New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Steve Latta auxillary bench questions

Posts

Steve Latta auxillary bench questions

#1

Steve Latta auxillary bench questions

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Steve uses a "riser" bench for his line and berry work. My back is telling me what a good idea this would be. I'm not fond of spending time on "shop furniture" so I only want to make one, and make it right the first time. I only have a poor picture of Steve's bench. Does anyone have suggestions for making this bench?

I am thinking it should be as long as a drawer. Width? Maybe as wide as a drawer? About sternum height from the floor? Other than dog holes and a cheap vise anything else on it? I don't seen any need for more than a 6/4 top, or less? Overhang amounts?

Re: Steve Latta auxillary bench questions

#2

Re: Steve Latta auxillary bench questions

Ron in Sterling, CT

Bill,

Steve's Riser bench was in one of the woodworking magazines (Pop Working, or Fine Woodworking ??) I don't remember which one, but all the details were shown, including measurements.

Ron

Re: Steve Latta auxillary bench questions

#3

Re: Steve Latta auxillary bench questions

JDK

PM Sent

Re: Steve Latta auxillary bench questions

#4

Re: Steve Latta auxillary bench questions

Ron in Sterling, CT

Bill,

If you don't already have it, the article was in Fine WoodwWorking Tool & Shops Winter 2015 issue.

Ron

Re: Steve Latta auxillary bench questions

#5

Link to Steve and another example.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

There is a PDF of the FWW article and plans available free if you are an on-line member: http://www.finewoodworking.com/woodworking-plans/article/mini-workbench-works-wonders.aspx

(You could always take out a temporary membership, which FWW offer, if necessary).

I have spent the past 2 months struggling with a painful, stiff neck. This is made worse when bending over a low bench (it's not from woodworking but has curtained much of my activity for the past two months. Fortunately now seeming to be working its way out). This has brought home the benefits of working high up, so this area is on my mind as well. What I plan to do is add a (removable) base to the mini-bench I built for wood shows. It's a great design and offers an alternative to Steve's ...


Details: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ShopMadeTools/BenchInAWeekend.html

Keep in mind that there are a lot of bench-on-bench designs, and other might help by posting theirs here as well.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Steve Latta auxillary bench questions

#6

Re: auxillary bench - Hay Shop Carver's Platform *LINK*

Bob Entwisle in NJ

Bill,

Click on the images in the Hay Shop link for a good view of the construction details.

Perhaps Sir William will see this and give some details on his "Loxiliary Bench"

http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/archives.pl?pro=search;pmd=sread;srchid=234396STfnoFML3cqRIJ1425127797;spage=1;sanc=459456;sbid=1001;md=read;id=459456#m_459456

Bob in NJ


Hay Shop Carver's Platform

Re: Steve Latta auxillary bench questions

#7

OMG!

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Recall, I don't like making shop furniture. I would have more time in that bench than in the Spice boxes. But with all the wood removed for holes it would be light weight. :) I will be using the dovetail leg attachment but the dovetails will unlikely be flauntable.

I don't understand the need for I'beam construction of this bench and the bench Latta wrote up. I intend to use a simple M&T or dovetail stretcher. I am considering an apron between the front legs. I can saw it out if it proves not useful to clamp to.

Re: Steve Latta auxillary bench questions

#8

Hay bench

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Adding a ramp I could drive my truck upon it for oil changes. But, I need to hold a spice box door or a drawer front, not my truck. Why ever did they make it so robust? But the simplicity of design is usefully inspiring.

Re: Steve Latta auxillary bench questions

#9

Re: OMG!

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

Even with the swiss cheese treatment, it's not light weight, but you don't need to make yours from 8/4 (1-7/8" finished thickness) rock maple, and you don't need a vise as big as the one I used (the price was right). lso, you can lose a little more weight by not making yours ambidextrous. The back legs on mine are as beefy as the front legs, just in case a right hander might some day inherit it. It needs to be as long s your tallest table leg, between the dog in the vise and the last dog. I would make the back end overhang about as long as the highest drawer you plan to use it to fit. (You can of course clamp it down with the back end extended beyond the end of your bench when you want to hang a drawer over it. For fitting very small drawers, just clamp a narrower board on the end.

I think mine is about 44" long. The heavy vise gives it another problem. If it's not clamped down and the vise is opened, it is overbalanced and falls on its chin.

I'm out of town, and can't post any more photos of details until I get home and back on my iMac on Monday.

Re: Steve Latta auxillary bench questions

#10

question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"I would make the back end overhang about as long as the highest drawer you plan to use it to fit." Don't understand what appears to be a critical point.

I had a "2 x 6" (nominal) oak rafter left from a barn raising. It was bowed to an amazing extent. In the end the materials will be about 1 1/2" thick.

The lumber works out to make a bench 11" wide. Is there a disadvantage to making it this wide?

Re: Steve Latta auxillary bench questions

#11

Re: question

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

OK, I'll try again. The way I explained that "critical point" didn't make a lot of sense. If you're using the bench to fit drawers into a case, move the bench to the right end of the "sub-bench" so it's end is hanging off. Then, assuming you fit drawers by planing their surfaces instead of planing the runners with a shoulder plane, you hang the drawer box (bottomless, at this point) over the end of the bench. You get good support if the bench end is longer than the height of the drawer. For very small drawers, however, the bench will be too wide to fit the drawer over the end of it, so you will need to clamp a narrower board to the top of the bench, extending beyond the end of the bench. For larger drawers, you don't get enough support on the other end, so it might be a good idea to build an I-beam the same height as the bench (like Derek shows) to clamp to the back of the sub-bench to support the other end of the drawer board.

A disadvantage of a wider bench is that it makes it heavier. An inch and a half thick is sufficient for using the Grammercy holdfasts that I use. An advantage to the wider bench you propose is that you can fit larger drawers (i.e., plane longer drawer sides) without resorting to the auxiliary support. Disadvantages include the need to use the narrow supporting board to support any drawer that is not 11" or more deep. For exmple, you might be be able to work full depth spice box drawers directly on top of the bench, but drawers with hidden compartments behind them might be too short to fit over the end.

It is a good idea to plane the top of the bench flat. That's more work for a wider bench. An advantage (tongue-in-cheek) is that you have more real estate for more dog holes. Dog holes can be useful for more than dogs and holdfasts: I drop marking gauges, marking knives, chisels, gouges, etc., and a work light into them.

Steve Latta and I both built our benches about 9" wide, but that's because that's the size of the board we had laying around to build it from. If you are using it only for stringing tble legs, you could make it lot narrower, but eventually, you would need to put tools and materials underneath on the sub-bench, which is a bit less convenient than putting them on top.

Re: Steve Latta auxillary bench questions

#12

Re: Steve Latta auxillary bench questions

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

I have a measured drawing of Steve Latta's auxiliary bench, but I'm out of town, and will need to get home (Monday or Tuesday) to process and upload the drawing. That said, Steve has always said that the exact size does not matter. He built his, and I built mine, from whatever was laying around. IIRC, Steve's top is bubinga, but he throws one together when he gets there whenever he is teaching away from his shop. I suspect FWW's editors insisted on dimensions, because some of their audience has no imagination. I think that the Tools and Shops issue in which you will find the latest incarnation of his bench is 2014, not Winter 2015, but I can't verify that either until I get home.

I think mine is about 44" long and about 9" wide. The height is what is important, but you have to figure that out yourself from the height of your "sub-bench" and your height, and to a certain extent on what you are going to use it for. I think optimum puts your palms flat on the top with your elbows hanging at your side and your arms level. You might start with it a couple of inches higher if you build it with the capability to saw a little off the bottoms of the legs. It's most important chracteristic is that you can use your tools on your work without bending over and hurting your back.

Re: Steve Latta auxillary bench questions

#13

Helpful

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"Dog holes can be useful for more than dogs and holdfasts: I drop marking gauges, marking knives, chisels, gouges, etc., and a work light into them. "

A consideration that had not crossed my mind. Sticking a light up there would be dandy and other tools as well. I think I'll make it 10".

I am not a fan of holdfasts. I only recently bought a pair. In the mean time I have become so accustomed to employing my vast collection of F-style clamps that I rarely use the hold fasts. Not never, just seldom, a last resort rather than first line clamping.

I have a collection of pieces of plywood of various widths that I clamp to the main bench for drawer planing.

Re: Steve Latta auxillary bench questions

#14

Re: auxillary bench - Hay Shop Carver's Platform

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

You don't need the rigidity of an I-beam; a T-beam or even an L-beam wold work fine. Mine is ambidextrous, and I use both holdfasts and a Moxon-style vise on the front, so I need a wide, thick front post. The top of Steve's original bench was attached to the legs with figure eight table top clips, so he needed more lengthwise support to keep it from racking. His FWW version uses a couple of small dowels in each beam, so it is not much stronger. I used a dovetail and beam with a web because I knew I would be putting sideways force on the leg to top joints and neither the eigs notr the dowels would be strong enough. For comparison, consider the leg to top joints used by Roubo to counter the forces of his leg vise.

If you are planning to take the bench away from your shop, e.g., for demos, you are likely to need to clamp it through the front of the legs with F-clamps. I cut the holes in mine large enough to accomodate Bessey K-body clamps. When I use it in my shop, however, I secure it with a pair of holdfasts, inserted into a row of dogholes in the top of my sub-bench. These clamp directly to the center of the web, so I have an unobstructed front face. I position the front of the bench flush with the front face of my sub-bench for holding stock vertically. As I will explain later,(with some photos), this vertical surface serves as the back jaw of my Moxon vise.

For an end vise, the largest I would recomend is the 7" Eclipse quick-release, carried by Woodcraft, Highland Woodworking and others. If you are only doing inlay stringing, a much smaller, less robust vise will suffice. I only used the heavy Columbian because the price was right, and I already had it when I started to build my bench.

Re: Steve Latta auxillary bench questions

#15

Re: Helpful

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

Your selection of pieces of plywood are certainly a viable approach to the task of fitting drawers. Using the top of the auxiliary bench doesn't work so well if you have to remove lots of thick shavings. A platform clamped to the top of the sub-bench works better, but for wispy shavings for final fitting, the auxiliary bench can be more convenient, especially if you have a Moxon front vise jaw attached and it extends to the end of the bench. The higher the auxiliary bench, the more difficult planing on top of it becomes. When I get home, I think I will be able to find a picture of that setup, but on someone else's bench.

I've come to appreciate holdfasts, especially the Grammercy, the more I use them. A disadvantage is that I need to keep a deadblow hammer at hand, and to be convenient it can take up bench space I'd rather be using for other tools. Also, the pads tend to come off easier than the pads on more modern clamps. I have four holdfsts, but two of them are used to hold the auxiliary bench to the sub-bench.

Re: Steve Latta auxillary bench questions

#16

Re: Leg Construction Details

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

I used the dovetail for structural reasons alone. It is half blind so it will be easier to reflatten the top. The flat swn hard maple top does have a tendency to move with the seasons. Note that there is only one dovetail socket per joint. If there were two tails and a pin, since the pin would be cut in long grain instead of end grain, it would be very easy to split it out.

The web of the I-beam is 3/4" flat sawn hard maple, dadoed, with glue, into the legs. The grain runs vertically, so it will expand and contract with the seasons at the same rate as the top. The legs are white oak, about 1-1/4" thick, which is sufficient for the Grammercy holdfasts to grip. However, oak or other ring porous hardwoods are not ideal for this purpose. When a holdfast is positioned vertically, especially with close spaced dog holes, The pressure from the holdfast can split out a wedge of the leg between two dog holes. So far, I've only had it happen on the back where it doesn't show. Since I added a removable Moxon vise to the front, I use the holdfasts a lot less in the legs. Explanation and installation of the Moxon vise will be provided later. For the time being, I will note that one bolt is mounted in each front leg. Consider the maximum width board you will dovetail in this vise, and that it must fit against the front of the bench between the bolts. Blanket and tool chests are often 24" tall.

Re: Steve Latta auxillary bench questions

#17

I missed the warning.......

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Practical as I am I can't wrap my head around a bench to do 1720 Line and Berry on a Baltic birch I'beam construction bench, as described in the FWW article. I will dovetail some legs into the sides of the top 1 1/2" plank and either dovetail or M&T a stretcher between the legs. I won't be striving for flauntable dovetail joinery so for me this may be the fastest way to get a sturdy leg attached.

Well that was the anticipation. Someone forgot to point out that dovetailing 1-1/2" oak would be a bit different than the dovetails I have been making in the 1/4" spice box drawers. The tails went quickly once I abandoned the dainty LN dovetail saw. Chopping the sockets didn't. I expect there is some experience for thick oak I am lacking. I now have a greater appreciation for large bench builders.

Re: Steve Latta auxillary bench questions

#18

Re: I missed the warning.......

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

It was almost six years ago, but IIRC, I roughed out the tails on the tablesaw, and just had the bottom of the V to clean up with a wide chisel. I marked the sockets from the tails, roughed out the socket with a couple of different diameter Forstner bits, and then chopped. I don't see any overcuts on the diagonals on the sockets in any of my photos, so I'm pretty sure I didn't saw them before chopping. My rock maple top probably wasn't much easier than your oak top.

Cutting the holes for the clamps in the web is easy on the bandsaw. I cut the holes in the legs for the clamps and the hole in one web for the vise screw and bars each with four holes at the corners with a drill bit and then a jigsaw.a jigsaw would have been quicker, and good enough, so I don't know why I used the scroll saw.

After I fit the tails and sockets, I cut dados in the legs, measured and cut the web to width and length, gued up one dovetail, glued the web into one dado, and finally glued the other dovetail and dado at the sme time.

Re: Steve Latta auxillary bench questions

#19

Re: Variable benches

TomD

Ultimately this just seems to be an admission that we need to more seriously consider variable height benches: because there is no perfect height; it takes several goes to find the correct wrong height; we may be wearing ourselves out in the process; or life got to us first.

Re: Steve Latta auxillary bench questions

#20

Re: Variable benches

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

I have one of those, too, the Geoff Noden Adjust-a-Bench, and also use another one built by the woodworking club I belong to, the CJWA. It is a great design, robust and convenient. However, after hauling the club's bench around in the back of my xB for a month and a half, I can assure you that the additional portability of my "Loxiliary Bench" has some distinct advantages. While it takes four people to load and unload the Adjust-a-Bench, I can load and unload, move, install and break down my Loxiliary Bench and the Work-Mutt I mount it on when I'm away from the shop all by myself. Installing the transport wheels on mine is also a lot faster and more convenient than retracting Geoff's bench's very sturdy casters.