New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

How to talk to 13 year olds

Posts

How to talk to 13 year olds

#1

How to talk to 13 year olds

TomD

After Ellis made the point that the best target is a grade 8 student, I wondered how do you do that. I don't even talk down to a 3 years old. 12 years later she is a double honors student. Writing nonsense is easy, it isn't a style so much as a lack of connection with reality. But other than throwing in a few folksy words, how do you write like a dumb as... a grade 8. Turns out that talking stupid is way easier than I thought: You can monitor the reading level of a document by turning on the readability statistics option in the proofing settings of Microsoft Word, of course you would be drafting the text in MSW. This activates the Flesch-Kincaid Grade Level measurement, which calculates the number of years of education needed to comprehend the text. Unfortunately my computer is too stupid to dumb me down (or up), since I have some 25 K version of word on my computer...

It's still confusing. How come, the average readability index concludes that the average reader only got to grade eight, with huge numbers needing to be well below that, to average out the graduates and college folks. It isn't even legal to drop out of school until Grade 11 around here. How is half the country doing it? Sounds like the schools should also be providing more pictures.

Re: How to talk to 13 year olds

#2

you're assuming a normal distribution ...

ian in Sydney

the distribution of reading ability is more likely some form of skewed distribution with lots of people around Grade 7 and 8 and very few at Grade 12+

and let's not go to far with maths ability -- today's issue of the local paper (which is targeted at readers around Grade 10) reports that most students entering teaching as a course of study only took Maths and Science as far as Grade 10

Re: How to talk to 13 year olds

#3

Based on our local paper....

John in NM

Most articles seem to be written by authors who stopped learning around grade 10 :D

Re: How to talk to 13 year olds

#4

Re: Based on our local paper....

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

The New York scandle sheets (Daily News and Post) have been consistently rated as being written on a 4th grade reading level. Whether that reflects a larger percentage of the population as English-limited or just ignorant I can't say. ;)

Re: How to talk to 13 year olds

#5

Ellis Walentine

Not to fret

Ellis Walentine

I see that my 8th-grade reading level comment really caught your imagination. I don't know who determines reading level, or if it's some kind of software analysis as you suggested, but to me it is a rough approximation at best. A better way of understanding it is in terms of conversation. Mainstream magazines tend top be written in a very conversational style -- friendly, relaxed, not too esoteric -- with an easily understandable vocabulary, direct, declarative sentences, straightforward references, no passive or subjunctive, lots of 1st person, etc.-- which probably, according to the grand gurus of reading levels, correlates with the level of understanding of a typical 8th grader. This is not to say that the content of the communication is stupid; just that it is easy to grasp quickly and fluidly, without having to parse a lot of high-handed academic lingo and verbiage, abstruse references. So we shouldn't think of the reading level designation as a pejorative, but rather as a credit to the author or editor for making the content comprehensible and easily accessible to any reader with a reasonable understanding of the language. The content is all there, even for the more gifted readers; it's just been made easier to digest, not dumbed down. That's my distinction anyhow.

Ellis

Re: How to talk to 13 year olds

#6

Funny thing about it....

John in NM

Some of the best technical writing I've seen has been in the field of woodworking :D

Supposedly "professional" tech writing is often horrible, because the author either does not know the subject or does know the subject and assumes the reader has a similar level of knowledge.

Woodworking articles rarely suffer from either of these problems, and given that most are in popular magazines, authors do seem to make an effort to make their work readable.

Re: How to talk to 13 year olds

#7

I think you're right Ellis

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

"So we shouldn't think of the reading level designation as a pejorative, but rather as a credit to the author or editor for making the content comprehensible and easily accessible to any reader with a reasonable understanding of the language. The content is all there, even for the more gifted readers; it's just been made easier to digest, not dumbed down."

__________

Ellis, your explanation is consistent with the Flesch-Kincaid readability test, which I had to look up.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flesch%E2%80%93Kincaid_readability_tests

It's a simple test--I am tempted to say 'eighth grade'. There are two variables, number of words per sentence, and number of syllables per word. Any paragraph can be run through this mill to yield a grade-level. So how to talk to an 8th grader, or anyone for that matter: use simple declarative sentences, free of jargon.

Wiley

Re: How to talk to 13 year olds

#8

Re: Not to fret

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Playboy's written on a much higher level, but nobody actually "reads" it anyway.

Re: How to talk to 13 year olds

#9

for example?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"Mainstream magazines tend top be written in a very conversational style -- friendly, relaxed, not too esoteric -- with an easily understandable vocabulary, direct, declarative sentences, straightforward references,{take breath} no passive or subjunctive, lots of 1st person, etc.-- which probably, according to the grand gurus of reading levels, correlates with the level of understanding of a typical 8th grader." :D

Re: How to talk to 13 year olds

#10

Ellis Walentine

Present company excepted

Ellis Walentine

The liberating part of not expressly writing to a mainstream audience is that I/we can have a little more fun with the writing. On this board, I don't think we're leaving anyone in the dust. :)

Ellis

Re: How to talk to 13 year olds

#11

Re: I think you're right Ellis

david weaver

I'm inclined to agree with your specification, wiley. I have to read more difficult things in my day job. When I get on here or when I read magazines, I like them to be fairly easy to read.

I don't reread my posts in forums, and if I have to read others' about a topic that I'm not 100% interested in, then I don't reread theirs, either.

Same with magazines. I can enjoy reading things that are supposedly below my reading level.

And I can make plenty of written posts that bring the reading level down for others :)

Re: How to talk to 13 year olds

#12

Dust

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

The would be "airborne particulates subject to vectored displacement by atmospheric pressure differentials" right?

Re: How to talk to 13 year olds

#13

Re: How to talk to 13 year olds

TomD

It's OK, I wasn't really panicking over the need to upgrade to MS Word For Dummies. While I was actually interested in what 8th grade is (based on that game show about 5th graders, one probably shouldn't be too smug) partly I was just stirring the pot, though one does wonder whether the photo hounds are really visual learners, or people with poor comprehension of English. With luck that sentence was so run-on, nobody will have been insulted. If you got this far it doesn't apply to you.

Re: How to talk to 13 year olds

#14

Are you sure?

John in NM

About the "subject to vectored displacement by atmospheric pressure differentials" part? I think you are neglecting to consider the skewed normal distribution resulting from adiabatic temperature gradients.

:D :D :D

Re: How to talk to 13 year olds

#15

Ellis Walentine

Fog index *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

I ran my erudite answer above through a free online readability/ grade-level calculator and found that only undergraduate-level readers were likely to grasp it easily. I should strive for better readability.

Nah. :)

Ellis


Readability Score Tester

Re: How to talk to 13 year olds

#16

Re: Are you sure?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I stand convected

Re: How to talk to 13 year olds

#17

Ah, now you're just spinnin'