New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Traditional cap iron construction

Posts

Traditional cap iron construction

#1

Traditional cap iron construction

Steve Voigt

Here's something that can be filed under "totally esoteric stuff that no one cares about."

Last week, I made my first traditional cap iron, and I'm making another today. By "traditional," I mean the type used with tapered irons in wooden planes. The bend is about 5/8" from the bottom, and the end is shaped in a gentle radius, whereas modern cap irons are bent in the middle, and often just have a flat bevel.

Before making one, I measured of bunch of old ones I have, and more or less copied the dimensions. There was one thing that really struck me though, which is the location of the threaded hole.

On a typical old chipbreaker for a 2" iron, the length will be about 4 3/4", and the hole will be about 2.75" from the bottom. From an engineering standpoint, I would think you would place the hole right at the midpoint, which would be 2 3/8." You would get more pressure right at the cutting edge that way. However, none of my old chipbreakers do this.

The only explanation I can think of is that they didn't want to get too close to the bottom of the slot, but on every iron I have, many of which are full length (or very close), the hole could easily be placed 1/4"-3/8" closer to the edge.

I'm not suggesting that they "did it wrong;" in my experience there is always a good reason things are the way they are on these old planes. I just don't know what that reason is.

If anybody is still reading this and hasn't lapsed into a coma, do you have any theories about this? If you do, I'm all ears.

Re: Traditional cap iron construction

#2

Re: Traditional cap iron construction

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Steve, I can think of two reasons why the screw would be back a little farther. The farther back from the edge the easier it is to screw the two irons flat face to face. If it is too far back the tension ought to be less at the tip where the two meet so this might be a sort of trade off. I never had a double iron that had trouble keeping the irons together at the cutting edge.

The other thing is that the slot in the bed to accommodate the screw would have to be longer if the screw were farther down. At some point access to make this slot is a concern.

Re: Traditional cap iron construction

#3

Re: Traditional cap iron construction

david weaver

I'll take a whack at this. Warren beat me to it earlier, but I agree with his comment about it being easier to get the iron and cap iron flush together at the screw (which is important to keeping the set) when it is further from the cutting edge.

I think there are two reasons this is better than moving the screw further forward.

1) the closer to the cutting edge, the more drastic the curve will be where the iron is flexing (less is probably better for fit)

2) the fingers of a well fit wedge are putting a lot of force on the cap iron, so there's no great reason for the screw to be further forward to prevent a misfeed via chip under cap iron.

Re: Traditional cap iron construction

#4

Re: Traditional cap iron construction

Kees

David and Warren allready gave very plausible answers.

I wonder about making a capiron yourself. It doesn't look too difficult, but bending heavy gauge steel isn't very easy either. How do you do this? And do you also make such a nice brass nut?

I have one plane where the capiron is a bit too narrow, so I was thinking about making one too. The first obstacle is finding the right material. Most capirons seem to be 2.5 mm thick and that is an unusual size. I can get 2 or 3mm easilly.

Re: Traditional cap iron construction

#5

Re: Traditional cap iron construction

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I looked at Ron Hock's cap irons at Valley Forge in 2009 with a thought to using them in wooden planes. I tried to tell him what was wrong with them, that among other things they needed more arch. At the time he had no idea how to use a cap iron; he must have thought I was some kind of nut. However he did say that since it was mild steel I could just put it in a vise and bend it.

Interestingly the capirons in the Seaton chest (1796) all have a small piece of steel welded to the bottom edge.

Re: Traditional cap iron construction

#6

Re: The "improved" cap irons

david weaver

I've had more than one discussion with people about the "improved" cap irons that are just slabs with a bit of a rebate at the end.

Nobody believed me that the older designs were functionally superior to the new ones, either.

Re: Traditional cap iron construction

#7

Re: Traditional cap iron construction

Steve Voigt

Warren and Dave

,

Thanks for the ideas. Those all seem like reasonable points.

Kees - I used 1/8" mild steel. Several of my old cap irons, late 19thc. - early 20thc., measure very close to that. So you will be fine with 3 mm.

My bending method for the first couple cap irons was very crude, but it worked. I have a piece of 1/2" steel plate that has a big chamfer on the edge. I found it in the scrap pile at the local machine shop. I clamped the blank so that about 5/8" was overhanging the edge of the steel plate. I used a block of wood under the clamp so that I could apply clamping pressure directly over the edge of the plate. Then, I smacked the edge with a 3 lb. sledge hammer. A few minutes of smacking gradually and evenly, and I had a good bend. If you overbend one side, just lay the piece flat on something and hit it on top.

By holding the cap iron tightly against a piece of 1/4"-thick steel and measuring the total thickness with calipers, I was able to judge the total amount of bend, as well as any variance. I went for .050" of bend and was able to hold total variance within less than .005".

I have no way of doing the fancy brass nut, and it's not important to me at all. I just tapped a 5/16"-18 hole to use with a couple lee valley screws I have. You can also get replacement screws by Hock from Highland Hardware - they use a 1/4"-28 thread.

Anyway, here are a couple pics of the finished product.




Re: Traditional cap iron construction

#8

Re: Traditional cap iron construction

Kees

Thanks Steve for the explanation. It looks good. Now you just need to add chamfers along the top ;)

Re: Traditional cap iron construction

#9

Re: Traditional cap iron construction

david weaver

Looks pretty good. I might be imagining it, but I think my older ones have a lot of thickness taper at the end.

I'm sure the brass nut was a wrought issue, as my butcher irons don't have any such thing on them and they are very handsome and nice to use (plus you don't have to notch the wedge to make room for a nut sticking up).

I'd assume on all of the later english ones, they kept the brass fixture because it looks nice, as those are all steel and wouldn't need the extra thread area of the fixture.

Re: Traditional cap iron construction

#10

Re: Traditional cap iron construction

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Very nice cap iron, Steve. It certainly looks to be serviceable.

David had mentioned a taper to the cap iron, which I remembered also. The cap irons in the Seaton chest were carefully documented by Peter Ross. They average about .1 inches thick from the hump to the screw, then taper to an average .06 at the top. This might have the effect of making a flatter surface once the irons are screwed together. At the curved end the cap iron also tapers so there is very little thickness where it meets the iron. In cross section it is shaped a little like claw, curved and coming to a point. Another interesting thing is that the hole for the screw is punched through making a little flange around to hole away from the cutting iron. Then there is a little more thickness were it is threaded. No nut.

The cutting irons themselves taper from about .13 to about .06. Parallel irons were available in the late 18th century, but they were more expensive, higher labor cost. A cap iron with a parallel iron has about as much taper as an uncut single iron; a tapered cap iron with a tapered cut iron would have more taper than a tapered single iron.

Someone mentioned earlier that the tools in the Seaton chest were not used, that this was suggested in the book . For the first edition (1993) the researchers were only allowed one day to examine and photograph the tools in very poor light. In 1995 Jay Gaynor and Peter Ross spent two months in a well lit lab with magnification to produce the drawings that appear in the 2nd edition (2012). The irons have some mashing of the thin ends, showing use.

Re: Traditional cap iron construction

#11

Re: The real reason...

TomD

Not even certain I am answering the right question... Further back the nut is the more steel in the blade that is usable, if that is what we are talking about. That is something customers look for even if as in the modern world they never put more than a 1/16 inch honest wear on the thing.

A very small point is shorter groove for the nut, which is all to the good.

Re: Traditional cap iron construction

#12

Re: Traditional cap iron construction

Steve Voigt

Warren and Dave, thanks for the encouragement, and for the info about historical cap irons. I think you both saw the most obvious shortcoming, which is that it need to be more "claw-like" as Warren said, a more pronounced taper at the end.

I'd love to do things like the faceted chamfers at the top, or the brass nut, but with only a drill press and 6" grinder, files and hacksaw, I need to keep it simple.

Re: Traditional cap iron construction

#13

Historic methods

Warren in Lancaster, PA

When we look at historic tools it is quite a challenge sorting out the reasons for certain features. Some are esthetic, some are functional, some are economic, some are technology. Some features combine functional and esthetic components. Just looking at the chamfer at the top of the cap iron, did they do this for esthetics or to give more access to the wedge for adjustment, or what?

In the old irons a small piece of steel was welded to wrought iron. This seems to have been an economic decision. Starting with that slip of steel welded on, it is easier and cheaper to make a tapered iron, also seems like an economic decision. However we also find that a tapered single iron works better, that a laminated iron is easier to sharpen full bevel. Today it is cheaper to make solid steel, parallel irons. Are the tapering and the welding worth the now extra expense?

In the 18th century the irons are thin, like 1/8 inch and getting thinner as you use the iron. Was this thickness chosen for economy of materials, or labor? Was it because thin irons are easier to sharpen? Why did irons become so thick in the 19th century at the same time workers were losing their planing skills to machinery?

Re: Traditional cap iron construction

#14

Technology of the day

Bob Hackett

The "inserts" of high carbon steel welded to wrought iron tool bodies were widespread because before the Bessemer process of producing steel became prevalent in industry most tool ,or "cast" steel was being imported from England. You see the welded insert approach in everything from knives to axes, chisels and plane irons. Skip Brack here in Maine has written and published several books on the history of tool making and tool makers in the US.Many of his books are available through the tool museum he has established in Liberty Maine across from Liberty Tools which he also owns.

It`s somewhat ironic that things have turned a 180 and now wrought iron is not being produced here in in the USA any commercial sense. As a result high quality wrought iron costs substantially more now than most tools steels. Most of the true wrought iron being used in this country is sourced from salvaged scrap. The only commercial source I know that still produces fresh rolled wrought iron is in England.

"The more things change, the more they remain the same". :)

Re: Traditional cap iron construction

#15

Re: I wonder...

david weaver

..if the thicker irons coincide with:

* planes that are machine made with little hand fitting

* sharpening stones that are faster

or both?

I don't know when industrially made carborundum or silicon carbide stones became available, but I do know from the shaving side that the carborundum company was making silicon carbide stones VERY early. More than 100 years ago, but i haven't ever seen anything to suggest 200 years go, though.

I don't mind an iron that is a little thicker, as I'm using a grinder, but even using a grinder with a CBN wheel, I think the irons that are extremely thick (some of the makers had irons approaching 1/4 inch thick at the business end) are a bit of a nuisance.

I've noticed that the sheffield later solid steel irons are again less than 3/16ths thick, it's a return to the old thickness, probably because there was no need to go with high thickness. The irons aren't parallel, but their taper is a lot less than the older hand made laminated irons. I think they are O1 steel, too.

Strangely enough, the cap irons have gone to steel, too, but most of the english makers chose to keep the fairly costly to add on brass fixture on the cap iron even though a threaded steel cap iron is plenty strong enough to go without it (and it lessens the labor on the planemaker to not have to cut the wedge to fit that thing - though said planemaker probalby had some fixture that they stuck a wedge in and blasted it over a cove type cutting bit or a shaper cutter).

Re: Traditional cap iron construction

#16

Re: I think....

david weaver

..it's pretty cool that you're doing this. Because I'm certainly going to be egged on to try it (though you've mentioned it to me before), too.

There's no shortage of good oil hardened first half of the 20th century NOS slotted irons out there, but there sure aren't that many corrosion free matching cap irons to go with them.

I wish I had a forge in my shop. Not to forge an entire cap iron, but to try hammering out some of the things I file when I do things right now. A metal cutting bandsaw would be nice, too.

Anything you try and share leads to all of us learning - if you and I are buying the NOS stuff (or maybe it's just me), it's not going to last forever, especially if we can actually convince people to make their own double iron planes. Something I haven't encountered yet - as far as I know, nobody else is doing it.