I tend to focus on the "bottom line." If I can apply the tools and techniques discussed here to achieve a gratifying result, I don't really care about the micro analysis of how and why they work. In fact, I find those discussions tedious. I would much rather be making shavings than worrying about whether the iron in my plane is 01, A2 or some miraculous new concoction, or whether my sharpening regimen ended at 8,000 or 18,000. If I can consistently hit my layout line and achieve a pleasing surface, I don't care if my shaving is .001 or .005 and I'm not going to spend time fretting over whether the newest crucible steel will get me to that last .001.

I freely acknowledge that my attitude will be considered intellectual sloth by many here. So be it. I would rather spend what little brain power I have left on subjects that enhance my enjoyment of life rather than trying to figure out how many faries can dance on the head of a pin. This is not to say that those pursuits are not valuable; indeed, they advance our "bottom line" knowledge of this craft. They're just not for me.

Hank

Re: Thoughts about Steel - and shaving thickness

#7

Re: Thoughts about Steel - and shaving thickness

david weaver

I'm not sure anyone would be able to tell that for sure unless they counted strokes.

You can definitely remove a greater volume of wood with thicker shavings (that's not saying much) and you can work with an iron for a little while longer after it's lost the clearance for thin shavings, and get more done for the same amount of effort. Each stroke takes some larger amount of force, but not proportional to its thickness - at least in terms of calories of work done.

I counted strokes on 2 thousandth smoother shavings, and can say I would not like to again do something like that again. Brent beach does a lot of it and measures wear bevels, and that's a good starting point for smoother work.

The rest of the stuff is a lot by feel. It would be interesting if one of the more academic and microscopically inclined folks would measure wear on the edge of an iron for a 1 thousandth shaving vs a 1 hundredth shaving (just using something easy like cherry and a plane heavy enough to make that an easy chore).

I feel at this point like with any decent steel, I can get tired before the plane needs to be sharpened. With wispy shavings and many passes, that wasn't the case.

Re: Thoughts about Steel - and shaving thickness

#8

Re: One other thought...

david weaver

...there is a fascination with steel that does not exist in the older planes. They seem to be fairly plain, and the switch to oil hardening steel that occurred ??? left the hardness of the irons relatively unchanged.

When you look in japan, most of the older stuff that we have access to is of an age that we'd consider new. It's post carborundum stone and their finishing stones that are of good quality (including the natural ones) can work harder steel.

Something that comes to mind to me is that if it's of no consequence to have steel a few clicks soft in the US, the japanese craftsmen certainly didn't share the same view. Alex Gilmore tested a lot of plane irons that were vintage and made for pros and they were in the 62 hardness range. Some new makers probably do achieve their claims (64-66). I guess the difference is that japanese woodworking does involve a lot of finished surfaces, even on large work (like architectural), where the surface is finished by many many small shavings.

I would assume that someone who took the trouble to wade through my first post might be thinking "but the japanese professional craftsmen don't like tools that aren't really hard".

Re: Thoughts about Steel - and shaving thickness

#9

Re: I loved those data things...

david weaver

...for a while, but I think what you're saying is you know what you need to know now.

Can't much argue about knowing what you want from the process and getting it. You own your wants that way, rather than having them be subject to whatever the next "it" article says they should be.

Re: Thoughts about Steel - and shaving thickness

#10

Re: Thoughts about Steel - and shaving thickness

TomD

I have often said around here, as have many others, that there really isn't much of a utility to extreme planes, shaving wise. It is hard to look out at the projects that seem to get done, and see any that really allow a fine shaving finish. When one is partially used you end up sanding the surface down, often.

But I think we have to be clear before we go off on the creation of a new myth, that this tells us more about each other than it does about planes. If I take you correctly, you are saying not that 1000 strokes with a finish plane dulls it less than 1000 strokes with a different set (though there probably is some difference}. But simply that if you take 1000 1thou strokes, rather than 100 10 thou, you end up at the same place with a lot less work, and a plane that is relatively more sharp than an overused finish plane.

There is also the fact that you can sometimes keep a plane working longer when it is dull on coarse work, by simply opening it up a bit. I have often told the story of my Japanese working plane that I took to the boat shop, where it stayed cutting plywood and fiberglass, as well as other stuff. It finally got so dull at the end of 6 months without sharpening that the bit seemed to be sticking out 1/8". It was a lot. I would not do what it did when I first brought it, but it remained useful until nearly the end. These days I would use diamonds or paper to keep it sharp, but I didn't want to bring all my stones over to the shop, so i just let it get duller and duller.

That story sort of supports your point, but the other side of it is that it was a pretty good Japanese blade, for 13.50. The whole jig might have been up after a month had it not been that good.

Where the argument falls apart is that if we were still discussing aspects of The Way of the Carpenter, that would include guys whose stroke/day is only limited by the available light. Why for guys like that would it mater what thickness they were taking, they are going to be at it all day, and it will be just as annoying if they have to resharpen too often whether the task is finish work or roughing. I can remember seeing videos of guys making cellos with those tiny violin planes, the size of your finger. There are millions of cuts, compared to a guttering adze, and edge retention would be more important, as well as carbon fiber tendons. But edge holding is important any time you have a long haul under way, and if your current tasks fit in with your arthritis, and the projects you currently take on, for now, great. But is that realization really news, or just what works for you at this point. All along there have probably been guys who wondered what all the fuss was about because they got within a finish plane stroke with their power tools.

Of course one thing one realizes after 46 years is that you don't really need to care what the Jones are doing, so long as what you are doing works for you.

Re: Thoughts about Steel - and shaving thickness

#11

Re: Thoughts about Steel - and shaving thickness

david weaver

You can (if it's desired) plane and then scrape and burnish most things that you can't plane, and still have a better finish than sanding. I know people on here have said before that nobody's customers are actually interested in that, and that's fine. I'm not a customer.

I didn't really follow most of what you're talking about there, but what I said in the original post that is of any importance is that worrying about it steel suggests that someone isn't working a shaving thick enough with whatever planes they're using. I don't know about the rest of that stuff you said, this many shavings at a thousandth or whatever. The only things I ever counted were shavings at 2 thousandths. I did say that a plane that will seem out of clearance on a thousandth inch shaving will probably still cut fine with a heavier shaving after that.

What I did say is that relative differences between irons of the various steels seem to be less when the shavings are thicker, and the times where you're working on something and thinking that you have to stop and sharpen too much are fewer.

I don't really know what the average person does using power tools, and it's not on my radar. I started off working in the shop of a guy who has a multirouter and a DC 580 planer with a micrometer thickness readout (and while I was bumming time there, he installed a byrd head). I thought it was incredibly boring. Every measurement we worked that was just a general measurement was to the thousandth.

I don't think the issue of taking a thicker shaving instead of taking an easy one is a passing thing, and it's no new discovery, either - i haven't come across any practice that I could possibly thing wasn't in widespread use.

The whole thing came up because of the argument below about finding out the composition of whatever the current "it" steel may be, and it doesn't move the needle.

Re: Thoughts about Steel - and shaving thickness

#12

Re: Thoughts about Steel - and shaving thickness

TomD

"I didn't really follow most of what you're talking about there, but what I said in the original post that is of any importance is that worrying about it steel suggests that someone isn't working a shaving thick enough with whatever planes they're using."

I get that you said that, I don't get why. Or in what context. I tried to narrow it to whether you were saying because you will proceed more rapidly to your goal, or because there is some magic beans about thick and thing shavings.

"What I did say is that relative differences between irons of the various steels seem to be less when the shavings are thicker"

Why?

", and the times where you're working on something and thinking that you have to stop and sharpen too much are fewer. "

Why?

Some of what I said had to do with wear pattern issues that you are claiming, and not describing, though you may have hit this elsewhere.

Part of it has to do with work pattern issues. I don't care what thickness you are cutting, if you are at it all day, you will need at some point to sharpen, and you will sharpen less if you have better tools. This comes down to a mater or exertion. If one is doing a small amount of work, there may be ways of organizing it so one sharpens, less, but it would seem tough to pull that off in full time mode.

Sharpening is less of an ordeal as one gains skill, which is another reason why a lot of this steel stuff is bogus. People worry about difficulty, but if they practice, they will eventually stop worrying.

I get your connection to PV, etc... I am not sure we established that was the target, but maybe we did. I don't think Bill will loose interest in his goal because of some way you have of working, when he works on totally different scale, and with a lot of power tools. His dilemma on wear is in his brain, and he either has some really clever reason for the consideration that actually will be a game changer, or he is in a rut about it. One simple solution is to run the tests and keep mum.

Re: Thoughts about Steel - and shaving thickness

#13

Re: Thoughts about Steel - and shaving thickness

david weaver

Why does the relative difference seem to disappear to some extent? I don't know. I think it's probably because the fast wear that occurs at the very tip of the iron doesn't do too much to affect planing a shaving that's much deeper than that wear/loss of clearance.

I'd rather leave figuring out why that is to someone else.

I agree on the sharpening time for newbies, that's something well established on the forums. Discussions of 7 or 9 minutes or something to sharpen a plane, or 5 minutes for a chisel. That would kill any workflow. I think the shaving thickness is a separate issue. One you can live without if you're only using power tools, I don't know, that's partly a foreign world to me now (but I do have a full set of power tools other than a jointer, I guess, just not nice really big ones any longer).

Here's my thought on less stopping and sharpening:

1) you can work further into lost clearance when the shaving is 7 or 8 thousandths (or 3 on a smoother or whatever) than you can when the shavings are 1 for a smoother and 2 for a jointer.

2) removing shavings two or three times as large puts you through more work and often through whatever you're planing to and on to something else. There isn't a constant sharpening for every bit of work that you're doing

I've never had any shop session longer than an hour where I was using planes or chisels and didn't sharpen something, so in my view, it's not an issue of wanting to go all day without sharpening - that's foreign to me, though I have read that there are japanese carpenters who brought enough tooling to jobsites and used it their tooling carefully enough not to be seen sharpening on paid time. That's a fine goal if you're getting paid, I'll sharpen when I have the urge instead, though. Just like most of us. It's part of the flow.

I only bring up PV because it's the "it" steel now. For a while, it was A2. I've got two PV irons, they are different feeling than carbon steel but they are quality goods. The *good* a2 irons were also very good, I thought. By good, I mean when you get one and it doesn't have chipout issues.

It's kind of a senseless thing because A2 lasted very well, now it's getting a reputation as being an oddball steel that is hard to sharpen and doesn't last that well. If something comes out that holds an edge in a test twice as long as V11, then that will be relegated to the same thing. meanwhile, I've got two irons that roll up a fat wire edge even on the most tired of novaculite stones, and they are a delight to use - to my surprise. In a magazine test of feet planed (the type of test I did with A2), they'd look terrible. In real use at the bench, they're actually a bit nicer to use than A2.

Re: Thoughts about Steel - and shaving thickness

#14

Re: Thoughts about Steel - and shaving thickness

TomD

"Why does the relative difference seem to disappear to some extent? I don't know. I think it's probably because the fast wear that occurs at the very tip of the iron doesn't do too much to affect planing a shaving that's much deeper than that wear/loss of clearance.

I'd rather leave figuring out why that is to someone else."

That's cool, I thought you had a theory, it doesn't really mater. What I was trying to establish was whether this claim was related to the wear characteristics relative to the different sets, or the simple fact that if one sets a plane twice as thick it takes half the passes to get the job done. I am still not clear. Both issues are out there, people who use setting that are really finishing settings to do rough work, are a somewhat common legacy of the metal plane/you can adjust it for any work/ but you won't bother, phenomenon.

"I think the shaving thickness is a separate issue. One you can live without if you're only using power tools, I don't know,"

If you did all your roughing on power tools it would be less tragic to be the inefficient plane user because all you are doing is taking off a few paper thin slices. So then a lot flows from that as to how tough it is to cycle your plane sharpening.

"I've never had any shop session longer than an hour where I was using planes or chisels and didn't sharpen something,"

Right, I would agree with that. Well other than my whole 6 month thing. But given that is the case, I do not understand why you think edge durability is irrelevant. You have mentioned that you are all about making the planes at this point, those are small projects, but if you are doing longer projects, then you will need to resharpen so how is edge durability irrelevant. With Japanese tools there can be a tradeoff with too much, as you say, restoration quality work required to fire them up again, at least in some hands, (I don't really mean a shot at skills there. I don't know why, but space wise I tried to have a fixed sharpening spot but have never been able to keep it for long. In a real shop you need about a space the size of a table saw to get a really efficient sharpening station). But there are alternatives that are almost instant for resharpening.

I only bring up PV because it's the "it" steel now. For a while, it was A2. I've got two PV irons, they are different feeling than carbon steel but they are quality goods. The *good* a2 irons were also very good, I thought. By good, I mean when you get one and it doesn't have chipout issues.

" I've got two irons that roll up a fat wire edge even on the most tired of novaculite stones, and they are a delight to use - to my surprise. In a magazine test of feet planed (the type of test I did with A2), they'd look terrible. In real use at the bench, they're actually a bit nicer to use than A2."

That is where it is at normal sharpening. That is why so many people prefer, Cast, O1, White Steel, and so forth. Of course if you want to power sharpen you can swallow A2 at the speed of light, with the right set-up, and one has to if one runs metal tooling with HSS, that stuff is extremly hard.

To me a lot of the choice comes down to how fast you can cycle the plane. It is something like 10 seconds on a Japanese single blade, but the point is it isn't a lot, and it doesn't hurt your fingers, like a Stanley. So I don't need A2, though the cheap stuff I have in my main plane is very hard wearing anyway, but if I have to take apart a Stanley, I want A2 squared. I don't want to sharpen that for the calendar year.

Re: Thoughts about Steel - and shaving thickness

#15

Re: Thoughts about Steel - and shaving thickness

david weaver

I don't have a theory about the shaving thickness thing, I just noticed it in terms of how much work I can get done. Certainly some of the "shavings are twice as thick" comes into play. I don't know if an iron that cuts 1000 feet at 5 thousandth thick cuts some number of times at some other thickness.

I have noticed, like anyone would, that if you use a try plane to take nice thick double iron type shavings (the ones that shoot straight out of the plane without offering much extra resistance to the user), you'll find yourself often working with an iron that won't stay in the cut if you halve the shaving thickness.

That part I have a grasp on, that and the more work gets done.

But the whole point was that if it matters at all if you have an "it" steel, it's probably not the steel.

I have less trouble with the stanley plane (in terms of time) than you suggest, but that's probably because I disassemble and set one all the time. I think the plane assembly totals probably something like 30 seconds longer than a single iron plane for me, and 15 of that is setting the cap iron. But I never tighten the blade, breaker combination on a stanley plane tighter than what I can do with the lever cap - it's much nicer to take apart and put the plane together without having to locate a screwdriver or use fingers to tighten the nut.

I want to build a dai this summer with a really low wear or a really steep one to see if I can cut back the time it takes me to set a cap iron on a japanese plane, because it's not 15 seconds, and the unit can lose its set when you change the depth of cut.

One other side comment, I've noticed the hitachi paper steels to work well, but they don't hold up any better than a decent A2, and with a grinder, the a2 is faster to hone. But I don't use a lot of either of those any longer. I believe the kzeroukai winners in terms of distanced planed have been "it steel" alloys more recently, and I figured that with the blue steel rikizai tsunesaburo irons, they were slightly less long wearing than the A2 irons and similar to sharpen (obviously easier to grind by hand).

The refining process that might occur that really benefits the better chisels, I've just not seen that amount to much with planes. The rikizai irons seem to last just as well as the much more expensive refined irons.

But still, with all of it, if any of it matters at all, it's a user problem, and not a steel problem.

I'd imagine that if any of the manufacturers over here wanted to work up a relationship with hitachi or who ever makes pre-made laminated steel, we could see LV or someone coming out with blue steel irons. I don't think the market is educated enough to understand why they're good, though.