Re: Going from 55 to 45
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
Derek, what difference is it that you notice when you drop to 40-42°?
I'm asking seriously; I have very little experience with angles below 45.
Hi Steve
Serious answer ...
There have been a few influences in the background that led to the decision to purchase a 42 degree frog for the #4 Veritas Custom.
Firstly, I had used a 25 degree A2 blade (for a 37 degree included angle) in a Veritas LA Jack for many years with great success on a shooting board. It produced a finer finish on endgrain than the plane that preceded it, a 60 degree HNT Gordon Trying Plane. The A2 blade also proved to be durable and I never experienced an issue with chipping.
Recently I compared a BU (at 37 degrees) with a BD (at 45 degrees) shooting planes, and one of the factors that became apparent was that the higher bed angle promoted faster blade wear.
All this would be academic if it were not for the effect that the chipbreaker has on taming tearout. There is no getting away from the fact that interlocked wood is vulnerable to tearout when planed with a common angle plane. Recent tradition had elevated the high cutting angle to be the main weapon against tearout. Being able to plane at an angle lower than 55 degrees was simply not an option for much of the wood I have in Western Australia. Generally 60+ degrees was needed.
Pushing a high angle BD plane is significantly harder work than pushing a common angle version. Being able to lower the cutting angle and still control tearout, while achieving an even smoother finish is a desirable goal!
So why 40-42 degrees? Two influences here: one is the knowledge that Japanese planes work in this angle range. The other was mention made by Warren over the years that he had modified his Stanley smoother (#3?) to 42 degrees.
I first tested this out with the jointer, for with I had 50- and 40-degree frogs. I spent some time comparing the two set ups, both ease of use, but especially the finish, and the latter without- and with an oil finish ...

This gave me confirmation that one could have a dedicated smoother (and jointer) with a low bed that would not compromise the finish, and instead obtain all the positive aspects. At that point I ordered the 42 degree frog for the #4.
What needs to be mentioned is a warning: in my experience, setting the chipbreaker is more demanding the lower the bed angle gets. A low bed smoother is not a beginners tool. It takes time to dial in. At the same time, a BU smoother with a high cutting angle really rocks! The BUS is nearly foolproof. The difference after a finish is negligible on most hardwoods. It is really only the softer woods where the lower cutting angle shows up on the surface.
One really needs to ask why I bother with the BD plane if the BU is so good? The answer for this that the blade of the BD plane is easier to hone since I freehand, and a BU blade is best prepared with a honing guide if you seek to add a camber (low primary bevel and high secondary).
Apologies for the long reply.
Regards from Perth
Derek