Re: question
William Duffield, on the Cohansey
OK, I'll try again. The way I explained that "critical point" didn't make a lot of sense. If you're using the bench to fit drawers into a case, move the bench to the right end of the "sub-bench" so it's end is hanging off. Then, assuming you fit drawers by planing their surfaces instead of planing the runners with a shoulder plane, you hang the drawer box (bottomless, at this point) over the end of the bench. You get good support if the bench end is longer than the height of the drawer. For very small drawers, however, the bench will be too wide to fit the drawer over the end of it, so you will need to clamp a narrower board to the top of the bench, extending beyond the end of the bench. For larger drawers, you don't get enough support on the other end, so it might be a good idea to build an I-beam the same height as the bench (like Derek shows) to clamp to the back of the sub-bench to support the other end of the drawer board.
A disadvantage of a wider bench is that it makes it heavier. An inch and a half thick is sufficient for using the Grammercy holdfasts that I use. An advantage to the wider bench you propose is that you can fit larger drawers (i.e., plane longer drawer sides) without resorting to the auxiliary support. Disadvantages include the need to use the narrow supporting board to support any drawer that is not 11" or more deep. For exmple, you might be be able to work full depth spice box drawers directly on top of the bench, but drawers with hidden compartments behind them might be too short to fit over the end.
It is a good idea to plane the top of the bench flat. That's more work for a wider bench. An advantage (tongue-in-cheek) is that you have more real estate for more dog holes. Dog holes can be useful for more than dogs and holdfasts: I drop marking gauges, marking knives, chisels, gouges, etc., and a work light into them.
Steve Latta and I both built our benches about 9" wide, but that's because that's the size of the board we had laying around to build it from. If you are using it only for stringing tble legs, you could make it lot narrower, but eventually, you would need to put tools and materials underneath on the sub-bench, which is a bit less convenient than putting them on top.