New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Going from 55 to 45

Posts

Going from 55 to 45

#1

Going from 55 to 45

Brian Holcombe

I have a bronze #4 plane with a 55 degree frog. I am considering going from 55 to 45, I find that the plane adjusts depth very coarsely and a heavy cut is very difficult to push.

I can't help but think that moving to a 45 degree frog will alleviate these issues. Is the case?

Re: Going from 55 to 45

#2

Re: Going from 55 to 45

david weaver

Yes, that is the case.

Before I learned to use the cap iron, I was enamored with high angles. The hardest plane I ever used was a 63 degree mujingfang. It went from a light cut to "you can't push it" with very few strikes of the hammer to add depth.

It left a fairly dull surface, too, but I was a fan because you couldn't induce tearout with it. I tortured myself with it and eventually got a large scraper plane.

There isn't anything you're likely to plane in this country that can't be done by a common pitch smoother, but there are a lot of things that aren't very desirable to plane with a 55 degree plane (namely softwoods and soft hardwoods).

Re: Going from 55 to 45

#3

Re: Going from 55 to 45

Brian Holcombe

Thanks David! You have confirmed my suspicions. I'm finding myself in the habit of simply backing off my jointer and taking a few finish passes, which is quite alright when dimensioning, but when attempting to finish plane partial assemblies I'm driving myself nuts with this high angle frog.

Re: Going from 55 to 45

#4

Re: Going from 55 to 45

Brian Holcombe

While we're on the subject I've set my chip breakers to your specifications basically to the letter when needed and can joint with little to no tearout. I back it off slightly for easy woods (straight grain).

Thanks for the write up you did a while back on those specifications, it is very helpful.

Re: Going from 55 to 45

#5

Re: Going from 55 to 45

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I have a bronze #4 plane with a 55 degree frog. I am considering going from 55 to 45, I find that the plane adjusts depth very coarsely and a heavy cut is very difficult to push.

I can't help but think that moving to a 45 degree frog will alleviate these issues. Is the case?

Hi Brian

Lowering the frog angle will reduce the centre of gravity and will also reduce the resistance of the blade through the wood (moving from more of a scraping to a slicing cut).

I suspect that the lower frog will require that the blade be extended further to cut. In other words, the lower frog offers a less hit-and-miss adjustments.

In my recent review/discussion of the custom Veritas planes, where it was possible to swap around frog angles, it was pretty obvious that the lower angle frog-plus-chipbreaker smoothed as well as a higher angle frog-minus chipbreaker, and that it produced a finer surface on bare wood. This difference disappears once a finish is applied.

I have a LN # 4 1/2, the Anniversary model, which came with a 50 degree frog. A few years ago - before I began utilising the chipbreaker to control tearout - I added a 55 degree frog (keeping in mind that I plane highly interlocked wood). The combination of a wide blade (2 3/8") and a high cutting angle was very unpleasant, even with a waxed sole, and the plane began to sit on the shelf. This has recently been returned to the 50 degree frog which, with chipbreaker, has become a user once again.

I also have a LN #3, which I purchased with a 55 degree frog. That works better since the blade is narrow ( 1 3/4") - one reason I have the #3 over the #4 (2" wide blade). The high frog enabled me to swap out the smaller handle for the one from a #4. Recently, I wanted a lower frog. I am restricted to a 50 degree if I keep the handle. Fortunately, there is not a lot of difference in using a 45- or 50 degree frog (the difference comes when you drop to about 40-42 degrees, as with the Veritas Custom).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Going from 55 to 45

#6

Re: Going from 55 to 45

Brian Holcombe

Thanks Derek, I appreciate your thoughts on the topic. Your comparison testing may have been the impetus for my consideration, or it simply pushed the thought to the front of my mind, but either way it was enlightening to see back to back comparisons.

The surface finish is an interesting topic, the 55 does produce a rougher finish on walnut but the difference on walnut is not disappearing when a finish is applied, it does however on some of the harder woods I use like white ash. So I think the wood used as a great impact on the results.

Re: Going from 55 to 45

#7

Re: Going from 55 to 45

david weaver

Glad it (the article) gets read from time to time!!

I've noticed several threads recently on different forums where someone says they're having trouble planing something and it takes a very long time for the most reasonable response which is just, learn how to use the cap iron on your plane.

Scrapers, sanding, router jigs...all kinds of goofy stuff from what I've seen.

Re: Going from 55 to 45

#8

Re: Going from 55 to 45

Steve Voigt

Fortunately, there is not a lot of difference in using a 45- or 50 degree frog (the difference comes when you drop to about 40-42 degrees, as with the Veritas Custom).

Derek, what difference is it that you notice when you drop to 40-42°?

I'm asking seriously; I have very little experience with angles below 45.

Re: Going from 55 to 45

#9

Re: Going from 55 to 45

TomD

55 degrees isn't for heavy cuts, so you should get a win there. The adjustment is only 21 % more fine, which does not seem to be all that night and day. The higher angle also reduces the quality of cut per grit by 21% on the 55. Or you can adjust the bevel angle to deal with that, in part.

Re: Going from 55 to 45

#10

Re: Going from 55 to 45

Brian Holcombe

45 degree is in the mail, so now I will have both if need be. I can only increase the bevel angle ( back bevel)....

Re: Going from 55 to 45

#11

Re: Going from 55 to 45

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Derek, what difference is it that you notice when you drop to 40-42°?

I'm asking seriously; I have very little experience with angles below 45.

Hi Steve

Serious answer ...

There have been a few influences in the background that led to the decision to purchase a 42 degree frog for the #4 Veritas Custom.

Firstly, I had used a 25 degree A2 blade (for a 37 degree included angle) in a Veritas LA Jack for many years with great success on a shooting board. It produced a finer finish on endgrain than the plane that preceded it, a 60 degree HNT Gordon Trying Plane. The A2 blade also proved to be durable and I never experienced an issue with chipping.

Recently I compared a BU (at 37 degrees) with a BD (at 45 degrees) shooting planes, and one of the factors that became apparent was that the higher bed angle promoted faster blade wear.

All this would be academic if it were not for the effect that the chipbreaker has on taming tearout. There is no getting away from the fact that interlocked wood is vulnerable to tearout when planed with a common angle plane. Recent tradition had elevated the high cutting angle to be the main weapon against tearout. Being able to plane at an angle lower than 55 degrees was simply not an option for much of the wood I have in Western Australia. Generally 60+ degrees was needed.

Pushing a high angle BD plane is significantly harder work than pushing a common angle version. Being able to lower the cutting angle and still control tearout, while achieving an even smoother finish is a desirable goal!

So why 40-42 degrees? Two influences here: one is the knowledge that Japanese planes work in this angle range. The other was mention made by Warren over the years that he had modified his Stanley smoother (#3?) to 42 degrees.

I first tested this out with the jointer, for with I had 50- and 40-degree frogs. I spent some time comparing the two set ups, both ease of use, but especially the finish, and the latter without- and with an oil finish ...


This gave me confirmation that one could have a dedicated smoother (and jointer) with a low bed that would not compromise the finish, and instead obtain all the positive aspects. At that point I ordered the 42 degree frog for the #4.

What needs to be mentioned is a warning: in my experience, setting the chipbreaker is more demanding the lower the bed angle gets. A low bed smoother is not a beginners tool. It takes time to dial in. At the same time, a BU smoother with a high cutting angle really rocks! The BUS is nearly foolproof. The difference after a finish is negligible on most hardwoods. It is really only the softer woods where the lower cutting angle shows up on the surface.

One really needs to ask why I bother with the BD plane if the BU is so good? The answer for this that the blade of the BD plane is easier to hone since I freehand, and a BU blade is best prepared with a honing guide if you seek to add a camber (low primary bevel and high secondary).

Apologies for the long reply.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Going from 55 to 45

#12

42 degrees

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I used a #4 smooth plane until 1981, when I bought a #3. Then I started using the old one for end grain and altered it to 42 degrees. Thirty years later I would say the difference between 45 and 42 is subtle, maybe not really important. I think the difference between 45 and 55 is great, but even here some claim not to notice.

I have written before that I think the ideal would be around 40 degrees for a double iron plane. However the closer one is to a theoretical minimum the less cushion there is for honing error. I have seen guys honing on videos who lift the iron "about one degree" and end up maybe over 35 degrees. So I would say the 45 degrees was chosen to give plenty of cushion.

Re: Going from 55 to 45

#13

Re: Going from 55 to 45

Steve Voigt

Apologies for the long reply.

I appreciate the long and thoughtful reply, Derek. Thanks.

Re: Going from 55 to 45

#14

Re: 42 degrees

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Warren, did you take the 3 degrees off the frog or the bed?

Re: Going from 55 to 45

#15

Re: Going from 55 to 45

TomD

I know I am going to regret this, but why would set the BU plane with a double bevel as opposed to any other. Presumably a geometry issue vs a sharpening one.

Re: Going from 55 to 45

#16

Re: 42 degrees

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I'm sorry Bruce, it was 30 years ago and I don't remember much. I think I get marginally better results from the angle reduction; I'm not sure I would bother again.

Re: Going from 55 to 45

#17

Re: Going from 55 to 45

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

.... why would set the BU plane with a double bevel as opposed to any other. Presumably a geometry issue vs a sharpening one.

Tom, not a silly question at all :) ... and, yes, you are correct, it is about geometry and not sharpening.

With the typical BD bench plane blade that receives a 25-30 degree primary/secondary bevel, adding a camber is fairly straightforward. It does not matter what angle the bed/frog is - such as when increasing this to 60 degrees for planing interlocked grain - the bevel angle remains the same.

However, to obtain a high cutting angle from a BU plane, the bevel angle needs to be increased. This could be 50 degrees for a 62 degree cutting angle (on a 12 degree bed).

Adding a camber to a 25-30 degree primary bevel is not much work since one is removing very little steel. Adding a camber to a 50 degree primary bevel, on the other hand, is a lot of work and essentially too much so. However, adding a high micro secondary bevel to a low primary bevel is a simple matter, and makes the cambering of a BU smoother straightforward.

(This micro secondary bevel is best done with a honing guide to more accurately judge the angle needed. This part is the aspect I found more laborious).

I wrote an article about this in 2007, which followed one of those "fun" debates on Knots. In the article I supplied the maths to show how much extra work is involved in attempting to camber a high primary bevel instead of using a secondary on a low primary. Read it if you are seriously insomniac (I will add that the topic was originally raised n connection with the cambers on a jack, but then morphed into the cambers on a smoother): http://www.inthewoodshop.com/WoodworkTechniques/TheSecretToCamberinBUPlaneBlades.html

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Going from 55 to 45

#18

Re: Going from 55 to 45

Brian Holcombe

So, I received the 45 degree frog and installed it. I planed over some walnut that was rather troublesome with the 55 degree plane.

I was able to further tighten the cap iron and still get an excellent, curled, shaving. At this point the 55 degree frog would be producing accordion shaped shavings.

Re: Going from 55 to 45

#19

Re: Going from 55 to 45

david weaver

Glad to hear it's providing good results.

I think you'll find you much prefer the plane at 45 degrees now, and find that it'll be a go-to for everything.

Re: Going from 55 to 45

#20

Re: Going from 55 to 45

Brian Holcombe

Thanks David! I fully expect the same, it's much more a pleasure to use now after the swap.