New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Are we at the peak?

Posts

Are we at the peak?

#1

Are we at the peak?

david weaver

Extracted from Tom's comment below that he's heard a few folks say things are on the decline (or will be soon?).

For each of us (who come to this with a pocket full of money and a desire for a hobby that sticks for a while and leaves something in its wake other than just spent money), there's a flurry of buying that happens early, we tune in to what can be bought or learned, and then we find something we like to do and tune out a little.

It seemed to me that when I got into this hobby about 10 years ago, everything hand tools was on the upswing. LN was getting bigger and having trouble keeping up with orders, LV was introducing stuff in the core of woodworking tools at a high rate of speed.

Larry has stopped taking orders for bench planes (and bill williams, who i understand was making a lot of the bench planes moved on), and there are a couple of other people making them now (but I don't know about the volume), but I don't see the kind of fanatical buy buy buy attitude that was prevalent a couple of years ago.

Is it decline, or is it personal (certainly, my purchasing of the core stuff has declined and tended toward the bizarre).

My only regret about my timing of this hobby is that the day of the local lumber supplier is over. That's probably something that never existed in a lot of places, but where I grew up (gettysburg), there were folks cutting and selling hardwoods. it was common back then if you wanted a shed, you went to the hardwood dealer and got materials to make a shed. My dad built a shed in 1980, we moved away from that house, but it is still standing and clear and in use in the back yard of that house. Probably the cost was similar to what it would cost to buy an OSB shed without a quality floor.

That leaves a void here in regularly available good hardwoods. Coupled with my favorite supplier retiring, it makes it seem like the stock that's left is either a little harder to get to (there are a couple of other affordable one-man operations around here), or lower quality (the stuff that comes through the local lumber supplier at market price is pretty uninspiring).

But the hobby itself, any thoughts?

Re: Are we at the peak?

#2

Maybe... maybe not

John in NM

I think a lot of the frenzy you remember (as do I) was driven by the booming economy, the quality of published materials, and the novelty of readily available high quality hand tools, in that order of importance.

The economy is no longer booming, but will likely boom again.

Publications are widely believed to have slipped in quality, but it depends who you ask. I think the internet has largely replaced them, good in terms of easy access to what you want to know, bad in terms of organization.

Most hand tool manufacturers are still around and doing ok, to all appearances. That may change depending on the economy, but one thing that really helps is the ease of reaching customers cheaply via the internet. That may change as well.

On the whole, I think these things are cyclical more than peak and over for good. The next peak will not be as great as the 1990's one, but there will be another.

Re: Are we at the peak?

#3

Re: Are we at the peak?

Curt Putnam

Sir David - interesting thoughts.

My take on the subject is that around 2003 or so, when hand tools started to really take off (driven in part by Christopher Schwarz), most folks were starting to explore the world(s) of vintage, Japanese, and new (LN & LV). I suspect that most of them were boomers who had some money in their pockets until the crash of '07 - '08. I know that, in my own case, I've been lucky enough to acquire most of the tools I want and that level is greater than the needs.

Most of the secrets have been resurrected, written to death and have videos on YouTube. For the boomers it's now mostly a matter of doing - rather than acquisition of tools and/or knowledge. For the younger folks, things are rougher or better as the case may be.

Here in SoCal, my perception is that lumber supply is driven by the cabinet industry. For example, at my formerly favorite suppler, 4/4 stock is now delivered planed to 25/32". No wiggle room for anything. Good lumber is insanely expensive when one can locate it.

Most of the folks I run into around here are strictly power, some very few are blended and I don't know of anyone who is strictly hand.

As to the future we can only guess but it is helpful to look at the demographics. As more and more people migrate to the huge cities, woodworking will decline unless it is small scale hand tool work. The Ikea approach to disposable furniture will continue and the idea of things built to last will steadily decline. Already folks go through kitchen cabinetry every 10 years or so. From my perspective the future is rather glum

Re: Are we at the peak?

#4

Jack Guzman from Maine

Not decline,evolve

Jack Guzman from Maine

I don't believe anything is actually ending here. I believe that due to the expansion of information things are changing. I think the "hobby" is just evolving. Larry Williams may be selling fewer planes these days but there are many more makers also.There are many more vendors of all the hand tools we use than there were ten years ago.

Since I started doing demos and getting out in public with my woodworking I'v met more people than I expected that are aware of or involved in woodworking.---Jack

Re: Are we at the peak?

#5

Re: Are we at the peak?

david weaver

Most folks are power here, too. There is one guy giving classes on hand tools, and having people in giving class type stuff, but going to classes isn't my bag (I'll spend the money on materials instead - I'd rather ponder things myself, anyway).

the woodworking club in pittsburgh, though, had a wood delivery at one point and even though I'm not in the club, I can go there and pick up my wood from the local mill guys who bring wood there. I don't have a truck, so I often have to plan and then break down my lumber into rough sizes that I can use, and I do it with...

.. drum roll...

a hand saw. You'd think I had 9 eyes when I pulled a hand saw out.

I'm sure there are guys in that group who do dovetail work by hand, but there was nobody there who did work entirely by hand (and to some extent, I don't always, either, but I like to do it entirely by hand).

I'm in the middle of the some of the best hardwood areas here, but until you get out of town and go to places where guys mill wood, the local stores are more interested in selling plywood and millwork/trim. Their hardwoods are either overpriced or underwhelming. A bizarre thing given how close we are to prime hardwood areas.

I guess there just aren't many customers any longer who are making significant quality demands for wood because their customers aren't willing to pay.

Re: Are we at the peak?

#6

Note on Old Street

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi all,

Just so there's no confusion....Larry Williams and Don McConnell stopped taking new retail orders simply because their backlog was so deep, they didn't feel like they could ever catch up in their working lifetimes.

Wiley

Re: Are we at the peak?

#7

Re: Yes

david weaver

I recall their announcement, it was probably what, a year ago now? maybe the link says.

I don't think they're part of any decline, or if there was such a thing, they wouldn't know it because their backlog keeps them insulated from it.

I don't know who is making bench planes now, but one thing that makes me a little nutty is as steve is getting started up here, nobody ever offered double iron bench planes.

I don't know what the market is for double iron planes, but I think the average person out there won't learn to use the double iron, and the plane will therefore just seem like a harder to use plane than a single iron of the C&W style.

I don't know what LN and LV are doing in terms of a decline, I tend to think the decline is more a distaste for a lot of people who have been around a decade or so to keep reading material that's targeted at the next round of people who are in their first two years of woodworking.

that worked well a decade ago, because that's when the wave started.

But I don't know that I see any less traffic on woodworking sites in general, and would assume the hobby is plenty strong.

Re: Are we at the peak?

#8

Re: Are we at the peak?

JDK

I've of the opinion we're in the midst of a great renaissance in woodworking, especially hand-tool woodworking, and we will remain so for the indefinite future. The satisfaction and peace-of-mind derived from the creative experience is so profound and edifying in comparison to the soul-destroying numbness of popular culture and the consumer society that our craft has no where to go but up.

Re: Are we at the peak?

#9

Jack Guzman from Maine

Clarification re:Larry Williams

Jack Guzman from Maine

That was a rhetorical statement. I have no idea of the condition of Larry's business.---Jack

Re: Are we at the peak?

#10

Re: Are we at the peak?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

It is interesting how easily people forget the word "progress". I suspect part of this is due to many handtoolers using vintage tools or reproductions, and being steeped in traditional joinery, which goes back centuries. In other words, the focus is on the past, not the future.

While there is much sense in learning from and emulating the methods and techniques of the past, one must not assume that there is, therefore, no room for progress. I am not referring to tools that are mutton dressed up as lamb, but awareness of areas that were limited by available materials and science in the past.

I look at the handplanes of Lee Valley and Konrad Sauer as examples as those striving to improve designs. There are a multitude of boutique manufacturers who have the means to cater for small groups with unique designs - largely because they do not have the overheads and they are able to work to changing work fashions. On a personal note I have an interest in ergonomics and tool design - it may be argued that tool designs evolved over centuries along the lines of 'what was successful was retained'. In my experience, there are many woodworkers who just use what they have because they do not know any better. The fact that it works does not argue that it is good.

There has been continuing progress in the power tool industry. New tools come on the market that speed up and simplify joinery. I do not own a Domino machine, and probably never will (it's not my thing), but it is really an amazing tool. On the other hand I do have a combination jointer-thicknesser/planer with spiral blades, and this has a place to play.

At this stage we are aware that it is the availability of good wood that will limit furniture making. Or will it? This argument only holds as long as we hold a view that looks back to traditional methods of logging. Already there are farms dedicated to the production of furniture grade trees. There is also an increasing awareness of the value of old growth, as well as salvaging used timbers, such as the Jarrah that went into roofs and piers - such a waste ... sigh ... but, wait, it will get a second life, and there is a lot of it (hence my thicknesser-jointer).

Are we at a peak? Will we ever be?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Are we at the peak?

#11

Re: Yes

Kees

Everyone always forgets the German ECE planes! There is a complete line of double iron wooden planes. With the Primus adjustment system but also with a simple wedge. And they are not even expensive, 70 euro buys me a smoother with a hornbeam sole.

Personally I think they are ugly as hell, but tastes differ and they deserve more recognition.

Re: Are we at the peak?

#12

Re: Are we at the peak?

TomD

I would buy a Domino Derek, when they go off patent, but I will be too old presumably. I remeber going through this with biscuit jointers, I didn't nned one, but when they eventually went off patent, I got the early PC. To me Domino is only worth, 1500, or whatever, if I had a production use for it. But a 200 or 400, it becomes a tool that would make certain things that have nothing to do with our hobby woodworking. Probably 90% of that kind of thing could be made with biscuits, but Domino is stronger in many situations. The thing to ask is also how much 1500 buys one in CNC, and the answer isn't much, but it is at least in the right direction, as far as new is concerned.

Re: Are we at the peak?

#13

Re: Yes

TomD

I have a few of those Kees, and they are very effective planes. There was a maker of German planes that got taken out. Their competition. I wish I had got the plane they made that had the adjustable bed angle, just for the curiosity value. But whatever, oops, there goes half the production.

Re: Are we at the peak?

#14

Re: More than that...

TomD

What was being described was a series of structural issues.

- The lump in the snake of boomers is part of it. But it was also generational. This is affecting a lot of sports, and activities.

- There aren't shop classes in many places, kids don't know how to do anything. They are also very close to electronic items that were always there for them, post 85. This both determines some of their interests; their assumption about how easy certain things are to learn (sampling vs playing musical instruments; our duty not to fight the wars, but to continue consuming through them, etc...);

- My dad is selling his grand piano so I thought I should check out the market for it in the big smoke, vs the place he lives. I was told that nobody wants pianos any more (his is very good, and not too big for a grand);

- I am in archery, and the magazine I get, just keeps getting older. It was like there should be a casket column in the last one I got. Actually archery is the only part of hunting which is growing, and the tech part is growing. If you hold to the old ways it is an unmitigated disaster, like the AR-15 taking over sport rifle hunting. But there is growth for reasons that aren't really relevant.

- There is secular trend towards smaller properties with no space for a stuff like shops.

- Notice that some of supplier now start their explanations of why certain choices are made with words to the effect that "well, it is a small market, and none of this stuff pays for itself...".

- We have lost several magazines, the catalyst was certainly the crash, don't know if there is more to it than that.

- The woodworking books section at all my local big box book stores, are no longer.

- Speaking of the crash, some of that was the general loss of common sense in housing, will that affect the desire to sink everything into our "investment" in the future. Probably won't affect anything, nobody seems to learn much. But furniture is connected to housing, and how grandiose that needs to be.

But as I said earlier, it was mainy just talking to a guy in the biz who told me that their projections are for decline and they need to find a second act.

All that said, there are other trends that may expand the pie, like run-away migration, so will there be fewer woodworkers in the future, probably not for a long time, but the rate of growth is also important, and if that flattens out... I didn't get into that with the guy I know, because I was thinking the worst because of the new second act talk.

Re: Are we at the peak?

#15

Hardly

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

One would be living a sheltered life to not see the growth in hobby and studio furniture woodworking.

Note the number of schools providing 1 day to 2 year classes. The explosion of Internet information. The expansion of tool stores to even small cities(Klingspor opens Ashville, NC store) . Proliferation of retail lumber sources, boutique tool makers, meetings. Innovation of new tool designs (LV, Festool and others)

Innovation in tools has enabled more people to make good stuff. Someone with less experience can make good joints with a Domino without having to learn to use a mortise chisel. A Keller jig enables first time success with dovetails. The list goes on- vacuum bagging, bent lamination, laser engraving, cnc machining, HVLP spraying, router bits of every imaginable shape including the LV Stanley 55 profiles, wipe on finishes, etc. etc.

Urban growth may not limit expansion of woodworking. "Shop to rent" will expand in Urban locations to meet demand for space and power tools.

As far as wood, we are an infinitesimal market for lumber. You may not like the price but lumber of any kind will always be available in the quantities we use. One furniture line abandoning cherry will supply the hobby and studio furniture market for that species, as an example. Studio furniture makers will adapt to "junk" wood embracing decay, natural edges, knots, splits, etc.

Re: Are we at the peak?

#16

Re: Yes *LINK*

Kees

Ulmia? They still make and sell planes. I have a few antique Ulmia planes, a smoother, a scrub and a rebate. And indeed they are very nice. I like the horn in use too.


http://www.ulmia.de/English/Ulmia-Hobel_2.htm#Putzhobel

Re: Are we at the peak?

#17

Re: Are we at the peak?

Bruce Mack

Look at literature. Read a good book and marvel at the ways it can inform your mind and evoke wonder, elation, and sadness. This is after at least 800 years of English literature.

Woodworking at a personal level is making something to please a single individual other than yourself. The maker speaks with a language of proportion, color, surface, tactile feedback and utility. The recipient shares some of this but also brings personal values and history that change the story. No end in sight.